3 ms·
This is a really shallow strawman. No one has been arguing that NASA scientists are better than private sector scientists. The argument is that having a seemin
by lolinder 3y ago
This is a really shallow strawman.
No one has been arguing that NASA scientists are better than private sector scientists. The argument is that having a seemingly-stupid goal that takes a lot of work can spawn off legitimately useful technologies that would never have been targeted by the private sector because moonshots aren't good investments. The theory is that it's a good way to very quickly iterate through many different ideas.
- tombert 3y agoI agree. This is just my opinion, but I feel like stuff is way more likely to be actually be accomplished if there's a tangible goal. A goal, even an arbitrary one, helps you actually figure out the limitations of a theory or design, and if you don't have a goal it is far too tempting to handwave away important questions and live in theoretical land.
- OGWhales 3y agoIn a similar vein, F1 racing has an enormous amount of engineering effort put into it in the name of winning a race and those efforts can have positive impacts outside of F1. It does sadden me that these days their designs are much more restricted, as I enjoyed the wacky ideas we would occasionally see when the rules were less restrictive.
- orwin 3y agoAnd sports, especially after the leagues/OIC fell hard on drugs, are pushing nutrional science (and medecine) like crazy. Even in weird ways: my sister can afford to pay her rent/food herself while studying because she prepare meal plans for a water polo team, which helps her study and find ideas for her college projects. Hopefully she can get through her studies without working in a kitchen again.
- google234123 3y agoThere aren't that many NASA scientists btw and they mostly are drafting requirements for the private sector scientists to actually do.
- lolinder 3y agoWas that true during the Apollo program?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYeah. The Apollo missions flew on Rockets designed and Manufactured by Boeing (S-IC), North American (S-II), and Douglas (S-IVB). The lunar lander was designed and manufactured by Grumman. That said, a lot of engineering goes into setting good purchasing requirements and assessing the results.