5 ms·
> ended up generating an enormous number of inventions later used in everyday life, from freeze dried food to flight computers, NASA has been promoting that cl
by Animats 3y ago
> ended up generating an enormous number of inventions later used in everyday life, from freeze dried food to flight computers,
NASA has been promoting that claim for years. But it's not real. Freeze-drying goes back to at least the 1930s and was used for medicines in WWII, but cost too much for wide use.[1] Flight computers came from the USAF missile programs of the 1950s.[2] Nor was NASA responsible for Velcro, Teflon, or Tang.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/801137/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/801137/
[2] https://www.afmc.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2190783/flashback-the-navaho-missile-part-2/ https://www.afmc.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2190783...
- lolinder 3y agoI don't really care if any of these things originated in NASA or had previously been invented—the bigger question for me is if they would have been widely used if NASA had not put the effort into making them practical. If NASA's moon mission caused them to go deep in the archives of forgotten technology and resurrect ideas that had long been discarded, they deserve credit for that. (I'm not saying this is the case, but you're also not saying that it's not.)
- tivert 3y ago> I don't really care if any of these things originated in NASA or had previously been invented—the bigger question for me is if they would have been widely used if NASA had not put the effort into making them practical. Probably. IMHO, the US military was and is probably far more effective at making emerging technologies "practical" than NASA is. Their budget's bigger and they buy more stuff, often mass-produced. NASA does a lot of one-off and small-run projects.
- ke88y 3y agoThe US military as a guaranteed purchaser, maybe. The US military as an organization, definitely not.
- tivert 3y ago> The US military as a guaranteed purchaser, maybe. The US military as an organization, definitely not. What do you mean? The military will ask for pretty aggressive improvements in capabilities, then be willing to pay essentially infinity dollars to get what they ask for. That was especially true during the Cold War. For instance, my understanding is the military played a crucial step in productizing semiconductors, because they were willing to buy them at volume when they were far too expensive for nearly every civilian use case. That volume allowed for the R&D to drive prices down and make civilian use practical. If the military hadn't been interested, things would have gotten to a much slower start.
- chrisco255 3y agoWe're on the internet which originated as a DARPA project, DARPA is part of Dept of Defense.
- fooker 3y agoThe US military and NASA enjoy a fairly flexible revolving door for technology and talent. For example, see the Hubble vs the two prior spy satellites having the exact same tech.
- churchill 3y agoNo, they don't. The scientists at NASA are as good as those in the private sector. If the private sector needs it badly enough, it'll make it without government interference.
- lolinder 3y agoThis is a really shallow strawman. No one has been arguing that NASA scientists are better than private sector scientists. The argument is that having a seemingly-stupid goal that takes a lot of work can spawn off legitimately useful technologies that would never have been targeted by the private sector because moonshots aren't good investments. The theory is that it's a good way to very quickly iterate through many different ideas.
- tombert 3y agoI agree. This is just my opinion, but I feel like stuff is way more likely to be actually be accomplished if there's a tangible goal. A goal, even an arbitrary one, helps you actually figure out the limitations of a theory or design, and if you don't have a goal it is far too tempting to handwave away important questions and live in theoretical land.
- OGWhales 3y agoIn a similar vein, F1 racing has an enormous amount of engineering effort put into it in the name of winning a race and those efforts can have positive impacts outside of F1. It does sadden me that these days their designs are much more restricted, as I enjoyed the wacky ideas we would occasionally see when the rules were less restrictive.
- orwin 3y agoAnd sports, especially after the leagues/OIC fell hard on drugs, are pushing nutrional science (and medecine) like crazy. Even in weird ways: my sister can afford to pay her rent/food herself while studying because she prepare meal plans for a water polo team, which helps her study and find ideas for her college projects. Hopefully she can get through her studies without working in a kitchen again.
- bdcravens 3y agoElectric cars also existed 100 years ago, but that doesn't mean Tesla doesn't deserve credit for completely reestablishing the category.
- LightBug1 3y agoTheir engineers do get much credit, but Tesla cars (well, at least for another decade) will be known as douche-mobiles. Not an insult. I'm highlighting a business branding issue. A mistake Apple, for example, would never have been so careless as to make.
- ghaff 3y agoWell, one difference is that Teslas sort of are luxury products. Given Apple marketshare in the US among consumers, it's hard to consider their products as luxury goods in the same way.
- ido 3y agoFunnily enough in many countries (India, China?) iPhones are definitely considered luxury/premium (compared to the competition, i.e Android).
- ghaff 3y agoSure. That's why I specified US. Hardly surprising. US-based company and higher income levels.
- ido 3y agoI didn't say you're wrong, just added it as an aside/addendum :)
- brianwawok 3y agoApple are the premium choice in the US as well. Green bubbles are seen as for plebs.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> Freeze-drying goes back to at least the 1930s and was used for medicines in WWII, but cost too much for wide use. Okay, so... the tech existed but was too expensive to actually use, NASA threw a bunch of R&D at making it practical, and now it's cheap enough to use. I'd say that's a great case for NASA getting credit for making the tech useful; that they didn't literally invent it from scratch seems rather beside the point.
- adolph 3y agoDo you know that it was NASA's R&D that made it practical or is that conjecture? From Institute of Food Technologists (IFT): Freeze-drying was invented by Jacques-Arsene d’Arsonval at the College de France in Paris in 1906. Later, during World War II, it was widely implemented to preserve blood serum. Since then freeze-drying has become one of the most important processes for preservation of heat-sensitive biological materials. During the 1950s, industrial freeze-drying of foods began. Freeze-drying is currently used as a preservation method for foods, pharma-ceuticals, and a wide range of other products. https://www.ift.org/news-and-publications/food-technology-magazine/issues/2018/february/columns/processing-freeze-drying-foods https://www.ift.org/news-and-publications/food-technology-ma...
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSo you're a hypothesis is that NASA was instrumental in figuring out how to reduce the cost or mass produce freeze dried food because... That was necessary for 4 astronauts?
- ChatGTP 3y agoSurely the military was more instrumental here...
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoApollo CM and LM had the Apollo Guidance Computer provide very advanced digital fly by wire for the time. (in fact I think it was one of the first DFBW systems). Later DFBW research on F-8 Crusaders started out using the actual AGC as well, interestingly enough. AGC was also one of the first machines to use integrated circuits (to keep it light, no doubt) so you could say that the apollo program also advanced computer research by quite a bit.
- wkat4242 3y agoThose missile computers of the day were mostly analog, lots of gears 'computing' trajectories. Really amazing inventions but not really adaptible to changing circumstances. Which makes sense in an ICBM because it has all the facts known in advance. This is where the much more interactive Apollo computer was really new at.
- Animats 3y agoNike was analog. (I've seen the ground-based analog computers at Site SF-51 in Marin). Atlas was digital, but in the early models the guidance computer was on the ground, with the ground sending commands to the booster during boost phase. [1] Navajo seems to have been the first missile with onboard digital computing. Polaris was self-contained and digital; it had to be, since the sub had no uplink. Missiles showed steady forward progress. Apollo had to solve many technical problems, but often specialized ones, such as how to handle liquid hydrogen in bulk and how to get stable combustion in a big engine. A major criticism of Apollo is that it produced too much specialized technology that was never used again. The Space Shuttle had a different set of problems. It was supposed to be a practical space transport, but only the orbiter was re-usable and it needed a months-long major overhaul after each flight. Not until the Falcon 9 did something cost-effective finally get built. [1] https://siarchives.si.edu/collections/siris_arc_402577 https://siarchives.si.edu/collections/siris_arc_402577
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]