13 ms·
"Home taping is killing music" The record companies did a fantastic job of killing music all by themselves, the quality has absolutely cratered and the occasio
by jacquesm 3y ago
"Home taping is killing music"
The record companies did a fantastic job of killing music all by themselves, the quality has absolutely cratered and the occasional great artist that has made it through the long slog to recognition has done so despite the music industry, not because of.
I spent a fortune on various formats and when streaming came along I simply refused to participate. I'm simply not going to pay a third time for music that I already legally own.
Note that the following was written well before streaming came along, but it is an excellent article on the realities of the music industry from the artists perspective written by Janis Ian:
https://web.archive.org/web/20070509181400/http://www.janisian.com/article-internet_debacle.html https://web.archive.org/web/20070509181400/http://www.janisi...
There is a fair chance that if you're under 40 that you've never heard of her, but I suggest you give her music a try as well, it is at least as good as her writing.
And another one by Courtney Love:
https://www.salon.com/2000/06/14/love_7/ https://www.salon.com/2000/06/14/love_7/
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI pay for streaming music because I've pirated all my other music, and it's convenient. Quality is subjective, I'm no audiophile and unless I'm using it on the go with low data mode on, I can't hear the difference... except the one time with a more obscure song, but I reported that and they fixed it. Maybe that was an accidental low data mode though.
- Lacerda69 3y agoBuy music directly from the artist. Streaming services are a cancer.
- scblock 3y agoStreaming services can be an excellent music discovery platform.
- antihero 3y agoI buy stuff with bandcamp, then import directly onto my navidrome server in ALAC.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI stream my own music, because you can do that now. It's $0/month, and I never have to worry about some cranky millionaire getting pissed at Spotify and yanking their music off of it. Nothing is so convenient that I'd ever pay an ongoing subscription. Those always feel like scams or ripoffs, and life in 2023 is so overfilled with subscriptions that they can't possibly be affordable to even you guys who make x3 what I do. Can they?
- carlosjobim 3y agoWhere do you get the free uplink?
- thrtythreeforty 3y agoGiven that you already pay for an Internet connection, it's $0 marginal cost.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI'll be (justifiably) downvoted for this, but he may be a millennial that "doesn't have internet at home". Which, if it were true, is to my way of thinking like telling me that you don't have indoor plumbing.
- carlosjobim 3y agoI have internet at home, but saying it costs $0 is stretching it, since you have to have a decent upload speed on the connection you're paying for. Not to speak of the server, in this day and age when most people only have a laptop.
- some-guy 3y agoI’m someone who has a large FLAC collection and an obsession with my private music tracker. I do it because of an obsession of collecting music, but modern streaming is “good enough” for 99% of cases. And unlike video streaming platforms, most audio platforms have “most” content that people want to listen to.
- itintheory 3y ago> And unlike video streaming platforms, most audio platforms have “most” content that people want to listen to. I'm worried about the potential for this to change. Netflix used to have a much larger catalogue, especially for movies. Nowadays the things I'm interested in may be spread across a dozen different services. Currently it seems that Spotify, and Youtube music (probably Apple music too, though I've not tried it) have almost everything I can think of. But I can certainly see a possible future where these services get much more fragmented. For instance, I know Apple is already pushing a classical only streaming service. Could/would they some day remove classical from their other streaming services and instead offer a higher priced bundle deal? I think it's possible.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoDo you already own all of the music you are going to listen to for your life? My own music tastes change over time. I don't listen to the same things I listened to 25 years ago - at least, not often. I want new music from time to time, especially if I'm walking places often. That's the thing with streaming. I'm OK with paying an amount that is less than a CD was 25 years ago just to have a bunch of music at my disposal. A bunch of new-to-me music from various genres and from various places in the world. It isn't like I'm going to purchase physical media any time soon. Is the service forever? Nope, probably not, but that's an issue for later me.
- jacquesm 3y ago> Do you already own all of the music you are going to listen to for your life? Probably not, but given that I spent until the end of the CD age to collect music I do have enough to last me for several lifetimes. I'm a bit strange in that I will listen to music over and over again until I have it internalized, and even after that. I don't need something new every day.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoI don't need something new every day Neither do I, but I'm also not going to spend decades - or even years - listening to the same thing week after week. Not to mention that my music tastes are much more varied than they were years ago.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's fine, not everybody is the same in this respect. I can drive people absolutely nuts by listening to the same piece a few hundred times in a row. Recently: Miriam Stockley, Perfect day (1999, sorry).
- mbesto 3y ago> That's fine, not everybody is the same in this respect. Which is incongruent with: > the quality has absolutely cratered You have no measure of music quality and everyone's views on quality are different, e.g. "not everybody is same in this respect".
