13 ms·
Docuseal: Open-source DocuSign alternative
- jstummbillig 3y agoSweet! The SaaS pricing in this space is insane. Will look into it.
- dcu 3y agohave you looked at zapsign.co? it's a good UX and it's not too expensive
- wintermutestwin 3y agoI just tried it out and it was totally unintuitive how to add fields to a PDF. I tried to chat with support, but it wants you to use WhatsApp. (?!) Then I went to their youtube channel to see if I could see a walk through and every video is in Spanish. I guess they aren't interested in other geos like the US.
- Karunamon 3y agoDefinitely going to formally evaluate this; it looks straightforward enough to administer and prices outfits like Docusign charge are just north of silly.
- ketanip 3y agoVery nice and easy to use product. Loved that you provided an live version to try it without any signup wall or anything. Also won't DocuSign accuse you of "misleading" their customers by using a name that is "too similar" to their ?
- paulnpace 3y ago> won't DocuSign accuse you of "misleading" their customers by using a name that is "too similar" Docuseal would be the winner with all the free press, and changing a name costs almost nothing.
- tough 3y agoThey should make a seal be the mascot
- tyingq 3y agoIt does seem on somewhat dangerous ground for "trademark similarity testing", "consumer perception", etc...with "docu-<next word starts with S>". I'd have gone with "DocSeal" or something that was a harder break from the "DocuSxxx" pattern.
- somery 3y agoThanks for pointing this out - it actually didn't expect that because of GitHub and GitLab and i haven't hears any trademark dispures between them. When Gitlab differs from Github by only 2 letters - DocuSeal vs DocuSign is already 3 letters. But i think that's a valid concern and i need to better investigate this - changing the name shouldn't be a problem when the project is still very new.
- tyingq 3y agoYeah, it's one of those things where there's no definitive guidance, just loose tests. It's possible, for example, that DocuSign wouldn't care. But, it seems different from GitLab/GitHub since the second word starts differently. GitHut, GitHow, GitHot, etc, vs GitHub would be more similar here.
- MaKey 3y agoI'd keep the name and not worry too much (I like it). Going after a small open source project would be bad press for DocuSign and even if they did, it would be a promotion for DocuSeal and you could change the name afterwards.
- wintermutestwin 3y agoI think the real problem with the name is that there is a docuseal.co
- reisr3 3y agoWhat is the bar for a "legally binding digital signature"? Is this a very complicated topic - or is it quite simple? I can sign a PDF with OSX Preview for free. I can pay a bunch of money to sign with Docusign. Both produce a PDF with a digital image of my signature. I assume both documents constitute a legally binding agreement, so long as I actually preformed the digital signature. What justification do the e-signature SaaS companies have for their exorbitant prices? I understand the "audit trail" angle - that's just collecting my IP every time I interact with the document. Is this a big SaaS scam?
- hellcow 3y agoDocusign makes it easy to collect lots of signatures from lots of people. That’s the use-case from my POV. 1 signature on 1 doc, use any PDF tool—no problem. When a board needs to approve 4 docs and you need 5 signatures on each, it needs to be easy. Whether that’s worth Docusign’s pricing or if there’s better alternatives, up to you. But it’s objectively a helpful tool.
- haswell 3y ago> Docusign makes it easy to collect lots of signatures from lots of people. That’s the use-case from my POV. 1 signature on 1 doc, use any PDF tool—no problem. Collecting lots of signatures isn’t Docusign’s value prop. The value is signature certification, and a proven track record in court. A single signature on a PDF is not technically difficult. The machinery to reasonably guarantee (edit: verify is a better word here) that it was you who signed the PDF is the thing that matters. The value increases from there as the complexity of the document being signed increases.
- Canada 3y agoDocuSign doesn't really do anything to reasonably guarantee that it was any particular person who signed the PDF. Not that it really matters. If there was something worth suing over then usually there will be plenty of other evidence as to who signed the agreement. Really the only thing that DocuSign does is timestamp the actions on the document. In order to get that a self hosted implementation would need some kind of third party system to act as a witness.
