7 ms·
Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and more
- WhatWorkingOn 3y agoThanks, as a user I hate it. As a developer this is a great library to use to satisfy product.
- boomskats 3y agoThis looks great. What does it do differently to Shepherd[0]? [0]: https://github.com/shipshapecode/shepherd https://github.com/shipshapecode/shepherd
- mohamedattahri 3y agoDriver, shepherd, you probably see where this is going...
- a-ve 3y agoA similar project named BabyJesus?
- sdesol 3y agoHere's some community information regarding the two https://devboard.gitsense.com/shipshapecode/shepherd https://devboard.gitsense.com/shipshapecode/shepherd https://devboard.gitsense.com/kamranahmedse/driver.js https://devboard.gitsense.com/kamranahmedse/driver.js The popularity for driver.js has grown significantly in the past few weeks. Not sure what is the reason for it though. Full disclosure: This is my tool
- boomskats 3y agoYour tool looks great, and I was never a huge fan of shepherd. I just wanted to know the objective differences between the two, or your reasons for building it. I'd already looked at the repository stats.
- dabeeeenster 3y agoIs it just me that closes these as fast as possibly whilst grumbling about how annoying they are?
- samwillis 3y agoNo, but also a lot of users enjoy them. It's like marmite, you either love it or hate it. Also note that most product managers love them. Quite often they are a symptom of a UI that isn't descriptive to particularly discoverable.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoI think they are good when you can both skip them and do them later. Usually you can skip them but rarely can I find a way to restart it once I’ve decided I want to commit the energy to learn the app.
- chadash 3y agoStep 1: open free tier or trial account with new app I want to take a look at Step 2: open app, see your stupid tour, close it Step 3: click around, realize this might be what I’m looking for but more complex than I realized Step 4: look for that maybe-not-so-stupid tour again, realize there’s no way to restart it It’s not all that different than opening up a piece of assembly-needed furniture that arrives in the mail. Usually I look to see it I can build it intuitively before I go to the instruction manual
- ricardobayes 3y agoYep, I agree there needs to be a way to restart a product tour
- ericmcer 3y agoUsually feels like a crutch for bad design, but some products just have a certain level of complexity
- ebiester 3y ago
- amsterdorn 3y agoWhat's with the resurgence of marquee elements lately? They're terrible for usability/readability and are visually annoying. If anything this is a red flag for other aspects of the library.
- local_issues 3y agoNo no no no no. Design your product to be understandable at first pass. Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone, while Sony forces you to do it on every new device. Let the onboarding be a forcing function for usability. This isn't a crutch, it's something worse and damaging.
- sebastianconcpt 3y agoYes to the pretend you can't have this as forcing force for usability but I'm good for adding it if the user answers "Yes" to have a tour.
- smt88 3y ago> Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone You're arguing in favor of a product tour. iOS usability is garbage. There are no affordances. Nothing is discoverable. There are a million inputs (mostly gestures) that no one ever finds out about unless someone tells them or they Google it, and they're not consistent across apps, even first-party apps. Sometimes "swipe the row left" means "remove," sometimes it means "more actions". It's just a jumble of inconsistent nonsense. Watch a non-tech person use their iPhone. They have no idea that they can do 50% of the things that they can do. Ever see anyone use "shake to undo" for example?
- MrBodangles 3y ago“Shake to undo” also doesn’t work more often than it does. You’d assume an OS-specific keyboard interaction would work anywhere there’s text input, but no!
- djbusby 3y agoI like these, but only a little. Don't force it on new users, but ask if they want a tour. Only use sparingly when new features/buttons/changes are added to the app. Only once per session. Prompt is Dismiss/Tour option. It's better if your app has an "intuitive" UX. But an un-forced tour can be helpful. Its better than the sign-in interstitial to announce features.
- wpietri 3y agoAnd please god offer a help menu somewhere that includes decent docs and an opportunity to re-run tours. So many designers seem to think I am opening an app with oceans of time while asking myself the question, "What delights do these wonderful people have for me today?" When in reality I'm opening them to get a specific thing done right now. Which is the moment when I am least receptive to somebody forcing me to look at their product baby photos so I can say, "yes, your baby is beautiful, no really". The points where I'm actually receptive to a tour are after I've completed my task and when I've just realized that I don't know how to do the thing I want to do.
- obeavs 3y agoThis. Why cant I ever easily restart my tour
- talboren 3y agosurely a good alternative to userflow which kinda sucks
- omg_ketchup 3y agoI think this is great at what it does. The only issue I have with it is the fact that if a targeted element is offscreen, it snaps to it instead of scrolls to it. Otherwise very, very slick.
- ricardobayes 3y agoThere is really nothing new in this over intro.js, shepherd or the other 10 competing modules. If someone wanted to offer something new in the product tour space, make a fully frontend-only tour that has the convenience of the cloud-stored ones. (Aka be able to click on HTML elements to attach steps). I think this would be a nice product nieche for the companies who don't want their product to phone up a random third party API for a product tour.
- 1023bytes 3y agoPlease include a Skip button if you use these
- mercurialsolo 3y agoWhile as a product user I hate product tours, as a product developer I always wish for an open source alternative. Library looks super cool in terms of the effects which are slick. Personally from over a few products have built, even the best designed product tours get dismissed 90% of the time in SMB & consumer products.
- yewenjie 3y agoHow does this compare with intro.js?
- no_wizard 3y agoIts MIT Licensed and doesn't cost anything to use commercially, where as intro.js is AGPL licensed and you need a license to use it commercially.
