6 ms·
Researchers Find ‘Backdoor’ in Encrypted Police and Military Radios
- johnny99k 3y agoIt sounds like the encryption was limited intentionally, so government organizations could easily decrypt it.
- anonym29 3y agoDing ding ding! The dark unspoken part? They don't need to worry about you distributing it domestically, because anyone using it domestically is subject to extralegal rendition and rubber-hose cryptography without a warrant. That's been formally legal since the passage of the PATRIOT Act (and from the infinite renewal of the NDAA), but even Lincoln ended Habeas Corpus on a whim when he found it convenient. We don't live in a constitutional democratic republic, we live in a totalitarian surveillance state LARPing as a constitutional democratic republic.
- archgoon 3y ago[dead]
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- unethical_ban 3y agoThe United States has many negative things about it, and its democracy is flawed at best, but you don't get combo points for tacking on adjectives. It is plain by reading the dictionary that the US is not totalitarian.
- mcpackieh 3y agoVery few people seem to make any effort to distinguish between totalitarian and authoritarian, and even authoritarian is used very loosely.
- pnemonic 3y agoI think the tin-foil man is saying that you wouldn't know a totalitarian state if it were successfully masquerading as a democracy. "Successfully" is the real loaded term here. Those that claim to see the cabal behind the curtain unfortunately have woefully underdeveloped facts to support it.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThere's no hiding totalitarianism, totalitarian governments exercise total control over virtually every aspect of the private lives of their subjects. Under totalitarianism, you can forget about choosing your school or career. You might -MIGHT be allowed to choose your mate, but even that isn't certain because totalitarianism is characterized by such an extreme lack of individual liberty that the state may even tell you who to marry. A subverted liberal democracy secretly run by a cabal of oligarchs but on the surface still playing hands-off with everyday people's lives is not totalitarianism. Totalitarianism is not some generic insult to describe any oligarchy or authoritarian government. Totalitarianism is the extreme absence of individual liberty.
- ohwellhere 3y agoI wonder if there are measurable personality differences that predict how well someone responds to hyperbolic rhetoric. For instance, the US has been doing down on the Economist Democracy Index in recent years. "Flawed democracy" is not totalitarian, but it's trending away from "full democracy" and cries of totalitarianism may well be responding to real concerns. In the abstract, I wonder if it's better to raise such issues with incremental language and small arguments, or to raise them with hyperbolic claims, or to tailor to your audience, or some other combination.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> I wonder if there are measurable personality differences that predict how well someone responds to hyperbolic rhetoric. You don't have to tell me that I'm weird, I already know.. Most people seem to think dictionaries are obsolete because spellcheck exists, not caring that the primary purpose of dictionaries is to look up the established meanings of words. I know I'm weird for thinking these established meanings should at least be acknowledged when deciding to stray from them. If people want to use hyperbole to make a point I think that's fine, and know that even if I didn't think it was fine it wouldn't matter because I couldn't stop them. But my personality is such that when I see somebody doing it without acknowledging the established meaning of the word, I feel compelled to remark on it. Particularly when people are doing it with serious words with heavy connotations, like totalitarianism or genocide. As for the deteriorating state of American democracy, I share most of your concerns, but I don't see a trend to totalitarianism specifically. For instance the government now exercises less control over who people marry today than it did a generation ago, much less three or four generations ago. I do perceive disturbing trends in corruption, wealth distribution, and administrative competence. But a corrupt incompetent oligarchy is not synonymous with totalitarianism.
- thumbuddy 3y agoThe US is owned by the small group of people who have the most money. I wouldnt call it a democracy or totalitarian it's most likely a cell system who regularly has many business deals "on behalf" of the country. Closer to an oligarchy. Basically Russia with a little more modern/recent success.
- jauer 3y agoThis article is discussing TETRA, an European system standardized by ETSI. How does US domestic politics apply to this?
- brickteacup 3y agohe didn't read the article at all and just wants to rant about his favorite pet issue ofc
- hulitu 3y agoAs usual. Made by an US company (Motorola)
- jauer 3y agoMotorola is just one of many vendors. The Issues discussed are rooted in the standard, not Motorola's implementation.
- anonym29 3y agoThe comment I'm replying to is about governments mandating weakened cryptography as a form of export control, which is the entire reason this vulnerability exists within TETRA.