- arnley 3y agoWhat makes docuseal better than documenso, which is in the same space and also open source? https://github.com/documenso/documenso https://github.com/documenso/documenso
- somery 3y agoDocumenso doesn't have all the features that are currently available at DocuSeal - also Docuseal if free in the Cloud when Documenso is $30/month Afaik the only thing Documenso can do is to place a signature - when with Docuseal it's possible to create more complex PDF forms with different field types like file/image/checkbox etc. While Documenso looks like an ambitions project - DocuSeal already appears to be more robust and can become a true DocuSign alternative with all the features already available and open-source
- wintermutestwin 3y ago>Documenso is $30/month WTF? Considering that DocuSign is $25 or even $10 and has the name and weight behind it, I can't imagine that they are selling many subs.
- somery 3y agoHi everyone, my name is Alex and I'm the creator of DocuSeal. I was not happy with the existing mainstream document signing solutions so I decided to create an open-source alternative. I've been working on this project since the middle of May and here is what the tool can do so far: - PDF form fields builder - 10 field types available (Signature/Date/File/Checkbox etc) - Multiple submitters per document - Automated emails via SMTP - File storage on AWS S3, Google Storage, or Azure - Automatic PDF eSignature - PDF signature verification - User management - Mobile-optimized DocuSeal can be self-hosted on-premises or used in the Cloud for free. DocuSeal was built with Ruby on Rails with a bit of Vue3 for complex UI parts like the form builder. Looking for some feedback and would be happy to answer any questions
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agohey. do you have support for pfx based signatures like jsignpdf does?
- somery 3y agoCurrently it’s possible to sign documents only using the autogenerated pkcs7 certificate in self-hosted DocuSeal (it’s done automatically be default). But it should be doable to make it work with different certificate formats to bring your own certificates. I’d be happy to explore those options and would appreciate it if you could open on issue on GH in case you’re interested to have this supported this in the tool.
- _aaed 3y agoLooks like great work for a 2 month project
- somery 3y agoThanks
- dtx1 3y agoHi Alex, what a great idea, thank you very much. Two years ago I was evaluating different signing solutions for the company I worked with and there were two killer features that forced us to go with docusign since at the time they were the only ones really supporting it: 1. Relaying of Submissions to other Signers We often found that we needed to get a Signature from someone at another company. However, we couldn't a priori say "Person X has to sign it". Often we had a contact person that would help us navigate the internal structure of the other company and relay the signing to that person. Docusign has the ability to allow us to say this person we know can decide who has to sign this document, even if we don't know that person. No one else at the time supported that use case. 2. Qualified Electronic Signatures So... Here in Germany our Government has some kind of Angst (might call it german angst) of anything digital. A Handwritten signature on a piece of paper is held in such high regards that the digital equivalent (qualified electronic signatures) require a video ident workflow with a passport held into the camera and so on. This has to be done via a third party service that takes like 15-20 Euro per validation. I know it's insane. There's a reason that theres no german silicon valley... Anyway, there are many situations where this level of validation is required by law. Just my 2cts after dealing with this issue here, I think 1. is something you might look into implementing, cause it's a use case that might come up more often, 2. is just really annoying for everyone.
- phrz 3y agoOne of the features DocuSign charges a lot of money for is batch envelopes, like uploading a CSV to fill out fields and send to different recipients (basically Mail Merge). Is this something that could work in DocuSeal?
- somery 3y agoI was planning to add this week a feature to download csv or xlsx with all the data from submitted documents (the person that posted this link on HN somewhat spoiled the release - it was not be posting this link and wanted to wait just a bit ) But I’m sure this can work the other way around - it should be easy to make it possible to import contacts from csv to collect signatures and data from the PDF submissions form in batches.
- johnfonesca 3y agoOur product Bulksign https://bulksign.com https://bulksign.com does this, the name of the product is directly inspired by that feature (sending same documents for signature to hundreds of recipients).
- KingOfCoders 3y agoThe benefit of DocuSign for me is, my clients already use DocuSign and have no problem using it with me.
- lolinder 3y agoDo your clients even notice, though? I'm a rare user of these platforms, but all I ever see is that I get an email with a link to sign something. Sometimes it's DocuSign and sometimes it's Adobe or something else, but I certainly don't feel any loyalty towards one over another, and as a signer, I certainly don't trust the platforms to hold onto my copy for me. It seems that unless you've got clients who are trying to use DocuSign as their personal document management system, as long as the interaction flow is essentially the same it should be fine.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoIt's usually NDAs they want (an me to provide) to have and DocuSign is fine with their legal department because they use it themselves. If I can't use DocuSign usually I need to print a PDF, sign it, scan it and send it back.