- partiallypro 3y agoCool js, but I absolutely despise websites or software that do this.
- marcopicentini 3y agoI always feel annoyed when I see this. Users don't read and skip everything.
- worldsayshi 3y agoAs a user I only want to know about a feature when I need it. I don't want a tour or of the blue! I want to do the thing I came here to do. It's very unlikely that your new baby feature is the thing I want to use right now. This is why I love command palettes. It allows me to discover features by searching for them. When I've searched for it - then allow me to take the tour of where to find it faster/more conveniently and/or show me the shortcut key.
- redocneknurd 3y agoUser onboarding tutorials implemented as wizards with masks have never appealed to me. It's like navigating through a forest while only looking down, limiting the overall learning experience. I once had to implement one of these tutorials, and the data revealed that very few people even used it. From that experience, I firmly believe it's an anti-pattern to avoid.
- tamimio 3y agoProblem with these type of tours is a lot of information shoved into your face in short time and then it disappears, few minutes later the user will be asking “what was this section for again?”, I tried it in a platform I built before, it was to fly drones and some sections where to control while others for video feed etcs, so you should know what to do before clicking due to the dashboard complexity, users will be nodding their head and hitting next without even reading any. Had to remove it eventually and instead I added a little information icon for each to hover over to get some info what that section is about.
- debarshri 3y agoI just saw Walnut.io [1] demo for another product today. I skipped through most of the demo, did not really understand anything about the product. I think it is not the tool but really depends on who and how these product tours are built. I can imagine some products are complex and needs explanation or hand holding by solution engineers, account managers etc. No product ever is so amazing that you don't need help or product tours. [1] https://walnut.io https://walnut.io
- Ultimatt 3y agoIf anyone is looking for a jQuery days version of something like this https://zurb.com/playground/jquery-joyride-feature-tour-plugin https://zurb.com/playground/jquery-joyride-feature-tour-plug...
- partiallypro 3y agoReally wish Zurb would release a jQuery free version of Foundation. I prefer it to Bootstrap, its lighter weight, but would be much lighter if they stripped jQuery and made it pure JavaScript/CSS.
- baron816 3y agoI built a library https://github.com/Evernote/Aquaman https://github.com/Evernote/Aquaman meant to accomplish some of these same tasks for a Redux app (also did the same think for React context, but that was never open sourced). The things this misses, I think, are that 1) you probably want the state of you app to trigger a guided tour, 2) you probably want a multistep flow at some point, and 3) the state changing logic of that flow probably should be separated from the rendering logic (all the steps of the flow should be together). That’s what I was able to accomplish with Aquaman.
- nbhusal 3y agoI made a more complete library a while back for those interested, driver has been known here for a while but Lusift is new and doesn't have that traction - https://github.com/lusift/lusift https://github.com/lusift/lusift
- ecuaflo 3y agoI also made a version of this https://github.com/CSFlorin/react-onboard https://github.com/CSFlorin/react-onboard
- philvb 3y agoTours aren't always bad, but they're often just poorly implemented, with too many steps that don't mean anything to the user. Onboarding that's contextual, like embedded tips, or relevant, like targeted onboarding by persona, or action-oriented onboarding, like checklists tend to be better. After leading onboarding and in-app education teams at Dropbox, I started Dopt [0], which is a react component library and SDKs to make it easier to build tours, but also more contextual and less distracting onboarding experiences like embedded tips and checklists. My hope with Dopt is that you can still build tours when necessary (like 2 step tours to introduce a new feature), but have a bigger and better toolkit for all types of onboarding and education. [0] https://dopt.com/ https://dopt.com/
- no_wizard 3y agowhy does your website need to gather cookies? first thing I'm hit with is a cookies splash screen, I'm wondering what I'm being tracked for. I'm also curious about this: >Hybrid work On the face of it, I like the upfront callout, however how did you guys land on Hybrid being the solution? Especially in the light of working 100% remote leads to more productive employees[0] [0]: https://thehill.com/business/4110598-remote-employees-work-longer-and-harder-studies-show/ https://thehill.com/business/4110598-remote-employees-work-l...
- philvb 3y agoFor cookies: we're using Posthog for tracking and it's helpful for us to understand how people use our website and product. Hybrid vs remote is sometimes polarizing, but hybrid has been really great for us to balance the heads down time and no commute of remote with being able to jam on stuff in person.
- no_wizard 3y agoInteresting. When Hybrid was made as a decision, where there any data points that were considered in that decision, or was it just made from the start, or top down? Do you think its not possible to have the same levels of collaboration remotely if the culture adjusts for remote only type expectations? (I rarely get to ping decision makers about these things, I apologize for the intrusion, I'm trying to gather as much data on this as possible recently)
- welder 3y agoIt's an old library... been using it for WakaTime since 2018 (5 years). It's very handy to highlight one feature on a page based on a url param, for example when your FAQ wants to link directly to a mentioned setting. We don't like product tours because they're annoying, so we only display one highlight per page showing the first thing you should do when onboarding. Like a tooltip highlighting a button on the page, not a product tour.
- jgalt212 3y agoI don't know what this does, but I do like the look of this site. It's as if the smarty.net people updated their site. https://www.smarty.net/ https://www.smarty.net/
- grumpy_tired 3y ago> you can click out to cancel the tour This is great! Finally an implementation that I can cancel and restart whenever I want. Thank you for making this.