6 ms·
Longitudinal study on the relationship between childhood maltreatment and ADHD
- dommer 3y agoThe title could have been worded better.
- voisin 3y agoDr Gabor Mate has a book on ADHD that is very readable and covers this well.
- bartchamdo 3y agoWhat is the title?
- tremon 3y agoThe GP is referring to Scattered Minds, I guess. But The Myth of Normal might also apply (I haven't read the latter).
- voisin 3y agoYes sorry I was referring to Scattered Minds. I have just started The Myth of Normal and there is definitely overlap but SM is specific to ADHD. TMoN is sort of a synthesis of all of his books (Including The Realm of Hungry Ghosts at least, which I’ve read. Not sure about any of his others)
- boomskats 3y agoAmong other things, Dr. Gabor Mate insists that ADHD is not a hereditary condition, something which is commonly accepted at this point. This article also mentions it as accepted fact towards the end ("Given the high heritability of ADHD..."). In my opinion, Dr. Gabor Mate is much more interested in being a contrarian populist / sensationalist figure than he is in science or scientific proof. His tendency to do things like diagnose Prince Harry with ADHD via a 90 minute livestream doesn't do much to change my mind.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoVirtually every other condition described by and psychology/psychiatry is descriptive, rather than explanatory, i.e., an appeal to causes (by which I mean explanatory in a manner worthy of the name, and not woolly and dubious notions like "chemical imbalance"). That is, we are describing some collection of symptoms, taken to be symptoms, which are grouped together for often tacit reasons and pathologized based on some pre-exiting intuition of the normative. (This intuition can be correct, but it need not be. I am merely making these things explicit.) In the case of what we call ADHD, you are effectively saying, that the symptoms most commonly labeled as ADHD have a hereditary cause. I wonder what the environmental angle is here. That is, can what we call ADHD be a response to an environment that is novel or taken as normative, when it is not? If an environment (and I include parents in this) is poorly suited to the child and does not response to the child's objective needs, it would not surprise me if the result is some of the behavior described. Take alcoholism. It is accepted that alcoholism can have a hereditary component. However, that doesn't mean everyone with this disposition becomes one. Environmental factors play a role in making alcoholism more likely. If your parents drink, or you fall in with a bad crowd that abuses alcohol, the chances that you will succumb to alcoholism increase. That doesn't mean it is deterministic, but if you have a predisposition, then it becomes more difficult to resist the temptation to abuse alcohol when put in a near occasion of sin. And culture can encourage or discourage such near occasions, or valorize or stigmatize the behavior in question. Obesity is another example. In the case of ADHD, I can imagine several potential factors. An environment that is biased toward a sedentary lifestyle (kids have tons of energy that needs to go somewhere). A hostile school environment that produces a sense of anxiety and alienation, perhaps though the methods of 'school management' and pedagogy employed. A school environment that is abusive, e.g., through bullying, or by punishing reasonable acts of self-defense. Rigidity of the education system (prioritizing following some program above responding to a child's actual particular needs). Indulgence and softness and a lack of reasonable and age-appropriate discipline as a corrective measure. (We are squeamish about it today, but children have not yet developed their reasoning faculties well, and they haven't learned impulse control or disciplining their desires. This means punishment for obstinate bona fide bad behavior must rely on licit means of producing unpleasantness, as these are readily perceived by children and taken to counteract indulgence.) I can imagine some cocktail of these things playing a role. That rates seem to vary by country (for children <6 years of age, compare the US with Poland; for adults, Australia with China) means it is worth considering cultural factors, or else assume the genetic differences across populations play a significant role, and if so, what affected countries could do about it.
- annie_muss 3y agoGabor Mate has got a lot of publicity recently but his ideas are (to put it charitably) on the fringe. I recommend Russell Barkley's youtube videos and books on ADHD if you want to understand the condition and the current research.
- fsociety 3y agoGabor Mate proposes that genes determine your susceptibility to having ADHD, but environment is the trigger. Russell Barkley proposes that ADHD is largely inherited through genes, quoted 65%-75%, and the rest is environmental. The big difference between them is that Gabor focuses on attachment theory and childhood trauma. Both are beneficial to learn from. It is harmful that the ADHD community does not accept both points of view. Because they complement each other well.
- kstrauser 3y agoObligatory counter-anecdote: by all accounts, I was a cheerful, happy little baby. My parents are wonderful people and we're a tight-knit family. And yet, I was recently diagnosed with ADHD by a doctor who, after finishing the diagnostic screening, asked "how are you not homeless?" I also have a kid who was diagnosed at a young age. Said kid was also a cheerful, happy little baby that we love dearly and did our best to raise into an amazing young adult. Which is to say that I'm not arguing against the study, but ADHD doesn't automatically mean neglect, or vice versa.
