9 ms·
Life on Earth didn’t arise as described in textbooks
- ezion 3y agoI'm still interested in any viable theory as to how random chemical processes are able to garner enough information in their own structure to replicate themselves. That is, Von Neumann showed us that to have a self-replicating automaton we need both the factory and the information for the factory (saved within it). We know that's what a cell is. But how do random chemical processes get there? Note: time works against chemical processes since the organic chemical compounds decay, keep that in mind when creating a hypothesis. Note 2: remember that in this case, both the factory & the information gets randomly mutated until you have a factory and information that's complex enough to error correct.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoI've always assumed it's something like the infinite monkey theorem?
- notnaut 3y agoIt’s that, but with the efficiency of violent competition to ensure things develop more coherently.
- micromacrofoot 3y agohmm right, so while the monkey needs infinite time... in reality there's a feedback loop that rewards the "correct" output
- notnaut 3y ago“Punishes” the “incorrect” output, more commonly.
- JD557 3y agoVery uninformed guess: couldn't you just have a factory with information of a different factory, with information of a different factory, with...? While the original factory is not self-replicating, if you reached a fix point you would get a self-replicating factory
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThis is starting to sound like Java...
- _uhtu 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis "The prevailing scientific hypothesis is that the transition from non-living to living entities on Earth was not a single event, but a process of increasing complexity involving the formation of a habitable planet, the prebiotic synthesis of organic molecules, molecular self-replication, self-assembly, autocatalysis, and the emergence of cell membranes. Many proposals have been made for different stages of the process." You can always start your search on matters like this on Wikipedia.
- ezion 3y ago[flagged]
- dotnet00 3y agoAre you suggesting that you aren't made of chemical compounds?
- _uhtu 3y agoIf that's the case on earth then life would be impossible, no? The sun provides constant low entropy energy to the planet that fuels chemical reactions. We see this support life starting at the bottom of the food chain, plants etc, which then supports the rest of life. That works the same way, providing energy for chemical reactions that build things by harvesting the energy. Like plants do, just with simple molecules.
- AstralStorm 3y agoAdditionally a lot of energy has been buffered in the rock itself as heat and not quite simple minerals. Underwater heat vents are solid candidates for abiogenesis.
- postmodest 3y agoYou keep saying that last part and it's meaningless. The Sun (and sometimes the earth itself) provides energy to the system, and we're talking about a billion years to go from "churning precursors in a hot soup" to "replicating molecular machines". I mean, what's your alternative theory? The Abrahamic God?
- RobertRoberts 3y agoI tried writing code to simulate the "Monkey's typing on a keyboard === Shakespeare" concept. It was a simple "hello world", and then with only the characters needed for the program. I didn't see it spit out any usable code when I played with it. But even if it had, it still wasn't able to run without my code existing already... (and the environment I coded it in)
- tiborsaas 3y agoA closer analogy would have been generating machine code directly.
- ezion 3y agoNow imagine that at every time step you also flip bits randomly on your own code. That's what needs to be done to achieve what was achieved.
- EnergyAmy 3y agoAre you coming at this from a creationist point of view? That's common rhetoric I heard when I was growing up. You'll need to jettison that entire way of thinking, it's built on faulty analogies like "the probability of shuffling a deck of cards into a certain arrangement is astronomically small, therefore evolution couldn't happen!" If you're actually interested in learning and not just sealioning, IMO this is a great resource: https://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/ https://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/ There's a section specifically on abiogenesis: https://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/list.html#CB0 https://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/list.html#CB0 To answer your initial question, it's really difficult to mentally grasp the scales involved with this. Billions of years, quadrillions of watts of power from the sun, some astronomically large number of chemical interactions happening simultaneously all over the early Earth. These numbers throw off one's naive sense of scale. The basic recipe of "hydrogen + time" will produce some very interesting results, however. Eventually we'll reach the heat death of the universe, or some other sort of end[1], but until then all the matter and energy bouncing around will get up to some cool stuff. [1]: Good reading here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe
- technothrasher 3y ago> random chemical processes You're begging the question here. How do you know it was random and not inevitable?
