8 ms·
Farmworkers thought a new overtime law would help them. Now, they want it gone
- changoplatanero 3y agoAnother classic case of not imagining the second order effects of a new law. Workers think that requiring overtime pay will benefit them but the actual result is that their overtime labor is now unprofitable and their hours get cut.
- croes 3y agoIt shows that the worker's wage is to low if they depend on overtime.
- steveBK123 3y agoTo be fair - how many STEM grads work strict 40 hour weeks with breaks included?
- TheBigSalad 3y agoBreaks included? Breaks in thinking jobs are not really comparable to breaks in physical labor jobs.
- poulsbohemian 3y agoIt's more complicated than that... Sen. Saldaña (quoted in the article) has been one of the main advocates for these laws because her parents were (are?) agricultural workers. The early part of her career was spent doing worker advocacy. So she sees this issue from their perspective. She's urban, female, very sharp, bilingual, and personally connected to this issue. On the other side you've got a whole lot of Eastern Washington old white men, who have done things a particular way for decades and don't want to change anything. From their perspective, things like worker housing should count in the overall pay package to offset overtime. I don't think they are lying when they say they can't be profitable on some of these crops, but the other side of it is that they also aren't thinking real hard about ways to improve efficiency, add economic value, or increase profitability. Many of them aren't bad guys. Even though my politics are very different from theirs, I think too often they get treated like country bumpkins, which leads to resentment. Their core identity is that they like predictability. The problem here is that they need someone to give them an out - show them a business path where they can make money and give workers a better deal at the same time. Unfortunately, you've got two sides that don't quite understand how to get to that place, because in part it is a business problem not a political problem.
- Ferret7446 3y agoMicrosoft's contractors say hi. An astounding number of "protective" policies end up doing the opposite of what's intended; you'd think we figured this out by now.
- science4sail 3y agoWashington's overtime law included a three-year phase-in, meant to ease the process. Last year, overtime pay kicked in after 55 hours a week. This year, the threshold is 48 hours, and next year it drops to 40. Schreiber says already, he cannot afford to pay overtime. Instead, he's brought in additional workers to spread the hours around. It's allowed him to keep nearly all his workers to 48 hours a week, not more. This reminds me of how some businesses will cap work hours so that their workers don't qualify as "full-time employees". In my spherical-cow-in-a-vacuum fantasy land, I would attempt to mitigate this by making all such laws use continuous functions instead of thresholds. This would also resolve a lot of the confusion around income tax brackets.
- VancouverMan 3y agoAn even easier solution is to get rid of these artificial and rather arbitrary distinctions and thresholds that have been imposed by government over the years. As we can see here, all they do is introduce economic distortions that in turn cause various problems for both the employees and the employers. Instead of doing productive work, the employees and employers waste far too many resources working around or trying to cope with these unnecessary bureaucratic impediments. Even if such regulations may have been introduced under the guise of helping workers, they've instead created a situation where workers are worse off in new ways.
- yardie 3y agoMaybe I don't understand the math but overtime is 1.5x wage. So to get around it farmers hire 2x workers at 1x wage? It seems that hiring more workers should be more expensive.
- chessgecko 3y agobut if the number of hours you need worked is constant than its cheaper to hire a new worker at 1x wage for that extra hour than the same worker at 1.5x
- mattw2121 3y ago100 workers working 70 hours a week at 20/hour: (100 x 40 x 20) + (100 x 30 x 30) = 170,000 200 workers working 35 hours a week at 20/hour: 200 x 35 x 20 = 140,000
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- kennywinker 3y agoExcept the cost of a worker isn’t just their hourly wage. It’s hiring + scheduling, should include benefits and retirement savings (but probably doesn’t), and in this case I believe the workers live on the farm during harvest, so you now need 2x the beds, 2x the food, etc.
- techdmn 3y agoSeems like unfettered trade with countries with low labor and environmental standards makes domestic production unprofitable. Surely we can only compete by limiting domestic labor and environmental protections. /s
- mattw2121 3y agoThey are going to end up with workers at 2 farms, doing 35 hours a week at each.
- offsky 3y agoThis is exactly what I thought. Or maybe 1 farm will split itself into two separate corporate entities and employees will work 35h for each one and nothing changes.
