27 ms·
The office is a theatre for work (2019)
- andai 3y agoDiscussed at the time (102 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21669726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21669726
- JohnMakin 3y agoNot making a statement vis a vis remote work vs in-office - but for me personally, some of the things mentioned in this post are exactly why I prefer to work in the office. These little things can end up mattering and becoming surprisingly impactful, at least IME.
- castlecrasher2 3y agoAs someone who's been remote-only for about six years, I agree. I'd prefer a balance of remote/in-office work, and the in-office work I've had during this time has been invaluable. Further, I agree with the author that there can be issues with office bullshit and I find that the vast majority of that is due to a combination of incompetence and poor organizational culture.
- backtoyoujim 3y agoThat's interesting. Do you mind saying whether you currently work in an office away from home or work from an office in your home ?
- jeltz 3y agoNot OP but I have done both and right now do a mix of both and 100% agree. These interactions was something I missed a lot when working 100% from home.
- croutonwagon 3y agoI worked from home 100% from Feb 2020 through October 2021 - so roughly 1.5 years. For me - work life balance suffered. I would often be found running back to my office to shoot out a quick email and then be found there working 1 hour later. - Work life balance suffered. I would no longer enjoy after hours lab stuff/HAM/games/music/tinkering in my office at home because the office was also where i did paid work. So it became exhausting even going in there. - office politics suffered. Which, running my infra/ops team, meant things got harder. It was harder for me to prevent shit from rolling downhill as some pushy rando would just directly bludgeon people on Teams etc.. People were generally more dickish and demanding (outside of my control in MANY cases). - Office politics suffered - in person meetings and all staffs and such are times where little things can get communicated. Saying hi to this person or whatnot or just seeing them reminded you that you need to reach out later etc. All zoom meetings and the like suffer from this. And for some it becomes de-humanizing - Work life balance suffered. Family expected me to immediately transition from work mode to home mode, i had little time for myself to decompress at the END of the day. I tried walking, including at the end of and begging of the day, but that was always seen as overrideable by many. - Work life balance suffered. Many started working random hours and would ping me in those times. Setting boundaries helped a little but I got more after hours calls in that 1.5 years than I did int he 5 years prior, or the 1.5 since coming back. - Work life balance suffered. Wife would expect chores and errands to be run while working. When at the office I spend those ebb times working on non-critical stuff, not laundry or market runs. - Managing folks and project became harder. My rockstars did great, even excelled and many have opted to stay fully remote (and I still feel like this is a large swath of people here on HN, supremely motivated and enjoy their job etc). But my average folks had productivity tank. I ended up playing babysitter for some especially bad employees. Literally had folks not so secretly going fishing without taking the time off, only to be found out when fires started and they couldnt respond etc. - Burnout increased across the team, including with some of my best. Partially because of the above. Ultimately i returned to the office, and drug a few along with me. Its helped in almost all of the above. I still work a more hybrid setup, sometimes leaving at lunch and working the afternoons from home etc. But mostly its in office.
- JohnMakin 3y agoI am an IC, but other than that all of this was true for me during the 3 years I mainly worked remote. I definitely can echo what you said about people being dickish and bludgeoning people on remote calls - especially when we didn't enforce a camera policy. People said things that to that point in my career would have been absolutely shocking, and I never have heard anything remotely close in an office setting. I guess it's probably easier to be that way when working with people who are nothing but a name and a title to you, but I don't know.
- cainxinth 3y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs
- jkick 3y agonice! that is I thought to post here
- steve1977 3y agoAnd also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Presentation_of_Self_in_Everyday_Life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Presentation_of_Self_in_Ev...