- HelloNurse 3y agoChemical processes are random because they consist of events that happen when atoms and other things randomly interact with one another as they move around and transition between states. What would it mean for a chemical process to be "inevitable"? Merely that it has a very high probability of happening?
- akasakahakada 3y agoMe feels like the usage of "inevitable" is to try to push the discussion toward religious and god or something like that.
- wredue 3y agoMaybe not. When we look at the evidence, it seems like life began pretty much as soon as it could have as the earth cooled. It could be that life starting on planets like ours basically just happens as a byproduct of the planet building.
- pfdietz 3y agoOr, it means that the conditions under which life could arise are not persistent. Life either originated quickly or it would not originate at all. For example, if life originated in a small warm planetesimal, it only had maybe 10 million years before the short lived radioactivity in the early solar system (which we know was there from the decay products) died away and the planetesimals froze.
- technothrasher 3y agoNo, not at all. It was to try to push the discussion toward questioning our ability to predict the probability of life arising. The "random" argument is typically an argument from incredulity, "how could random processes make such a specific thing? The probability is astronomically small." But with only one universe observed, and only one instance of life observed within that one universe, we don't have any way to say that random processes just accidentally formed life vs the probability that it is likely, or even inevitable, that life would form given the properties of the universe. Adding a god to the discussion doesn't really advance anything at all, honestly. It just explains the mystery with a bigger mystery, so it doesn't explain anything.
- donutdan4114 3y agoSurvival of the fittest, in relation to atomic structures. https://medium.com/@clay.c.edgar/the-basic-building-blocks-of-life-my-analogy-for-evolution-281cbd019974 https://medium.com/@clay.c.edgar/the-basic-building-blocks-o...
- Enginerrrd 3y agoI think the only necessary ingredient for life is sloppy self-replication. I'd have to look at von Neumann's proof but the theoretical assumptions may not all be valid. On that note, I'm curious about quasi crystals or crystals prone to substitutions in the lattice. I envision a crystallization process that occurs right on the edge between crystallizing/dissolving. Then any small unit block with some particular contaminant that is slightly more stable becomes favored by evolutionary processes and entropic ones. If such a thing is possible, and has a sufficiently high upperbound on possible variations, I think you can get a lot of interesting behavior. Over a long period of time, perhaps a crystal unit block could develop that encourages more of its own creation. It's a fine line though, because usually crystallization doesn't have sufficient complexity to keep evolving, and it's usually driven more by external conditions than by local conditions in the lattice, but nevertheless, it's the most plausible bridge to life I've ever come up with.
- AstralStorm 3y agoHence why the guess is that it was clays not crystals. Clays are more complex mechanically, somewhat porous, kind of work as a prototype cell wall. Consensus is more on the side of biofilms than crystals at that point. There are relatively simple multiphase processes that can create such lipid and biological bubbles. Just check how micelles form from random hydrocarbons in water with additives. The more stable micelles would allow biofilms to form inside, and so it goes. Generally cell wall first hypothesis over RNA/peptides first. Through such a biofilm micelle only certain chemicals can get in or out. This favors particular molecules "crystallizing" (or rather polymerizing) inside such micelles.
- Enginerrrd 3y ago>Generally cell wall first hypothesis over RNA/peptides first. I've always felt that RNA was probably a very late addition to the game of life.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scop 3y agoYes! I vividly recall the moment when I realized that the emergence of life of earth wasn’t just the lucky occurrence of a cell coming into being, but a cell that could also replicate itself in a non-destructive, information-passing manner. Truly mind boggling stuff. I feel like “time” is often used to obfuscate just how incredible such a development would be, “well if given enough time, then of course we saw a cell that reproduced itself in a sustaining way that actually passed on non-corrupt information while not destroying itself.”
