6 ms·
And now Stanley Blackend ... Decker can explain why they can't do what Milwaukee can. https://toolguyd.com/milwaukee-usa-made-hand-tools-2023-update/ https://t
by bombcar 3y ago
And now Stanley Blackend ... Decker can explain why they can't do what Milwaukee can.
https://toolguyd.com/milwaukee-usa-made-hand-tools-2023-update/ https://toolguyd.com/milwaukee-usa-made-hand-tools-2023-upda...
https://toolguyd.com/milwaukee-usa-made-pliers-screwdrivers-pricing-preorders-2023/ https://toolguyd.com/milwaukee-usa-made-pliers-screwdrivers-... (prices)
I think this says more about how badly Craftsman has shat the bed and less about manufacturing in America.
- api 3y agoThey may have outsourced even the business and management talent for manufacturing and become a mere brand that resells stuff built to spec by others. Shareholder value is maximized until everything is hollow and then it goes to zero.
- bombcar 3y agoThis I feel is closer to the reality - craftsman has "sold the brand" so hard that they can't charge anything like a premium, and their quality is now south of Harbor Freight.
- vl 3y agoIn fact Harbor Freight has 4 levels for hand tools. Pittsburgh Pittsburgh Pro Quinn Icon Icon is great, but also is very expensive.
- dieselgate 3y agoIt’s easy to shit on HF but some of their products are basically industry standard - like winches and floor jacks. It’s really odd to be honest because people will frequently mention buying something cheap off “Amazon or Ali express” and then scoff at HF. I’ve seen some HF products out perform SnapOn tools in YouTube reviews. Not everything is “good” but it’ll get the job done.
- vl 3y agoYes, this! Where would you go to buy air compressor and accessories at retail but HF? Nobody caries them. I bought excellent standing air compressor at black Friday sale couple years ago!
- dreamcompiler 3y agoI love shopping at HF but I've had to learn through experience which of their products are decent and which are utter dogshit. And sometimes I still buy the dogshit if I know I only need the item once and plan to toss it.
- amluto 3y agoEvery now and then a crappy tool is exactly what’s needed. Ever had a hole in a countertop but a misaligned or otherwise inadequate hole in the plywood under it? (Or just wanted to drill a new hole through both?). Get a cheap, crappy Forstner bit the same size as your hole, stick it in the countertop hole, and drill through the plywood base. Cuts perfectly and takes very little time. Also destroys the bit very quickly. I don’t think there’s any benefit to using a nice Forstner bit for this. (A cheap hole saw could also work, but some fiddling with the drill bit portion may be needed.) Obviously one should use a high quality diamond bit for cutting the countertop in the first place, with proper dust control.
- smegger001 3y agobuy cheap for the first one and if you ever have to replace it you know you will use it enough to pay for a quality replacement. that way you spend money on tools that need it.
- bombcar 3y agoFor my purposes harbor freight is where sears used to be - hand tools with lifetime warranties and easy replacement. Power tools I look elsewhere but for hand tools and cabinets even their low-end stuff is great, or at least good.
- manual89 3y agoHonestly even their mid grade and above power tools are decent. I have an earthquake xt electric impact that makes short work of suspension and lug nuts.
- bombcar 3y agoThe main downsides of their power tools is the refusal to make them share batteries and that the decent ones get into the Milwaukee/Dewalt tool price areas.
- jjav 3y ago> For my purposes harbor freight is where sears used to be That's very contrary to my experience. I have a lot of tools. Most of my hand tools are Craftsman from Sears back when they were around. Nearly all of them are very adequate quality for a non-professional (i.e. used only on weekends, not full time). Sears hasn't been around for a while but I still have all the tools, all work great. I went through a phase of trying to save money and bought a lot of junk from HF. Nearly all of it was an exercise in frustration and I've thrown it all away in anger. Soft metal, bad tolerances, pure junk. The only HF tool I have left is a cement mixer. It's not great (the belt keeps popping off) but for my limited cement needs it's been tolerable.
- thumbuddy 3y agoSame. I do wonder if people touting these things have bought or needed to rely on a tool for a long period of time...