- rcktmrtn 3y agoNot really though. FTA: > ... These are all ways to avoid bullshitting - but unfortunately there’s one simple way to avoid bullshit - by being critical. It’s far easier to retreat to the critical, negative position and say why things won’t or can’t work. Except… this is a mistake. I think this article does an admirable job contexualizing itself in the very real world of "bullshit" work performance, but simultaneous not being satisfied with giving into cynicism. The bullshit jobs critique is very good and probably does seep into material talked about here, but on an individual level it's a beautiful and worthwhile activity to unravel the parts of the "bullshit" that are actually meaningful. Signaling and performance might be hyperreal and pornographied in the current world, but they still have a valid and healthy version worth considering. The idea that "All the world's a stage, And all the men and women merely Players" is a beautiful part of the human condition that long predates modern capitalism. It's refreshing to read something that acknowledges the need to "meet people where they are" in terms of how you interact, but doesn't give into the narrative that this means you're condemned to a life of bullshit. It's good to have a larger understanding of the world's ills too, but I think people who spend their whole work day just thinking about how their jobs are irredeemable bullshit are fools.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoWell, seems like "Critical Theory", which is about applying "critique" as much as you can in the context of Philosophy or politics or related, is like the Nexus Hub of "Fashionable Nonsense", AKA: Bullshit.
- Pannoniae 3y agoYeah, this is an epidemic in workplaces. Everyone just wants to appear to do things - so the hard things don't get done because everyone is more focused on showing that they work instead of tackling the problems. I don't really have a good solution to this but it's really messed up.
- ryanSrich 3y agoRemote work that’s based on quality output is the solution. At least in software development. My first job was in an office. I became friends with someone who I’ll say mastered the “art of not working”. He was always the first one in, the last one out. When decisions needed to be made, he was the one people would consult with. However, he never did any meaningful work. It’s not like he was a people manager. He wasn’t. He was a developer. But he never developed anything. He just appeared to. That appearance of work gave him job security, raises, and eventually more power within the company. It truly was an art form as I don’t think any company would have noticed. That’s how good he was.
- kzrdude 3y agoHow did you notice?
- HL33tibCe7 3y ago> When decisions needed to be made, he was the one people would consult with. Sounds like a useful employee. Maybe not rushing around constantly allowed him time to actually think through problems.
- ryanSrich 3y agoSure but he wasn’t even the best dev on the team, or even someone I would have went to for answers. He just appeared to be. The entire thing was a ruse. Also, it’s not that he wasn’t running around. That’s actually my point. If running around and looking busy is what it took, he’d do that. Essentially he did everything he could to give the appearance of working. Now that I’ve been in the industry for over a decade, I can say it’s a pretty common type of character. They’re usually the ones that get promoted.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoCoders are the new Managers. Because CPUs are the new workers. (kind of obvious if we are knowledge workers now. At some point we had to invent the knowledge equivalent of a JCB or a steam engine) Now this has lots of implications. Managers are there mostly to organise and supervise workers. If one tech bro can organise a thousand CPUs globally, what is his manager organising? How we treated managers was qualitatively different to how we treated workers (see Unions for example). So do we pay the tech bro what we used to pay his manager? Do we give the tech bro a key to the executive washroom? Should we pair him up with a "politician type" who can go to the meetings? Sort of like how YC funds 2 founders cos that is shown to work better? Work theatre is still a thing, and becomes more performative the less impact your work has on any outcomes. Twitter and Musk has been an inflection point. If firing basically anyone who did not commit code, if that works (for some definition of works) then we are in a new world. "How do you manage a company through code?" - asking the same questions that were asked 500 years ago when we asked "how do you manage a company / state through written words?"
- MikeTheRocker 3y agoThis makes no sense unless you're going to redefine what management means. > If one tech bro can organise a thousand CPUs globally, what is his manager organising? A programmer leveraging distributed compute is nothing like coordinating an organization.
- p_j_w 3y ago> A programmer leveraging distributed compute is nothing like coordinating an organization. It seems some of us have taken the analogy of the CPU to a brain a little bit too literally and reducing human interaction to computing flows. It might be true in a very strict sense if you wanna go hardcore materialist (which is fine philosophically), but it seems like a shitty mental model, doesn’t it?