- knewter 3y agoI've always found "you don't understand, it took a really long time" to be an incredible copout
- bee_rider 3y agoIt might just feel that way because it is a boring answer, but boring answers are usually a good sign. We all want the emergence of life to be special, but there’s every reason to believe it was just random. You can fit some pretty unlikely events in (billions of years)*(however many planets). It is really more space, than time, I think, though. I’m actually not sure how many planets there are in the whole universe (not just the observable universe; if we happened to have sprouted up on another planet we’d just be asking this question from inside a different light cone, nothing special about ours).
- pfdietz 3y agoNo, it's a copout. The handwaving about "a long time/many planets" is very weak, when confronted with the complexity barrier between non-living matter and the simplest known system capable of Darwinian evolution. All that time, and all those planets (that we can see in the observable universe), give a number that is very small compared to the unlikelihood of just randomly surmounting this barrier.
- bee_rider 3y agoIs there an actual mathematical model of the complexity barrier that I can look up? I don’t see any reason to limit things to the observable universe. What prevents life from emerging outside of our light cone?
- arp242 3y agoImagine a molecule that can create identical copies of itself from some other molecules floating around; not by any "factory" but just by "lego mechanics". This is more or less what prions do. At some point a slightly different molecule appears which is better at converting the molecules, or perhaps they can convert other types of molecules for replication: the first evolutionary step. Perhaps some other mutation allows molecules to "harvest" the other molecules to replicate themselves: the first predators. Over time this becomes more complex; from singular molecules and proteins to lots of molecules and proteins. I don't know what Von Neumann "showed us", but IMHO it's not hard to imagine life starting from very simple and humble origins given the enormous timeframes involved (IMO the biggest challenge in understanding these sort of things is understanding just how long a million or 10 million years is, insofar we're even able to do that in the first place).
- SkyBelow 3y ago>This is more or less what prions do. I feel this is a bad example to use because prions only do so due to the existence of plenty of things as complex as prions. We would need an example that creates more complex structures out of simpler building blocks, not equally complex building blocks.
- arp242 3y agoThat's fair, but it's the best example I know of to demonstrate how this could have worked, even though it's not perfect. Happy to hear of other better examples.
- akasakahakada 3y agoCrystal can grow itself if you put it into or let it touch a solution of its own kind. I would say solid state is more complex than fluid.
- pfdietz 3y agoCrystals have very little information content, though.
- nicoco 3y agoAre you implying that the only viable theory is that of a creator god to you or do I not understand your post?
- ezion 3y agoI never implied that in my comment.
- nicoco 3y agoOK, so what is your favorite explanation then? You seem to imply /something/, maybe just be explicit about it?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Scarblac 3y agoIn his defence, just that abiogenesis sounds impossible to him doesn't necessarily mean that he has an alternative explanation.
- nicoco 3y agoAgreed. But that sounded like creationist dog whistling to me, and I'm curious why OP doesn't want to be explicit about what he thinks. Being explicit usually leads to improving the quality of a discussion IMHO.
- pfdietz 3y agoYou are exhibiting a deplorable behavior here, equating questioning of a scientific hypothesis with creationism dogwhistling. When did asking "how do we know" become forbidden in science? Convention OoL is looking entirely too dogmatic and religious for my taste.
