3 ms·
Come on, be serious. Civilian ferries don't carry dedicated firefighters. The crew receive some cursory training in basic firefighting every once in a while. Th
by nradov 3y ago
Come on, be serious. Civilian ferries don't carry dedicated firefighters. The crew receive some cursory training in basic firefighting every once in a while. They depend mainly on fixed firefighting systems that dispense CO2, suppressants, or water.
It's impossible to operate a forklift on the tightly packed cargo deck of a ferry, especially while the space is filled with toxic smoke. Nor is there room onboard for a fire resistant container.
It's hilarious how a bunch of software developers who have never spent any time at sea think they have all the answers.
- martin_a 3y ago> The crew receive some cursory training in basic firefighting every once in a while. That is EXACTLY part of the problem. You put people with lots of flammable stuff under their asses on a ship in the middle of nowhere, with no help readily available, and hope that some sprinklers will be good enough to do the job. Don't you see a problem with that, that should be tackled?
- nradov 3y agoI see all sorts of marine safety problems that could be tackled with sufficient resources. If you're an expert in this area then I would encourage you to work through your national authorities to propose further SOLAS amendments. They come up with new ones on a regular basis. https://www.dnv.com/news/what-s-new-with-solas-2024--227502 https://www.dnv.com/news/what-s-new-with-solas-2024--227502 The thing is that ferries are generally a low margin business so imposing a bunch of extra firefighting requirements will make some of them at the margins no longer economically viable. And fires aren't necessarily even the biggest risk: they also have to worry about collisions, loss of power, storms, navigational errors, cargo shifting, etc. Realistically I just don't think civilian crews can be expected to effectively fight major fires in 50KWh+ lithium battery packs. Instead they should focus on fast, safe evacuation; when there is significant loss of life due to shipboard fires it's usually because the crew waited too long to abandon ship and screwed up the lifeboat deployment. Once the people are off then just let the vessel burn, or perhaps let a skeleton crew try to put into a nearby harbor where fire boats with trained personnel can take over. It may also be practical to do something on the prevention front such as a quick visual inspection of EVs for obvious battery pack damage and dashboard warning lights. Or require packs to be discharged below 20% or whatever before boarding (passengers will complain about this).
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoA long time ago I was trained to be an officer on commercial oceangoing ships. In addition to regular classwork and practice with firefighting equipment, we were sent to Military Sealift Command Firefighting school to get experience fighting fires in actual shipboard conditions. It's a bit more than "cursory training." I'm not sure everyone came back with all their eyebrows intact :-) Not an expert firefighter by any means, even back then. Just responding to this to add some data. Still, you make a good point: if you're not regularly fighting fires, that training atrophies like anything else. If fire like this breaks out anywhere but on the main deck, my guess is that they'd just flood the space with CO2.