9 ms·
>At the end of the three-year project, the team aims to have a commercially viable prototype that can be scaled up to commercial production, first as a theft de
by gruez 3y ago
>At the end of the three-year project, the team aims to have a commercially viable prototype that can be scaled up to commercial production, first as a theft deterrent device, and potentially later as a complete vehicle entry and control system that could replace traditional keys and fobs.
What's the point of this? Modern cars already have engines that are cryptographically tied to keys[1]. They're not perfect, but is adding a whole new rube goldberg machine into your car really better than fixing the existing system?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immobiliser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immobiliser
- screamingninja 3y agoExactly. What's even worse is that it takes a huge research grant to come up with this. > With a new $1.2 million dollar grant from the National Science Foundation...
- fnimick 3y agoThat amount of money is absolutely nothing compared to the waste that goes on in the startup industry. Remember the $445 million self driving pizza oven delivery van?
- barbazoo 3y ago> Remember the $445 million self driving pizza oven delivery van? What I find hilarious about our industry is that this could be completely made up ... or not.
- bookofjoe 3y ago>Pizza robot truck startup Stellar snags $16.5M from Jay-Z https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/Stellar-pizza-robot-truck-startup-snags-165m-from-jay-z/633303/ https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/Stellar-pizza-robot-truc... >Stellar, which was founded by former SpaceX employees in 2019, uses a robot to cook mobile ordered pizzas which are then delivered by the truck driver.
- gruez 3y agoThat's nowhere near the $445M claimed though. Crunchbase lists them as having only having raised $25.5M. The $445M if real, must be the valuation. https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/steller-pizza https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/steller-pizza edit: looks I'm looking at the wrong company, see replies for details
- bookofjoe 3y agoAlso, the vehicles have a human driver rather than being self-driving.
- retzkek 3y agoThe $445M figure is for another mobile pizza startup, Zume. https://www.axios.com/2023/06/12/softbank-pizza-robot-shuts-down-zume-445-million https://www.axios.com/2023/06/12/softbank-pizza-robot-shuts-... Discussed last month: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36293636 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36293636
- ilyt 3y agowhataboutism
- Nextgrid 3y agoStartup waste is generally funded from investors though. This seems like it might be funded by government grants which are funded by taxes.
- COGlory 3y agoInvestors using 0% interest loans funded by taxpayers.
- gruez 3y agoAre you referring to quantitative easing/ZIRP or specific government programs that give favorable loans to specific industries?
- COGlory 3y agoQE
- gruez 3y agoThe Fed is the cause of QE/ZIRP, but it's not "funded by taxpayers" in any meaningful sense. The mechanism by which QE is done is that the fed prints money and uses it to buy government bonds and other assets, which pushes bond prices up, and consequently yields (and therefore interest rates) down. All of this doesn't cost the fed anything. The money is printed by them, after all. It's not like they're borrowing money from some other bank at 2%, and then distributing to the wider economy at 0%.
- calderwoodra 3y agoDomino's has a near $14B market cap. Disrupting pizza delivery is a worthwhile venture!
- henryfjordan 3y agoIf you could get that robot-cooks-as-you-drive idea right, even without the self-driving bit, you can out-compete Dominos by saving half the trips (back to store from delivery address). The technology was immature but the fundamentals were there, and they'd save a not-insignificant amount of gas.
- Eisenstein 3y ago> they'd save a not-insignificant amount of gas I wonder the efficiencies of cooking in a vehicle as opposed to a fixed pizza oven.
- henryfjordan 3y agoIt all comes down to insulation I'd assume
- Brusco_RF 3y agoIt will necessarily be worse than the fixed oven.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tetraca 3y agoThat's easy. Put it on treads, and add a tree cutter/stripper, and a hopper, so that it can pick up all the fuel it needs to wood-fire the pizza off the side of the road before it goes to the next destination.
- Eisenstein 3y agoVertical integration. Great idea. It could also have a grain mill so it can stop by some wheat fields and make its own flour.
- fomine3 3y ago
- b112 3y agoWait... so the pizza would be delivered, fresh from the oven?? Is... do you know ... are they taking investors?
- jrockway 3y agoYeah, that startup doesn't sound terrible to me. Like the other comments say, it's a multi-billion dollar industry. If you cook the pizza while you're driving it to the destination, then you change the time 15 minutes cooking + 15 minutes driving to just 15 minutes cooking and driving. Twice as fast. But of course, you could offer the same latency by having a non-customizable menu and having pizzas ready to go when they're ordered. If it's 6:30PM on a Friday night, odds are someone wants the Pepperoni pizza that just came out of the oven. No fancy hardware required. The pizza is technically less fresh, but are minutes of freshness worth millions in VC? I don't know.
- alphazard 3y agoThe "waste" in the startup industry has corrective mechanisms built in. Investors can pull their money out and take their business elsewhere. Taxpayers cannot pull their money out of the NSF and reallocate it to a different government agency.
- janalsncm 3y agoSure. In theory, investors can behave as rational actors. In practice, you get all sorts of chasing the Next Big Thing because there’s too much money flowing around to too little fundamental research. So I’m ok if we spend $1.2M on research. That’s like 5 developers for one year who would otherwise be allocated by the invisible hand into effectively useless endeavors like high frequency trading or ad tech. Cut to the alternative universe where they’re working at Blackrock and a car thief is driving their car away.
- boobsbr 3y ago> So I’m ok if we spend $1.2M on research. I'm not. Where do I opt out of funding government grants? At least I can decide not invest in something if I don't want to risk losing money.
- fnimick 3y agoYou don't get to, because you don't get to opt out of the social benefit that they result in. (remember that government spending basically created transistorized logic, microchips, and computer networking as we know them today. would you have opted out of those too?)
