3 ms·
Obligatory counter-anecdote: by all accounts, I was a cheerful, happy little baby. My parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family. And yet, I was
by kstrauser 3y ago
Obligatory counter-anecdote: by all accounts, I was a cheerful, happy little baby. My parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family. And yet, I was recently diagnosed with ADHD by a doctor who, after finishing the diagnostic screening, asked "how are you not homeless?"
I also have a kid who was diagnosed at a young age. Said kid was also a cheerful, happy little baby that we love dearly and did our best to raise into an amazing young adult.
Which is to say that I'm not arguing against the study, but ADHD doesn't automatically mean neglect, or vice versa.
- ithkuil 3y agoThis study links ADHD children that are not cheerful and happy with them being mistreated. It probably tells something about the link of the behaviour of the child and the likelihood of it being mistreated. After all parents are human too and many don't live up to the task, which is a very hard task especially if the child is difficult. The study doesn't necessarily imply that all ADHD children exhibit those behaviours. The fact that both you and your child don't perhaps is an indication that there may be other confounding genetic factors beyond the main ADHD traits
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoThis is a good explanation of why the study should be dustbined as another problematic effort to scapegoat parents for their children's mental health challenges. Like "refrigerator mothers" as a 1950s cause of autism.[1] And now, thanks to this study, every parent of an ADHD child can likewise feel doubt and experience a dose of finger-wagging from self-annointed servants of public. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory
- ithkuil 3y agoMy take-away from the study wasn't that ADHD is caused by bad parenting, but that when parents are faced with challenging children and they behave poorly, they make things worse. Is that controversial? Should you as a parent just mistreat your children because they are exhausting you? Some may thing that perhaps acting tough on those kids will somehow solve the problem, but hey you'll just make things worse. Is that framing blaming the parents? I don't think so; I think the parallel with the refrigerator mother is just an emotional reaction on something that is only superficially similar
- tremon 3y ago"how are you not homeless?" Wouldn't the obvious (and slightly glib, but I hope you can see my point) reply to that be "because my parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family"? Note that they say ADHD symptoms, not necessarily ADHD prevalence. So it could very well be that the only thing they're saying is that ADHD is much more manageable if you have (enjoyed) a good, stable upbringing.
- bamfly 3y agoOurs were cheerful happy babies until they turned into moody, constantly-bonkers late-toddlers/preschoolers/lower-grade-elementary-kids on whom zero disciplinary or behavior-correction approaches worked, whatsoever. None. Even a bit. Both were eventually diagnosed with ADHD. Both got on meds. Now we're not constantly stressed every waking second with a chaotic house full of screaming and shit flying everywhere. We'd have thought we were just the world's worst parents, if we hadn't had a third on whom every approach worked, exactly the way the experts say they should. That's when we were like, "oh, maybe it's not entirely our fault, maybe we should take these kids to a shrink". We'd read these books on various parenting approaches, try each very earnestly and consistently for months at a time, and not once would any of it look like it did in the book. Nothing worked. Third kid, no ADHD? It all went exactly the way the made-up examples in the books said it should. It was a revelation. "Oh, this is what this stuff's like for most people! Holy shit, this is so easy!"
- travisjungroth 3y agoSo your anecdote actually does go against the bidirectional relationship in the study. I’m not saying it disproves it or anything, just that this is things going the other way. The model is that there’s a loop of bad behavior -> worse treatment -> worse symptoms -> worse behavior. Taking the kids to a therapist interrupts that cycle. Bad behavior -> more appropriate treatment -> better symptoms -> better behavior.
- bamfly 3y agoWe noticed a correlation between worse treatment and worse behavior, and course-corrected. The trouble was that even going wildly the opposite direction made things better... but just a somewhat-nicer circle of hell, and achieved only at immense time-cost (consistent long stretches of positive 1-on-1 attention, regardless of behavior, amounting to hours a day per kid, were necessary to have any notable effect) that wasn't going to be tenable long-term while keeping all the other plates of life (and we've got a pretty damn easy one, otherwise) spinning—plus, you can't really do that when they're in school, and neither can the teachers. And that still wasn't enough to get us out of hell, it was still really bad. Meds (& therapy—but if this miss that for a couple weeks, nothing bad immediately happens, while if they miss the meds even one day...) did the trick. Amazing. We can just tell them stuff, and they mostly listen. We can talk to them about something they just, moments ago, did that was wrong, and they know what we're talking about rather than being genuinely confused, and will not just commit to do better, but will actually try and maybe not immediately repeat the behavior, even entire minutes (LOL) later, and almost never start to just absentmindedly do it again while we're still talking to them about it. Punishments or harsh reprimands are (and were, after we caught on to those being not just ineffective, but counter-productive, even in very mild forms) reserved for immediate safety problems that can't wait for a touchy-feely approach, or many-times-repeated bad behavior, and don't usually result in hours of backlash-behavior later, as they used to, and do usually have an overall-positive effect. They notice straightforward natural-consequence-type correction and respond to it, rather than its having zero effect whatsoever. But, yes, we can add 2 to N for worsening treatment being the opposite of helpful for (at least our) unmedicated very-ADHD kids, for sure. That was definitely something we saw.