- MengerSponge 3y agoI'd argue you just need the right flavor of abstraction. I can't wait until you can just type from bschool import mba
- JSavageOne 3y agoThis is why I'll likely never work in an office again. So much theater, posturing, and bs. I'd rather be judged strictly on my results, which remote work maximizes. When offices were still a thing at least one could have some alone time to focus and a sense of privacy. Open offices are awful and straight dystopian unless you're actually a startup with < 20 employees. Why employees put up with that is beyond me, but I'm glad that COVID put offices out of fashion. Just wish I could get some apology letters for the office grunts and Uncle Toms who used to make a big deal out of WFH to make themselves seem relevant.
- imiric 3y agoIME these issues are not exclusive to office work. While they are more visible in an office environment, they also happen when working remotely, but are just less visible, and potentially more out of your hands. In an office you're mostly forced to play these games if you want your career to progress. Remotely you can somewhat avoid them, but ultimately if most of the company is playing this and you're not, you will either stagnate in your role, or be let go.
- civilized 3y ago> Much as we might like to think of organizations as rational machines - the reality is that companies are social organizations and people interacting with people is the way decisions are made and how work gets done. My experience is largely opposite to this. I agree that we usually need to coordinate to take action in modern organizations, but this coordination is often a formality tacked onto the more meaningful individual work that preceded it. 1. Important decisions aren't made in a meeting unless at least one person has thought through the options beforehand and come prepared to explain the pros and cons of each and why their recommendation makes sense. 2. Work doesn't get done in a meeting unless prerequisite individual work was done beforehand. There has to be some thing to discuss in the meeting. An individual has to prepare that thing. Decisions can be made and work done with short, few, and informal meetings, but not without serious individual preparation and production.
- steve1977 3y agoI would agree with this. Most of the work gets done between interactions of people, not during those interactions.
- bowsamic 3y agoThat is what they're saying. Your individual work is placed relative to the social organisation and the interactions therein. That isn't the complete opposite, it's the same thing. Have you ever tried working in a job where your boss just ignores you, no one cares what you do, and you're just getting paid anyway? Obviously, some people are intrinsically extremely motivated even with no contact for years, but many people, probably most, without any social organisation or interactions, will not manage to work, even if they want to. Even just the threat of not having anything done by the next meeting is a huge part of the "social organisations and people interacting with people" that "gets work done"
- civilized 3y agoIt's too vague to know what it's saying. Much like the common experience of an hour long meeting that no one prepared for that doesn't go anywhere. I agree that your interpretation has some truth though.
- isykt 3y agoYou can have work theater or work surveillance, take your pick. Someone has to make sure the money is being spent well and if you’re not good at making that case you’ll get canned. All these “I work better from home” folks never mention how they prove it to the company.
- bearjaws 3y agoWhy would they need to prove it on an arbitrary forum? Shouldn't their company / hiring manager have KPIs for their role and track them ? By maintaining that job they are clearly meeting whomever's opinion of good enough to keep the job.
- michaelt 3y ago> By maintaining that job they are clearly meeting whomever's opinion of good enough to keep the job. By the same rationale, would you agree that if a company insists on workers returning to the office, the are clearly not meeting whomever's opinion?
- Apocryphon 3y agoCompanies rarely openly say decreased productivity is the reason of RTO. It's always obscured in positive-sounding rhetoric about fostering collaboration, etc. The real reason, whether it is actually became they are not meeting expectations on one extreme, or to stroke the ego of executives on the other extreme, or simply to justify office real estate, is known only to management.
- lliamander 3y agoHaving good KPIs is hard. It does not excuse surveillance management, but it makes it understandable. I think it is important for employees that want to have less surveillance put forth the effort to heavily communicate to management.
- jkaptur 3y agoI mean, one easy way I prove it is by showing up on time to meetings because I don't have to scramble between two conference rooms. That's just to start.
