5 ms·
[EDIT] Again, I really don't understand why I'd be downvoted for asking a legitimate question like this. It's rather disconcerting. While it's great to think ab
by noduerme 15y ago
[EDIT] Again, I really don't understand why I'd be downvoted for asking a legitimate question like this. It's rather disconcerting. While it's great to think about a future in which this technology is safe and widely available, it seems to me I'm being attacked for simply asking basic security questions that I would ask about any large system that was going through trials prior to mass rollout. And rather than hearing any specific answers, I'm just being attacked and voted down. I think anyone who's spent time in IT would probably ask these things first before they deployed a new system in their company office, so I don't think it's unreasonable to ask them about about a potentially game-changing social innovation.[/EDIT]
That's true. But blowing up a diesel truck is hard to do remotely, and requires someone to actively attack at a specific place and time.
I'm not sure why I got downrated for my post; I'm just asking, doesn't this create a lot of security holes and attack vectors that need to be studied before allowing it? I mean, I haven't heard anything about security, at all. The focus seems to be on a safe driving experience, but where's the white paper on counter-hacking measures? Can you imagine if Google launched Gmail without any kind of plan to mitigate stolen passwords or hijacked accounts? As it is, there are plenty of people who do have their accounts hijacked. Luckily, that doesn't lead to collisions and deaths.
Consider for a moment how many people run Windows and IE, with the latest security updates, who are still vulnerable to zero day exploits. Consider how many don't update their software and get swept up in botnets a few days later. Now imagine each and every compromised PC has physical control over 2-3 tons of rolling aluminum and steel, that can go anywhere on a public highway, with human beings inside it.
An attacker who had taken control over a botnet of compromised autonomous carscould drive swarms of them wherever they wanted by remote control.
Now, rather than downvote me, tell me what security protocols will be in place to prevent the scenarios I've outlined.
- kelnos 15y agoNo network access. The computer that controls the car doesn't need to talk to anything other than the car. That eliminates a slew of attack vectors right there.
- noduerme 15y agoIs "no network access" going to be part of the legal framework under which the vehicles operate? Presumably they need to download maps from somewhere, along with traffic updates, road hazards, etc. Most new cars have network capabilities as it now stands. So it's unreasonable to assume that they won't have any network access. And as we know, anything with network access can eventually be rooted.
- icebraining 15y agoMy guess is that the basic systems (keep the car from going off-road or colliding, letting people takeover, etc) will run on an real-time barebones OS on a embedded system and will have a very simple and well defined interface to a full machine that runs all the crap like the UI, navigation systems and such. I wouldn't discount having your car stolen remotely, but hijacking with humans inside is unlikely to work, and so is crashing into things.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoIf it's navigating according to a map that's downloaded from a network, upload a faulty map to it. Then it will go whereever you want it to.
- icebraining 15y agoWell, two things: * Being possible is not the same as being easy or likely. For example, what if the system only accepts maps digitally signed by the company? You know have to either get the signing cert from the company or break digital cryptography. * If there's a person inside, the can still take over and drive it themselves or tell it to park and ask for technical support.
- Game_Ender 15y agoThese aren't "dumb" cars. For example, Google's have a high fidelity laser range finder that builds dense 360 point clouds 15 times second. If the car is given a bad map which sends it into a build or other cars, the collision avoidance system will recognize that fact before an accident occurs and stop the vehicle.
- jarek 15y ago> But blowing up a diesel truck is hard to do remotely It really isn't. Rebels/terrorists/freedom fighters† the world over could tell you how to detonate an explosive using an off-the-shelf prepaid cell phone. † pick your preference
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoEvery advance comes with the ability to cause problems (for the record, I didn't downvote). The question is: are we better off without the advance? Personally, I think the answer is rarely (if ever) "yes". Quality of life has gone up over time, and I don't expect this will change that. Of course, there is the possibility of things going wrong, but, on average, things generally get better, faster, than the alternative. (At least, I hope so ;).