13 ms·
Abundance and scarcity are both evidenced in deep time by feast and famine qualities in the archaeological record. We believe in abundance because it happens o
by ggm 3y ago
Abundance and scarcity are both evidenced in deep time by feast and famine qualities in the archaeological record.
We believe in abundance because it happens often enough. Extreme lack of abundance causes survival bias: dead men tell no tales.
The existence of tools which demand time to make and primitive stone tool factories suggest abundance: division of labour is necessary to invest time in tool making for future benefit. There has to be a relative surplus, more food than not, less time for survival only, to make tools work.
We believe in abundance because of millennia of life experience incorrectly or not.
In modern times, most scarcity problems are supply chain not actual exhaustion, diamond mines and gold not withstanding. Rare earths aren't rare. Uranium isn't rare. We aren't running out of lithium. Erlich/Simons explores the reality of abundance in the earths crust.
Things may get expensive or hard to find from time to time but our brains are mostly tuned for optimism.
Extreme pessimism in a species is neither pleasant nor useful. Why live a life of fear, reality not withstanding? Stoicism, that's beneficial. Some hesitancy to optimism? Useful. Unremitting black depression and Calvinistic preordained hell on earth? That's jonestown by another path (Jones sold salvation in the afterlife but you know what I mean)
- hallqv 3y agoModerating optimism is overrated. Most people should make an effort to be more optimistic, due to our biological negativity bias. That will serve them better.
- ggm 3y agoYes, I do tend to agree, but on some things (AGW geohacking) I'm less sure. Mostly I agree. Maybe it's best to moderate euphoria and stick to wry humour in dark times.
- ramraj07 3y agoDo you have any academic or even non academic reference for this so called biological negativity bias? My entire life experience has been that people are too optimistic for their own good not the other way around.
- jibe 3y agoNegativity bias is pretty well researched and supported. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3652533/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3652533/
- spacebanana7 3y agoSee the loss aversion literature in economics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion
- Jommi 3y agopublic optimism being the apparent majority can still be true even if overall our decisions and inner thoughts sway to majority pessimism
- hallqv 3y agoPublic opinion definitely veers towards over-pessimism, see for example Hans Rosling book Factfullness. Here is a short summary from a psychological perspective: https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/sex-murder-and-the-meaning-life/202112/10-biases-blind-us-world-getting-better https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/sex-murder-and-the...
- cassepipe 3y agoWhich if true suggest that a slight tendency to negativity has served an evolutionary purpose: survival. It would be in line with the fact that you've noticed people who got in trouble for being overly optimistic ("too optimistic for their own good") On the other hand, you may also think that is serves little purpose in a civilized society (by which I mean a society where making a mistake/a judgment error is not punished by death by your environment) and may be a hindrance in your life. I don't have an opinion about it in general but I do think humanity is being overly optimistic about its ability to stop/tame climate change while aiming at achieving/conserving a way of life that relies on energetic abundance. It looks very much like collective denial to me. It's like hearing a addict telling he can stop tomorrow if he really wants. Let's hope I am wrong because if I am right it's not gonna be pretty, it's already not looking great.
- adrian_b 3y agoWhile your examples like rare earths, uranium and lithium are indeed among the chemical elements that are not very rare (though the differences in abundance between various kinds of rare earths are very large), any engineer should better be well aware about the natural abundances of the elements and in all new designs less abundant elements shall never be used instead of more abundant elements, unless this is really unavoidable. Some elements are indeed so abundant that they can be used without any worries, like carbon, iron, aluminum, calcium, sodium and more than a dozen others. The elements with medium abundance, like lithium, are available in quantities that are many thousand times less than the abundant elements, so even if we should be able to use enough of them to cover all our needs, if such elements would constitute e.g. one percent or more of the average composition of all the things we have, then that would mean that it is likely that they are used in quantities that are too large to be sustainable. The less abundant elements are available only in quantities that are many million times less than the abundant elements, so they should never be used without first making sure that it is impossible to substitute them. Nowadays, a lot of people all over the world have to spend a lot of work with the search of more abundant substitutes for less abundant elements. Much of this work could have been avoided if better choices had been made in the past. The reason why many bad choices have been possible is that the costs for most chemical elements that are included in a product are fake, they include only the smaller cost for mining, processing and transportation before the product is made, without adding the greater costs that would be needed for the recovery of the element from an end-of-life product and for repairing the environmental damage caused by its mining. The payment of these extra costs has been pushed into the future, when someone else will have to pay them, instead of the users of the elements mined now.
