10 ms·
NASA enters ‘home stretch’ to reach golden asteroid
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lax4ever 3y agoFFS NASA, the word is 'quintillion'.
- KMnO4 3y agoWhat the heck is “$10,000 quadrillion”? For anyone who dropped out of grade school, you would write that as “$10 quintillion”.
- EA-3167 3y agoOr more accurately, "It's only worth that as long as it's in space, if you bring it to Earth then it's worth very little, along with all of the iron, nickel and gold on Earth." Talk about crashing markets.
- imtringued 3y agoThe least it can cost is as much as it's marginal cost of extraction and delivery. These asteroids are so large it would take trillions of dollars to extract all the resources.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> if you bring it to Earth then it's worth very little Years ago I did some back-of-the-envelope commodities analysis on this. (Of course, the firm I worked for didn't represent it as such.) It's worth more than "very little," though obviously not quadrillions of dollars. In the long run, the dominating component of unit costs are refining, not transport. The latter is amortized over a large mass; the former limits the rate at which commodity hits the market. In the short term, measured in tonnes, it would be transport. Scaling such that the short term, in tonnes, is a short amount of time, in present dollars, defines the venture's economies of scale and thus minimum viable configuration.
- manarth 3y agoDepending on how quickly it "arrives", it might not just be the markets that are crashing.
- Clockface12 3y agoWell said. :D
- r00fus 3y agoJust don't look up
- LargeTomato 3y agoNASA, capable to capturing a $10 quintillion asteroid but, according to the hacker news commenters, completely incapable of making rational economic decisions. These Internet commenters are so smart.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y ago> NASA, capable to capturing a $10 quintillion asteroid They really aren't capable of capture. It hasn't been done yet, even for much smaller space rocks. This mission will "observe" i.e. fly by or orbit the rock. That's all we're capable of now, so the valuation is quite moot and selling the mission on that basis is close to deceptive.
- svnt 3y agoI prefer exadollars.
- doublerabbit 3y ago1 petapound please
- LargeTomato 3y agoYou are not the target audience. The lower half of the bell curve of target audience did drop out at grade school.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y agoSince that asteroid will only be "observed" by this mission, it's exact value if retrieved is moot. Not that we have the technology to move a dense space object that's "173 miles at its widest point" to a useful place. What would that useful place even be? Would you put an object "173 miles across" in LEO next to the ISS? I doubt it. We also don't have the technology to land it in a controlled way.
- imiric 3y ago> Not that we have the technology to move a dense space object that's "173 miles at its widest point" to a useful place. Would that really be out of reach for what we can currently do? Naively I would think that strapping a few boosters to a rock to nudge it in a direction closer to Earth, and then decelerate it to keep it in a stable orbit, seems like something within our capabilities. It might take a lot of time and resources to accomplish, but I've heard crazier ideas from Elon before. Any reason why it wouldn't work? That said, are there nearer and smaller objects we could mine first? Any ideas why NASA decided to focus on precisely this one?
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y ago> Would that really be out of reach for what we can currently do? Naively. I would say yes. I think you're far far underestimating the thrusts needed to move big rocks and match orbits. But please go ahead and do the math if you think that this extra-ordinary idea can work. Having a 173 mile metal object in LEO is also a non-starter - getting it there and keeping it there are both insanely dangerous if anything goes wrong. The ISS's orbit is not stable without periodic booster thrusts (1). And higher orbits where there is not-one around - how useful are those exactly? They could become useful, maybe. but that's not what we can currently do. 1) https://www.universetoday.com/155694/watch-what-happens-to-astronauts-when-the-international-space-station-gets-an-orbital-reboost https://www.universetoday.com/155694/watch-what-happens-to-a...
- imiric 3y agoSure, I'm aware it would take an extraordinary amount of thrust, but the exact amount will depend on the acceleration and speed we want it to move. If we would be willing to wait decades (centuries?) for it to reach us, it could possibly be done cheaply with solar sails. And this wouldn't have to be anywhere near LEO/HEO to be useful. Getting it somewhere in the order of the distance to the Moon, or even much closer than Mars, would make mining and transportation that much cheaper. We could even blow and transport chunks of it at a time instead of the whole thing, as a sibling comment mentioned. It's not much worth to us in its current location, so these missions are merely exploratory.
- PaulHoule 3y agoIf you had that much precious metal it wouldn’t be precious anymore. The really juicy targets for exploitation are carbonaceous asteroids and the wet asteroid Ceres, the latter of which could be cut up into a habitat for a population larger than Earth can support. People have this obsession with technology and metals but really it is Carbon, Hydrogen, Oxygen and Nitrogen that drive civilization in terms of human bodies, cattle, fabrics, plants, food, plastics, chemicals, etc. Colonizing Mars looks unimaginative and unambiguous in comparison.
- commandlinefan 3y agoYeah I wondered the same thing - without doing any research beyond reading the article, is gold actually useful for anything if it's plentiful? Now, if they could find a lithium asteroid for instance, that would actually be useful.
