6 ms·
TikTok Extends the Wasteland
- Pannoniae 3y agoTikTok is like social media without the interactive part. You just watch and consume, that's it.
- Karunamon 3y agoNonsense. It's like any other form of social media in that you can lurk if you want to but interaction is trivial. Comments, video replies, stitches, not to mention the possibility to interact with live streams.
- explaininjs 3y agoWhere are you that you aren’t regularly encountering groups of young people filming themselves for TikTok?
- redeye100 3y agoI've seen a lot of people producing content for TikTok. Both low-effort (just having fun) and high-effort
- anonu 3y agoThe world has always been creators versus consumers. The Internet.... And specifically TikTok, have shown that the creator can fragment into millions of sub genres, interests and tastes. It's a fantastic phenomenon that will continue to play out. Catering to creators opens up a whole set of startup opportunities. Generative AI tools that can help creators better express themselves will do well.
- porridge_ 3y agoI've been getting this feeling about YouTube lately. Every channel seems to produce videos that offer nothing (save entertainment) in return for my watching. I don't want that! I want something better. So my question is how can I counteract the wasteland?
- benjaminbachman 3y agoDon't use it.
- andsoitis 3y ago> entertainment > I don't want that! Do you know what you DO want? If you can express that, then it should be possible to find sources for that, such as education.
- asddubs 3y agoI use the blocktube addon to block almost any channel that isn't educational in nature.
- mdorazio 3y agoIf you watch the videos that only provide entertainment, you're creating demand for more of that content. If you go out of your way to find and watch videos that provide more than entertainment, you'll get more of those instead. And yes, they do exist. For example, I've been working my way through the videos of Cutting Edge Engineering Australia, which is fantastic content if you're at all into machinery or fabrication. On a side rant, this is the same question that comes up with respect to Hollywood and pisses me off. "Why are most films now derivate, SFX-heavy garbage?" Answer: because people keep rewarding those movies with their dollars.
- im3w1l 3y agoA demand change is part of it, but not necessarily sufficient as it's often hard as a student to tell entertainment from the real deal.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoFind channels that will educate you. Hobbies, Documentary, etc. I have just changed out my entire HVAC System watching and learning HVAC on Youtube for the last 3-4 weeks. Saved myself about 5000k-10k. Now I am considering continuing my journey in HVAC Service (since I purchased the tools to do the job) as a side hustle (friends & family or word of mouth). It has been very rewarding.
- KaoruAoiShiho 3y agoThis is a huge problem with mass media. Our brains know that certain content is useless for us yet we still find them appealing. That's why algorithmic content recommendations won't be able to solve the problem, only generative AI will. This will turn our logical brains from consumers to producers, and we'll be able to communicate to the AI the exact content that we want to see and not just be forced to accept the clickbait that's on the market.
- venv 3y agoIf someone consumes what you call useless content, why would they use AI to produce anything else? It's not as if there isn't useful content around, already.
- KaoruAoiShiho 3y agoJust referring to entertainment (ie not educational videos), the clickbait social media entertainment is easier to consume and is readily recommended, you know you have at least a little bit of interest in it. It just tends to be lower quality entertainment than what you know is possible. Long form entertainment is higher investment and higher risk in that if you don't like it, there's more energy/time expended. So there's a choice between low risk entertainment that caps out at like 20% of the value of what your favorite thing is, and higher risk entertainment that very well could still be terrible but might have a chance of being good. AI bridges that gap to de-risk the high investment entertainment so you no longer have to make that choice.
- c22 3y agoThis prompt->generate->tweak prompt loop provided by 'ai' is far more addictive and malign than any existing clickbait. The companies deploying this technology will make fabulous gains at the expense of the consumers who will ultimately waste their entire lives iteratively 'producing' nothing of value.
- amelius 3y ago> Our brains know that certain content is useless for us yet we still find them appealing. And then after watching we think: what a waste of time! So perhaps what we need is an algorithm (AI?) to compute for us if we will like any given piece of content. I.e., the recommendation algorithm should be under /our/ control, not theirs.