- 3y ago
- bee_rider 3y ago> Note: time works against chemical processes since the organic chemical compounds decay, keep that in mind when creating a hypothesis. This caveat does not seems to make sense to me, the advantage of time is that you run the experiment over and over, if one particular run of the experiment fails and then the organic chemicals involved decay, that doesn’t mean time isn’t still on your side. Also keep in mind that the experiment is run on an absurd number of planets and of we can only be around to ask the question on the planet where it worked out.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoMy amateur-pop-philosophy-science way of thinking of it is that the transition from low to high entropy creates all kinds of interesting and complicated physical patterns along the way. Enough time, and the right patterns, and self-replication could emerge. But it's the externally driven 'stirring' of the low->high entropy transition that makes this possible. That is, life exists at the barrier between active and cool energy states. Sun to atmosphere/surface, hot planet core to surface/ocean. It's a (extremely complicated) product of these transitions. So it's not so much about "how can this just happen by chance" as if you think about what life actually is -- a boundary condition between two entropy states -- it makes more sense: There is a stir stick spinning (solar energy & earth's core) in a very complicated long lasting layered beverage (our earth), and life is the clouds of pretty patterns as the layers mix. The self-replication doesn't happen without that stick being stirred. It's not magic, it's just really complicated. Biochemist Nick Lane writes quite a bit about the alkaline hydrothermal vent theory and it is very compelling. I don't know (bio)chemistry well enough to fully understand it but it's something like (please people who understand this better correct me...) a) Very early earth had the 'lucky' combination of active hot core and cool (but not frozen) water covered surface. b) In addition to 'hot smokers', 'warm' (e.g. closer to cell / body temperature) vents exist and existed on the ocean floor. c) The ocean water was relatively acidic compared to now. But the warm vents had alkaline chemistry. d) The specific chemical reactions involved (hand waving here) as the warm vents mixed with the ocean created complex molecules, some organic. And some of the products produced were capsules/bubbles with 'walls' similar in structure cells. e) There's (more hand waving) reactions that can happen across the walls and molecules produced inside the 'cell-like' things. f) At some point they 'escape' the vent and its energy source. And in escaping 99.999% of them 'die', but eventually one that escapes does so in a way that it can self-sustain from other energy sources. g) At the same time at some point those proto-cells develop RNA or RNA-like processes internally such that they can reproduce It's f->g that I guess is the confusing part for me. But work is being done in the lab to try reproduce this whole process. In any case eventually the sun and earth will die, all cell machinery will stop, and entropy will have finally had its way with us. It's not a self-sustaining automaton. It requires an externally driven energy transition.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akasakahakada 3y agoWhen the thing is not just simply a molecular but work as a group, that can create some "energy potential" by itself, like attractive to water or nutrition or something. The whole idea of self evolution is not impossible.
- glitchc 3y agoThis is clearly a troll. Can we not feed the trolls, folks?
- lkj24ltkj 3y ago[flagged]
- pfdietz 3y agoIt has come to this. Asking real scientific questions is trolling.
- EnergyAmy 3y agoThey're not actually interested in the answer. It's like asking "If humans evolved from monkeys, why are there still monkeys?!" You explain what a common ancestor is but it doesn't matter because they've already moved on to another bad faith question and aren't listening. There's real interesting questions to ask here, you're right. They're not getting asked in this thread, though.
- pfdietz 3y agoThis is a convenient excuse for not answering the question. No, science doesn't excuse you if you decide the question wasn't answered in good faith. That's because if your theory cannot answer a question like that, it's a bad theory, regardless of the motivation of the person asking the question. What's I see here is people defending conventional OoL as a kind of quasi-religion, with dogma that does not need to be experimentally demonstrated and must not be questioned. I treat all religions with disdain, including yours.
- deadbeeves 3y agoThis isn't a place to make formal scientific inquiry, and that's not the way to ask scientific questions formally. The way to do that is to write a paper to a journal citing findings that appear to contradict whatever hypothesis is in dispute. If you ask a question about science to a random person on the Internet they're entirely within their right to say "I don't think you actually want to learn something you don't know, I think you're asking your question to put forward an argument that I've seen many people before you put forward and that I'm tired of hearing, and therefore I'm not going to humor you by answering your question", until you convince them that talking to you isn't a complete waste of time.
- ly3xqhl8g9 3y agoUntil a synthetic agent will be here we can only guess. The current best guesses seem to have to do with the free energy principle, active inference, Markov blankets [1]. It might be just that simple: it's what happens when some proton gradient reduces ferredoxin [2]. Also related [3]. [1] On-going series of lectures, "Physics as Information Processing" - Chris Fields Lecture 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpOrRw4EhTo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpOrRw4EhTo Lecture 2 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WkWIqpxWRM4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WkWIqpxWRM4 Lecture 3 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOZp_XNYijQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOZp_XNYijQ [2] "How does chemistry come alive?" - Nick Lane, Alkaline hydrothermal vents at 18:44, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmvS7tgvy6U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmvS7tgvy6U TL;DW at 52:00 "How does chemistry come alive? It happens when a focused, sustained environmental disequilibrium of H2, CO2, and pH across a porous structure that lowers kinetic barriers to reaction continuously forms organics that bind and self-organize into protocells with protometabolism generating catalytic nucleotides which promote protocell growth through positive feedbacks, favouring physical interactions with amino acids, a nascent genetic code where RNA sequences are selected if they promote protocell growth so genetic information has meaning from the beginning" [3] "Origins of the RNA-Protein World – Lost in Translation?" - John Sutherland, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSjIDStlZg8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSjIDStlZg8
- ivanhoe 3y agoIt's hard to go beyond: "Even highly unlikely events will happen occasionally if you let the system run long enough".