- brightball 3y agoThat’s why I’m interested in the company who is making Aluminum batteries.
- WalterBright 3y agoA few years back, a 60 Minutes segment was on a startup was making grid scale batteries out of seawater and dirt. Haven't heard anything about it since. Lithium batteries are great due to their energy/weight ratio. But grid scale batteries have no issue with size or weight, it's energy/cost that matters. And seawater/dirt is cheap as dirt (!).
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Extreme lack of abundance causes survival bias: dead men tell no tales. Not really; that would require everyone to die. But mostly famines have survivors, and their experience of the famine was not "I don't see what everyone else was complaining about".
- ggm 3y agoWithin 2 generations at most it's "OK boomer" Also, there's some evidence we forget bad memories faster than good ones. I would also point out if you survive famine or plague, you often find yourself in relative abundance. Wages rose after the black death.
- NavinF 3y ago> there's some evidence we forget bad memories faster than good ones Source?
- Izkata 3y ago> Within 2 generations at most it's "OK boomer" You got that backwards, "OK boomer" is current scarcity responding to boomers acting like the abundance of their generation is still around.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThere's actually way more 'abundance' around the Earth then 50 years ago, it's just spread out more evenly. For example, even in Cambodia there's a Rolls-Royce dealership now. And even the 50th percentile Cambodian household has the material wealth now of at least a 5th percentile US household. Those saying 'OK Boomer' are mostly just ignorant and/or frustrated because they expected to have even more wealth automatically, when that doesn't make sense anymore now that the entire world can effectively participate in the market.
- jojobas 3y agoUp until the Neolithic Revolution human population was stable, before that people were venturing out to hostile lands in search for food, as populated land couldn't carry any more. Infanticide as a population control measure was the norm, early Australian explorers recorded about 30% of children being killed and/or eaten business as usual. There is no reason to think they were unique, equilibrium with your food chain is a cruel mistress. Early stone quarries don't necessarily speak of abundance, it might have been a measure to extract more food out of existing area when time spent hunting/foraging barehanded didn't yield more food.
- defrost 3y ago> early Australian explorers recorded about 30% of children being killed and/or eaten business as usual. This seems extremely unlikely. While it is true that early European explorers of Australia were notorious for not surviving and starving en route, it is also true that very few of them, if indeed any, took children along as a form of emergency ration. Can indicate which "early Australian explorer" you're thinking of? Perhaps you're thinking of explorers commenting on indigenous behaviour? I'm not finding much on eating children in the works of Francis James Gillen & Walter Baldwin Spencer so again, perhaps you can provide a source? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Baldwin_Spencer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Baldwin_Spencer https://www.prm.ox.ac.uk/spencer-papers https://www.prm.ox.ac.uk/spencer-papers https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-1127482824/findingaid https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-1127482824/findingaid
- jojobas 3y agoSure. https://quadrant.org.au/magazine/2021/12/infanticide-in-traditional-aboriginal-society/ https://quadrant.org.au/magazine/2021/12/infanticide-in-trad... https://sci-hub.se/https://www.jstor.org/stable/40330368 https://sci-hub.se/https://www.jstor.org/stable/40330368
- defrost 3y agoGood on you for the reply and the two sources, have an upvote for engaging :) Quadrant Well, there's your problem - it's not a science or anthropology journal it's an unabashedly conservative wank fest for overly educated private school chums that utterly hate the proles and Australian aborigines. > According to University of Michigan professor of anthropology Aram Yengoyan: Who has spent how much time in Australian aboriginal societies? > Contemporary European observers of nomadic, tribal Aborigines were in apparent agreement that about 30 per cent of new-born Aboriginal children were routinely killed. Again, no surprises there - there's an extremely long list of things that early European observers agreed upon about aborigines ... and most of them were garbage, worthless save as justification for having repeated massacres of local groups upset about being pushed from their lands. > According to Samuel Gason (1845–97), an early settler of the Flinders Ranges, writing of the Dieyerie tribe of the Cooper’s Creek area between South Australia and Queensland, “about thirty per cent