- ithkuil 3y agoThis study links ADHD children that are not cheerful and happy with them being mistreated. It probably tells something about the link of the behaviour of the child and the likelihood of it being mistreated. After all parents are human too and many don't live up to the task, which is a very hard task especially if the child is difficult. The study doesn't necessarily imply that all ADHD children exhibit those behaviours. The fact that both you and your child don't perhaps is an indication that there may be other confounding genetic factors beyond the main ADHD traits
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoThis is a good explanation of why the study should be dustbined as another problematic effort to scapegoat parents for their children's mental health challenges. Like "refrigerator mothers" as a 1950s cause of autism.[1] And now, thanks to this study, every parent of an ADHD child can likewise feel doubt and experience a dose of finger-wagging from self-annointed servants of public. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory
- ithkuil 3y agoMy take-away from the study wasn't that ADHD is caused by bad parenting, but that when parents are faced with challenging children and they behave poorly, they make things worse. Is that controversial? Should you as a parent just mistreat your children because they are exhausting you? Some may thing that perhaps acting tough on those kids will somehow solve the problem, but hey you'll just make things worse. Is that framing blaming the parents? I don't think so; I think the parallel with the refrigerator mother is just an emotional reaction on something that is only superficially similar
- PaulKeeble 3y agoLike almost all psychology studies I doubt this survives its first attempt at replication. At most this will survive 20 years, someone else will do a similar study and fail. Either that or a reviewer will determine this study was clearly flawed or biological research will show more likely causes. There is too much evidence pointing to other causes of ADHD at this point on biological grounds to take psychological explanations seriously.
- AlexanderNull 3y agoThis research doesn't claim to show any cause of ADHD, it's only showing potential exacerbating influences on, or at least confounding factors of, the severity of symptoms those with ADHD present later in life. Children who expressed more negative emotional outbursts were more likely to be mistreated later, and those that were mistreated were more likely to express ADHD symptoms, and those those expressed more ADHD symptoms were more likely to be mistreated. There's no causal explanation expressed there, simply correlations that could be used to identify at risk factors earlier on in life. Everyone expresses their ADHD differently and identifying patterns in life that may either aggravate or alleviate the difficulties of the condition can potentially be helpful in the long run.
- dzink 3y agoWhat if you look at it from a different perspective. The body and brain are two roommates with different needs and if you treat one poorly it acts it on the other. If a child has a fast processing brain eager to learn and crunch problems and a body full of energy, then when one or both of those has nowhere to go, they will act out. Families have an abundance of mental stimulation cheap right on their phones, TV, etc. That likely makes both parents and kids less likely to move their bodies as much as the body required to generate natural endorphins and balance the needs of the brain. AKA: staring at screens or people all day and not moving as much as your body needs to will make you miserable, regardless of how successful your mental tasks were. Carbs create more energy for the body and proteins with fat make more food for the brain, if one consumes more of one than they need and less of the other, they will also suffer. If you eat a bunch of carbs you will want to move more and think less. A child or adult who gets to vary physical and mental exertion will be more focused and able to work. Test that. ADHD symptoms may not show as much in tired bodies telling you if the issue is that or an actual pathology in each person.
- theGnuMe 3y agoI mean ADHD is executive function dysregulation. An overtired kid can have a lot of behaviors and be able too tired to work. I don't find myself focused after a long day of work. I think what you mean is that what physical and mental exertion may do is train your body and increase your stamina which improves your focus long term. Sure it may help develop the neural pathways. Much like learning to read is hard at first but then becomes easy. Also people with ADHD can hyper-focus on the things that interest them. I am not sure what you mean by or how you would test varying physical and mental exertion in any reliable way. If we make kids run a mile and then rest and give them a math test what does mean?
- dzink 3y agoMy argument is that if your kid has: 1. A lot of physical energy and is forced to sit on a chair 8 hrs a day, they would be miserable without a way to expend that energy. If they get to burn energy before or intermittently during the task, they will focus far more easily. 2. A mind as fast as a Porche and you make them drive behind a Tractor 8 hrs a day (listening to a slow talker describing things they already know), they would not be happy. I think ADHD is really underutilized mental and/or physical processing power. Some of us think and move like elephants and others like hummingbirds and we have to operate together. The educational system is often designed for the former, not the latter.
- daniel-cussen 3y ago[flagged]
- empressplay 3y agoI know a number of people who grew up in areas where the water was never fluoridated and where the toothpaste had a very low / nonexistent level of fluoridation (rural Australia) and they have ADHD. There's no link.