- ruined 3y ago>This year, Mendoza and two other women approached Schreiber and told him that if he was limiting them to 48 hours a week, they wouldn't cut asparagus this year. They didn't want to be on the farm seven days a week as required during the asparagus harvest. >They had their own economic puzzle to figure out, and fewer hours meant it no longer made sense to pay for child care for all of those days. okay, so he won't give more than 48 hours, but he's still requiring a 7-day schedule. this isn't about the hours, this is about stupid scheduling. and what prevents him exactly from changing the hourly, so the total pay is equivalent? if you take the example of 70h at 30/h with no overtime, 70h at 26/h with time and a half would be roughly equivalent. as with everything management complains about, this is a management problem
- patcon 3y ago> he won't give more than 48 hours, but he's still requiring a 7-day schedule My read is that the workers want more, and the workers want 7-day schedules. They want to work 7 days when there is full work, to store up for winter. But the economics don't make sense when they can't commit fully during that week. I don't like how it sounds, but if the worker from the article if believed to be representative, then I think that's what's going on. > and what prevents him exactly from changing the hourly that's a good idea. a bit weird that it means everyone makes less (and is underpaid by industry standards) if they don't work through the harvest season though... seems like a tough situation all-around Disclaimer: I'm a socialist and cofounder of a tech worker co-operative, so I favour workers rights. I'm just admitting that this situation is confusing :)
- cxr 3y ago> My read is that the workers want more, and the workers want 7-day schedules. No. This is a classic instance of the X/Y problem. If they began working half the number of hours in a day for half the number of days in a week that they had been before, except bringing home the same amount of money, there would be no issue; no one would show up saying, "We want 7-day schedules". The workers don't want 7-day schedules. They want to be paid greater than or equal to what they were making when they were working 7 days a week under the old arrangement.
- kennywinker 3y ago> "I can't hold my employees to 40 hours, because it's just not enough to live on." This is the crux of it. Man wants to pay his workers a non livable wage and have them stay on-farm 7 days a week. That’s an unreasonable proposition. This law might be the wrong lever to pull, but the fundamental issue here is farm owners are trying to get people to do something without paying them fairly. The solution, in my mind, is collective bargaining. Farm workers should group together and demand whatever would help them, and lawmakers should support them doing that - rather than a top-down approach that ends in whack-a-mole. There is no one little tweak from somebody who’s never picked a veggie in their life that’s going to fix this - empower and support the people to fix their own problems.
- oneTbrain23 3y ago[dead]
- johncessna 3y agoThey make 30 dollars an hour. Given you got that far into the article, what are your suggestions for the farmers pain points? How would you price asparagus that needed twice the labor costs to harvest than a box next week that didn't?
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoYes, it is very convenient that NPR picked a type of produce that demands relatively high hourly wages so that labour would look greedy in this circumstance. But make no mistake, the exact same thing will happen on farms with much lower hourly wages where the same level of skill isn't required. As for your second question, you and I both know the answers are difficult. Do you think it's reasonable for American labourers to make the same as a labourer in Peru? Because that's the issue here: globalized trade causing a race to the bottom in labour compensation. IMO there aren't many great answers, but "pay people a Peruvian wage in the US" certainly isn't a good one.
- closewith 3y agoAnd yet, 40 hours at $30 power hour is not enough to live on.
- linuxftw 3y agoThis is only a problem if there's a surplus of labor. Which there is, because migrant workers come in and work for wages that no local person would accept. If you can literally double your workforce overnight while at the same time paying them all less, that's a policy failure.
- poulsbohemian 3y ago>migrant workers come in and work for wages that no local person would accept I'm sorry but this is more political talking points than reality... depending on jurisdiction, many of these ag positions are exempt from minimum wage, where people are still paid based on production. That is - the wage is kept low by regulation, put in place by the people who benefit from keeping those wages low. You aren't wrong when you say there are migrant workers, but it's important to put that in context. In commercial ag, there are many types of workers who migrate around the country (and yes, also into Mexico) following the seasons. So for example if you are a skilled asparagus picker (yes this is a thing, and not a surprise it is mentioned in the article), you may start the season in Mexico, work through CA, and then continue northward following the season. So it isn't just a matter of "wages no local person would accept" but also a matter of training and skill. As an employer, you want someone who has the training and skills who you can trust year after year. Predictability. You don't get that hiring the local high school kids for the summer. Yes, I know there are places like Iowa where corn detasseling is a right of passage, but that's just not the case for the bulk of west coast commercial agriculture.