- at_ 3y agoOne of the main joys of being a contractor is that this dynamic can be turned on its head. No amount of bullshit can save you from not delivering on a task you have been explicitly paid to do, and people often assume the best (rather than the worst) if you shoot for 'silent success' as a delivery mode.
- throwawaysleep 3y ago> No amount of bullshit can save you from not delivering on a task you have been explicitly paid to do IBM and Accenture are masters at the bullshit of not delivering so they can keep on billing.
- acheron 3y ago"If you can't be part of the solution, there's a lot of money to be made prolonging the problem."
- manicennui 3y agohttps://despair.com/collections/demotivators/products/consulting https://despair.com/collections/demotivators/products/consul...
- acheron 3y agoYep, that’s the one. I think about it a lot.
- w0mbat 3y agoReally, this headline format works for anything, like "The office is a prison for work", "The office is a whorehouse for work", etc.
- drc500free 3y agoA good exploration of these metaphors is Gareth Morgan's Images of Organization[1] . To your point, my personal favorite is "Organization as Psychic Prison" - not in the sense of keeping physically curtailed, but in the sense that it is hard for workers to break out of the memes and processes of an administrative organization. A good summary is here[2]: 1. Machine: an organization is a series of connected parts arranged in a logical order in order to produce a repeatable output 2. Organism: an organization is a collective response to its environment and, to survive, must adapt as the environment changes 3. Brain: an organization is a set of functions designed to process information and learn over time 4. Cultural System: an organization is a mini-society, with its own culture and subcultures defined by their values, norms, beliefs, and rituals 5. Political System: an organization is a game of gaining, influencing, and coordinating power 6. Psychic Prison: an organization is a collection of myths and stories that restrict people’s thoughts, ideas, and actions 7. Instrument of Domination: an organization is a means to impose one’s will on others and exploit resources for personal gains 8. Flux and Transformation: an organization is an ever-changing system indivisible from its environment [1] https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/196016 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/196016 [2] https://academy.nobl.io/gareth-morgan-organizational-metaphors/ https://academy.nobl.io/gareth-morgan-organizational-metapho...
- _8j50 3y ago- Brown nosers who have minimal competence but get ahead by doing anything but their job - Coworkers who play politics based on shoulder surfing others - Coworkers getting bullied and isolated because they don't do face to face social crap well enough to get in with right "office gang" as I call them. - Having to look busy and do busy work so you don't look unproductive even though you are - For big companies: coworkers in remote offices and different time zones don't get the same career opportunities because they can't be face to face with the right people - Huge one for me: Having to tolerate bullshit political debate and tasteless jokes in the background (open office) and even forced participation when I just want to do my job without hearing about freaking trump or biden and shit or who random people like to have sex with and how! I don't get it. I mean I would think the legal people would be all for remote working just because of the liability it removes. It sure us a theatre except most participants play the role of a third rate congressman or think the story is about prison life/gangs. I admit to exaggerating a bit on some points but I am confident that if you just want people to do office work and be productive, remote work is the best way. If you can't then either you are managing wrong or you have a lot of people whose only skill was office politics and theatrics who don't know how to bullshit remotely. I think "the great reshuffling" might be triggered largley by that. A lot of bullshitters like that can do great in roles where face to face manipulation is useful for example.
- imiric 3y agoThis resonates a lot with my experience. Take OKRs, for example. Everyone is expected to set their target goals, publicize and discuss them with others, and follow them religiously. Otherwise you send the signal that you don't like setting goals for yourself, and thus have no desire for self-improvement, which reflects poorly on your performance review. There are company-wide ceremonies about OKRs themselves; workshops, office hours and endless discussions about best ways to plan, track and meet your objectives. The amount of time and effort spent just doing this management work makes up a large portion of working hours. Speaking of performance reviews, they're another huge waste of time. In the ever-important self-review you're expected to present proof to your higher-ups that you're not only worthy of keeping the job, but also why you deserve that 4% raise. So you better have been taking notes of your accomplishments in the past 6 months, otherwise those OKRs might come in handy. Your work would apparently be invisible to the company if there were no performance reviews, so make sure to make the best case for yourself, and to cherry-pick peers that would leave you a positive review. The amount of theatre and politics involved in modern work culture is exhausting. I just want to get good work done, and go home.
