7 ms·
I'm starting to feel like all of this is just a lost cause. We campaign against some shitty bill. It fails to pass. Someone brings it up again the next sessi
by kelnos 3y ago
I'm starting to feel like all of this is just a lost cause.
We campaign against some shitty bill. It fails to pass. Someone brings it up again the next session, and we have to do it all over again. Eventually, people get tired of fighting, and it passes.
Every time I've written to my Senator or Representative about something they support but I don't like, I get a form letter in response that just restates their existing position. I don't get the feeling that anything I do matters. And honestly, I'm doing the bare minimum here. I can't imagine how depressing all this must be for people who engage in actual activism around these issues.
- EatingWithForks 3y agoI want to emphasize that rights are not won once. Rights must be continuously fought for. Collectively, society has succeeded in performing an outcry against bills like this, and they've done so for well over a decade at this point. It's important to know that this is what winning looks like. Actual activism keeps this in mind: winning looks like bad things not passing. It looks like keeping an eye out for societal danger, mobilizing against it, and celebrating once the danger has been defeated-- with the knowledge that they must remain vigilant.
- JoshTriplett 3y ago> I want to emphasize that rights are not won once. Rights must be continuously fought for. Collectively, society has succeeded in performing an outcry against bills like this, and they've done so for well over a decade at this point. It's important to know that this is what winning looks like. That may be, but once in a while it'd be nice to pass something positively affirming specific rights that prevents anyone from easily trying again to take them away. Constitutional amendments are hard to repeal. And some states have passed legislation that says things like "this can't be repealed by the state legislature, only by a vote of the people".
- irjustin 3y ago> That may be, but once in a while it'd be nice to pass something positively affirming specific rights that prevents anyone from easily trying again to take them away. For the point of discourse, I'll point out that the "otherside" thinks the exact same thing.
- brightlancer 3y agoThere is a great irony in folks downvoting your comment when the original article is about an attempt to codify positive "rights" which would infringe upon the innate rights of everyone else.
- EatingWithForks 3y agoPositively affirming rights are passed, and often passed regularly. But remember we monkey brains are drawn towards the negative. Positive news doesn't make it on the news that often, and even when they are, we forget them way faster than negative news. Within the fairly recent times, people of certain races could marry. People of certain sexes could marry. Sweeping minimal standards for healthcare have been passed. If you go to the state level, Minnesota for example has been crushing it by guaranteeing abortion access, fertility treatment access, family planning, 12 weeks off for the birth of a child, universal school lunch, legalizing weed, etc.
- brightlancer 3y ago> Positively affirming rights are passed, and often passed regularly. If a legislature (or government generally) can grant a "right", then it can take it away. That means it isn't a right, it's a privilege. Oh, what's that? The government responded to the Will of the People? So, the Will of the People can revoke that "right". OR, a group that you think is abhorrent could get a majority to declare whatever rights they want. I'm constantly astounded how many people confuse authoritarianism for liberalism.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoBecause you don't have to think too hard about the downsides when the outcome supports your view. Everyone really also needs to remember everyone has rights, or no one has rights.
- isaacremuant 3y ago> Positively affirming rights are passed, and often passed regularly. But remember we monkey brains are drawn towards the negative. Positive news doesn't make it on the news that often, and even when they are, we forget them way faster than negative news That's such a cop out. This is not a balancing thing. Since 911, privacy and fundamental rights have been increasingly crushed and no amount of gay marriage offsets that. It's two separate things. Hell, while things like gay marriage are awesome and expand rights, we seem to be now using identity politics to limit them. So no, there's no "glass half full" here.
- zirgs 3y agoThe problem with mechanisms like that is that they can also be (ab)used for bad stuff. For example - in my country gay marriage was made explicitly illegal with a constitutional amendment in 2005. Many other countries could legalise it with a simple majority vote. But we now need either a 2/3 majority or a referendum. Both of which are very unlikely to pass.
- lynx23 3y agoMarriage is a dying concept anyways. With a few exceptions, it appears it is only used to secure relationships where children are involved. And given the declining birth rate and steadily increasing independence of women, marriage is a rather antiquated concept. It will not be missed.
- qwerty456127 3y agoMarriage is a solid legal ground for getting a visa for your partner whenever you move to another country - this is very useful.
- zirgs 3y agoYup - my country considers gay couples not married - even if they have been married in another country. Even worse - if another country requests that information - my country will also say that they are not married. Because - obviously - they will ask the country that the couple are citizens of not some random 3rd country.
- qwerty456127 3y agoDo they really request that from your country of origin? I thought an apostilled american marriage certificate (which is relatively easy to get, no matter what coutry you are from) usually is enough.
- lynx23 3y agoOh yes, I still remember the few cases where I saw that being put to "good" use. It was always about enabling immigration which would otherwise have failed. Find a woman to do a fake marriage with, pay her for it, and voila, you are in!
- aio2 3y agoI know I'm stating the obvious, but we're screwed.