- travisjungroth 3y ago> But Golm noted that “it is important to highlight that the findings of the study are not deterministic. What this means is that the presence of negative emotionality or ADHD symptoms in a child does not mean that they will be maltreated. It only increases the likelihood to experience maltreatment.” Your story isn’t really a counter-antidote all. The study is saying that a feedback loop exists, not that it’s the only variable. If anything, your anecdote supports the study. A baby had a positive disposition and was treated well, avoiding the feedback loop so much that the management of the symptoms stood out to your doctor.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>Which is to say that I'm not arguing against the study, but ADHD doesn't automatically mean neglect, or vice versa. Yes that's how statistics work
- emptysongglass 3y ago> Obligatory counter-anecdote: by all accounts, I was a cheerful, happy little baby. My parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family. And yet, I was recently diagnosed with ADHD by a doctor who, after finishing the diagnostic screening, asked "how are you not homeless?" The doctor's question doesn't make sense given the context you've provided. Do you have a career? The fact that you're on Hacker News and can afford to care for a family indicates you've at least managed your symptoms with any number of tools or methods. So, "why aren't you homeless?" The question answers itself, from all appearances. But if there's something you've left out that could provide missing context, I'd be curious to know.
- operatingthetan 3y ago"why aren't you homeless?" Also sounds pretty unprofessional for a doctor to say and really strange in that context to the point that I don't really believe the poster's story.
- kstrauser 3y agoEh, believe it or not. It's no skin off my back either way. But doctors are people, too, and he and I built an easy, informal rapport. I'm certain he wouldn't have said it if he wasn't sure I'd laugh in response.
- operatingthetan 3y agoSomething is off here. Now you're presenting it as a joke, and previously you offered it as a literal "counter-anecdote" to the OP. If it was actually a joke then it's meaningless in the context of the thread.
- kstrauser 3y agoI think you're reading too much into this. The anecdote is true. It really happened. The doctor's comment, while deliberately phrased humorously, was serious. He identified some quite significant symptoms, and was happy for me that I'd managed to do OK in life in spite of them.
- theGnuMe 3y agoInteresting comment that untreated ADHD is a cause of homelessness. Medication for ADHD is low dose stimulants. I wonder if the meth epidemic stems from untreated ADHD. Then maybe the government regulates ADHD meds to keep people homeless. Or if we treated the homeless for ADHD they wouldn't be homeless.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoI've worked with homeless people in a shelter environment before, and my experience was that the most prevalent psychiatric issues among that population were schizophrenia, bipolar disease, and various addictions (especially alcoholism). There were a few who I thought had some ADHD issues, but I don't know if that led directly to them becoming homeless or not. Granted this does not constitute anything like a research study, but it does suggest that just treating people for ADHD might not have a lot of impact. I did a quick search and was only able to come up with the abstract for a study that claimed ADHD had a ~4-5x higher prevalence among homeless individuals than non-homeless individuals. The abstract alone indicates a couple potential issues with the study (e.g. subjects were only white men, and they used a population sourced from people who had gotten treatment at a particular medical center), and it doesn't indicate any causation. I don't really think ADHD meds are regulated to keep people homeless, and I'm not sure about the meth epidemic being related to ADHD, but I don't think it would hurt to get people the treatment they need, whether they can pay for it or not.
- jowea 3y ago> Then maybe the government regulates ADHD meds to keep people homeless What for?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thatfunkymunki 3y ago> by all accounts, I was a cheerful, happy little baby. My parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family. Maybe a bader-meinhoff effect thing for me because I see that my previous comment on HN is also related to this, but I am also an ADHD patient that had similar thoughts until considering a little harder about what that actually means for someone who is neurodivergent. I read a book "The Drama of the Gifted Child" by Alice Miller which gave me an interesting change of perspective on this topic. Her other book "For your own good" is longer but also an interesting deeper dive.