- astrange 3y agoThe PATRIOT Act has been expired for three years now. This is like when people tell you Flint doesn't have clean water (it's been fixed for four years.) Sometimes, time passes.
- thumbuddy 3y agoYea they allowed it to expire because they can just buy our data from private industry's now... Who needs an act when the "free market" lets you invade anyone's privacy by the petabyte. Call up your local advertising startup and offer some cash, you'd be surprised what's on the table without even getting to the big companies (google, amazon, Facebook, etc).
- anonym29 3y agoThe relevant provisions of the NDAA haven't!
- Spooky23 3y agoNo. These are police radios. All of the transmissions are recorded at the dispatch center and routinely get audited and used in various ways.
- Spooky23 3y agoMost police traffic isn’t secret and these radios replaced fully open radios that were commonly deployed just about everywhere. The bigger security threat is that police will often have actual sensitive conversations on personal cellular devices and SMS. This is just another example of the good old boys network of public safety gear selling bullshit products.
- thumbuddy 3y agoThe major reason why police radios are encrypted barring SWAT is so they can say racist things about the people the merc for laughs, adrenaline and clout. SWAT arguably has a public safety reason.
- kube-system 3y agoYes, cryptography has often fallen under many countries weapons export restrictions for the same reason weapons do: to provide an advantage under times of war. There's nothing surreptitious about this, it is the entire point of these types of laws.
- 0xbadc0de5 3y agoClosed, proprietary encryption algorithm is found to have serious, possibly intentional weaknesses: Shocked, shocked, I say!
- hinkley 3y agoNext up, our researchers investigate the properties of water. #3 is surprising.
- egberts1 3y ago*GASP* Dihydrogen oxide is also used to contaminate our food, spike our industrial solvents and found in nuclear reactors! Even in form of a pollutant that is being spewed out from those pesky hydrogen-fuel automobiles. Its pervasiveness is worse than poisonous CO2!
- hinkley 3y ago[flagged]
- still_grokking 3y agoIndeed. That's such a surprise! Every time.
- kube-system 3y agoThere are also weak algorithms and weak key lengths which have been open-sourced and meet various countries export requirements. If export laws require radios to be sold with weak encryption it doesn't really matter whether the code is shared or not. When institutions buy COTS products, they almost always use it as is, especially when interoperability depends on it.
- dhx 3y agoCVE-2022-24401: The Air Interface Encryption (AIE) keystream generator relies on the network time, which is publicly broadcast in an unauthenticated manner. This allows for decryption oracle attacks. CVE-2022-24402: The TEA1 algorithm has a backdoor that reduces the original 80-bit key to a key size which is trivially brute-forceable on consumer hardware in minutes. CVE-2022-24404: Lack of ciphertext authentication on AIE allows for malleability attacks. CVE-2022-24403: The cryptographic scheme used to obfuscate radio identities has a weak design that allows attackers to deanonymize and track users. CVE-2022-24400: A flaw in the authentication algorithm allows attackers to set the Derived Cypher Key (DCK) to 0. "At its core, TETRA security relies a set of secret, proprietary cryptographic algorithms which are only distributed under strict Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) to a limited number of parties. These algorithms consist of the TETRA Authentication Algorithm (TAA1) suite for authentication and key distribution purposes, and the TETRA Encryption Algorithm (TEA) suite for Air Interface Encryption (AIE). The TEA suite consists of four stream ciphers with 80-bit keys: TEA1 to TEA4, where TEA1 and TEA4 were intended for commercial use and restricted export scenarios while TEA2 and TEA3 were intended for use by European and extra-European emergency services respectively. In addition, optional, vendor-specific end-to-end encryption (E2EE) solutions can be deployed on top of AIE." [1] https://tetraburst.com https://tetraburst.com
- dylan604 3y ago> > CVE-2022-24402: The TEA1 algorithm has a backdoor When does a backdoor get promoted from bug? Does a backdoor require for to have been intentionally added? How do researchers prove intent?
- Rygian 3y agoFrom the page: The vulnerability in the TEA1 cipher (CVE-2022-24402) is obviously the result of intentional weakning. While the cipher itself does not seem to be a terribly weak design, there is a computational step which serves no other purpose than to reduce the key's effective entropy. Similar weakened cryptography has played a part in flaws in GSM (A5/1, A5/2), GMR (GMR-1), GPRS (GEA-1), DMR ('Basic' and 'Enhanced' encryption), and P25 (ADP) and mostly results from export control practices (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars#PC_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars#PC_era) at the time of design. Unfortunately, in the decades that have passed since then, this cipher has remained in use both inside and outside Europe without loud and clear warnings being issued about its actual security posture.