- thumbuddy 3y agoThe average HF tool is probably expected to survive a single project. If you've ever taken apart any of their power tools it's honestly really sad. Some of the components are average for higher end tools but where they cut corners making them horrible will leave you scratching your head... Literally 10 dollars more could make a tool sold by a competitor for 100 that is sold by them for 20 unnoticeable to most hobbyists... Still not good nor reliable but passing for lay people.
- miah_ 3y agoAll "brands" do this now. Rather than selling one thing, they sell a variety in a "Good, Better, Best" tiered system so that a customer is never priced out of buying from them. TTI does this too: Ryobi (Good), Ridgid (Better), Milwaukee (Best).
- bombcar 3y agoTTI is annoying because There is a bunch of Ryobi tools that have no Milwaukee counterpart.
- onetimeusename 3y agoThat's my thought about it too. I'm not convinced labor being too expensive in the US was the reason manufacturing left in the first place. I think it might have just been a cost cutting move to manufacture in Asia which was done more for short term financial gain and designed by financial types. But the loss in talent and knowledge is very costly long term.
- Incipient 3y agoCost cutting by moving to Asia is due to labour. Possibly a bit of cheaper environmental regulation too. But what else is there other than labour?
- topkai22 3y agoTariffs and other restraints on trade meant to draw companies in in exchange for “access to the market.” Although cost reduction was a huge factor.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThis article discusses why the lack of industrial supply chains locally really hurts - the availability of basic parts like custom screws without lead time is exemplary of the problem. The entire chain of production exists in Asia and not in America. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/28/technology/iphones-apple-china-made.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/28/technology/iphones-apple-...
- Gibbon1 3y agoPart of it is running a manufacturing plant makes your typical Ivy League MBA's head hurt.
- api 3y agoThree things: 1. Even slightly cheaper labor matters at scale. 2. Lax environmental regulations make materials, disposal, and energy cheaper (which is really just dumping externalities on others). 3. China for one subsidizes its industries. Corporations can’t generally compete with governments, especially big ones with their own sovereign currency.
- reducesuffering 3y agoWKUK - What do we do https://youtube.com/watch?v=iN8xhU6ChRI&pp=ygUSV2t1ayB3aGF0IGRvIHdlIGRv https://youtube.com/watch?v=iN8xhU6ChRI&pp=ygUSV2t1ayB3aGF0I...
- tcmart14 3y agoCant you just feel those gains trickling down? If not, I'm sure it'll happen at any moment...
- jacquesm 3y agoOnce you ship the dies overseas there is no going back. Apropos Milwaukee: I had one of their circular saws which dropped from a roof that I was working on and I thought for sure it's a goner. Climbed down, not a mark on it, still dead straight. It must have landed very fortunately but still that was quite the drop. and you'd at least expect some impact damage. There was a scratch on it, but that may well have been there from before the drop and it didn't look like anything to do with impact.
- bombcar 3y agoTheir tools are pretty damn durable; I have broken some but that's to be expected (and the repair/warranty has been quite reasonable). Uncle bumblef*ck always does the drop test, because it's quite realistic, especially for tools used on a ladder. His teardowns are always fun: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbfNzt0UMGc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbfNzt0UMGc
- lovich 3y agoAh, is he back on the teardowns again? I was an avid watcher of him for a few years until he went off the deep-end with covid and backing the canadian caravan. If he's gone back to what he was good at(teardowns of tools with explanations of the materials and manufacturing choices) I might start watching him again
- mikrotikker 3y agoI enjoyed the real talk and his support of the truckers in face of the abusive Canadian government. It was a pretty popular position there in any case. Boatloads of supporters out in subzero weather proved that. I definitely empathised with all of that. There's reports and studies coming out every week proving him right so.... I guess if you're a more sensitive, tow the line type you may have been put off. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/covid-lockdown-study-b2351604.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/covid-lockdow... https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/22/chris-whitty-scientists-would-not-call-lockdowns-ministers/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/22/chris-whitty-sci... https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/17/briefing/covid.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/17/briefing/covid.html
- JKCalhoun 3y agoNot really manufacturing in the U.S. when the machines for your factory are offshored to Belarus.
- insaneirish 3y agoMeta commentary on toolguyd... its principal has a PhD in materials science and I find the site to be pretty trustworthy.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoOld Craftsman never actually manufactured anything. They just subcontracted out to other American tool manufacturers that built products with their branding. Those manufacturers are mostly gone now due to 30+ years of bad trade policy so New Craftsman can't tap into an existing skill base.