- RetpolineDrama 3y agoYou brought this on yourself when you signed up to work at $bigCo. There's a whole wonderful world of startups out there that don't work this way, and it sounds like you'd be a lot happier there.
- sarchertech 3y agoI’ve also worked at plenty of startups that worked just like this. Once they hire an engineering VP from bigco, the infection spreads quickly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 3y agoSmaller shops too, not just startups. I've been in places with ~300 employees that don't have all that ceremony around performance and self set goals.
- ryandrake 3y agoAn Ex-Google employee had a hot-take[1] on Twitter a few months ago that nicely sums up the fact that work theatrics are starting to become the only thing that matters. It seems every year work (at many companies) becomes more and more about performance art and self-promotion and telling a story about getting things done, than it is about actually getting things done. 1: https://twitter.com/bengold/status/1618589049803132931?lang=en https://twitter.com/bengold/status/1618589049803132931?lang=...
- js8 3y agoI think it's because the rise of liberalism in the recent decades. Every political/economic system has a way how individuals can freeride at other's expense (be selfish). In authoritarian systems, it happens through becoming a corrupt authority. In collectivist systems, it happens through tuning out in lazy disinterest. In meritocratic (liberal) systems, it happens through hustle and pretense of usefulness.
- Spivak 3y agoI think it's more base than this; in order to be valued you have to be seen as useful. This is only somewhat related to being actually useful. Workers who haven't drunk the company Kool-Aid have realized that their own personal value is maximized by giving priority to work that is visible over doing the best or most work.
- js8 3y ago> in order to be valued you have to be seen as useful My point is, that's a characteristic of liberal (individualist, meritocratic) paradigm. In other paradigms, your value comes from something else than usefulness. In authoritarian (patriarchal) system, your value is inherent in your (or your family) social status, like your wealth. And in egalitarian (collectivist) system, you're valued (but also less so) inherently by virtue of being part of the group.
- nullc 3y ago
- aprdm 3y ago100% ! Doesn't take any of it too seriously, try your best to be part of the act and have a positive impact on it, don't get upset if it isn't working out for whatever reason or if it simply isn't your kind of theatre ! There are many theatres out there..
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoThe most obvious example I can think of is the "walk and talk". For a casual work conversation, walk around the office and talk to your peer. You are literally going around performing work for an audience, intentionally or not. Sure, "presentations" are also performance, but are really a caricature of work.
- booleandilemma 3y agoThis idea, that work is theater, the only thing that matters is the performance, not actually getting work done, etc. is to me symptomatic of some kind of bubble. Real work has always been about work, and if people aren't really working it means that we're in for some sort of correction. Whether that means layoffs, incumbents getting beat out by companies actually doing real work, or something else, I don't know.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoKeep going down the clownhole and you’ll realise that nobody really does any work. Take a company like twitter. It’s a finished product but you’ll have 10,000 employees there. You’ll have an entire department for youth engagement. You’ll have an internal theatre group putting on shows. But who actually does work? Maybe a dozen people? The rest are just there because somebody needs to be there because that’s what is done. The problem we have as a species is that we’ve been so effective at optimisation that we have eliminated the need for anyone to exist. A few farmers can feed the country. A few automated production lines could produce the goods. But then all the other people would starve to death. So we just keep on making jobs to put them in. It gets further and further away from reality the further down the hole we go. You’ll have someone who’s job is to read tweets and rate their suitability. Why? To make sure the suitability from the suitability committee is enforced of course!
- Zanneth 3y ago> The problem we have as a species is that we’ve been so effective at optimisation that we have eliminated the need for anyone to exist. A few farmers can feed the country. A few automated production lines could produce the goods. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Human labor is still desperately needed throughout the world in order to keep things running. It’s not just farmers. You also need drivers, clerks, mechanics, accountants, etc. And that’s just to get food into your local grocery store. Nothing in modern life is free, even though it may seem easy for most of us living in the developed world. All of this stuff exists only because people are working really hard to keep it that way.