- cwkoss 3y agoIt feels like in the next decade either politicians and CEOs will be dragged into the streets by angry mobs, or a fascist authoritarian tech panopticon will be crystalized and citizens will no longer have the means to make their leaders feel afraid. Either way, future isn't looking to cheery.
- guru_sizif 3y ago[dead]
- nemo44x 3y agoKeep in mind most of the things you care about, half the country is against. And you win some and you lose some. So you don’t get your way every time. No one does. But your opponents are just as upset. Because you do win some battles too.
- callalex 3y agoNowhere near half the people support these extremist policies. The senate doesn’t represent popular opinion by any reasonable margin at all, and it’s harmful to imply that it does.
- themitigating 3y agoElections?
- callalex 3y agoElections prove my point. Popular votes are entirely uncorrelated with Senate representation, by design. Same with presidential elections. Compare the voting results of the US house (which is also biased but I won’t dig further into that now because it will devolve into a flame war) to the US senate for empirical evidence.
- Dalewyn 3y agoThe offices of President, Representative, and Senator are all ultimately decided by popular votes. Yes, the President is acshuarry voted in by the Electoral College, but do you know how the Electors in the College decide who to vote for? By reflecting the results of the popular vote in their respective state. Now, if you are sincerely ignorant of how civics work in the USA, kindly go and educate yourself. It's honestly a really interesting and fun subject. But, if you are deliberately spreading false information, kindly sod off like the third rate bank clerk that you are and stop inciting conflict.
- 3y ago
- vegetablepotpie 3y agoWe could give up, or we could step it up. I’m assuming we all have some about of disposable income when I say this, but we could plan lobby trips to DC. With airfare plus hotel, it would cost each person about $1,500 for a visit to congressional offices and a night stay. We could go to congressional offices as teams and have at least one of us from each district show up. It would send the message that, not only do tech people care about data privacy, but that we’re getting increasingly organized. Politicians will take notice and consider more carefully about bills they support.
- failuser 3y agoThis is a mystery to me. When the sums of money that change decisions in Washington show up they tend to be small. Rarely even a million. Why can’t be those sums crowdsourced? I have a couple of guesses. 1. This is so low because there is low competition, the amounts will quickly go into billions if challenged. 2. They actually support those causes and will refuse money that comes from the people, not the corporations. 3. Anyone who would try that will be discredited, sued or even eliminated. Money is just a small part of it.
- themitigating 3y agoDo you still vote for them? That's the only message that matters.
- labster 3y agoThat’s simply not true. Politicians are human and like to be liked; they also like to feel good about helping constituents. Lobbying actually works — why else would corporations spend so much money doing it? Voting is the absolute minimum participation you have in democracy. It works about as well as shooting for a minimum passing grade. Democracies require the people to actually participate, like the word itself implies.
- nikanj 3y agoCorporate lobbying = A very nice weekend getaway in a 5-star destination (+1 welcome of course), featuring a few key talks about the issues important to the sponsor and leaving ample free time to explore the luxuries offered by the travel destination Private citizen lobbying = A letter that needs answering.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoYou can keep doing the same thing expecting different results or you can learn. "Activism" mostly has no consequence in general. Unless it has vast scale, funding, and actually brainwashes the masses, bribes the people in charge. The other approach is take your business elsewhere like Apple, Wikipedia and so on is preparing to do.
- isaacremuant 3y ago> Every time I've written to my Senator or Representative about something they support but I don't like, I get a form letter in response that just restates their existing position The funniest (Anecfote not from the USA) is when they state in their response email something that you have first hand experience of being false, such as "this legislation does not ban the right to protest because we've seen protests take place" when, the legislation does give that power and they do prevent them, but allow Corporate approved protests to go on (think protest for something unobtrusive). I just hope more people realize govs don't have their (the people) interest in mind when pushing increasing authortiarian power for them.
- pravus 3y agoI guess my question would be why we feel like we must live in a society where we have to beg an elite cadre of distant "representatives" to do anything. I've been consistently reminded my entire life that if we don't do this society will immediately collapse into a steaming pile of anarchism. It leaves me wondering why so many complain about the yoke if they asked for it. Also, I use the royal "we" here because I certainly feel no affinity to any of the political behemoths in charge. I would much prefer to live in a world where these assholes acted more like consultants than tyrants.
- fireweed 3y agoComing from Hong Kong, I would say we need to keep it going not matter how depressing it is. Or one day, you will even lose the means to fight. That's what happened in Hong Kong.
- user3939382 3y agoOur entire political system is corrupt. The only interests that matter are megacorporations, the super wealthy, and the military. Our elections are a sham because candidates aligned against these big interests can not win. Any avenues of electoral participation are theater.
- weberer 3y ago"The condition upon which God hath given liberty to man is eternal vigilance; which condition if he break, servitude is at once the consequence of his crime and the punishment of his guilt." - John Philpot Curran