5 ms·
Here's a video from Beta, a wrench manufacturer in Italy.[1] Think about what it would take to build a plant like that from a cold start. What you'd need to kno
by Animats 3y ago
Here's a video from Beta, a wrench manufacturer in Italy.[1] Think about what it would take to build a plant like that from a cold start. What you'd need to know. All the ways you could screw up. How much it would cost to recover from a bad decision. Notice what they automated, and what they didn't.
Who wants to be a millwright? Or a production engineer? To build a factory, you need both. Once you've built the factory, you don't need most of them them any more. It's a job with high layoff potential. Top pay is maybe $125K.
You need people who've built your kind of factory before. Here, they need people who've built mechanized hot forging shops. Since few of those are built in the US each year, there's no pool of such people.
Stanley, the company, had forgotten how to build a plant like that.
They relied on the equipment manufacturer, and perhaps some consultants. That didn't work out.
It takes a long time to get a good factory going from a cold start. It took Airbus 21 years before they made a good airplane. It took Tesla 15 years from start to significant production volume.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azDUFQ-e0EM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azDUFQ-e0EM
- YeBanKo 3y ago15 years to build a very competitive car and 21 year to build a plane like airbus sounds pretty good actually. It’s actually not that long for a country. It does require a consistent policy encouraging domestic production, some level of protectionism.
- CobaltFire 3y agoI keep getting offered production engineer jobs and the pay does NOT scale with the job requirements. $125k in San Jose for semi manufacturing is the top of that job that I’ve seen, and those jobs aren’t getting filled.
- thumbuddy 3y agoThe irony is if they hired you they'd save tens of millions if they have any scale...
- VectorLock 3y ago>Here's a video from Beta, a wrench manufacturer in Italy. >It took Airbus 21 years before they made a good airplane. It took Tesla 15 years from start to significant production volume. Extrapolating from complexity it would only take a few months at worse to make a factory producting drop forged box end wrenches.
- psunavy03 3y agoYou're confusing the complexity of the product itself with the complexity of being able to produce said product at scale to acceptable levels of quality. These are not the same thing.
- thumbuddy 3y agoThe amount of naivity around this topic is actually scary. Seems like a lot of people really do assume every physical/ made by hand product is easy, and requires no talent or experience. Meanwhile, 90% of the posts on here about tech products end up somewhere along the lines discussing dunning Kruger, and false superiority. The dichotomy is wild especially knowing that when people burn out in tech they often end up working in a skilled trade. Physical products are hard. Automating them means you've screwed up half a million times and have a lot of cash to even do it.
- Closi 3y agoThis! Although I think the most likely failure considering the amount of money spent on the plant is that they probably dove head-first into automation and hit the integration challenges this can have. (Perhaps a business case of “on-shoring makes sense if everything is automated!” that failed to account for the challenges of opening a fully-automated facility)
- thumbuddy 3y agoEver see that meme about newcomers to ML make a giant leap to bert/chatgpt? Id wager 100 bucks you're right. Also bet a lot of dudes nephews made a lot of money while being unqualified for their positions.
- danielvf 3y agoI've worked in manufacturing, been adjacent to manufacturing for most of my life, and written software for custom factory floor machines. That Beta wrench factory wouldn't be hard for someone in the industry to stand up. It's is fairly low tech, little automation, and 95% off the shelf machines. Even the two possibly custom machines I saw in that video are built out of off the shelf components. This really isn't rocket science. You have a list of operations needed to make the product. You take that list and turn into machines, and time it takes to do each operation. If this is slower than your target time per part, you increase the number of machines on that operation (see all the tumblers in the wrench video). The US has many cities with deep industrial expertise. The US and China are roughly manufacturing output peers, even though the US has 1/5 the population. I know someone who stood up a production line in the US for some of the most complex pieces of metal ever made, involving hundreds of machine cells, (more many nations have made nuclear reactors than make this thing), and the production line side is something that's just isn't that hard. The planning is work sure, but it stuff that's been done before bazillions of times before. Standing up a manufacturing line is far less risky than creating new software - assuming you've got experienced people doing it.
- oneTbrain23 3y agoMaybe that person you know did that 20 years ago. USA right now has very little manufacturing plants like it used to have in the 50s to 80s. A lot got shifted out during Bush Jr time. I know a dozen machinists ended with Amazon after they lost their plant jobs around Obama's time.
- edrxty 3y agoYeah, I second this. If anything, the process in the video is painfully under-optimized. It's not that hard to get to the point where you have a few machines in a lights out warehouse with a skeleton staff somewhere spitting these things out like a machine gun. I am curious what this legendary machined part referring to is though....?
- ReptileMan 3y ago>I am curious what this legendary machined part referring to is though....? Ultra silent propellers for submarines most probably.
- ReptileMan 3y agoSidenote but I was really surprised at the low hardness of the wrenches - around 47HRC I expected to be in low 50-s at least.
- ZiiS 3y agoToughness is more important; or put another way these will be hit with a hammer to dislodge a stuck bolt.
- bigbacaloa 3y ago$125K is good money for ordinary folks ...
- thumbuddy 3y agoIn San Jose Cali you could never afford an actual place to live with that. I mean an apartment sure if you compete for it. median home price is 1 million, and average rent is 3k/month. Both of those number are rising btw.
- prepend 3y agoBut they aren’t building factories in San Jose, right? It’s a low/moderate salary in Manhattan too, but no factories there. So it seems unlikely that anyone would live in San Jose and work this job. The median US salary in 2021 was about $70k [0]. I’m guessing factories are being built in less than median cost of living places so $120k is 1.7x the median, so pretty good. [0] https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-us-income/ https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-us-income/
- thumbuddy 3y agoInteresting guess find a town a half hour commute from San Jose and the cost of living my guess is you won't see a real improvement. I estimate this from having to turn down several jobs in Cali over the years. The one was almost doable but the commute was an hour and a half because of traffic, and a 10 her work day with 3 hrs of driving isnt sustainable. Especially after I asked how often people pull more than ten hours days...
- prepend 3y ago> 10 her work day with 3 hrs of driving isnt sustainable. I thought the same thing until I sustained it for 14 years. It’s interesting how perspective changes with circumstances. When I was in my 20s I remember saying “how do these old guys commute for 4 hours a day.” Then I hit my 30s and had kids and wanted good schools and whatnot, but my income didn’t jump. So I commuted for a long time. Happy I don’t do that any more.