- ianai 3y agoGold is crazy useful. Platinum is one element I could see having expanded uses if it were suddenly much more abundant too. Lots of use cases for things that are hard to deteriorate.
- RC_ITR 3y agoYeah, what would we possibly do with a near unlimited supply of one of the most conductive metals that is also extremely resistant to oxidation?
- commandlinefan 3y agoWell, thanks for giving me an answer to the question I asked, in your own way, I guess.
- hazmazlaz 3y agoI am genuinely trying to give constructive feedback here - when you say things like "I didn't do any research" when asking a question, it has a tendency to cause people to be dismissive of your question because the act of asking without first expending effort and then advertising that fact makes the questioner sound entitled. Sort of like implying "my time is too valuable, but yours isn't". Next time try leaving that part out, and keeping the question simple, e.g. "What is special about having an overabundance of gold that isn't possible with a limited supply?" or by first doing a reasonable amount of research and leading with that, e.g. "I read a couple of webpages about the current uses of gold in science and industry, but I still can't figure out what would be possible if we had a limitless supply of it, can someone with more knowledge about this topic help me out?" Hope this helps, like I said, I am genuinely trying to be constructive here, and no negativity intended towards you.
- BashiBazouk 3y agoIf this probe confirms what this asteroid is made of, and it's as rare as some articles say we should be putting a colony on this rock before Mars. All the stories talk up the gold but that is a lot of iron that does not require launch costs (or greatly reduced costs). It may not be profitable in the short term, but who ever controls this resource may have a leg up in solar system colonization in the coming centuries.
- hnburnsy 3y agoI find the solar propulsion much more interesting than the mining value ... https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/solar-electric-propulsion-makes-nasas-psyche-spacecraft-go https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/solar-electric-propulsion-make... >But the rest of the journey, once Psyche separates from the launch vehicle, will rely on solar electric propulsion. This form of propulsion starts with large solar arrays that convert sunlight into electricity, providing the power source for the spacecraft’s thrusters. They’re known as Hall thrusters, and the Psyche spacecraft will be the first to use them beyond the orbit of our Moon. >In fact, the thrust is so gentle, it exerts about the same amount of pressure you’d feel holding three quarters in your hand. But it’s enough to accelerate Psyche through deep space. With no atmospheric drag to hold it back, the spacecraft eventually will accelerate to speeds of up to 124,000 miles per hour (200,000 kilometers per hour) relative to Earth.
- thebruce87m 3y agoI thought they had an error in the text with “three quarters” until I remembered American currency. I was thinking “three quarters of what?”
- euroderf 3y agoThrust equivalent to three quarters sounds like a LOT actually. Compounded.
- irq-1 3y ago>In fact, the thrust is so gentle, it exerts about the same amount of pressure you’d feel holding three quarters in your hand. US quarter is 5.670 grams * 3 = 17.01 grams 0.01701kg * 9.8 m/s2 = Force of 0.166698 Newtons
- hrnn 3y agoIf there is no drag to hold it back, why is there a limit on the speed it can gain?
- techbuttman 3y agoFuel is the limiter. Tanks of xenon gas are used for fuel. And if you ever needed to slow down, you'd need to burn even more fuel.
- blackoil 3y agoHow feasible is it to throw a water rich asteroid towards Mars?
- Oarch 3y ago"I'm for the jobs this comet will create."
- thehappypm 3y agoIdea: crash it into the moon. Then mine it from the moon
- credit_guy 3y ago> located some 499,555,545 kilometers away from Earth Looks to me this journalist is not aware distances in space are not constant.
- venusenvy47 3y agoMaybe the article will refresh automatically with the actual distance when you visit the page. That would be a cool science website.
- irq-1 3y ago> JPL is also providing a technology demonstration instrument, Deep Space Optical Communications, to fly on Psyche. This instrument is designed to test high-data-rate laser communications https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/tdm/dsoc/index.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/tdm/dsoc/index.html > ...increased data rates throughout the solar system with 10 to 100 times the capacity of state-of-the-art radio systems currently used by spacecraft. . > Ground systems: A high-power near-infrared laser transmitter at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory’s Table Mountain facility near Wrightwood, California, will uplink a modulated laser beam to the flight transceiver and demonstrate the transmission of low-rate data. > The uplink laser will also act as a beacon for the flight transceiver to lock onto. The downlink data sent back by the DSOC transceiver on Psyche will be collected by the 200-inch (5.1-meter) Hale Telescope at Caltech’s Palomar Observatory in San Diego County, California, using a sensitive superconducting nanowire photon-counting receiver to demonstrate high-rate data transfer.
- MarkMc 3y agoStep 1: Buy put options on gold Step 2: Announce a credible space mission to mine a gold asteroid Step 3: After the price of gold tanks, sell the put options Step 4: Cancel the space mission Step 5: Profit! How long until this business plan works and millions of people’s life savings are wiped out?
- bofadeez 3y agoTo say it's worth $10,000 quadrillion is to completely misunderstand how price formation works by supply and demand. It should say "Asteroid found will make gold under $1 per ounce"