- spywaregorilla 3y agoHow about fire?
- Schroedingers2c 3y agoEven if the probability for this to succeed is really really small, there's a good chance it will happen when you have billions of years time and idk how many orders of magnitude (10^40? 10^50?) of atoms/molecules constantly interacting.
- pfdietz 3y agoNo, that's not clear at all. The smallest known system capable of independent existence and Darwinian evolution has billions of atoms. A mere 40 or 50 orders of magnitude is trivial compared to the unlikelihood of this arising by chance.
- picometer 3y agoThe replies to this comment are zoning in on the epistemological dilemma it poses. Soliciting theories for one of the most difficult scientific puzzles, on HN of all places: do you expect someone to serve you up a neatly-wrapped viable and plausible mechanistic theory? And yet, I think it’s a serious comment, not a troll, because this is the right epistemic stance. We don’t know how life emerged yet and this is rightly uncomfortable. As for the object-level topic: I’d direct my attention to any research that investigates the relationship between the cell wall and the inner organelles. I suspect that the viability of the cell factories was dependent on its co-evolution with the cell wall, which, by creating a semi-closed (permeable) system, would change the entropic conditions inside the cell.
- User23 3y agoWe don’t even have a good grasp on what life is! Try to get an explanation of why a living thing is alive, but when it dies despite having the same observable material condition its corpse is not alive. I’ve yet to hear anything beyond the most obvious begging of the question; it’s always some variation on living things are alive because they have life processes and nonliving things aren’t because they don’t. And what’s a life process? Well it’s a process that occurs in living things of course.
- deadbeeves 3y agoI'll take a stab at it: a multicellular organism dies when the processes that are able to sustain the operation of the cell community cease, thus causing the individual cells to die individually or to live as single-celled organisms in the wild for a short while. The main processes that are essential to the life of an organism as a whole are the supply of nutrients and oxygen, the elimination of waste, and the coordination of various support activities between different groups of cells in the body. They're essential because most of the cells have delegated the capacity to perform these functions to the organism, allowing an increase in efficiency at the cost of tying their survival to the survival of the organism. A cell dies when it's damaged mechanically or chemically, or when it's unable to sustain its metabolism thus causing chemical damage, or when its programming instructs it to destroy itself for whatever reason.
- marcinzm 3y ago>Note: time works against chemical processes since the organic chemical compounds decay, keep that in mind when creating a hypothesis. The question is how quickly do they decay in a sterile environment. A virus which has no active mechanism for preventing decay can last for days. RNA can have half lives measured in days. That's a lot of time and I'm sure there's more stable variants but in modern times stability is not a prime concern for organic molecules.
- rmasters 3y agoI found this video to be quite informative and addresses a relationship between the information incorporated into a chemical process and its function. Nobel laureate Jack Szostak from University of Chicago delivered the Eyring General Lecture on March 17, 2023 at Arizona State University. "The Origin of Life: Not as Hard as it Looks?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLzyco3Q_Rg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLzyco3Q_Rg
- pfdietz 3y agoLooks like a good application of Betteridge's Law.
