3 ms·
>Remember hyperloop? Remember he got kicked out of PayPal? Remember boring company? Remember solar city? One could say similar things for other well succesful
by coldtea 3y ago
>Remember hyperloop? Remember he got kicked out of PayPal? Remember boring company? Remember solar city?
One could say similar things for other well succesful businessmen:
Remember NeXT? Remember he got kicked out of Apple? Remember the G4 Cube? Remember MobileMe? Remember Ping?
- alexb_ 3y agoHey, you're finally understanding that Steve Jobs was a hack!
- marcosdumay 3y agoNot quite. He was very good on gathering a specific kind of people and organizing them to an specific kind of work. He got that very reliably. When that kind of work aligned with success, he was successful.
- CamperBob2 3y agoJust like that Alexander the Great guy. Way overrated. He didn't kill that many Persians at all, it turns out. Just sat there on a horse barking orders.
- NicuCalcea 3y agoYou're right, other businesspeople get lucky too.
- giantrobot 3y ago> Remember NeXT? Remember he got kicked out of Apple? Remember the G4 Cube? Remember MobileMe? Remember Ping? Your rebuttal doesn't really make sense. Only NeXT and getting ousted from Apple were personal events for Steve Jobs. MobileMe (now iCloud), the G4 Cube, and Ping were all initiatives of Apple as a company which was far more people than just Steve Jobs.
- city41 3y agoHe was well known for disliking fans in computers, a factor in the G4 Cube. Also a big reason why the Apple 3 was such a failure. Just saying. Overall I certainly think Steve Jobs was anything but a failure.
- mcphage 3y ago> Remember NeXT? Wasn't that the computer that the first web browser and web server were developed for and on? And a bunch of famous video games were developed on it? It was never a consumer computer company, but for its niche it was pretty successful.
- coldtea 3y agoWe're speaking about success as a business, on its business goals, not what was developed on it. If somebody wrote the "first web browser" on BeOS it make it any less of a failure as a business venture.
- mcphage 3y ago> If somebody wrote the "first web browser" on BeOS it make it any less of a failure as a business venture. Maybe if Tim Berners-Lee had, BeOS wouldn't have been a business failure. Or at least successful enough to be purchased for $400 million?
- knome 3y ago>Wasn't that the computer that the first web browser and web server were developed for and on Tim Berners-Lee invented the WWW, and wrote the first server and browser while working for CERN.
- mstade 3y agoYes, using NeXT workstations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_server#/media/File:First_Web_Server.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_server#/media/File:First_W...
- rvz 3y agoThis is about the business itself and NeXT Inc. was a commercial failure for workstation class personal computers in the market.
- zoky 3y ago> Remember NeXT? You mean the basis for Mac OS X? > Remember he got kicked out of Apple? You mean by John Sculley, who basically nobody remembers as having been associated with Apple? And then how Steve Jobs came back to Apple and led it through most of its golden years? > Remember the G4 Cube? You mean the spiritual predecessor to not only the Mac Mini, but the Intel NUC and other small form factor computing platforms? A platform that only suffered from the failing of being before its time, rather than a fundamental design flaw? > Remember MobileMe? The service that eventually transmogrified into iCloud, which, if not a driving force, can hardly be considered a minor player on the Internet today, if for no other reason than the number of @icloud.com email addresses? > Remember Ping? No, I honestly don't, but hey, not every idea can be a winner. At least Steve Jobs' bad ideas failed quietly. Compare and contrast to some of Elongated Muskrat's more… questionable business decisions, like buying Twitter for $420.69 per share just for the lulz.
- coldtea 3y ago>You mean the basis for Mac OS X? I mean the company and OS that failed to leave to Jobs expectations, company pivoted to sell the OS on PCs, failed on that too, and was only spared bunkruptcy because Apple was desperate for an OS and Jobs. The rest is meaningless retorts in the same vain, when all of the above are failed projects associated with Jobs, just like Musk has his own, which was the point.
- zoky 3y agoYou’re kind of undercutting your point by saying “Apple was desperate for an OS and Jobs.” In other words, firing Jobs was Apple’s fault, not Jobs’. Steve Jobs was exactly what Apple needed and would go on to provide exactly what they needed, only Apple under Sculley was too short-sighted to see that. If anything, getting fired from Apple was ultimately a triumph for Steve Jobs, given the benefit of hindsight. My point is that when you put Musk among the pantheon of Silicon Valley CEOs, he doesn’t especially stand out for anything except being lucky. Compare him to Bill Gates, who, for better or for worse, revolutionized computing? Or Larry Ellison, who has somehow despite the odds miraculously managed to keep Oracle afloat and somewhat relevant for decades—no mean feat indeed? Elon seems to be little more than a charming, lucky idiot. Make no mistake, charm and luck will take you far, but only so far. Sooner or later, one or the other will run out, and for Elon, it seems like he has depleted both resources at this point.
- mitchitized 3y agoI was there when Scully "took over", and can tell you from firsthand experience that Steve Jobs was the young, rebellious entrepreneur whose startup had grown far beyond his experience (or interest at the time). Scully may have been the only man in Silicon Valley with the guts to push Steve out, and Steve knew that it needed to happen. He couldn't, because Apple was his baby - he needed someone to give him that last shove. You mean NeXT, the company he sold back to Apple for $400 million dollars? I would argue that the majority of design flops from Apple in the past twenty years were more Jony Ive than Steve Jobs, based on history and design style. That said yeah not every idea the man had was rock solid, but comparing Steve Jobs to Elon Musk is laughable. Elon was wealthier than 95% of the people in the United States, the second he was born. He's been playing with a stacked deck this whole time. Whenever someone says "oh so-and-so is so successful" only two questions enter my mind: 1. where did they start? 2. how much help did they get along the way? I would argue that in Elon's case he's been successful despite himself.
- coldtea 3y ago>Elon was wealthier than 95% of the people in the United States, the second he was born. He's been playing with a stacked deck this whole time. So like 16,595,000 other US citizens?
- shagmin 3y agoJust guessing here, but I'd guess out of that ~16m US citizens, you're more likely to find people that have started a multi-billion dollar business than compared to the general population. And the other demographic that tends to be big on starting businesses are immigrants. And Elon Musk just happens to fall into both groups really.
- throwaway2990 3y agoIves fading into non existence was the best thing that happened to modern apple. He was slowly killing everything.
- tolmasky 3y ago> Remember the G4 Cube? Remember MobileMe? Remember Ping? I think it's weird to compare failed products within a company (and minor products at that) to failed companies. I think you may have not even listed some of the more notable ones (The Apple LISA, the iPod HiFi). But he wasn't betting the company on the Cube, or MobileMe, or even Ping. These were low-stakes (and arguably low effort) bets taken within a company that was simultaneously having insane success in other departments. The G4 Cube came out between the iMac and the iPod (2 years after the iMac, 1 year before the iPod). That seems like a damn good product-line, and if you could choose any one to miss on, it'd be the niche prosumer device, not the two consumer devices. > Remember NeXT? > Remember he got kicked out of Apple? These could be interpreted either way. It seems all part of the larger "Apple story arc", and more comparable to Tesla's shaky middle period, than as binary successes and failures void of any surrounding context. However, I do mean that it could go either way. I wouldn't fault someone as judging them as true failures separate from the later Apple success.