3 ms·
>In a sentence, we need a public infrastructure in place to care for the mentally ill that currently are forced to live on the streets of our major cities. May
by coldtea 3y ago
>In a sentence, we need a public infrastructure in place to care for the mentally ill that currently are forced to live on the streets of our major cities.
Maybe that's putting the cart before the horse?
How about what is needed is changing the conditions in society, workplace, and culture, so that fewer people end up "mentally ill", and those that are environmentally or genetically mentally ill do not get broken and marginalized and have their conditions gravely worsen, as do their "solutions" (from isolation, homelessness and living on the margins, to drug abuse, murders, or even mass shootings)?
(Wow, downvotes. Fixing the cause as opposed to a band-aid is controversial. Well, I guess you get the society you deserve).
- yardstick 3y agoBut there will still be some mentally ill people right? Not everything and everyone can cured. Just like we will always need jails.
- coldtea 3y agoYes. Far fewer, and with lesser societal impact and harm, for which existing infrastructure would be more than enough. Kind of how other first world countries (even nominally poorer ones) only have a tiny fraction of the problems with mentally-ill homelessness, crime, shootings, and so on.
- simbolit 3y ago"Just like we will always need jails." citation needed
- yardstick 3y agoHitler.
- wildrhythms 3y agoI get what you're saying but Hitler never went to jail; his forces were eliminated by the armies of multiple world superpowers working together. Imagine if such manpower and might were used to eradicate homelessness and hunger.
- coldtea 3y agoHitler was the person running jails, camps, and asylums and sending people there. So this argument kind of backfires...
- yardstick 3y agoWould we have been better off putting Hitler in jail before all that? He didn’t just switch a crazy light in his head overnight. All I’m saying is, there will always be people that need to be inside jail rather than outside jail. The parent asked for a citation. I said Hitler. Because it would have been better if he was inside jail and not running it. Another one: Charles Manson. He was jailed. I don’t think there is any society where he could have lived and not committed atrocities. Unless you lived in a society that legalised such atrocities but I’m not interested in living somewhere like that.
- slibhb 3y agoAdvocating for "changing the conditions in society, workplace, and culture" is a bit of a moonshot.
- coldtea 3y agoAnd how is not going for that "moonshot" work out for you?
- iancmceachern 3y agoI, for one, am down for this moon shot. Let's do it
- cvwright 3y agoA hell of a lot better than in most places that have tried a “moonshot”. Russia in 1917 being the major example.
- iancmceachern 3y agoDon't you remember Apollo? That was more recent, and was successful, and widely considered as a good idea. It's weird to choose an obscure, older historical reference to suit your point, while the literal best example possible, the example that created the term, is sitting right there.
- cvwright 3y agoIt’s this belief that engineering and public policy are exactly the same, that keeps getting us in trouble.
- kelnos 3y agoI agree, but band-aids at least stop the bleeding while the bigger issues are being taken care of. Changing those conditions, even if everyone could agree on what needs to be done, and the political will were there, right now, will be a multi-year -- perhaps multi-decade -- process. I don't think we should let people suffer while we wait for that to happen. I think we should start committing mentally ill homeless people to mental institutions, and force those addicted to drugs/alcohol into rehab programs. They need to be off the street in safer environments for these treatments to be successful. After those problems are dealt with, we can put them in supportive housing and get them into job training and placement programs. That's not going to be perfect; it may just not work for some people. But it will work for many, and our cities will be safer, healthier, and cleaner as a result. The problem is that there are not enough resources and funding, and the political will to fix that isn't there. And yes, we need to fix structural problems too: * Neutralize NIMBYs who fight new housing; once the formerly-homeless get through their treatment programs and are in a position to be back on their feet, we need places to put them that aren't insanely expensive, especially if we expect these new residents to eventually start paying for their own housing. * Raise minimum wages (somehow also for salaried workers in addition to hourly), with automatic yearly increases indexed to inflation or CPI or whatever. Eliminate the distinction between tipped and non-tipped workers; base wages should be living wages, conforming to the minimum wage laws. * Either a) put some differential/ratio-based caps on executive compensation, or b) tax the shit out of high income earners to fund fixes to income inequality. * If we can't get some sort of universal healthcare, at the very least we need to require that health insurers cover mental health and addiction treatment at much better levels than we do now. But fixing structural problems takes a lot of time. I don't see better mental health & addiction services as putting the cart before the horse; I think both attack vectors are essential.
- nradov 3y agoHigher minimum wages are the last thing those people need. We're talking about the least productive workers. If minimum wage is $20 and their labor is only worth $10 then no one will hire them at all. They will remain dependent on handouts and never have the opportunity to gain real work experience. Under the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) of 2008, medical insurers are already required to cover mental health the same way they cover physical health. The issue is not so much with insurers but availability of providers. It doesn't matter whether your insurer will pay the claim if you can't get an appointment with a local psychiatrist in the first place.
- vasco 3y agoNobody knows what parts of society and culture create more mental illness. Some people will tell you they have the cure for the problems with our culture, but I disagree with most that proclaim to have the answer. You don't even have the answer, you're just listing the effects and stating they are bad and that we should not have them. No shit, the problem is what to change and what the effect will be.
- coldtea 3y ago>Nobody knows what parts of society and culture create more mental illness. I'd say we have a very good idea. It's just denial when people are pretending we don't.