- neom 3y agoExtremely tangentially related, but I found this youtube channel recently that is all about police and military radio and it's honestly fascinating stuff: https://www.youtube.com/@RingwayManchester/videos https://www.youtube.com/@RingwayManchester/videos I found it because I was doing some research on number stations[1] and got sucked down the rabbit hole. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjaLfOySsFc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjaLfOySsFc
- _0xdd 3y agoLove this channel, highly recommend. Came to discover it the same exact way.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- miguelazo 3y agoIf this back door had been found in Chinese-marketed communications hardware, it would be front page news in the WSJ and NYT.
- noodlesUK 3y agoI wonder if this affects "Airwave", which is the UK's national public safety network (based on TETRA). If it does, then ETSI has some answering to do. If we used export level crypto on a piece of critical national infrastructure, we're just idiots. It also further reinforces that weakening crypto is almost always a bad idea, as you'll end up using it yourself for interoperability's sake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airwave_Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airwave_Solutions EDIT: It looks like Airwave uses TEA2, which isn't backdoors but is definitely vulnerable to the other issues such as the oracle attacks (with complete plaintext recovery).
- tamimio 3y agoI remember I did a project back in 2010 where you can decrypt GSM A5/1 using very simple tools like USRP etc., and I remember during the research it seemed what it was an intentional by the government/agencies to allow a quick bypass without getting the operators involved, so I wouldn’t be shocked if this is the same situation.
- fmajid 3y agoThe US doesn't use TETRA but a US-specific standard called Project 25, which also has a history of poor crypto choices. There is something about telco standards committees that keep reinventing the crypto square wheel, same with cellular standards and also WiFi. What's remarkable (not in a good way) about P25 is that the mandated a voice codec is the intellectual property of a MIT spin-off and they never negotiated a standard license fee so that company can essentially charge as much as it wants for a government-mandated standard. San Francisco paid over $120M to equip 11,000 buses, so over $10,000 per radio (TETRA radios are also expensive due to no economies of scale, but they cost a more reasonable $4,000 each).
- mschuster91 3y ago> There is something about telco standards committees that keep reinventing the crypto square wheel, same with cellular standards and also WiFi. The companies involved in creating these standards want to enforce usage of their patents, because even under nominally FRAND terms it is a guaranteed shitload of money for about 10-20 years as everyone has to license the patent. On top of that come the demands from secret services and pigs who want to be able to root around in communication as they please - and unlike ordinary IETF standards which are created by experts, anything involving radio transmission automatically involves the governments with their ability to license or to not license, so the committees are under a huge leverage to let as much bullshit pass as possible without generating too much outrage.
- fmajid 3y agoExcept both TETRA and P25 are for police and public safety.
- cryptonector 3y agoQuick! Ban cryptanalysis!
- Jigsy 3y agoWell, if the Police and Military have done nothing wrong, they've got nothing to hide.
- dmvdoug 3y agoThis made me laugh out loud frfr. Well done, you.
- nehal3m 3y agoOne of the authors responded to correct a Dutch publication about this research [1]. He explains the attack thusly: - Attacker intercepts message that he decides he wants to decrypt. - Attacker later goes to a location of his choice, and targets a (possibly different) radio with his directional antenna, pretending to be infrastructure. - Attacker plays with the radio's perception of time to discover the keystream used to encrypt the previously intercepted message - Attacker applies keystream to message and obtains decrypted message. The connection between radio and mast is therefore not directly attacked. It is therefore not a man in the middle. At a different time, another connection is set up, whereby that radio then leaks material with which an earlier message (possibly from another radio) can be decrypted. Finally; Even back then, 32 bits were not sufficient to protect confidentiality, especially given the often sensitive use cases of TETRA networks. [1] https://tweakers.net/nieuws/212022/onderzoekers-vinden-kwetsbaarheden-in-radio-encryptiestandaard-van-c2000.html?showReaction=18984890#r_18984890 https://tweakers.net/nieuws/212022/onderzoekers-vinden-kwets...