- insanitybit 3y agoI suggest a new name. `SealDoc` etc. The `Docu` part is going to cause you trouble imo. I would also suggest maybe an explainer about how it's possible. Specifically, what makes a contract legally binding if it uses this system? The main reason people use DocuSign/ HelloSign is, in my opinion, because it feels safe legally to do so. Are there laws that make it possible for your service to work?
- quadrature 3y agoWhat is the API like ?, is this something I could easily embed into an application ?
- somery 3y agoembedding will be available in August - the ideas is to create a npm package to bring the PDF document form into apps for developers
- quadrature 3y agothats awesome. great work developing this!
- woodylondon 3y agoAs i understood it the difference was esignature (was what this was providing) and esign was to sign with a digital certificate. esignature is plenty for most things. Docudeal looks really cool and simple! and compared to the crazy costs of HelloSign, Docusign etc. One thing I would say is provide a RestAPI so easy to integrate into our own applications so we can have the GUI on our side.
- somery 3y agoRestAPI integration will be available in August
- supermatt 3y agoThe way a system like docusign works is that it is a (trusted) independent third party that will verify that the owner of email address X is the one that "signed" the specific version of an agreement. By self-hosting, you have access to the infrastructure and can manipulate it to your will. There is no proof that the counterparty signed anything - you could just manipulate it to say they did. This potential for misuse could make it difficult to enforce your contract should you be required to do so.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dtx1 3y agoNot entirely true, cryptographic signatures exist. For example the EU eIDAS Law allows Advanced Cryptographic Signatures to basically just be PGP Signed Emails
- Nextgrid 3y agoWhich unfortunately nobody uses because non-cryptographic signatures (such as Docusign or this but hosted by an independent third-party) are considered good enough in practice. Hell, nobody even has a smartcard reader, and as far as I know none of the eID cards have contactless capability that phones (who all have NFC readers nowadays) can use. I wish smartcards took off and computers included readers as standard. This would not only solve strong authentication but also payments (just insert your bank card and do EMV-style payments with comparable levels of security).
- pohuing 3y agoThe German eID has had that for years now. And it works pretty well. Only problem is that nobody uses it because our processes aren't adapted to it. The first time I used it for anything, apart from signing pgp keys, was to collect 200€ rent assistance and it worked flawlessly in 4 minutes.
- 3y ago
- xnx 3y agoTIL that Google Docs has a built-in eSignature capability: https://support.google.com/docs/answer/12315692?hl=en https://support.google.com/docs/answer/12315692?hl=en In beta though, so consider that when using.
- tiahura 3y agoAdobe Acrobat also has it.
- noodlesUK 3y agoIn order for this to be legally useful to users in the EU/UK, this would need to comply with the eIDAS regulations. I’m not sure what that entails, but it would be worth looking into. A lot of the value of a signature provider comes from it being a neutral trusted third party. They slap a signature and a time stamp on a document, and you can get them to testify that the document existed in a particular state at a particular time.
- o1y32 3y agoSigning documents online is not a technical problem but a business and legal problem. DocuSign and other commercial companies have a business not necessarily because they have any unique technology or the best user experience (they often do), but because they handle all the complex stuff around signing documents. A reality many people don't see is that many commercial companies really have the expertise in certain areas and have the resources to handle the non technical side of things, at least much better than open source communities. Similar to "open source tax filing software", I'm afraid this is another example of people thinking open source solves every problem. I for one don't see myself using any of such tools unless they are actually reliable, competitive and trusted by many corporations and individuals.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y ago> I for one don't see myself using any of such tools unless they are actually reliable, competitive and trusted by many corporations and individuals. People said the same in 1999 for online banking. "According to research by Online Banking Report, at the end of 1999 less than 0.4% of households in the U.S. were using online banking. At the beginning of 2004, some 33 million U.S. households (31%) were using some form of online banking. Five years later, 47% of Americans used online banking, according to a survey by Gartner Group" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_banking#Internet_and_customer_reluctance_and_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_banking#Internet_and_cu...