- gumballindie 3y agoQuality may have tanked but profits soared. Music, movies and any other corporate product are meant to appeal to as many people as possible. Therefore they have to be average.
- techdragon 3y agoCorporate profits soared, but not the profits that get paid to artists. Wholehearted support for the efforts by the WGA, SAG, and the related unions, to stop “big corporate media” fucking over everyone in the arts even if it won’t help the average Spotify streamer today or tomorrow, but perhaps eventually it will further into the future…
- gumballindie 3y agoIndeed. As a side note i wasnt praising corporations, quite the contrary. Some of the things provided are good but overall corporations are detrimental to the society, environment, public health, security and the economy. Both in the music industry and outside.
- techdragon 3y agoI didn’t even for a moment think you were praising them, it’s just so easy for people to forget the percentage breakdowns behind the PR pieces these companies put out. I’m sure I’ve done it myself too often enough. Corporations aren’t inherently an evil concept… the rubicon was corporate personhood. The idea that corporations have equivalent rights to people unless we legislate that they don’t… that’s the mind poison… the rot that has slowly eaten into society and for more than a hundred years has been backing up capitalism and corporatism and all the greed and corruption with the subtle backstop of thought terminating cliches like “people have rights and corporations are people so they have rights” and normal people don’t want to learn a mountain of history to unpack the lies and bullshit… And companies have the money to hire the best PR… so they have done a pretty good job convincing everyone on the sorts of subjects that are in the corporations best interests… sadly.
- cubefox 3y ago> The record companies did a fantastic job of killing music all by themselves It wasn't the record companies which ruined the music industry. It was us, the consumers. We ruined it with piracy. https://i.insider.com/4d5ea2acccd1d54e7c030000 https://i.insider.com/4d5ea2acccd1d54e7c030000 We always like to imagine big organizations as the "baddies", and us as the "goodies". But the reality doesn't always follow this convenient narrative. Sometimes it turns out we were the baddies all along.
- arlcode 3y agoIt looks way different if you include data of the last 14 years though (even inflation adjusted) https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database/ https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database/
- cubefox 3y agoThis isn't inflation adjusted as far as I can see. Even if it were, the revenue now should be much higher than in 1999, given that the world economy grew a lot since then. Here is an actual inflation adjusted chart, which looks pretty damning: https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/US-recorded-music-revs-1999-v-2020.png https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/...
- Kuinox 3y agoYou are trying to collerate loss of revenue with the loss caused by piracy, without any data of loss caused by piracy. Also, showing a graph without the last 10 years is making the data lying: https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database The music industry earnings has never been that high than today. Also, actual studies shows piracy helped sales, not hindered earnings: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/eu-study-finds-piracy-doesnt-hurt-game-sales-may-actually-help/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/eu-study-finds-piracy...
- cubefox 3y ago> You are trying to collerate loss of revenue with the loss caused by piracy, without any data of loss caused by piracy. The only explanation for the complete collapse of CD sales starting in 1999 is piracy. Napster & Co. Anything else is dishonest. > Also, showing a graph without the last 10 years is making the data lying: https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database No, this data is lying because it ignores inflation. Here is an inflation adjusted chart, which shows a massive drop in revenue: https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/US-recorded-music-revs-1999-v-2020.png https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/... Moreover, even if revenue were on the same level today as it was more than 20 years ago, which it isn't, this would ignore the fact that in the meantime the global economy has increased substantially, such that the revenue without piracy would be much higher than back then. > Also, actual studies shows piracy helped sales, not hindered earnings: This is about video games and highly speculative. For music there is overwhelming evidence that piracy completely crushed the CD market.
- footlose_3815 3y agoWhat do you mean, the natural evolution of music wasn't meant to be face-tattooed, cough syrup-drinking suicide-flirting mumble rappers who all talk about the same shit?
- mrguyorama 3y agoOh so you prefer the wealthy old white guys who were born with a silver spoon in hand pretending to be "down and dirty" rednecks who's woman left them, who's tractor won't start, and who does nothing but drink cold beer? Lyrics are dumb in popular music.
- footlose_3815 3y agoPersonally i like bands with musical talent who don't brag about themselves in the music. I know the bar is pretty high lately, especially with US music... /S European progressive metal is really fucking awesome, and it really sets the standard for modern eclectic music.
- ojhughes 3y agoRock/Metal/Punk is still doing really well with no shortage of great artists. Just check out the Radio 1 Rock Show with Daniel P. Carter - nearly every week there is something new that I like
- bazoom42 3y ago> the quality has absolutely cratered You just got old. It happens to everyone, and every generation says the same thing: The music I enjoyed when I was young and impressionable was great, but all the stuff they make nowadays is crap. People were whining about how Beatles destroyed music, how rock’n’roll was just monkey noise, how crooners like Sinatra wasn’t real singing.
