3 ms·
They didn't give directors $750mm of shareholder money. They gave about a tenth of that in stock and appreciation did the rest.
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
They didn't give directors $750mm of shareholder money. They gave about a tenth of that in stock and appreciation did the rest.
- mikeryan 3y agoThis is in reference to a different suit. It’s for Elons comp package not the boards comp. Even in regards to the boards comp they were stock options not stock so the compensation is based on the option strike price not just appreciation.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIssuing stock still costs existing shareholders money in terms of diluted ownership stake
- zamalek 3y agoFurther, if the stock is stagnant or declining, this would be taking money from investors via stock dilution. If Jim puts $10 into the company for 10 of 100 total shares, and you increase the shares to 200 by handing out money to executives - Jim now owns $5 (10 of 200 shares) with his other $5 being used to "print" the shares. This is not currently the case with Tesla, but the stock has a reputation for being volatile.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIt’s taking money from investors no matter what the price does. If the price is going up the existing investors now own a smaller percentage of a more valuable company. It’s just more obvious if you get diluted while the company doesn’t change value.
- harry8 3y agoIf $735m is not paid to directors, for any reason, however it was generated, however it was calculated, whether options, cash, stock or anything else, no matter what - it belongs to shareholders. It is a transfer of $735m from shareholders to directors that is being reversed and sent back to shareholders, where else could it possibly go? (Well lawyers, but that's another discussion.) Note I'm saying nothing about whether this is good or bad or anything else.