are murdered by their mother at birth”. These are the same early settlers frequently associated with poisoning water holes and killing the very people they spent some time defaming as barbaric. The problem with all these accounts is that many aboriginal groups continued through until recent times with their traditional practices, in the Western Desert [1], far north Queensland, remote Kimberley regions (where I'm from) etc. and anthropologists didn't find much in the way of actual baby eating. What you have in the Quadrant article is a collection of all the European "Aboriginals are heathen scum" gossip of times past bundled up and presented as fact. Your second link, the paper on scihub by Collishaw (1978) is, umm, kind of long winded and noncommittal - it passively rejects the 30% figure thus: both reported that 30% of the children were killed at birth. These contrast with other reports from S.W. Australia of infrequent infanticide. and then never really commits to a frequency figure other than discussing at length the kinds of things that happened at much the same frequency in European countries at the same time - deformed children were often killed at birth, in hard times with not enough to eat weaker children would die to allow stronger children to survive. It's an odd paper that has a few sound sources (Spencer .. good source, but unsurprisingly had a strong European point of view) but largely appears to repeat a lot of settler gossip. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-30500591 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-30500591
- throwawaylinux 3y ago> The existence of tools which demand time to make and primitive stone tool factories suggest abundance: division of labour is necessary to invest time in tool making for future benefit. There has to be a relative surplus, more food than not, less time for survival only, to make tools work. I don't think that's really true. The species wasn't permanently on the brink of starvation such that they didn't have time to bend down and pick up a stick and use it to add to a shelter or throw at an animal, so in the very literal extreme sense we carry a surplus of energy with us. But the equation isn't necessarily much different between one person dividing their time between making tools and hunting, and a division over a slightly larger group. Efficiency improvements with primitive tools would have been large and quite immediate. Also people would have obvious and immediate specializations before any formal organization. Some would be faster, some stronger, some better climbers, some better at sharpening sticks. So there wouldn't have to be some significant build up of a surplus before pretty sophisticated tool making and division of labor would emerge, IMO.
- inglor_cz 3y agoOld European fairy-tales do mention famine and war as a backdrop. Our ancestors were perfectly used to the condition of "mostly scarcity, sometimes abundance". You are correct that extreme scarcity will kill everyone, but places where extreme scarcity actually happens (e.g. Svalbard or Atacama) were never settled in the first place. Traditionally inhabited places (prior to the Industrial Revolution) were the ones that could sustain some population indefinitely, and if the situation slowly worsened, people abandoned them and went elsewhere, instead of passively waiting for death. And they took their memories with them.
- hyperthesis 3y agoSome claim "primitive" people only needed 3-5 hours per day (https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_affluent_society https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_affluent_society), I expect perhaps less in times of great abundance. Leaving plenty of time for knapping - if that's what you want to do. IMHO abundance solves itself, as population grows past carrying capacity, leading to famine, war, conquest and death. (The cycle being eventually broken by TV then reddit). Division of labour is only necessary to create time in an economy detached from survival.
- throwuwu 3y agoAn average might come out to 5 hours a day for food but I’d bet that’s not evenly distributed and looks a lot more like extremely long days spent hunting or gathering while plants are in season separated by times of very little action while you are basically starving and rationing the food you have left. Your second statement is literally the Malthusian hypothesis which has been proven wrong repeatedly. Division of labour is a good thing. It really sucks having to do everything yourself poorly because you don’t have enough time to do it right.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoTry reading some Wengrow & Graeber to correct your understanding of anthro/archaeology
- rewmie 3y agoI feel your comment adds nothing of value. It would be interesting if you could contribute to the discussion if you had anything of value to contribute. Posting arrogant comments that boil down to a dubious homework assignment is just noise.