- edrxty 3y agoAs with most things, the truth is in the middle. This is obvious hyperbole but for the purpose of making a point. There are a __lot__ of useless jobs out there.
- t14n 3y agoYes, human labor is critical for subsistence. But let's look at how many people are employed by industry in the US: https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/employment-by-major-industry-sector.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/employment-by-major-industry-... About 2% of people in the US work in agriculture/forestry/animal handling/etc. If you include transportation workers, that's still about 5% of US workers. And if you include wholesale workers and utilities workers -- that's still < 10% of the US population. All of this work is critical and necessary (to your point). But I think the BLS data is evidence toward OP's point that we've automated and optimized a lot of the work necessary for subsistence.
- coding123 3y agoI wonder if most of life is theatre sometimes. Had a mental breakdown one day when I was younger, when I was taking the bus to work - programmer at a healthcare startup. And I was thinking about some homeless people - and in my head I didn't understand how I was so highly paid and these people - older than me, probably worked as mechanics in the past, or some job that was useful. Then there's me, where I was working daily on code that matches patient records. The company sends me to conferences like HIMSS and there's just all these other companies doing the same thing. I'm just like so I'm basically in sales - all this work that I do on patient matching is so that we can sell some kind of solution to others. What do these other people need it for? Why didn't they pick another company that was better and faster? What justifies my life being a happy existence moreso that someone that fixes cars. I mean that's useful, fixing a car. I still break down periodically and wonder why my life is justified to be so comfortable. Is it just that I've decided to sell out in specific ways that make me worth it over someone else? There also doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason why someone that fixes cars shouldn't be paid massively more. I mean from a utility perspective, this patient matching is just doing a lot of marketing fluff about saving time. It's all a superflous industry though. If things were done differently, there would be no patient matching. And in fact, is a medical record on a computer that much more life and time saving than paper records? How often does a diabetes patient really have a digital record on file that when they come after a car wreck, unconscious, that some specific medication should NOT be given. Are those ER doctors really going to query IHE web services to find this person and know something about them? It's all just weird to me, how we justify and move to the next thing. I guess without "progress" there will be someone complaining, so we keep changing. So the people worth having a house are willing to keep changing with the world. But it's all wrapped up in lots of salesy stuff an feels very immoral. And now I'm not even in healthcare anymore. So I don't even have that! I am no longer able to fake tell myself that "hey I'm saving lives - this is worth it". Is it truly our personal greed that drives us to make our lives meaningful. It's so that we can get that bigger house and faster Xbox and new clothes. Life is all theatre when you think about it. Maybe that's why it's easy to say "office is theatre for work" It's all theatre.
- blippitybleep 3y agoI got myself a fancy job at Spotify. It was a dream come true, or so I thought. I couldn’t believe how many meetings I had to be in each day. I couldn’t believe how little autonomy I had or how much time I had to devote to preparing (months in advance) for performance reviews. I also couldn’t get over how many middle managers had a chip on their shoulder about the idea that “technical” work might have equal value to management work at a tech company. I became a contractor and that’s where I realised the true programmer dream. I just cycle between collecting requirements & analysis and writing code. I spend maybe 2-3 hours in meetings per week, just to aim the cannons, as it were.
- munificent 3y agoI understand why many people will perceive this article as saying that the workplace is inherentely inauthentic or dishonest, but many sociologists will tell you that all social venues are theatre-like. As humans, we have many roles that we take on for the different contexts that we live in. Me as "dad" at home with the kids, me as "husband" with my wife after the kids go to bed, and me as "employee" at work are very different roles. I use different language, have different goals, different tone, different energy level. At the same time, none of those are any less "me". They are all authentic. They're just contextual. And it is entirely natural that knowledge work requires social skills and performance. You may write the most beautiful efficient code in the world, but if it lands in the repo without anyone noticing, it has no effect. It must be seen and used by other humans to provide value.