- dimmke 3y ago>since the app offers no option to share selectively, posts are instantly available to everyone This is not true, there are many ways to restrict who can see videos you post on TikTok. You can set it to "followers only" or "friends only" where only mutuals see. There's even an option to make a video completely private - only viewable by you. This is common knowledge for anybody who has used the platform in more than just the most cursory of ways, and I suspect that the author has not. Furthermore, the article makes the point that most people (2/3rds) consume TikTok instead of making content for it, then spends the rest of the article comparing it to reality television. People post all kinds of content to TikTok. Short form sketches, their music, short dramatic films. >The term “attention economy” captures the extent of this domination: To be considered worthwhile, ideas must first entertain. Here is a 3 minute video of a transgender person talking about the unique way they connected to the anime Neon Genesis Evangelion: https://www.tiktok.com/@justnausicaa/video/7253444290603388206 https://www.tiktok.com/@justnausicaa/video/72534442906033882... It made me think about the series in a way I never had before, and it's just a person talking to the camera. No jump cuts of "vlogger voice." Then there's satire, where a point is made through comedy: https://www.tiktok.com/@bjcalvillo/video/7231313547857349930 https://www.tiktok.com/@bjcalvillo/video/7231313547857349930 Here's a short clip of a speech Ursula K Le Guin, famed 20th century science fiction author gave in 2014: https://www.tiktok.com/@leftoftheprojectorpod/video/7210068612265135403 https://www.tiktok.com/@leftoftheprojectorpod/video/72100686... Here's something that is closer to what the article describes, but I think it's beautiful: https://www.tiktok.com/@dutchdeccc/video/7223142742933703978 https://www.tiktok.com/@dutchdeccc/video/7223142742933703978 All of these came across my "For You" page in the past couple months. As humans, might we be "wired" to view images of people communicating an idea as more exciting than text? Maybe. But I remain unconvinced that TikTok is somehow "worse" than anything else.
- michaelteter 3y ago“ They repeated every test They checked out all the data on their lists And then, the alien anthropologists Admitted they were still perplexed But on eliminating every other reason For our sad demise They logged the only explanation left This species has amused itself to death “ - Roger Waters, -Amused to Death_ 1992
- brudgers 3y agoPossibly related? https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47311/the-waste-land https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47311/the-waste-land
- gochi 3y agoLoved this article. Many seem to be missing one of the points of the article, which is that there is little separation between "informative" and "entertainment" anymore. You are the performer-teacher. You are the performer-welder. You are the performer-chef. I think about people after the Minow speech, the likes of Julia Child who were on a public station educating people but also the entertainer. You tuned in not just to understand how best to make your next meal, but because of Julia Child. So I don't believe that it's worth trying to dissect the two apart in the modern age, but rather focusing on advertisement. We need far better regulations to address the modern usage of content, and a complete eradication of "native" ads that attempt to mimic the platform's programming. A silly sponsored label tag isn't good enough.
- hirundo 3y agoMy best high school teacher was the best entertainer. He traveled the world in the summers and took pictures of the stuff we were studying, and showed them to us as part of long involved stories that had the whole history class silent. My friends from that class still remember things he told us forty years ago that we would have forgotten before we walked out the classroom door if transmitted in a dry lecture.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoI think this is totally different. From what you describe, I get the sense your teacher showed you things that made the stuff you were studying more real to you (and in the process taught you more about it, too), which is absolutely great. That's way different from, say, some YouTuber or TikToker who always has to stay bouncy and high-energy, and has to keep telling barely-related jokes and stories, just to keep their audience from clicking through to the next thing -- all that waters down the informational content instead of adding to it.
