2 ms·
What exactly were those studies on? Those bags are almost certainly polyethyelene without any additives, which is safe and has been in widespread use for almos
by userbinator 3y ago
What exactly were those studies on?
Those bags are almost certainly polyethyelene without any additives, which is safe and has been in widespread use for almost a century.
Petroleum jelly is far more reactive than PE, although it's substantially the same chemical structure, yet most of us regularly use it on our skin.
If the biggest concern about sous vide is the plastic, then I think that's a very strong argument for its safety, as I'm sure you get far worse byproducts from other more common cooking processes like baking or frying.
- NovaDudely 3y agoWhile the end of your comment could be seen as 'whatabout-ism', you are right that in simply over cooking something or just adding to much salts/sugars to some foods would probably be a bigger issue.
- whatshisface 3y agoOne wonders why they go to all the trouble of these expensive scientific studies when they could just let people on HN make up answers.
- zarzavat 3y agoSalt and sugars are natural parts of our environment and salt is actually a necessary part of our diet. We have organs evolved explicitly for the purpose of maintaining homeostasis of salt and sugar, namely our kidneys and pancreas. For plastics we have no evolved tolerance.
- evilduck 3y ago> For plastics we have no evolved tolerance. Based on what evidence? What do you think happens when you overheat animal fat or oils in a cooking vessel and "season" it? It forms a plastic. We've been living and eating alongside that type of plastic since we learned to cook food as a species.
- TylerE 3y agoThere are plenty of things that are perfectly safe, even beneficial, on the skin that are harmful if eaten, injected, or inhaled.
- qbxk 3y agogenuinely, i ask, like what? i was told by a doctor once that the general rule is to never put anything on your skin you wouldn't also eat, inject or inhale. your skin is your body's largest organ, and allows many types of molecules to pass through it in either direction. if you rub it on there, you may as well be injecting it, the effect is the same, except, in most cases, the magnitude
- vel0city 3y agoHand soap, for one. Probably not a great thing to be eating. I'd probably also avoid eating most moisturizers, those probably aren't great to eat. Anti-fungal creams to fight toe fungus probably aren't for eating as well.
- TylerE 3y agoWell, GP's example of petroleum jelly. In small quantities it's a strong laxative. In larger quantities it's a chocking risk.
- pbhjpbhj 3y ago>Petroleum jelly [...] most of us regularly use it on our skin. I think I've used it maybe a handful of times in my whole life; once a year at the very most. Do you mind expanding on your statement here?
- calf 3y agoMy highschool science teacher told use Vaseline was an excellent moisturizer, she said to put in on after showering, when your skin is moist, for best effect.
- astura 3y agoIt's an ingredient in many topical medicines, like antibiotics ointment. Also an ingredient in some lip balms and lotions (like Aquaphor).