- tstrimple 3y agoYou can opt out here: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/expatriation-tax https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/expa...
- dralley 3y agoGovernment funded research gave us computers, the internet, EUV technology, GPS, lasers, and all sorts of other shit. If you're on HN in the first place, there is an approximately zero percent chance that the few dollars of your tax money spent on this kind of research hold a candle to the benefits you've gained from it.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoPeople get irate about government spending here's a big difference between someone wasting your money and someone wasting their own money.
- mcpackieh 3y agoHow could one justify the other? Justifying waste by pointing to more waste is insane.
- hospitalJail 3y agoThe more politics I see, the more its just grifting.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoWasn't there a rash of thefts of Kia and Hyundai cars recently?
- mrexroad 3y agoYeah, they’re targeted specially because they do not have immobilizes.
- dharmab 3y agoBecause Kia tried to save money by removing said security systems from base models.
- commandar 3y agoThat was because the base model of those vehicles didn't have an immobilizer like every other car on the market as a cost cutting measure. They also have ignition switches that are relatively trivial to bypass. It's possible that some other manufacturer may try it again in the future, but the hit to Hyundai/Kia's reputation has been substantial.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y ago> ignition switches that are relatively trivial to bypass. The switches themselves aren't bypassed. Their design for the lock cylinder is so crappy that it can be snapped off, exposing the peg that actuates the switch.
- dharmab 3y agoThis would be nice to retrofit onto my old Honda, which has an easily exploited flaw in its rolling code system. Modern cars also have new vulnerabilities: https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/ https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...
- gruez 3y ago> This would be nice to retrofit onto my old Honda, which has an easily exploited flaw in its rolling code system. There are aftermarket immobilizers systems as well, that also use cryptographically bound keys. > Modern cars also have new vulnerabilities: https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig... If car manufacturers can fuck up implementing today's immobilizer systems, what makes you think they won't fuck up implementing the rube goldberg contraption? Why do we have to switch to it just to get a non-broken cryptographic implementation?
- goodpoint 3y agoJust like the one from TFA, mass production devices are easily defeated because they are all the same.
- EGreg 3y agoSo let me get this straight Modern cars have engines that are cryptographically ties to keys But the Pentagon couldn’t put biometric locks on their humvees? https://www.ibtimes.co.in/isis-takes-dozens-captured-us-humvees-tanks-syria-iraq-602939 https://www.ibtimes.co.in/isis-takes-dozens-captured-us-humv... They can’t account for trillions of dollars… but we vote them more money they didn’t even ask for https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/us/politics/trump-budget.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/us/politics/trump-budget.... ”Mr. Trump’s budget, the largest in federal history, includes a nearly 5 percent increase in military spending — which is more than the Pentagon had asked for“
- Eisenstein 3y agoLet me get this straight -- there is graft, waste, and incompetence in the defense industry??
- galaxyLogic 3y agoThe men in power always abuse that power, more or less. We need oversight but politicians are not very interested in doing oversight because corporations use their money as free speech helping their favorite politicians get re-elected, because of the Supreme Court decision that allows that to happen. So we need a more informed population to stop corruption from happening, but some politicians don't like the idea that people should be able to read whatever books they want.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat's probably true, but tangential to the absurd point made above. There is almost zero reason to include robust locks or immobilizers on military vehicles. They're either occupied by soldiers with guns. Or in a locked facility, guarded by soldiers with guns. Or abandoned on the battlefield (in which case, they should be scuttled, but shit happens and sometimes you need to GTFO ASAP).
- kube-system 3y agoLocks are often intentionally omitted from equipment in environments where high availability is prioritized. They are also often omitted in locations where physical security is provided at a broader level.
- oxfordmale 3y agoWhat about a classical mechanical key? I am referring to a laser cut key, the type that can't be easily lock picked, other than in Hollywood movies. The problem is relay theft, where thief's relay the signal of your fob key inside the house to the car via a simple antenna and amplifier system. Cryptographically signing won't help. However, this can be fixed by adding a motion sensor that makes key fobs go into a sleep mode when they have been inactive for a minute. Upmarket car manufacturers like Mercedes have started to add this. The only reason this is not yet widespread as increased car theft is good for car manufacturers. Keyless cars top the list for most stolen cars across the UK, with around 93% of all stolen vehicles in 2020 being taken without vehicle keys. Addressing this stupidity would be the first step. It is like projecting your bank account details and security details on the facade of your building, and then being surprised your bank account is drained.
- gruez 3y ago> What about a classical mechanical key? can be picked >The problem is relay theft, where thief's relay the signal of your fob key inside the house to the car via a simple antenna and amplifier system. Cryptographical signing won't help. AFAIK the attack you describe only applies to keyless entry systems (ie. you can open and start a car without having to pull your key out), which is related but not the same as an immobilizer. Transponder keys without keyless entry systems still exist on today's models, and is the default on most cars unless you opt for an upgrade. >However, this can be fixed by adding a motion sensor that makes key fobs go into a sleep mode when they have been inactive for a minute. That helps against someone cloning your key while you're at your desk, but it seems way easier to clone the key while the driver is walking away from the car? That way you know which car to steal and don't have to follow the victim into the building, which might be secured (eg. office building with badge system). Measuring RTT time and/or trilateration (multiple antennas inside car) should be much more reliable.
- oxfordmale 3y agoPicking a laser cut key isn't trivial. Even picking a standard house lock isn't trivial, especially not in the dark. They don't clone the key, they use an antenna to amplify the signal from your key fob and then drive off. In principle you can do this by following someone, but much safer to do this at 2am at night. Similar to a one time password, the signal is only valid for a short period of time.