- linuxftw 3y agoExactly none of what you said invalidates anything I said. If the migrant workers had a lot of in-demand skills, farms would not be able to double the workforce overnight. If there weren't migrant workers, employers would need to train workers. And in order to not lose investment on that training, they'd need to pay their workers more than the alternatives. But they don't, because the exploit migrant workers. How are they exploiting them? Well, if wages go up domestically, the cost of produce will go up domestically. Which means produce from other locations will fetch a higher margin, which will allow those economies to develop.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoThis is a micro example of why planned economies are hard and will usually fail. There are many such examples over centuries: https://ourworld.unu.edu/en/systems-thinking-and-the-cobra-effect https://ourworld.unu.edu/en/systems-thinking-and-the-cobra-e...
- jrgoff 3y agoI wonder if a fair trade style label would help with this problem, allowing farms that provide higher wages to charge more for their products and consumers to have the option to support that or to purchase other cheaper options as their budget and preferences dictate. I know that I have adjusted my purchasing based on organic/grass-fed, etc. labels. I know those aren't perfect, but I hope that they lead to increasingly sustainable/ethical options in the future.
- croes 3y agoPervert system where workers need it to be exploited to make a living.
- kennywinker 3y agoThis article is from NPR, which is theoretically as left as mainstream american media gets. Now look at the article and count the “facts” that the farm owner’s got into the article, and count the “facts” that the workers got in. This is biased writing. It’s telling mostly the farmers perspective, and fully allowing them to weave a narrative - while only talking to the workers to get a few pull quotes backing up one element of the story: that things have gotten worse. “Business” journalism, in fact, most journaism, is from the perspective of capital. We read it, and imagine ourselves in the position of the owners and investors, trying to profit. But it’s far far more likely that if we were part of this story, we would be in the position of the workers, trying to survive on the scraps the owners toss our way.
- bamfly 3y agoThere's a reason NPR's expanded as "Nice Polite Republicans" in certain circles.
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoThey also conveniently selected a farm for the article that grows a type of produce (asparagus) that requires unusually skilled labour that this demands a higher hourly wage than average. The article is absolutely slanted.
- wffurr 3y agoNPR at most leans left. It’s hardly a socialist newsletter. https://www.allsides.com/news-source/npr-media-bias https://www.allsides.com/news-source/npr-media-bias
- gruez 3y ago>and fully allowing them to weave a narrative - while only talking to the workers to get a few pull quotes backing up one element of the story: that things have gotten worse. Well don't leave us hanging. What are some ways this is better for the workers, that you think NPR omitted?
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago
- SoftTalker 3y agoEntirely predictable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HWR_14 3y agoThe numbers in this article were manipulative to make it sound like the bill was unworkable. But the numbers, removed from weasel words like "up to X" bear out that it's a marginal increase. He says 1/2 of the cost to produce asparagus is labor. I won't argue with that, it could be although he late complains about the high prices of other things. Later he "cannot raise prices by 50% because the labor costs shot up." If he paid the overtime, his labor costs would have gone up this year by 15%[0]. His total costs by 8%[1]. After the phase in period, his cost of producing asparagus would go up by 10%. 10% is far less than 50%. Later he claims that "skilled workers make $30/hr". Clearly, the implication is that he pays those workers $30/hr. But he doesn't! For his best paid workers he pays 2/3 of that at $20.XX/hour.[2] That means the overtime rate is what he thinks skilled workers should get paid the entire time! Edit: I forgot to check, but legal minimum wage is $15.74/hr at his farm. That means he's paying a ~25% premium over what they could make at any other job. That's not much. Especially when he didn't pay overtime over 40 hrs/week. [0] They worked 70 hrs/week. Everything after 48 is 1.5x time. So that's 22 hours at time and a half, or an extra 11 hours of pay on top of 70 hours already. [1] Rounding numbers make 15% and 8% [2] Some made "over $1400/week" @ 70 hours/week and everyone makes "under $1000/week" @ 48 hours/week