4 ms·
It's great to see this getting more attention. User-agent discrimination (i.e. "go away if you're not using the latest version of Chrome") needs to become illeg
by userbinator 3y ago
It's great to see this getting more attention. User-agent discrimination (i.e. "go away if you're not using the latest version of Chrome") needs to become illegal. As long as I'm not overloading your service or similar, what hardware or software I use must not be restricted. The same goes for other deliberate obstacles to accessibility and interoperability --- creating a "standard" that's so complex and churned frequently enough that only Google can implement it and keep up with changes, and then spreading propaganda to encourage all sites to essentially become Chrome-only regardless of their actual utility, is something that needs to be stopped.
I recommend finding everyone responsible for this and exercising your right to free speech on them. It works for politicians, and it should work on this other flavour of bastard too.
Once again, Stallman was very prescient: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
- TylerE 3y agoWhy shouldn't the owner/operator of a website be able to decide who to sling bits to? How is this, conceptually, any different from sites that used to block IE out of spite?
- userbinator 3y agoHow is this, conceptually, any different from sites that used to block IE out of spite? I don't agree with doing that either, but whereas things like changing UA headers/page-rewriting proxies would easily get around that sort of discrimination, this is now cryptographically secure. Governments are scared of encryption because it could be used against them. The population should've realised the same could also apply to them, because it is now actually happening.
- dhx 3y agoFor the same reasons a shop owner must sell to all customers without discriminating on ethnicity, religion, disability, etc? Would it be acceptable for a website owner to block users from Detroit (78% African Americans)[1] or block users from El Paso (82% Hispanic)[2] because the website owner claims that fraudulent ad clicking is more prevalent from those cities? Would it be acceptable to only serve web pages to people without disabilities and without a need for specialist accessibility software because it's not economically viable to consider users with disabilities? Would the poorest 10% of the population be able to access web pages and services delivered over the Internet with old hardware (all they can afford) and with limited computer literacy and limited ability to raise complaints (that are ignored anyway or responded to by an AI algorithm that doesn't care)? A website owner is still discriminating when they hide behind technology such as AI algorithms, Web Integrity APIs, etc and pretend that their use of such technology is non-discriminatory. [1] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/detroitcitymichigan,MI/PST045222 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/detroitcitymich... [2] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/elpasocitytexas,elpasocountytexas/PST045222 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/elpasocitytexas...
- archerx 3y agoI block China and Turkey from some of my websites to reduce bots and hacking attempts, does this make me a bad person for discriminating or should I have to tolerate the script kiddies, ddosing and exploit searches? I’m not defending google’s crap but I should be able to block anyone I want from my websites if I choose.
- bundie 3y ago> I block China and Turkey from some of my websites to reduce bots and hacking attempts, does this make me a bad person for discriminating or should I have to tolerate the script kiddies, ddosing and exploit searches? No.
- allarm 3y ago> does this make me a bad person for discriminating Yes. And not only for discriminating. You make the web shittier than it already is, and more fragmented. > or should I have to tolerate the script kiddies, ddosing and exploit searches? This part is unrelated to the first part.
- archerx 3y agoYes, I am the bad guy for defending my sites from being defaced and my clients private data stolen from the bad actors coming from those two countries specifically. It is totally me making the internet a shittier place. If only I had the strength and energy to unblock those countries to tolerate the unrelenting abuse and attacks so I won't be such a terrible, horrible person.
- allarm 3y ago> Yes, I am the bad guy What's the point of asking a question (...does this make me a bad person for discriminating?) if you're not ready to accept some of the answers? Yes, geoblocking totally makes the internet a shittier place. In the same way as the hackers and scriptkiddies make it the shittier place. It's a chicken and egg situation. You're blocking part of the world because it's dangerous waters. I am blocking part of the world because I disagree with the politics of that particular part. We are together making geo-blocking tolerable and acceptable. We're together making the internet more shitty than it deserves. Congratulations. By the way, I'm not sure I wouldn't have done the same thing you did. I guess if I can't properly manage the security of a resource, the easiest way to deal with it would be to eliminate the source of the attack vector. I wouldn't deny that I'm part of the problem though. Because that's exactly what I am.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 3y agoWhat if I block the latest version of Chrome, but allow the previous version? Is that allowed under your proposal?
- Avamander 3y ago> It's great to see this getting more attention. User-agent discrimination (i.e. "go away if you're not using the latest version of Chrome") needs to become illegal. UA should be fully deprecated already. It rarely achieves its goals at this point. There are better alternatives.
- judge2020 3y ago> As long as I'm not overloading your service or similar, what hardware or software I use must not be restricted. A lot of the push is not for bad actors literally DDOSing servers, but bad users degrading the service for other users. If most users of a service agrees to, for example, run an attestable environment to access a service, then that service should be able to refuse access to users who don’t buy into it.
- devsda 3y ago> If most users of a service agrees to, for example, run an attestable environment to access a service With Chrome's near monopoly in browsers, most users will run an attestable environment when chrome ships it without ever knowing and agreeing to doing so. Even if Google manages to "collect" consent, this has so much potential to adversely impact everyone(including businesses) except Google in the long term that it should not be allowed.
- judge2020 3y agoIf the customer is already running in an attestable environment, why would they disagree with attesting to that environment? > this has so much potential to adversely impact everyone(including businesses) except Google in the long term How so? It prescribes mechanisms to ensure websites don’t exclude certain browsers/OSes > To protect against both risks, we are evaluating whether attestation signals must sometimes be held back for a meaningful number of requests over a significant amount of time (in other words, on a small percentage of (client, site) pairs, platforms would simulate clients that do not support this capability). Such a holdback would encourage web developers to use these signals for aggregate analysis and opportunistic reduction of friction, as opposed to a quasi-allowlist: A holdback would effectively prevent the attestation from being used for gating feature access in real time, because otherwise the website risks users in the holdback population being rejected.
- devsda 3y ago> If the customer is already running in an attestable environment, why would they disagree with attesting to that environment? There are countless modern PCs that have secureboot enabled by default. Does that mean all their users endorse and agree with secure boot based attestation knowingly? My point is defaults cannot and should not automatically be treated as implicit consent/knowledge. Attestation will be enabled by default when Chrome ships WIE and the "majority" condition you mentioned will most certainly be true from day one. That doesn't necessarily mean that every single user of chrome is onboard and happy with WIE.
- flagrant_taco 3y ago> It's great to see this getting more attention. User-agent discrimination (i.e. "go away if you're not using the latest version of Chrome") needs to become illegal. I really hate this attempt by Google and hope they don't follow through, but why should this be illegal? Software users agent strings are just an identifier added on by a browser to give the server context, it's not a protected class. Google has every right to gate use of their software however they choose, we can just stop using it. We don't have a fundamental right to an open internet, no one owes us this. I hope we can get back to the days when the internet was much more open and less commercialized, but that day won't come by legal regulation.
- landoftheice 3y ago[dead]
- JohnFen 3y ago> User-agent discrimination At least you can spoof the user-agent string.