- Alifatisk 3y agoCan I redact text too? If not, is there any software close to Adobe Acrobats functionality?
- Gasp0de 3y agoHow do these electronic signatures work? Is it PGP? Where does one store the secret (e.g. private key) and how can someone prove that it is really my signature?
- somery 3y agoCurrently the documents are signed with PKCS#1 signature, signed documents can be verified at https://demo.docuseal.co/settings/esign https://demo.docuseal.co/settings/esign (to ensure that they were produced by the tool and not altered/forged by some third party). Additionally I'm planning to add a merkle-based log of documents to ensure that documents were not altered by the party that is self-hosting the tool.
- rkagerer 3y agoIt's great to see fresh efforts being made in this space. I categorically refuse to use DocuSign, due to objectionable clauses in their Terms and Conditions ( https://www.docusign.com/legal/terms-and-conditions https://www.docusign.com/legal/terms-and-conditions or https://archive.ph/y27U4 https://archive.ph/y27U4). Some examples are below. As far as I'm concerned nobody should agree to use their service. Unfortunately DocuSign has monopolized electronic signatures in some contexts (examples from my own local experience: healthcare, real estate), to the extent that it's become exceedingly difficult to request a simple PDF to print, hand-sign, scan and return. Such friction is common at companies who outsource their paperwork to third party workflow providers. I'm fortunate that folks I do business with tend to want my signature badly enough to escalate to someone with authority who can make a procedural exception, but I doubt everyone is so lucky and suspect many users are effectively "bullied" into accepting the Terms regardless of their wishes. Clauses I find objectionable include: - various consents to analytics, including use of my data to feed their machine learning (might have been more palatable if they provided some insight and stronger confidentiality assurances) - 2.1.1 waiver of jury trials and class actions - 8 indemnification (a and e are a little broad, I'm not going to pay for your lawyers in circumstances that don't warrant it) - 9.2 is unfair; any damages caps should be reciprocal - confusing and possibly overly-broad intellectual property rights clause 1.1 (they should explicitely restrict their protections to only DocuSign's IP, not "all IP"). - They expressly disclaim any warranties regarding accuracy, quality, fitness for purpose or that information they provide will be error-free. That feels dangerous in the context of forming contracts. A fundamental value proposition of their business is accuracy ("Oops we made a mistake and actually your counterpart did not really sign the document..."). Liability here falls back to the parties, and as a consumer I refuse to be liable for their mistakes. - Nor am I a fan of increasingly common clauses along the lines of "we can modify our terms at any time and you'll be deemed to accept the revisions" or "you further agree to any other notices we might choose to inject elsewhere onto our site" or vague expectations I consent to additional third party licenses not disclosed at this time (and ironically some of their preamble along these lines seems to be in conflict with 10.8). If you and I agree to something, then later you want to change your mind, you'd better come back and seek fresh consent. If you're making changes so often as to make that annoying and inconvenient, then it's a sign you have too many salaried lawyers on staff and need to replace them with a team empowered to stop wasting my time and yours and get this right the first time. Customer attention is a precious resource, and companies sending out legal updates on a frequent basis can't possibly in good faith expect consumers to keep up with reading them. - I take offense to their Terms page making connections to Twitter, Facebook, Salesforce, Google analytics, etc. and subjecting me to cookies prompts. All this is not required to simply provide me with your terms of use, and somewhat inappropriate seeing as I haven't yet consented to anything. These are off their current website, but I recall similarly problematic terms the last time I started (and subsequently abandoned) a signature attempt some years back. And don't even get me started on their Privacy policy. (Among the various problems... nobody should have to "opt out" of their personal data being sold to other parties).
- sandGorgon 3y agoany chance you want to include docsend functionality ? it is VERY incremental to what you are doing. And a bunch of us would totally pay for it.
- somery 3y agocan you please elaborate what exactly from docsend you'd love to see available in docuseal?
- sandGorgon 3y ago"who saw my document and how much time" on a page level. thats basically the only incremental value of docsend over docuseal. most other features overlap.
