3 ms·
> The first counterargument is that industrial technologies come and go. I graduated college in 1996. I had four language classes - C, Pascal, FORTRAN, and CO
by scarface_74 3y ago
> The first counterargument is that industrial technologies come and go.
I graduated college in 1996. I had four language classes - C, Pascal, FORTRAN, and COBOL.
Out of those four C is still heavily used.
If someone graduated college 20 years ago and they were taught Java, and they stayed on the course as a Java developer, they would still have plenty of work today. If they learned how to use SQL Server 2003, Oracle or MySQL, they would know one of the three top databases today.
> Had she followed that advice in the 60s, she points out, her students would have spent their time studying JCL
That’s kind of irrelevant.
20 years ago Microsoft was king of the desktop, Unix was big in servers and Apple was a distant second when it came to seconds. In 2023, how much has changed?
> This is false. “The only way to improve at X is to do it” is the advice you give when you actually have no idea how to improve…
This is also false. I was an active fitness instructor for 8 years and my cardio was great and also was a weightlifter. I could teach a two hour master class and go hard without giving out of breath. The first time I decided to do an outdoor 5K on a whim, it took me 40 minutes and I felt like I was going to die. I had to do run specific training.
> Instead of substituting for a traditional degree, recruiters are calling bootcamps jokes
I’ve found BootCamp grads far better junior developers when I was in enterprise dev than CS grads.
> My Advanced Software Design Web
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.”
- Swizec 3y agoYou need both. To get good at doing the thing, you have to do a lot of the thing. To optimize your doing of the thing, you have to spend time understanding the thing. Because pure doing eventually hits a wall. Take boxing for example. You can be really good, have great stamina, and even a fantastic jab. But then a coach looks at you and says ”When you throw the jab, try twisting your forearms 10deg more, and adjust your shoulder like so”. Suddenly you have a whole inch more reach. Whoa! And none of those optimizations will help when you’re sparring against a terminator who steamrolls you with 2x your punching rate. Even if all their punches suck. see also: The pottery class metaphor –> https://excellentjourney.net/2015/03/04/art-fear-the-ceramics-class-and-quantity-before-quality/ https://excellentjourney.net/2015/03/04/art-fear-the-ceramic...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scarface_74 3y agoThe canonical thing you are describing uses bowling as an analogy https://daedtech.com/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-the-expert-beginner/ https://daedtech.com/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-th...
- ghaff 3y ago>I’ve found BootCamp grads far better junior developers when I was in enterprise dev than CS grads. And I imagine someone who had a crash hands-on course in plumbing would be better at doing some basic plumbing that someone with a mechanical engineering degree from an elite school. And that's fine if I need some basic plumbing done rather than someone who can model fluid dynamics.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhat do you think the vast majority of the 2.7 million developers in the US are doing? They are your standard Enterprise CRUD/framework developers.
- ghaff 3y agoI don't think I'm disagreeing. If I need some basic plumbing work done, I'm far more likely to hire even a relatively inexperienced plumber than an MIT mechanical engineer with very little practical experience. And if I just need a fairly interchangeable entry-level enterprise developer I might well hire a bootcamp grad rather than an MIT EECS major (who will cost more and may have less hands-on experience). The former may not grow in their job as much--or they may--but that's not really my problem if they help address my current need.
- scarface_74 3y agoI think we are mostly in agreement. Even though I started in computers like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36801868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36801868 I “pivoted” to Enterprise Dev - and really restarted a stagnant career - in 2008-2012 (muddled my way through the recession) Career projection for an enterprise dev is just like a BigTech dev to a smaller degree. Junior engineer - learning the ropes and learning how to be a real professional developer. They will learn the then current frameworks and learn how to turn requirements into code. A boot camp grad has a leg up here. Mid level - they can work mostly independently and by now they can take a relatively complicated feature from requirements to production following standard best practices. They may even be able to lead a team of developers working on a feature. Senior - they can figure out what needs to be done (high ambiguity), lead multiple teams (scope and impact). (After this I happened to pivot slightly and fell into a role at BigTech in the cloud consulting department.) Senior+ - they can have an organizational impact and lead corporate technical strategy. At higher levels, you need to know more about architecture and design. Even in large tech companies, being a good developer and knowing algorithms only distinguishes junior and a mid level developer College wouldn’t help anyone after they pass the L5 level.
- jeremy_wiebe 3y ago> > Had she followed that advice in the 60s, she points out, her students would have spent their time studying JCL > That’s kind of irrelevant. To be fair, I graduated from a small college in 2001 and I still had a course on JCL. Local industry used it and my program was basically a factory for graduating programmers who could help fix Y2K issues.
- scarface_74 3y agoI have a friend who has worked for a contractor for the military who was doing JCL at least as late as 2015. I think another friend is still doing mainframe type stuff today.
- funcDropShadow 3y ago> > This is false. “The only way to improve at X is to do it” is the advice you give when you actually have no idea how to improve… > This is also false. I was an active fitness instructor for 8 years and my cardio was great and also was a weightlifter. I could teach a two hour master class and go hard without giving out of breath. The first time I decided to do an outdoor 5K on a whim, it took me 40 minutes and I felt like I was going to die. I had to do run specific training. This is also false. If you look at professional soccer players. They do all sorts of excercises that you never see in a game. I assume lot's of American footplayers also lift weight in training. Yet there are no weights on playing field. Shouldn't they just play games in training?