- pdonis 3y agoLife didn't start as cells. It started as "naked" self-replicating molecules with no supporting infrastructure. Think a virus without its protective protein coat. Cells only came along much later, because they are much harder to evolve. We already know that an energy input, such as solar energy, to a large collection of simple molecules like methane and ammonia can produce the building blocks of life: amino acids and nucleotides. Once a short chain of nucleotides is formed, it will (slowly) replicate itself by attracting other nucleotides in the environment. That's all the original "life" on Earth consisted of. The simple chains of nucleotides were both "factory" and "information". We don't know all the specific steps that life took between those first simple replicators and cells. We may never know for sure because data left over from that time is so sparse. But that's not the same as not having a viable theory. We have that.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat's a good story, but is there any evidence for it? We know simple building blocks can be created, in low concentrations, with large amounts of other components that don't end up in life. The concentration of any given chemical in this mix is exponentially dependent on its complexity. The "once a short chain is formed, it will (slowly) replicate" is entirely unsupported by experiment. Indeed, it's difficult to see how it could work, when it's replicating in a soup loaded with junk monomers.
- Sosh101 3y agoI think Von Neumann suggested what might be needed to engineer a complex self-replicating system. He didn't suggest a process that might incrementally lead to that though (abiogenesis in the case of biological life), which might be able to rely on simple chemical behaviors to start accumulating complexity.
- GuB-42 3y agoIf it is random, and the universe is infinite, as we assume it to be, it will happen somewhere, an infinity of times, no matter how unlikely the event is. There should be exact copies of you popping into existence somewhere from quantum fluctuations alone. Current studies are about finding the most likely pathway, rather than knowing whether of not it is possible. We know it is possible because we are here. As for the technical details, look up "abiogenesis" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis )
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- specialist 3y ago> able to garner enough information "Garner" is perfect here, thank you. > But how do random chemical processes [make the leap from molecules to cells]? Ya, that's a kicker. Another mind bender for me is the concept of "self". When some collection starts to prefer their own company over others. That boundary (or barrier or affinity or homophily or whatever) between "me" and "not me".
- deadbeeves 3y agoChemical processes are not random, at least not in the way you're using the word. When you mix a base and an acid it's not subject to a roll of the dice whether they will neutralize or not. If you pour oil into water there's not a small chance that this one time they will dissolve into each other. >We know that's what a cell is. But how do random chemical processes get there? Work backwards. Think of the simplest cell you can. Now remove the membrane and the little molecular machines are free to wander in the medium arbitrarily far away from each other. The chemical processes are still happening, but they just take a long time to finish. All you need is for the abiotic medium to contain at least one of every of those molecules to have a sort of diffuse protolife.
- RupertEisenhart 3y agoRecommend this paper[0] that discusses the 'infinite monkeys' version methodically. [0]: https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1304/1304.3381.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1304/1304.3381.pdf
- lern_too_spel 3y agoThe same way Christianity and Islam became prevalent. Pre-scientific people made up many stories about the universe. The ones that spread the farthest are the ones that replicate, by killing and converting opposition like these religions have. Similarly, many compounds have randomly formed that exhibit parts of what we call life. The ones that exist in noticeable quantities are the ones that successfully replicate.
- uoaei 3y ago"Life === multi-cellular organisms" is also a rather antiquated take on the matter. This headline is misleading. In fact we don't even have a solid definition of "life", which leads to multivarious hypotheses on how the various stages arose. The subject of the article itself is interesting, I just wish science writers were more precise in their language to reflect the precision and specificity of the scientific hypotheses being explored.
- hotstickyballs 3y agoDo you have a better definition?
- lazide 3y agoI’m guessing that he’s asking that they write down/define the definition explicitly that they’re using in articles like this so we have some idea what they’re advocating for or testing/exploring exactly.