- lazide 3y agoNot to say this is happening in your case grand parent poster, but something to possibly reflect on as well - ADHD symptoms seem VERY highly correlated with childhood narcissistic abuse (as in, being in a system of narcissistic abuse from childhood which someone can't escape produces almost the exact same symptoms, when you get down to it). RSD (rejection sensitivity dysphoria) which is coming to be recognized as a common ADHD symptom is very highly correlated to emotional neglect. Narcissists are amazing at convincing everyone, especially themselves, that everything is fine when it definitely isn't actually fine (for someone). The gaslighting of everyone around that is required to sustain this is part of what seems to cause the confusion, anxiety, depression, dysregulation, etc. These symptoms include: - being unsettled and restless/hyperactive, or extremely checked out (including excessive daydreaming to escape reality). Sometimes flip-flopping. - difficulty discerning their own actual mental and physical state reliably, which causes issues self-regulating successfully (including swings between emotional dysphoria, numbness, and hyper-aroused emotional and physical states) - avoidant behavior, often with magical thinking (aka procrastination with 'it will all be just fine') - either people pleasing (and corresponding boundary issues) or extreme defiance of authority. Sometimes flip-flopping. - anxiety and depression (often cyclical/flip-flopping) - constant rumination/distracting self talk - insomnia and odd physical problems which come and go - impulsivity - addictive behaviors - self esteem issues (of various kinds), and self-blaming. - a history of unstable relationships, including trauma bonded relationships. - feelings of alienation Additionally, trauma bonded folks tend to get into cycles where they can't remember or lose track of the various bad things the abuser did (to survive), often defend the behavior of the abuser to others, and have memory issues and confusion which makes it hard to consistently understand the issues and leave/defend themselves. They are extremely common in these situations as a survival mechanism. Additionally, I've run across several folks with diagnosed ADHD/ADD that said their family life and childhood was fine or even great - until they actually started looking at what was going on, and then it started to make more sense. All of the close friends I know with ADHD diagnoses had one or both parents that seemed to be presenting with NPD or NPD like symptoms (if you actually looked/knew them), and if you knew what to ask for, a history of emotional abuse or neglect. Additionally, this background seems to be extremely common among Engineers. A common pattern with ADHD is for folks to lean heavily on the rational mind as a coping method, as they can't trust their emotions, or often have problems trusting people (even those they are supposed to trust, including themselves), and have learned to rely on concrete evidence (instead of gut feel), documentation, rules (either to follow, or to avoid), and pure rationality as a coping mechanism. Additionally, there is a massive amount of overlap with Complex PTSD, which many folks seem to have taken to refer to as 'childhood PTSD' - as it is due to long term, ongoing exposure to trauma that someone can neither escape nor process successfully, the conditions for which are easier to produce in childhood than in adulthood in the modern world. [https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/post-traumatic-stress-disorder-ptsd/complex/ https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/post-traumatic-s...] The meds helped them, as before that, they often got really confused as to what was going on, or couldn't feel/tell what they were feeling in a useful way. A common issue with folks being abused by someone with NPD is they get trapped because of the confusion and stress produced by the person with NPD on their target, due to the constant emotional manipulation (and other things) denying the reality they are actually in and what they know to actually be true, along with corresponding punishment (often subtle or indirect) if things start to actually get better for the target. As to if these are all the same thing or completely different things, or if it's multi-generational abuse showing up, or genetic predispositions to certain types of processing issues related to otherwise normal environments and child rearing? There doesn't seem to be a clear answer. What does seem to be clear is that ADHD diagnoses have been skyrocketing while clearly narcissistic behavior is also skyrocketing (not necessarily NPD mind you, but definitely narcissistic behaviors and manipulation).
- annie_muss 3y agoI have a very similar story. Come from a stable loving family and initially did well. Only after leaving home did I come up against the wall of ADHD. On reflection, my parents and teachers were providing a huge amount of support. Outside of that supportive environment things fell apart: lost many jobs, couldn't keep up with basic life tasks. If I hadn't been so lucky I could've easily been homeless. I finally got diagnosed at 30 and the doctor was similarly surprised.