- the_only_law 3y agoIt’s also a sign you aren’t looking. Yeah, music is going to be trash if you’re just looking at what’s popular on the radio/TikTok/charts. Spend some time on bandcamp going through what’s been posted in your preferred genres.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoYes! One of the many joys of the internet and cheap computers is that anyone can produce music with very little upfront cost compared to before. If you trawl around through youtube videos with 100 views, obscure bandcamps, audiophile forums, niche discord and subreddits, etc, you can find all sorts of absolutely fantastic music. It obviously takes some work, but it's a lot of fun to discover as well!
- the_only_law 3y agoOh yeah, I forgot about YouTube, some of the best stuff I’ve found in recent years have been on channels that curate/promote music in particular genre. I have one for all sorts of punk genres, as well as one for doom metal and its related genres. They’re great, because they have all sorts of stuff, old and new, and help cut down on the cruft. My only complaint about bandcamp is the mobile app. As far as I can tell, there’s no way to change the sorting when you’re looking through a genre, so it’s usually filled with albums and artists I already heard years ago, but their website is much better.
- nick-of-time 3y ago
- intalentive 3y agoDigital audio killed the industry. Why buy an album when you can 1. Use Napster 2. Use Limewire or Kazaa 3. Download from FTP trading sites 4. Torrent from Pirate Bay 5. Listen on YouTube 6. Listen on Spotify Digital supply is effectively infinite so the price goes to zero. How to apply DRM to files ripped from a CD that can be compressed down to 3 MB? There are other factors, like changes in youth culture and competition from other forms of entertainment, but digital audio + distribution completely transformed the music ecosystem. In the 1990s it was possible for talented, intelligent young people to start a band and pursue music as a career because the expected return was so much higher -- not only monetarily but in cultural cachet and the excitement of the local "scene". But all that has dried up. Labels aren't giving out big advances, nurturing unknown bands, or paying for million dollar albums any more, because they won't recoup the costs like they used to. Meanwhile potential talent got a job, went to college, or stayed home and played video games. Once music lost its "goods-character", as Carl Menger would put it, all the upstream inputs -- like fancy, palatial recording studios -- withered away.
- tenebrisalietum 3y ago> all the upstream inputs -- like fancy, palatial recording studios Digital audio from the listener end had its piece, but two other trends also converged: - Digital audio from the producer end continued to advance and become cheaper. You can make pretty good recordings on a laptop with the appropriate sound interfaces now, if you have a decent soundproofed room. That is assuming your music isn't digital synth based. Studios are a thing of the past or what a person who likes to produce music calls their bedroom or basement. - People started caring about the portability of music much more than the quality of it. That trend goes as far back as the Walkman. Regarding the quality, now no one cares if the SNR of your "recording studio" can accurately record all 20-20KHz band of a pindrop from 5 miles away at delta-sigma modulated 192Kbps. If it sounds good with headphones or a car stereo it's fine. This is why MP3 was successful despite its audio quality issues.
- hulitu 3y ago> 1. Use Napster 2. Use Limewire or Kazaa 3. Download from FTP trading sites 4. Torrent from Pirate Bay 5. Listen on YouTube 6. Listen on Spotify There is one thing i learned from Warez: If you like the game, buy it.
- menacingly 3y agoI think the increasingly-impossible long slog is actually a mathematical certainty. It’s actually a mistake of the goal, in nearly every field, because it’s intrinsically contradictory. “I want to be at the top, but I don’t want to make the stuff that isn’t to my taste that the current people at the top make” There will be very few winners as the participation increases, the “winners” don’t scale nearly as aggressively as the amount of people fighting to be one do. OnlyFans, YouTube, Twitch, Music, Acting. They’re all headed to the same place. Look how intuitive it is when you apply it to something like Crypto then ask why the same logic doesn’t apply virtually everywhere.
- 999900000999 3y agoI'd argue with digital distribution there's just more of everything. Within moments I can access rap music from France, Japan, etc. This was nearly impossible just 30 years ago. In the 90s I guess I could ask an importer to sell me a French rap CD, pay 100$ for it. Etc. Or I'd probably just give up. That said mainstream music is forced to the lowest common denominator to appeal to the maximum number of people
- BurningFrog 3y agoI agree that music quality has gone down a lot, and that people don't pay much for music anymore. To me, that doesn't look far from the "home taping is killing music" prediction. It was another technology that did it, but with less money coming in, less great music did get created.