- adr1an 3y agoI was about to complain on the title too. They say that a theory is being challenged on how life on earth started and then all of a sudden in the first 2 paragraphs jump a couple million (if not billion) years straight to multicellular organisms. I didn't read any more, I do hope they started discussing how multicellularity arose and only the title was amiss.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoConsider the authors of papers and studies don't write the articles and headlines. The headline is written as a click-hook, to get PR, because, well "publish or perish" and that's how the funding comes in. It sucks, but also if you just published the paper with a dry summary, it would also get ignored. Also, the bias is old. "Eukaryote" means "true cell"! It's right in the name, this bias about what "real" life is. Of course it's our anthropocentrism, I guess, but... I also think, on the broader point about abiogensis... it's quite likely that the cosmos is rather full of things that look like our prokaryotes. But eukaryotes and complicated multicellular life is either going to be extremely rare or non-existent within anything observable in, say, our galaxy. I say this because prokaryotes arose almost as soon as the earth cooled and developed a liquid ocean, and have been here almost as long as the planet. But eukaryotes have only been here for maybe 15% of the planet's existence or less, and seem to have basically arisen as kind of a 'fluke' event, and only once, and seem to have something to do with the very particulars of cell energy dynamics, mitochondria, and the fusion of archaeobacteria and bacteria, etc. Just really weird stuff. Putting it yet another way... prokaryotes have existed for almost the entire life of our planet, compose most of the life and biomass of the planet, and shape it in its most fundamental ways but are much the same as when they started, because they have rather strong intrinsic physical limits on energy and complexity. So, yes, life != multicellular organisms, but maybe it might turn out that eukaryotic and/or multicellular life is the only real "interesting" kind of life from the most broad perspective.
- silvestrov 3y agoTLDR: multicellular organisms appeared [when] Earth’s oxygen concentrations ... remained 5-10 times lower than today So multicellular organisms came before high oxygen levels.
- pastage 3y agoSidenote I think it is refreshing that there seems to be so much collaboration between Lund in Sweden and Danish institutions like this. This is the third time a Danish paper on HN mentions Lund. I have no insight in why it is like that.
- capableweb 3y agoThanks to the bridge between the countries, it's only like a one hour car ride between the two universities. Both of them are also part of the region Øresund/Öresund which has lots of collaboration between the two countries, because of the proximity between the two. Jokingly called "Greater Copenhagen Region" sometimes as the pull on the region from Copenhagen is stronger than the pull from the Swedish counterpart Stockholm.
- soup10 3y agoMany textbooks and scientific resources describe phenomena from hundreds of millions of years ago as "indisputable facts", this include everything from the origins of life on earth, to the big bang theory, what happens in black holes, formation of the solar system and galaxy, how geology has evolved and many more. Additionally they make pseudoscientific predictions about exactly when and what will happen millions of years in the future. For instance the sun will turn into a red giant in "approximately 5 billion years". I don't know why they try to pass off so many theories as facts, probably a bunch of science politics combined with hubris and unwillingness to admit what we don't know.
- akasakahakada 3y agoBecause we have theories and proofs for those theories. Others like "god created the world" or something have nothing to support them. Therefore those are currently being viewed as facts as long as there is no alternative theory and proof. You can't say that "but we will find disproving material in the future so this is not fact". If this kind of argument is valid, I can also say that "you will be wrong anyway in the future so you are just wrong all the time". Do not use future to determine today.
- noSyncCloud 3y agoSince you're obviously such an expert in all these fields that you can confidently assert that none of them know what they're talking about, why don't you link to some of your published papers where you prove that the accepted theories and analyses are wrong? If you're going to insult and denigrate entire fields of research, I think you should put your money where your mouth is.
