5 ms·
> Secondly, some of these, like storing at a low/high state of charge or high/low temperature performance are nowadays managed by the BMS - models that don't ha
by londons_explore 3y ago
> Secondly, some of these, like storing at a low/high state of charge or high/low temperature performance are nowadays managed by the BMS - models that don't have that are already not competitive. The reason is that energy density already crossed the threshold at which some of the capacity can be spared for this purpose.
No - this is dishonesty by some battery/car manufacturers. They say "Our car can drive 300 miles", and "our car battery will last 10 years/100,000 miles", but the reality is that if you actually drive it 300 miles on each charge, you'll only be doing about 30,000 miles before it no longer meets your needs.
Instead car manufacturers say things like "only charge to 85% to prolong battery life" and "under 15% charge is for 'reserve capacity' use only".
An honest manufacturer would only advertise the amount of capacity you can actually use day to day, rather than the capacity that is there but you really shouldn't use unless you want your battery to die young.
- benj111 3y agoIs it dishonest when an IC car manufacturer advertises a range, but the fuel light comes on before that? If you use a tank full of petrol each day, your car may not last 10 years. If you only do 1 mile a day, every day, it may not last 100k miles. All mechanical things have usage patterns that are worse than others. You just get used to the tradeoffs.
- Beached 3y agoan honest manufacturer would advertise the fuel economy you can expect day to day, rather than the fuel economy of a perfect test scenario. car manufacturers have been overstating range/fuel economy since the dawn of time. people are tuned to look at those numbers and think "in perfect lab conditions." and no one expects these numbers to be their day to day numbers
- mcbishop 3y agoDeception in marketing doesn't mean that there haven't been significant improvements in battery management systems.
- Tade0 3y ago> but the reality is that if you actually drive it 300 miles on each charge, you'll only be doing about 30,000 miles before it no longer meets your needs. False. Nowadays manufacturers include a capacity buffer, so you're not actually fully charging/discharging. Teslas used to have no buffer whatsoever - exactly like smartphones - but they dropped the practice a few years ago. Case in point: the battery in the Mercedes EQS 450+ has a nominal capacity of 120kWh, while usable is 107.8kWh - that's a 10% buffer - likely on the top end because that's where most of the wear happens. You can reasonably expect 200,000 miles out of that before range degrades to 80% of the original figure. And no wonder - that's less than 600 cycles assuming highway driving. Consumer-grade batteries last this much, and the ones in EVs are anything but consumer-grade.
- r00fus 3y agoExcept for the Nissan Leaf, most EV car batteries do great at managing heat even in adverse conditions (high heat, fast charging, etc). I have a 5 year old EV which is always charged to 100% and it’s lost maybe 5% of its range capacity so far. Perhaps it was over provisioned (undersold the actual capacity) but it’s unlikely as it’s a cheap compliance car (that I still love to drive).
- gpm 3y agoThe convenient truth of the matter is that you don't want to drain your battery "to 0" regardless of whether or not it increases wear and tear on the battery, because you don't want to be stranded. As such giving lifetime aspects under that assumption that people won't do that regularly is fairly reasonable. On the flip side, I agree that the "100%" mark should be the mark that people regularly charge to, people don't leave empty space in the tank for fun.
- wesleyd 3y ago> An honest manufacturer would only advertise the amount of capacity you can actually use day to day, rather than the capacity that is there but you really shouldn't use unless you want your battery to die young. Toyota do this. In fact, all PHEV manufacturers seem to do this: they keep their batteries between 15% and 85% and only advertise this range. Insofar as they advertise it at all: the battery size in eg a Prius prime is buried in a footnote, and the range - miles/km - is what’s advertised, and is real, and corresponds to the 15-85. I guess it is more important in a PHEV to never fully charge not discharge their batteries: most cycle from full-ish to empty-ish much more than a BEV. And so it is more logical for them to publish their 15-85. But the honesty is refreshing; BEV numbers feel disingenuous to me. I ignore all breathlessly excited battery “breakthrough” headlines, but I ignore any from Toyota less!
- monkpit 3y agoAs a layperson when it comes to batteries, this whole 15-85% thing seems like a silly detail that should be handled by computers. Like, at 85% the readout should say “100%”, and at 15% it should say “0%”. Is that something they do, or do they expect users to be aware of these thresholds?
- Tade0 3y ago> Is that something they do Pretty much. There's a catalogue of EVs here: https://ev-database.org/ https://ev-database.org/ Where nominal and usable capacity is stated. Currently even Tesla includes a few kWh of buffer capacity. State of charge in li-ion batteries isn't a straightforward thing anyway. 4.2V used to be considered 100%, but nowadays some chemistries allow for going up to 4.35V safely - doesn't sound like much, but it translates to ~15% more capacity.
- martin8412 3y agoMy VW PHEV does this. It doesn't use the HV battery below 20% and the range calculator knows this.
- vbezhenar 3y ago
- newaccount74 3y ago> An honest manufacturer would only advertise the amount of capacity you can actually use day to day Why? It's not common to use your cars full range every day. Most people I know drive <100km on most days, and use the full range of their car maybe twice a year when they go on vacation. Why would manufacturers advertise worst case numbers if they are not representative of the average consumers needs? If they advertise their cars for business use, they probably should put some more detailed info somewhere. But if you advertise your car to commuters, it makes sense to use numbers that the average commuter can expect.
- badtension 3y agoWhat's stopping them from advertising exactly that? Usable everyday range being 200km and occasional max range 500km for prolonged life of the battery pack? Just inform the customer instead of doing the advertising mumbo-jumbo.
- eptcyka 3y ago50% of the time I use my car, I drive more than 150 miles on a trip. However, I do not commute with my car. And most people should press their local authorities to develop infrastructure so that they don't have to either :)