- saqadri 3y agoJust today I was forced by Docusign to pay $45/user/mo in order to continue using the service for a single document I had to send out for signatures. Seeing this pop up on HN right after feels really nice. The cloud-hosted version seems to be very simple to use, so nice job on this. Like some of the other comments pointed out, the key element here is trust -- in the 3rd-party platform collecting signatures, and in the confidence that it cannot be manipulated. These are solvable challenges, but calling that out explicitly in your documentation and website copy will help convert skeptics, or at least convince them to give it a try.
- judge2020 3y agoDocuSign is free for 3 signatures a month - did you need more or were you using more advanced features?
- wintermutestwin 3y agohttps://www.docusign.com/plans-and-pricing https://www.docusign.com/plans-and-pricing Looks like it is $10/mo for 5. I don't see free...
- judge2020 3y agoThey don't advertise it, but if you start the trial then cancel, it'll downgrade you to the free plan. The features are limited - you have to upload every time and recreate the fields every time, but it works for occasional use.
- saqadri 3y agoThere was a free trial period that expired, and there was no free option for additional documents that required multiple signers.
- judge2020 3y agoI think you just got hit by their marketing page that hides the fact that there's a free plan. I'm on the free plan and I was able to send out a document with three signers. https://rr.judge.sh/Screenshot%202023-07-20%20at%201.03.45%E2%80%AFPM.png https://rr.judge.sh/Screenshot%202023-07-20%20at%201.03.45%E...
- tiffanyh 3y agoThese projects never realize that eSign tech is a commodity, the actual business you are in is creating market level Trust for your platform. Eg if you’re a CFO, would you being willing to take the risk just to save a couple of bucks on a no-name eSign service for all your sensitive legal & vendor agreements, or use the worldwide Trusted eSign platform of DocuSign - which has gained acceptance by regulators as being an authoritative legal signature of contracts.
- grokgrok 3y agoIf your company has a board and a CFO then sure, go with the trusted solution. If you're starting a scrappy, modern, real world business, things like this can help avoid death by a thousand cuts that is paid microservices.
- FpUser 3y ago>"Eg if you’re a CFO, would you being willing to take the risk just to save a couple of bucks " Typical FUD preached by many online companies to lure customers. Even verbal contracts are enforceable (with the caveats of course). These will be fine for the most boring cases. The others are signed with lawyers anyways.
- gamblor956 3y ago"take the risk" This is the important part you're ignoring. Yes, verbal contracts between businesses are binding, but only to the extent you can actually prove the terms in a court of law. Using DocuSign (or similar) is about risk mitigation, specifically about being able to prove the the contents of the contract in legal proceedings. The risk with being a business that allows for verbal contracts is that one of your vendors may be unscrupulous and truly screw you over. And that's a matter of when, not if.
- FpUser 3y agoYou are suddenly switching from Ducusign vs Docuseal to DocuSign vs verbal. That was not point of my reply.
- trallnag 3y agoLast time I wanted to sign a document with the reputation of a third party I used PandaDocs free tier. Worked fine enough
- guideamigo 3y agoRuby backend in 2023!
- victor9000 3y agoOof, unfortunately the Alfredo license kills a lot of use-cases for this project.
- somery 3y agocan you please elaborate which use-cases? - maybe that's something that actually can be possible by splitting some parts of the project into MIT licensed dependencies?
- victor9000 3y agoI'm thinking of cases where the pdf is accessed over a network. Like integrations with systems that do billing, invoicing, taxes, tickets to a game, rent receipts, pulling pdfs from your email, pulling pdfs from S3, almost everything?
- sizzle 3y agoDocusign legal team is probably foaming at the mouth after seeing this. Godspeed OP
- xvilka 3y agoSuch software works best when there's integration/plugins with most popular PDF viewers and editors: Okular, Evince, LibreOfice.
- ensocode 3y agoThanks for this. An open source solution is so necessary in this space. There is a need for some common trusted party who hosts that thing, as self-hosting doens't make sense I think.
- sandGorgon 3y agoone more point i want to mention - if u intend this to be used for genuine document signing, you may want to switch to a .com domain and do a registry lock[1]. I mean these are legal documents at the end of the day. If u ever want to do enterprise contracts, they will insist on this. Might as well do it now, while ur still early. registry lock is only possible for a limited set of TLD AFAIK. https://www.nameshield.com/en/cybersecurity/registry-lock/ https://www.nameshield.com/en/cybersecurity/registry-lock/