- pmorici 3y agoThose companies are still around but they are making industrial grade tools sets for commercial and government customers that are less price sensitive. Craftsman even continued their Made in the USA Tool line for a time under the “Craftsman Industrial” brand. You can still get Made in the USA tools you just have to be willing to pay 5-10x the price. Wright, S&K, MAC, Proto, Snap-on among others all still make tools in the USA
- simfree 3y agoSome of these tool vendors make most of their money with predatory loans pushed by tools. Gotta be the young guy with a large, high interest loan for your Snap-On tools: https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/comments/sxkdsl/so_a_buddy_and_i_took_a_look_at_our_snap_on/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/comments/sxkd...
- prepend 3y agoNote the person in that article is completely off on their math. They have a 19% line of credit and seem new to understanding how interest and principal work. (The article person thinks it’s 19%/month and is shocked that they are paying more than the principal in interest). The loan described here sucks but seems similar to buying everything on a credit card and as a new tradesperson 19% is probably as good a loan as you’ll get without a credit history.
- simfree 3y agoMost credit unions will give you better terms than 19% interest on a personal loan as a teenager if you have not seriously damaged your credit profile already. These tool loans certainly aren't going out to people that have already rolled the bus on a Capital One $300 credit line credit card.
- robomartin 3y ago> I think this says more about how badly Craftsman has shat the bed and less about manufacturing in America. Sorry to burst your bubble. Manufacturing pliers and screwdrivers is a joke when compared to, as an example, manufacturing a cordless drill, battery packs, charger and accessories. We cannot do ANY of that in the US. Something like this: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milwaukee-M12-12V-Lithium-Ion-Cordless-1-4-in-Hex-Screwdriver-Kit-with-Two-1-5Ah-Batteries-Charger-and-Tool-Bag-2401-22/100615066 https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milwaukee-M12-12V-Lithium-Ion-Co... Nope. Can't do it. Not unless you are willing to play $500 for it, or much more. Let's put it this way: If you take the time to create a detailed list of every component, material and process required to manufacture and deliver that product, you will quickly discover that NONE OF IT is made in the US. In business terms, the supply chain for the manufacturing of such products is long and very expensive, because it isn't local. Guess where you'd have to buy all the components from? China. A corollary is that you cannot make this product for less (or even the same) than what it costs to make it in China. Impossible, even if the factories existed. While people love to talk about "Buy American" there's a huge gaping hole between those who virtue-signal with bumper-stickers and flags and the much smaller group who actually practice --to the extent possible-- what they preach. BTW, I have attended trade shows where Chinese OEM manufacturers showcase products they make, including tools. To put it in simple terms, anyone can sign a deal with any of these manufacturers and have a line of quality hand and power tools with their own brand and logo. You go to these conferences and can actually talk to and buy from the very companies who are making tools for the top brands in the US and Europe.
- defrost 3y agoGood and accurate comment. Worth mentioning that one can also go to pharma manufacturing and trade shows in China and discuss bespoke bulk synthesis deals and leave with free sample bags of uncapsuled high grade perscription drugs with a "to US patient on US soil" value of tens of thousands of US dollars.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoSure. But a reminder that this didn't happen by accident. Capital went in search of cheap labor, to increase profits. The cheap(er) labor wasn't in the USA. We let capital do this. We loosened capital flow rules, we loosened profit repatriation rules, we reduced or eliminated tariffs. That's not to say that Chinese/Asian companies would never have gotten good at doing this on their own. But the situation we are actually is not really a result of their excellence and/or costs - it's because we elected political representatives who allowed the capital class to fuck us over, and so they did.
- myegorov 3y agoRight on. Craftsman tools have been frowned upon at least for the last 20 years. Milwaukee sawzalls are legendary.
- silisili 3y agoBlame SBD, Craftsman is just a brand name. But yes, I agree. TTI(Milwaukee, Ryobi, Ridgid) is, IMO, the best at what they do. SBD basically relies on old brand names with a dash of patriotism to exist. Even Chervon(Flex, Skil, Ego) outclasses them these days where they compete. I tried the new Craftsman V20 kits that came out, and every single tool was problematic. I felt like they were basically just ripping off nostalgic people with garbage old stock. Ryobi and Skil, on the other hand, make stellar tools at a lower cost.