- nkjnlknlk 3y ago> Me as "dad" at home with the kids, me as "husband" with my wife after the kids go to bed, and me as "employee" at work are very different roles. I use different language, have different goals, different tone, different energy level. FYI this type of code-switching is not universally present for everyone though it may be for you. Some people are their "authentic" selves the majority of the time. It is often suboptimal to be that way though.
- munificent 3y ago> FYI this type of code-switching is not universally present for everyone though it may be for you. There's a difference between overt code-switching like people do when among members of their own race versus others compared to the more basic "I don't tell dirty jokes around grandma but I do around my bros." > Some people are their "authentic" selves the majority of the time. I don't think of any of these roles are inauthentic. People contain multitudes. You're right that some people deliberately collapse their roles and behave mostly the same across all contexts. I think it's usually done as a sort of power play to show that they don't have to behave differently to suit others around them. Trump is a good example.
- imbnwa 3y ago
- DoneWithAllThat 3y agoThese threads are so wild to me. According to the collective HN hive mind, nobody does any real work, managers are totally unnecessary, offices are inevitably a waste of time and money, companies will try to exploit you at every opportunity, and you shouldn’t try to work beyond the bare minimum to advance your career. Meanwhile here I am, with a boss who I feel values and respects me and who is absolutely critical to my job performance and happiness, I make tons of meaningful human connections and collaborate 10x better face to face in the office (not to mention like my coworkers and like doing things like go to lunch with them), have consistently tried to go above and beyond my role’s requirements and have been rewarded consistently in my career for that effort, and absolutely do real, meaningful work every day (albeit as a relatively small cog). All while working for a big company that has politics and problems and bureaucracy but still manages to achieve amazing things despite the hurdles that operating at this scale incurs.
- exBarrelSpoiler 3y agoSounds great, you've really found the place for you. Only question is: what are you doing posting on HN then?
- nkjnlknlk 3y agoSounds like you have some combination of: a) good luck b) privilege (gender; ethnicity; wealth) c) a personality that performs the "theater" authentically d) good people around you e) alignment on your perceived value between others and yourself That is an envious position and one I'd love to hear more about especially since it is at a big company. How did you go about finding this opportunity? What were your interview strategies for identifying bullshit companies?
- dontupvoteme 3y agoI think a lot of companies don't actually make anything so there's no fundamental reason to really care (or if cynical : be proud) As an extreme example - thousands of brilliant engineers would pay money to work for F1 teams. Not forever, but a little while, and certainly not just for the resume, but to say they did it. (I'd be lying if i didn't say I sometimes daydream about it.) As a moderate example - medical technology/devices. It's certainly exploited to some degree on the most global capitalist level (e.g. you can pay people less if they have intrinsic motivation) but there is something neat about working a 12 hour day on something that will help sick people get better.
- RandallBrown 3y agoA few years ago I was offered a job with a very long commute. The pay was good and the recruiter assured my that I could work from home half the time (this was all pre-covid.) After a few months I got some bad feedback from my manager's manager. I rarely had a need to talk to him directly so I almost never saw him or messaged him. He was convinced that however we were tracking story points said that I was less productive from home and I needed to come in more. I came in every day for a week before returning back to my normal two days at home three in the office routine. Shortly after that the office got reorganized and that manager's desk just happened to end up near my new one. Obviously I started seeing him a lot more and he gave my manager feedback that I was doing much better work. Nothing had changed. Work definitely feels like a theater.
