5 ms·
The entire idea behind technical analysis is that it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. The more people believe in a certain rule, the more that rule turns out to be
by amelius 3y ago
The entire idea behind technical analysis is that it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. The more people believe in a certain rule, the more that rule turns out to be true.
It might work that way with astrology too, but it's not so clear.
- raincole 3y agoAstrology would be a self-fulfilling prophecy if enough people took it seriously. For example if everyone agreed on that Gemini means good at science and Leo is good at art, the whole education system would be designed around this belief and it would hugely impact how children think of their own potential.
- azalemeth 3y agoThere's a very good episode of The Orville essentially based on this premise in disguise and it goes as horribly wrong as you think it would. Humans would totally do this. If anything, I'm pleased by the fact that we don't do it quite as much as we could...
- lisper 3y agoI wrote a blog post about exactly this about three years ago: https://blog.rongarret.info/2020/09/can-facts-be-racist.html https://blog.rongarret.info/2020/09/can-facts-be-racist.html
- antognini 3y agoThere is a good example of this in Ancient Rome. By around the time of Augustus Romans were fervent believers in astrology. One of the most notable cases of astrology becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy has to do with the death of the emperor Domitian. An astrologer named Asclation had earlier predicted that Domitian would die on September 18, 96 AD, and Domitian's enemies used this as a sort of nucleation point to organize his assassination. So although the date was made up, it had the effect of focusing the efforts of the assassins on a particular date, and they were successful in assassinating him on September 18. The full story that survives probably has some embellishments, but is entertaining. As the day approached Domitian became increasingly nervous. On September 17, he called Asclation before him and asked him if he stood by his prediction. Asclation said he did. Domitian then asked Asclation how Ascaltion himself was to die. Asclation responded that the stars said that he would die by being torn apart by dogs. Domitian then had an idea, and condemned him to death by burning. Asclation was immediately led to a public square, tied to a stake, and a bonfire was built underneath him. Not long after being lit, however, it suddenly began raining and the downpour quenched the flames. In the wet mess, Asclation's stake tipped over and a pack of dogs found him and devoured him. This development naturally did not put Domitian's mind at ease. The next day he became a nervous wreck. Around noon, he asked an attendant what time it was. The attendant, who was part of the conspiracy, lied and said that it was an hour later. Seeing that the danger had passed, Domitian relaxed and decided to take a bath. As he was about to go out, an official rushed in and asked for his signature on some documents. The official appeared to have an injury to his arm, but this official was also in on the conspiracy, and his sling concealed a dagger. When he got close to the emperor he stabbed him to death.
- arvinsim 3y agoI think our current society is doing this by segragating people to classifications like "jocks" and "nerds".
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoChinese "sign years" are a good example where it seems not to shake out. There's a 12-year cycle between repeating signs, but it doesn't seem that every 12 years you get whole cohorts of specifically intelligent/kind/diligent/cunning/lazy/science-loving/humanities-oriented/whatever children in a given school year, which will nearly universally be composed of only two star signs (Chinese New Year falling about halfway into the school year). It's even more obvious on the 60-year "element-animal" cycle that the world doesn't go 3 generations between people having "fire dragon" or "earth horse" characteristics. It'd be hard to hide such statistical effects on an yearly interval, whereas the Western zodiac hides its predictive failures by not having signs that are commonly stratified into different groups.
- LesZedCB 3y agoor as the classic joke Zizek likes to tell > you ask some parents about santa clause. they say we are athiests, but we pretend to believe in santa clause to make our child happy. then you ask the child about santa clause, and they say i pretend to believe to make my parents happy.
- nine_k 3y agoIf the Santa Clause is null and void in your belief system, other Clauses, including the Presents Clause, remain in force to the fullest extent possible.
- trashtester 3y agoInstead of intruducing "Presents Clause", I think you can extend the "Santa Claus" concept to have several layers of meaning. Presents is one of those layers, but there is also tradition, coziness, familiarity, excitement and playfulness. While some kids may become very vocal about it when they suddenly stop believing in Santa Claus as a literal being, they children (and adults) can continue enjoying him for as long as they're not embarrased by it. Having a small child in the family believing (or pretending to believe) can be a way for everyone else to enjoy him. And some families continue to have him even when nobody believes. The same is sometimes true about religions. People can continue to value them even if they stop believing in the literal Sky-Father.
- nine_k 3y agoMy formulation makers fun of typical commercial license agreements. I can see how Santa Claus can live as a fairy tale, with small kids playing with the idea of the entire thing being somehow real, the same way as Goldilocks or Bambi. This is indeed cute, unless taken too seriously. It's quite a bit harder with religions: they are not a once-a-year pleasantry, but are things that shape your entire view of the world and the way of life. A faintest idea that they are but a cute tale is literally a destruction of a worldview, a catastrophe instead of a mild disappointment. Knowing, say, Christianity or Islam as a cute tale only works for people who never were believers.
- trey-jones 3y agoIt's definitely not the entire idea. It plays a part, but that's just human psychology. The same reason that round numbers tend to act as support and resistance. These rules are not mystical; they are provable. There are a lot of metrics in Technical Analysis, and most of them I know nothing about. Technical Analysis doesn't claim to know the future (only the liars and fools), but embraces efficient market theory, which is about the present.
- whimsicalism 3y agoIf there was actually tradeable alpha in technical analysis it would have been arbitraged away a long time ago.
- imnotlost 3y agoThere is a well-worn joke in the economics profession that involves two economists – one young and one old – walking down the street together: The young economist looks down and sees a $20 bill on the street and says, “Hey, look a twenty-dollar bill!” Without even looking, his older and wiser colleague replies, “Nonsense. If there had been a twenty-dollar lying on the street, someone would have already picked it up by now.”
- whimsicalism 3y agoReplace the twenty dollar with the tens of millions at minimum if basic technical analysis (ie. dead cat bounce level stuff) is leveragable and yeah I think you have a pretty close approximation to reality: more likely you are hallucinating than you found $20 million on the street.
- jjav 3y ago> “Nonsense. If there had been a twenty-dollar lying on the street, someone would have already picked it up by now.” I don't remember too much from my finance courses in business school but one comment from the professor always stayed with me. He said that if there was any succesful pattern to trading, there are firms on wall street which can afford many orders of magnitude more brain power and compute power than you, so they will zero in on it pretty quick if it works. As soon as they do, it doesn't work anymore. Proof: Otherwise they would all be making infinite profit. Makes sense. This means any trading algorithm that can be programmed is pretty much obsolete (if it ever was any good) by the time it's working.
- whimsicalism 3y agoShort term trading is an adversarial, not cooperative, game.
- trashtester 3y agoSure. Still, it may sometimes form group dynamics, where one group is competing with another. A good example is during a short squeeze. It's kind of like a group of lions hunting a giraffe. Globally it's adverserial, but within the lion pride, it's cooperative.