- daniel-cussen 3y ago[dead]
- tetrep 3y agoI might be reading a bit too deep into this, but the source of data for the study titled it as "Fragile Families" (since renamed to "Future of Families") and it really makes it sound to me, as a laymen, that the data is skewed towards families that might not be representative of an average family / we might not be able to take much away from this beyond the groups that were actually studied. This is a study about a relationship between mental development and abuse, and it's done with a data source skewed towards low-income families with unmarried parents in large cities. Are these families more likely to be abusive or have ADHD in the first place? Less likely? There's a relevant joke that the results of most psychology studies should have "for college students" appended to it. I think this study needs a similar caveat appended, "Longitudinal study on the relationship between childhood maltreatment and ADHD in low-income unmarried families in large cities." From https://ffcws.princeton.edu/about https://ffcws.princeton.edu/about The Future of Families and Child Wellbeing Study (FFCWS) is based on a stratified, multistage sample of 4898 children born in large U.S. cities (population over 200,000) between 1998 and 2000, where births to unmarried mothers were oversampled by a ratio of 3 to 1. This sampling strategy resulted in the inclusion of a large number of Black, Hispanic, and low-income families. Mothers were interviewed shortly after birth and fathers were interviewed at the hospital or by phone. Follow-up interviews were conducted when children were approximately ages 1, 3, 5, 9, 15, and 22 (began late 2020). When weighted, the data are representative of births in large US cities. Beginning with the baseline interviews in 1998-2000, the core study was originally designed to primarily address four questions of great interest to researchers and policy makers: (1) What are the conditions and capabilities of unmarried parents, especially fathers?; (2) What is the nature of the relationships between unmarried parents?; (3) How do children born into these families fare?; and (4) How do policies and environmental conditions affect families and children?
- thevagrant 3y agoDr Russell Barkley has posted a rebuttal to the lack of play opportunities/childhood maltreatment theory. One of the points he makes is there are twin studies and many of these twin studies that show genetics being a large contributing factor. Unless we believe these twins lived in families that neglected only one child. He is one of the most respected researchers in this field. Watch at 1.5x speed https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7hic_eGCA_0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7hic_eGCA_0
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoI believe this as well. I was diagnosed with ADHD a couple years ago and it explained a lot about my life and family. Both of my parents were deeply emotionally disregulated and there was a ton of physical and emotional abuse at home when I was growing up. Looking back at my parents behavior today, I’m convinced that they would be clinically diagnosed as well. In my case, both things were true and I get the sense that this is a fairly common scenario. The bottom line is that we have to learn to adapt and cope with living in a world that really wasn’t designed for us, and not understanding myself led to addiction and a ton of other bad stuff. I have to remind myself that hardly any of this information existed 30 years ago and that my parents were trying to cope, just as I am today.
- hirvi74 3y agoI have the group of symptoms know as ADHD. I was not diagnosed until I was a 22.5 years old a.k.a (my 5/6 year of undergrad). I grew up in the South Eastern parts of the United States some many moons ago. There was no such thing as "ADHD" or any kind of other disorders back then. The school system didn't screen people for shit. You were either "normal" or "severely mentally deficient" -- even then we might share the same classroom. I could go on and on about all the Hell I was put through, but all I can say is that the school system ruined my childhood and teenage years. It wasn't just school. It was my parents, my friends' parents (both to a lesser degree), coaches, etc.. I do not harbor any hatred towards anyone because of it. It was no one's fault -- literally no one knew. I was smart enough to get by, so clear there couldn't be anything wrong with me, right? If I am being honest, all the issues I faced while younger still affects me to this day. As and adult, I still have virtually no confidence in myself. But how could I? I did/still live my life from one failure to the next. I was not unintelligent, but I'm also nothing to write home about. The world works one way; I work another. I'll never achieve what I am "capable" of in life. But that's okay, I won't be the next FAANG developer, and maybe it's not all it's cracked up to be. We all die in the end anyway. My goal is to just enjoy my life from here on out. Not sure how, but I'm just taking it each day at a time.
- asyx 3y agoSame here except that my mother (probably) has ADHD too and my parents are divorced so my mother kinda left me to my own devices because her childhood was more like yours. I have no career ambition besides not hating my job. I don't have a dream employer or want to climb up the career ladder to some arbitrary position in which I can retire. I just want to have fun doing what I'm doing and as soon as my job stops being fun to me I quit. I can't be a failure without expectations of myself. I overachieve just because my bar is so low. Before being diagnosed with 29 or 28, I had so much anxiety because of this. Not anymore. My goal in life is to get up in the morning and not looking at my watch mumbling "only 8 1/2 hours left" to get myself through the day.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]