- majormajor 3y agoA lot of commentary here on HN about this as an "office vs remote" thing but my read is much more a "large organization" vs "small organization" thing. "We want to ship and try as many things as possible" is often the only way to survive as a small new growing company in a competitive market. But it's rarely what companies maximize for when they're big and successful. The politics and theater comes from normal human interactions in a large group with a lot of intentional overlap/redundancy and not a lot of existential pressure. The org wants to be robust against any individuals leaving, they want to have teams ready to go in case they do need to move quickly in response to something, but most of the time they're just spinning wheels and keeping the money printers going. Remote work isn't going to prevent those dynamics, or the need to make sure you appear to be valuable through all that. If you fail at the "appearing valuable" game in an org like that, you're gonna be at the top of the list to cut when growth slows and the company hits the "reorgs and layoffs" part of the script. The more intrinsically motivated, "let's directly do impactful things!", sort of person can easily end up bouncing themselves off the wrong incentives for years in an org like this.
- moomoo11 3y agoHow about something better? Anyone who's there past series A/B of a upward trajectory company is basically deadweight. Having worked in the past at a tech unicorn, I'll say that the quality of talent that came in later was atrocious. They came from big tech and other impressive places, but they were so rigid and inflexible to work with.. Everything needed "process" or had to be so clear (like following Lego build instructions) otherwise they couldn't operate. I don't wish to bring up a cringe military analogy, but I do believe us early folks had a operator mindset where we understood the mission end goal and executed on it. These guys need calendars, notes, a million SaaS tools, to just ship a new feature that adds a button that makes an API call. I'm talking software "ENGINEERS" (key word) who spent more time making BS documents that nobody read or found much value in (literally never viewed by anyone else). The worst part were the big tech managers who came in later and just made the place a hellhole to work where nothing got done anymore. I honestly believe that the future success of the company was only possible due to 90% of the work being done by the 10% who were there early. These later stage employees were just show we were growing on paper. Honestly that experience has ruined working at companies for me. I just can't do it anymore, especially with people like that who are just bad, full stop period fin. And it sucks to just collect a check because its too easy.
- RajT88 3y agoI've been noodling about this for years now, without really coming up with such a concise thesis. A notable example from my prior job: There was a developer who during the early phase of cloud adoption, wrote some wrappers in powershell for the Azure Powershell cmdlets. They did some quality of life of stuff, and he checked into source control dozens of these wrappers. I recall it being about 80. He got talked about as the azure guy. Some time goes by. I need to do some Azure automation, so I look into those wrappers. They don't do anything useful for most use cases; I write my own automation from scratch. I go on to have many interactions with this dev; he doesn't really know Azure particularly well, but still has the reputation of being the azure guy. I am pretty sure nobody calling him the azure guy actually ever used any of those scripts, and I'm similarly confident those scripts never got used for anything even by him. Don't get me wrong - was a smart and nice guy, and a good dev and great at his job. But - the mythos he had built with those ~80 files checked into source control allowed him to find opportunities to work with Azure and get to know it better. I eventually left the company. Who knows, maybe he really is an Azure guru now?
- dontupvoteme 3y agoTiming is everything For years I was "the big data/programming" guy at a small ~1k total employee company because I spent a lot of time with a lot of freshly available data sources, internal documentation and code, python, PHP and Apache But I never studied anything close to it, just right place, right time and made some tools to help out people/part of the business that needed help. (They were, for reasons not of their own making operating with sticks and stones. Those tools are also software sticks and stones but with ugly glue all over, but they work and that's what was needed and what was done) I'm sure
- omgomgomgomg 3y agoThe office is for bosses who cant focus on work unless they get to micromanage and slow down everything and then think nobody else can if theyre not in office.
- lamontcg 3y agoFuck all this bullshit and work from home. Seriously. This is why.
- kazinator 3y agoI'm in software. The theatre is all in the running image. Hero/protagonist: instruction pointer; the continuation. Antagonist: undefined behavior. Deus ex machina: garbage collection. Comedy: duck typing. Tragedy: static typing. Flashback: lexical closure. Foreshadowing: light thrashing. Situational irony: 90 megabyte hello world. Props: objects. Wings: static objects. Aside: debug trace. Soliloquy: verbose log. Act: component. Scene: module. Script: script.