- moh_maya 3y agoStellar lifecycle models are based on a combination of theoretical physics, experimental physics results that set bounds on (in a way) the theoretical predictions, and mathematical modeling - all of which is also validated through observational physics of stars that are, actually, at the red giant stage, and sampling stars at the intermediary stages - based on actual observations. Armed with all of this data, and working on an assumption that current ‘laws’ of physics will continue to apply in the future, scientists can make reasonably confident predictions. Similar approach, though admittedly with far less mathematical modeling, is also the case in biology. Even textbooks and scientific resources have to assume, at some point, that we start with a framework of axioms. But most science textbooks also first introduce the idea of models, hypothesis and the notion that a ‘law’, is only as good as the most recent experiment that supports it - and that the scientific method requires us to discard or amend the ‘law’ if new evidence contradicts its predictions. To keep repeating this foundational idea every step of the way seems tedious - it’s reasonable to treat gravity on earth as a fact in the face of overwhelming observational evidence, for instance. I don’t see how any of this reflects hubris and unwillingness to admit what we don’t know. For instance, as an (ex-)biologist, I completely agree we do not have a good model for consciousness; or that we simply don’t have a solid functional model of a cell that allows us to model and predict its behaviour at detail and with all its complexity - we are still, in fact, discovering layers of complexity and nuance. But there are some things we do understand well. Same in physics - the search for a Grand Unifiying Theory continues. ‘Dark matter’, as I understand it, is an acknowledged proxy for many things we don’t yet understand. So..not sure I agree with your position :)
- lifefeed 3y ago"Prehistoric sea creature of the Cambrian period. Photo: Getty"
- junglistguy 3y ago[dead]
- postmodest 3y agoI am surprised by how many commenters seem to be anti-scientific comments or crypto-creationist arguments. This is one study covering a form of life that was largely replaced during the Cambrian explosion, and took place right after massive glaciation , while the environment was very different to today, or even the Cambrian epoch. The main point of the study is that Oxygen levels may have been lower than thought, which isn't "a problem for science" because "science" isn't even sure if the many fossils from that period were animals (and would require higher oxygen levels). And for people here who didn't read the article: this isn't about the origins of _cellular_ life, or even multicellular life. Multicellular life had been around for tens of millions of years. And life itself had been around for billions. This study asks "are we wrong about how much O2 COMPLEX life requires?" And we may be, Because the ediacaran had different life forms than we have now after the Cambrian explosion.
- skrebbel 3y agoWhich commenters are you referring to? You piqued my interest but nobody said stuff like “a problem for science” as far as I can tell. EDIT: this wasnt meant as a jab. I’m not well read in this topic so it’s hard for me to detect the “crypto creationists”.
- gilleain 3y agoLikely 'ezion' below, given various references to 'information' which is often a focus of Intelligent Design advocates. Also it's an odd coincidence, but there is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezion-Geber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezion-Geber - a city only mentioned in the Bible...
- swayvil 3y agoMaybe it's all determinism and noise, except for humans. Humans get intelligence. Or maybe it's intelligence all the way down. A thousand different shapes and sizes of memory, logic, communication, etc. All the way down to cells and beyond. I like the second theory.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoI prefer the first one. If your theory is true that means theres a greater enteligence, a greater plane of being. This is not good.
- flanked-evergl 3y agoWhy does science journalism always have to involve misleading or wrong headlines :/ This article is not about the origin of life any more than a book about childbirth is about the origin of life.
- specialist 3y agoMy noob understanding of this article: Multi-cellular life split into plants and animals ~800myo, during the Avalon Explosion. Science has long assumed high concentration of oxygen predates animals. But researchers have now determined that oxygen levels were far lower than thought necessary when evolution of animals started to really take off. So now we must come up with new theories for origins and evolutionary explosion of animals.
- lkj24ltkj 3y ago[flagged]
- lkj24ltkj 3y ago[flagged]
- mint2 3y agoThis comment makes zero sense whatsoever… in the small small chance this was posted by an actually misguided person rather for reactions: Without humans the moon still would have existed, bound by gravity in an orbit that can be described by what is called math. Discovering and naming a concept does not mean creating it. Antarctica was not created by the person who saw and named it, neither did the first person to try to measure the circumference of a circle decide that it should be 3.14 times the diameter. Whether or not it was measured and named it would still be the same ratio.
- flangola7 3y agoIt seems self evident that math does not need a specific species of ape to exist.
- lkj24ltkj 3y agoObligatory video of Dr. Tour 'debating' a reddit youtuber: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvGdllx9pJU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvGdllx9pJU Hilarious introductions.
- hackeraccount 3y agoLife from an inorganic is tricky. Judging from the timeline though going from eukaryotes to procaryotes is weirdly just as tricky if not more so. I mean - eukaryotes showed up after life had been on earth for 1 - 1.5 billion years. Procaryotes showed up almost right after the Earth could conceivably supported life at all. That's always struck me as really weird. It also makes me think if we ever find alien life we're probably going to be disappointed.