- throwuwu 3y agoDo they dispute that fruit only grows at certain times of year as do tubers or that animals are migratory and calve once a year? Perhaps they take issue with the entire concept of seasons?
- sudhirc 3y ago> In modern times, most scarcity problems are supply chain not actual exhaustion, diamond mines and gold not withstanding. Rare earths aren't rare. Uranium isn't rare. We aren't running out of lithium. Erlich/Simons explores the reality of abundance in the earths crust. Everything eventually becomes rare if not used judiciously. This mindset of unlimited supply is flawed. It leads to the eventual destruction. Probably that's why most ancient civilizations had rules to only take what's needed from the nature. For example in Western Countries, crabs and lobsters were once seen as "poor man's food". They are now a gourmet luxury item.
- zosima 3y agoFor many commodities the opposite relation is true. Only when the commodities are used in a high enough quantity is there enough incentive to really try to create as much of them as possible. I don't think lobster is more scarce these days, than it was in the past. Rather the opposite.
- sudhirc 3y agoThis paper disagrees with you. https://academic.oup.com/icesjms/article/72/suppl_1/i7/620442 https://academic.oup.com/icesjms/article/72/suppl_1/i7/62044...
- defrost 3y agoEvidence of lobster use comprises midden remains, artwork, artefacts, writings about lobsters, and written sources describing the fishing practices of indigenous peoples. I can't be the only one that loves a massive untouched midden pile. +1 for your paper.
- zosima 3y agoNo it doesn't. It claims overfishing in many areas. Not a decline in lobster.
- sudhirc 3y ago
- bamfly 3y ago> We believe in abundance because of millennia of life experience incorrectly or not. It's only not been near-universal to experience at least one severe famine that kills many people you know, in a full human lifespan, in the Western and (relatively—this goes back a while) developed world, since like 1600 (thanks, potatoes and corn!). Even then, wasting away hungry for entire seasons was still something you were pretty likely experience a few times. Only industrial nitrogen production mostly ended that. Luckily, malaria and cholera and such kept the number of mouths to feed in check, LOL. The past was horrible.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe US was the first country to eliminate the specter of famine around 1800. Thanks to free markets.
- viewtransform 3y agoFree markets and the labour of 1/5th the population working in slavery.
- User23 3y agoSlavery is a great evil, then, now, and forever. Nevertheless, antebellum American plantation slavery, where the overwhelming majority of persons in chattel bondage were held, was focused on cash crops like tobacco and cotton, and not on feeding the populace.
- viewtransform 3y agoSlaves were used to grow rice (South Carolina, Georgia), sugarcane (Louisiana), corn (Virginia, to Mississipi), wheat, and vegetables (sweet potatoes, beans, okra, collard greens, squash, cabbage etc) They were used in cattle ranching and hog husbandry. They worked as butchers and meat processors. In places like the Chesapeake Bay region enslaved individuals were involved in oyster harvesting and processing.
- cassepipe 3y agoThe single reason we live in a world where scarcity problems are supply chains issues is because of fossil fuels. Stuff does not extract itself, stuff does not move by itself, remove fossil fuels from the equation and the whole civilization you've come to know, love and also hate, crumbles. Current limitations : - Using that almost free energy from the ground changes our environment in a way that threatens our survival (which will have to rely on even more energy expenditure) - What happens when we run out ? (Actually it's more about spending more and more energy for disminishing returns) - Do we have enough to make the transition to renewables/nuclear while shielding ourselves for the currently happening global warming ?
- cryptonector 3y agoWith the development of shale oil and gas, the U.S. now has hundreds of years' worth of proven natural gas reserves. The end of oil has been predicted for 60 years and it's never come. It will come some day, but right now it looks like we're very far from exhausting shale oil.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoYeah just ignore the planet overheating
- SpiritualGuide 3y agoRight direction, but it's much more basic than that. Organisms have a tendency for both abundance and scarcity because both have existed throughout our evolutionary history going back to single-celled organisms or even before... and will continue to exist for as long as we exist. It's part of the optimization of resource consumption for survival.