6 ms·
Time is running out on the Climate Clock
- aSithLord 3y agoI read this same article in 1995...
- haizhung 3y agoAnd yet, we still fail to reach consensus on the most basic premise, phasing out co2. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/22/g20-countries-fail-to-reach-agreement-on-cutting-fossil-fuels https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/22/g20-countries-...
- RandomLensman 3y agoAdaptation will come first pretty soon, then decarbonization and geoengineering - solving the now will beat solving the future in political priorities. Doesn't mean things are not done simultaneously but emphasis will likely shift.
- systemvoltage 3y agoI feel like they’ve lost my trust in the climate movement. I sincerely believe that it’s a small kernel of truth surrounded by lies and degrowth ideology. I want to live in a clean, beautiful planet; and share many things with climate activists. However, I can’t get behind the insane push for green washing, ESG, climate alarmicism, JustStopOil loonies, etc. This is not science, it’s ideological activism of the worst kind: to regress as a human species. The same group of people that keep drumming climate change have other opinions that are predictable: depopulation, degrowth, reducing quality of life, social justice fundamentalism (Tim Urban’e term), etc all stemming from one political axis point located at the top-left corner. I wouldn’t be so against it if it didn’t have an authoritarian aspect to it. Soon you’ll have California mandated carbon budget. Fuck that.
- aa1234556 3y ago[flagged]
- DangitBobby 3y agoYeah, this attitude is pretty much exactly why it's already over.
- anon84873628 3y agoWell if there were any contrasting ideological factions that accepted the reality of climate change, we might have a diversity of viewpoints and solutions. As it stands only the "extremes" have been truly taking it seriously. I'm sorry they haven't been able to wrap the kernel in something more palatable to you. If you want the "movement" to be different then be a part of it.
- systemvoltage 3y agoIf lies are not palatable to me, sorry, not my problem.
- dTal 3y agoWhat lies? We could do with some specifics.
- kmeisthax 3y ago>all stemming from one political axis point located at the top-left corner I'll say the quiet part out loud: you're worried about the authoritarian left - or, as the libertarian left calls them, tankies. Green washing and ESG aren't an authleft project. They were invented by corporate interests looking to avoid brand damage, so at best we could say it's a right-libertarian project. Insamuch as people apply social justice frameworks to environmental causes, it is to say that global warming is going to kill underprivileged people first and faster than wealthy people. Depopulation (aka "overpopulation") was the authright framing of environmentalism: we have too many mouths to feed and we need to stop making more, and conveniently for us it just so happens to be some other people's fault. These viewpoints are irreconcilable; in fact, I would argue the social justice environmental view is specifically a response to the authright trying to rehabituate themselves as environmental crusaders rather than industrial murderers. I object to calling JustStopOil loonies for the same reason why I don't call BuzzFeed loonies for pioneering clickbait. Smearing black paint on art is their tactic, not their goal. As far as I can tell there isn't really a libertarian (left or right) answer to global warming. Greenwashing and ESG won't actually fix the problem, because the problem is a public choice problem. Western standards of living are built on infrastructure that only loves oil and rejects all else. Everyone else wants western standards of living and is copying the same infrastructure to get it.
- systemvoltage 3y ago> Green washing and ESG aren't an authleft project. They were invented by corporate interests looking to avoid brand damage, so at best we could say it's a right-libertarian project. This is naive I think. The same crowd goes to Davos every year. It’s far deeper and insidious than “we don’t want to pay for lawyer/lawsuits”. The real quiet part is this: they want their genetic lineage to have better resources than others. Usually, group dynamics (tribe) provides a better overall outcome for their kids. The fracturing of unity has led to a bunch of elite clans to seize Gov power through proxy of social justice, climate change, etc.
- kmeisthax 3y agoOk, so some of them are also auth-right. One might argue further that the political compass is not topologically flat, and that at the extremes right-authoritarianism and right-libertarianism are the same ideology. After all, what's the difference between today's brutally authoritarian regimes and a large corporation that owns monopolies on everything? It's all abusable power. I also object to discussing this in terms of "genetic lineage". Humans are mesaoptimizers, none of our intelligence gives a shit about what evolution gives a shit about. Social justice was something that the economic elites were able to appropriate, Rebel Sell style, because nothing about capitalism forbids irony. However, there is nothing left-wing at Davos. They have no intent on actually bringing social justice about when it contradicts the moral foundations of their ownership. So their support boils down to "black lesbian dollars are still green" and rainbow logos, and not "let's stop destroying the world and impoverishing people for profit".
- sixQuarks 3y agoYou’re getting downvoted but you’re right
- aa1234556 3y ago[flagged]
- Thoeu388 3y ago> The world has less than six years left to hit crucial global climate goals, according to the clock. > Last year was even a record-high year for energy-related CO2 emissions. > Energy infrastructure and structural change is not something that you do in a couple of months. It’s something that needs years,” So we only have six years. CO2 production is rising. Key players are not on board. And even if everyone would be aligned politically, we will never manage to make technical changes on time! It is like cars emission car regulation in EU. New cars are very energy efficient and have low emission. But too expensive so nobody buys them. Average vehicle age is 15 years (in Czechia) and it really stinks! Perhaps we need better and more realistic plan, that would actually work!