- dvngnt_ 3y agoi would still prefer that than a dry lecture in which they're reading from a powerpoint
- jrm4 3y agoFunny enough, I just watched a Tiktok video that made think the literal opposite of this. For reference, it's this jwilliamsj guy, a young black man absolutely eviscerating another guy's explanation of "Why we shouldn't use the n-word." It was amazing. A methodical, with references, academic breakdown of another persons (arguably terrible) idea. In 5 minutes and entertaining. I don't know y'all. Tiktok is made of people. And while I'm often astounded at the sheer inanity of most of it, I also can't help but see that the lack of a "corporate filter" is definitely bringing some quality -- or at least experimentation -- the likes of which we haven't seen and may really be a counter to e.g. this whole SAG strike thing (which is to say, oh no you mean now Gladiator 2 and Deadpool 3 will come out slightly later? so sad)
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 3y agoHow easy it is for people to believe the absence of what they cannot see
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gruez 3y agoRight, but article isn't arguing every video on tiktok is "a vast wasteland" (ie. "from vapid and violent programing to the clamor of endless commercial breaks"), just that it's the predominant content format. The fact that there's one well researched video doesn't really contradict that.
- jrm4 3y agoBut it seems to aggressively miss the possibility of: "The kids now use and understand the language of 'television', whereas before only 'television' did. The power of attention is on balanced more democratized, and even though it seems weird and crass, it may usher in a new way to 'talk about the world.'"
- red-iron-pine 3y agoa needle in a haystack. the motivated and eloquent were going to make those points regardless of if its on the Tok, Youtube, or radio. democratizing it means that for every erudite point there will be 100 others. half of them will be q-anon or shitposts about kanye west's wife's new outfit
- aCoreyJ 3y agoIn the end I kind of feel like TikTok does allow more positive interactions than Facebook and Twitter promote, so maybe it won't be as disastrous for society and mental health as those platforms have been for millennials
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoSomewhere along the way, for many, the Internet become the focal point, rather than a means of obtaining information that enriches your life. This is the defining characteristic of the overly online crowd: their relationship to the Internet is substantively different to those who aren’t. And it colors how they behave online, and how they socialize.
- thenerdhead 3y agoGreat article. Postman was ahead of his time. Also Jerry Mander(yes, that is his name) regarding advertisement when it comes to entertainment on television. Sadly the conclusion each activist makes is that there’s no way to reform it. We have to live with it. I think the realization of the wasteland helps you in your life if you allow it: https://jondouglas.dev/entertained-from-disappointment/ https://jondouglas.dev/entertained-from-disappointment/
- moribvndvs 3y agoTerrifyingly eye-opening. I’m a Xennial without children. Recently, I spent a week with a sibling and their teen kids to spend a little quality time together. I was mortified to find my nieces and nephews stumbling around like zombies, irritable if not entirely unresponsive and incapable of having any semblance of a conversation, seemingly unable to take interest or pleasure in anything until they were curled around their device and scrolling TikTok. It was infuriating and alarming. I’ve been trying to wrap my head around this. Perhaps I’ve just gotten old enough to take up the mantle of my parents, this is just the same thing I did to them and I should check myself before I make a hypocrite and a fool of myself. Except I don’t feel like this quite neatly explained the rift. > Understanding TikTok through the lens of ubiquitous reality TV allows us to see that oddly named phenomena like “Main Character Syndrome”—in which the overly online dramatize their lives—aren’t aberrations. If TikTokkers act like the stars of their own entertainment channels, that isn’t a psychological issue—it’s an accurate assessment of the media landscape that reality TV established. On TikTok, we really are encouraged to treat our online presence as the proscenium arch, a curated pass to our “real” lives, even when we’re producing content explicitly for entertainment. There we go. See, in _my day_ I was just a passive observer to other worlds. There were countless channels, films, games, etc. that created a reality that was often more vivid and compelling than meatspace. But for the most part, I was just the audience. I unplugged regularly to assert myself to the rest of the world, because that’s what I had learned I needed to do. Now, this alternate reality is bidirectional and real time. They aren’t merely observing, but interacting with the world through the lens of social media. And they’ve been doing it that way for the bulk of their lives, so it feels normal. Everything else doesn’t. This helps me empathize with them more, but not the other way around. It doesn’t really help me rejigger my interactions with them to make them more meaningful. And I can’t help but feel this way of interfacing with the world is disastrous.