- bloopernova 3y agoI remember reading a horror book about rats in London after a nuclear war. One scene has stuck with me for 3 decades: A woman sits in her house pretending to have a cup of tea. She's dying of radiation poisoning but goes through the motions of her pre apocalypse life rather than face what is happening. Bugs swarm through the dirty water in the tea mug, but she's denied reality so deeply that she doesn't see them. It feels like industrial societies, especially governments and corporate leadership, are doing the same thing. Denying reality because the alternative is too big, too mind numbingly terrifying to accept. I was walking my dog this morning, and had a flash of an imagined future. The grass was replaced by soil that was brown and cracked. Lush trees and foliage gone, only withered stumps remain. Houses were gone, just a few burnt beams left. No wildlife at all. Maybe we should use all that AI power to generate a satellite and street view showing the potential future. Though I can't delude myself into thinking it would change anyone's mind. To save you all the trouble: OK Doomer.
- bloopernova 3y agoIn reply to myself I wanted to share a thought. This one is less bleak but probably less palatable too: Governments should give their militaries a standing order: when society collapses, hunt down the billionaires hiding in their bunkers, ships, castles, wherever they may be hiding. Make it known that the richest 0.01% of the world has no chance to escape the doom of humanity. Maybe that would make them try to prevent it happening. The 0.01% are the ones with power, and all they do with it is hoard it and seek more.
- netsharc 3y agoThe higher your percentage at the top, the more connected you are with political leaders... Difficult to see this happening.
- musha68k 3y agoTerrifying thought, same as with aerosols as the predominant spread vector for SARS-CoV-2 being “invisible” I tended to think the “comprehension problem” probably is the invisibility of CO2. But yeah maybe it wouldn’t even be enough to make it “visible” with AR glasses etc. to make the necessary global shifts… Let’s quit the doomerism none the less though, this planet should still have just enough smart apes to make this work without taking everyone and everything else down with us.. How could we hack our ape minds to make this work? Maybe social dynamics could work? High status / high success in life = low carbon emissions? How to get there? New game rule set? Taxes etc? Chicken / egg issue though.
- gmuslera 3y ago"Because the clock say so". Like in Pratchett's Small Gods, we shouldn't believe in the clock instead of the worrying trends that are unleashing in front of us. There was a lot of political and economic players putting that limit, but right now it looks pretty evident than we already might had crossed the safe limits, and by a long shot.
- dTal 3y agoThere is only one solution to the climate apocalypse, and it's not popular: Fossil carbon extraction needs to be halted. Worldwide. Close the coal mines, shut down the oil rigs. Everything else is just rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. It's very, very simple: at the beginning of the Paleozoic era, atmospheric carbon was 20x higher than today, a level that the current biosphere cannot survive in. Gradually, over the next few hundred million years, that carbon was sequestered into the ground. We are now digging it back up and burning it, thus returning it to the atmosphere, within a span of decades. You can talk about LED lightbulbs and carbon credits till the cows come home, but the only thing that can halt this is preventing people from burning carbon that came from the ground - and the only way to stop that is to ban its extraction. "But what will we do for energy?" Lots of things. We have options. Personally I'm a fan of the magic green rocks that give energy forever. "But how will we power things that need high energy density / make plastics / lubricate my e-bike chain etc" - Oil. We can make it from anything carbon based. It's not even hard. We just have to stop digging it up and burning it.
- knewter 3y ago> I'm worried people might die. The only solution is to kill lots of people. You know that, when productivity goes down, people that can barely survive already will die. Right?
- locustous 3y agoWe had experienced serious reductions in carbon utilization in the 2008 recession and COVID restrictions and there wasn't any kind of pull back signal from the temperature record that I can make out. Real global "experiments" that do not back up these extreme positions. If you really want to make changes it seems to me that the best place to put effort would be pro nuclear rather than cutting industry to the ground. Serious investment in thorium seems a good place to start.
- systemvoltage 3y agoThis sounds like North Korean authoritarianism. Even the CCP would back away from this. Edit: responding to comment below about CFCs - Equating CFCs with all fossil fuels is an error of few orders of magnitude in scale. Edit: Those complaining I can't use reply button, it's because of throttling.
- throwaway5959 3y agoWe’re not having kids precisely because humans aren’t going to stop until they’ve ruined this planet. It’s immoral (in our opinion) to bring children into a world that 100 years from now will be significantly spoiled.
- Ekaros 3y agoI doubt that outside some island nations any population is ready to pay the price what it would truly mean to effectively lower emissions. Certainly for developing countries it is unacceptable. And the developed ones, will not go far enough. Or if they try it will be political and potentially economical suicide in short term.
- musha68k 3y agoPRC holds 50% of world’s EV share by now. 22% of new registered vehicles are EV vs 5% in US. Clearly we are not even trying to compete. We keep on falling behind with our behind mindsets. And yes, I’m an 80s fan as well but those times are nothing but the age old past by now. Nothing will bring them back, continued denial will just rob us of our future.
- flooow 3y agoIt's an interesting philosophical question. Let us take it as read that if you have children, you are morally obliged to work to ensure that the planet is habitable for them and future generations. But if you choose not to have children, do you have any moral obligation to ensure the planet can continue to support life after you have died? I could foresee a future when more-or-less everyone agrees that something drastic would have to be done to save the planet, but an electorally-significant block simply say "don't care, dead soon, so long and thanks for all the fish".
- Ekaros 3y agoEven if majority (60-80%) agree that something drastic has to be done, I have little faith that they will agree that same thing has to be done. People are always ready to trade others' things away, but never their own...