7 ms·
Mega-dose vitamin C in treatment of the common cold (2001)
- binkHN 3y agoThis is this from 2001.
- foobarbecue 3y agoIt seems like HN has stopped adding the year to articles lately? Is this a change of policy?
- morelisp 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoNot at all! but the years get added manually, either by submitters or moderators. What submissions did you see that needed a year but didn't get one?
- foobarbecue 3y agoGotcha. I just went back and checked some and they all have years now. Hypothesis: this was a perception bias on my part. The decline of social media has increased my HN engagement so that I'm reading more posts earlier, before they've had the year added.
- dang 3y ago> Hypothesis: this was a perception bias on my part. I don't know if it was or not but you definitely get a chocolate star for considering the possibility. You wouldn't (well, I can't) believe how uncommon that is!
- dang 3y agoAdded. Thanks!
- jozvolskyef 3y agoAnd yet widely believed, even by recent MD graduates*. * n=1 MD graduate, 3rd Faculty of Medicine UK
- NtochkaNzvanova 3y ago[flagged]
- DamonHD 3y agoI read it. The abstract seemed commendably clear. A folk rememdy doesn't pass muster, so easy to save money and not bother for my next cold.
- Netcob 3y agoI could see it being a pet peeve of many.
- gary_0 3y ago/newest is low-traffic enough that plenty of people hang out there, and there are no downvotes.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago"Doses of vitamin C in excess of 1 g daily taken shortly after onset of a cold did not reduce the duration or severity of cold symptoms in healthy adult volunteers when compared with a vitamin C dose less than the minimum recommended daily intake." Double blind, N = 400, and the placebo came out insignificantly ahead.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- halotrope 3y ago[flagged]
- CodeBeater 3y agoIf you don't mind me asking, what things did it help you with?
- dingdingdang 3y agoCount me in. Additionally I don't personally approve of commentators being downvoted for doing something that falls outside the predominant opinion expressed within a thread. Go ahead and post juxtapositional stuff, it's healthy!
- simmerup 3y agoAside from the fact that the study showed no improvement after Vitamin C dosage, you should be careful at that dose in regards to kidney stone formation. Worth staying very hydrated
- dehrmann 3y agoIt does amazing things for scurvy.
- mistrial9 3y agoit is possible that the human body makes an adjustment to repeated large doses of Vitamin C, and simply excretes more and absorbs less material. If the dose stops abruptly, it would take some days for this simple filtering to reverse itself. IANAD
- dctoedt 3y ago> and simply excretes more and absorbs less material My B-I-L once said that Americans have more vitamins in their urine than many people do in their bloodstreams in emerging economies.
- hombre_fatal 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 3y agoYeah, I don't even know where this "vitamin C for colds" thing even came from. It's never made sense to me.
- mihaitodor 3y agoLinus Pauling, AFAIK: https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/07/the-vitamin-myth-why-we-think-we-need-supplements/277947/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/07/the-vitam... His theory has been debunked over and over...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoFrom someone that sells Vitamin C? Kinda like the coat guy who said: if you go outside without a coat when it's cold you'll get sick.
- d13 3y agoOr, “catch a cold”. It’s amazing to me how many people still think that being cold actually causes a cold.
- moralestapia 3y agoHuh? Why wouldn't it make sense? Making sure you have adequate levels of minerals and vitamins while you're sick makes A LOT of sense to me. I literally only take multivitamins when I get a flu or something.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoVitamin C is hard to be deficient in, so it’s no surprise that nobody needs it. It’s why multivitamins look bad in research: it’s unethical to craft a study where people are deficient, so you’re just comparing cohorts of non deficient people.
- LinuxBender 3y agoIt probably also does not help that the studies are done using a synthetic ascorbic acid that has the wrong pH levels and are missing the synergistic trace elements that are always found in plants that have vitamin C. So we need a large number of deficient people and to feed them a lot of raw guava or raw sweet red peppers. I know where to find deficient people but doubt we would be allowed to experiment on them even if they volunteered and it meant free food.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThat pretty much defeats the whole purpose of this research in the first place. The tested theory is that "If you get a cold, mega doses of vitamin C will help it go away faster." It's not a theory that has anything to do with "Your cold will go away faster if you also have scurvy."
- LinuxBender 3y agoAgreed it's not valid nor have any of the other studies. It would be very difficult to find someone only deficient in C. Usually when people are deficient in they are are missing many other confounding and compounding elements as well. It's like watching Mythbusters which makes me want to make a show called MythBusterBusters. obscure reference to all the silly dogmatic scientismatic methods that show used albeit entertaining.
- jibbit 3y agoHundreds of people in the uk treated for scurvy in the last year
- radicalace 3y agovitamin c is overlooked. its a potent antioxidant. ingesting enough antioxidant is going to have some of of effect biochemically.
- meepmorp 3y agoIngesting enough of any chemical will have an effect on your biochemistry.
- wswope 3y agoTo give some context around the history of vitamin C research, the whole idea of megadose vitamin C as an immune system booster/cure for the common cold/cure for cancer was more or less pushed by a single figure: Linus Pauling. He was an extremely influential and successful 20th-century chemist, who earned both a Nobel Prize in Chemistry and a Nobel Peace Prize. In his late 60s, he became interested in "orthomolecular medicine" (the theory of making people thrive through some imagined perfect balance of vitamins), and became an advocate for megadose vitamin C therapy. He used his influence to set up some respectable large-scale trials on the subject, but when they failed to find substantial effects, Pauling basically doubled-down in his beliefs, and spent the rest of his life regarded as a minor quack.
- mjklin 3y agoNobel disease! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease
- DoreenMichele 3y agoIt has been argued that the effect results, in part, from a tendency for Nobel winners to feel empowered by the award to speak on topics outside their specific area of expertise, although it is unknown whether Nobel Prize winners are more prone to this tendency than other individuals. I moderated a list for parents of gifted kids at one time. Bright kids tend to have bright parents, so most of these people were used to being the smartest person in the room and most of them defaulted to assuming that if you disagreed with them, you were basically "just stupid." It was really challenging at first to get people to assume the other person was also smart and likely had good reasons for having drawn different conclusions.
- dev_tty01 3y ago>although it is unknown whether Nobel Prize winners are more prone to this tendency than other individuals. I think we can at least confidently say that other people are more willing to listen to an NP winner. That could completely explain the phenomenon.
- trillic 3y agoAfter a long pacific crossing with no fruit onboard, I'd highly advise all pirates to megadose Vitamin C.
- worik 3y agoLook! There's a duck!!
- water9 3y ago[flagged]
- pilotInPyjamas 3y agoI recommend that people look for a meta analysis instead of individual trials when searching for medical research. Whilst randomized controlled trials are excellent, the sample size is often quite small. A meta analysis avoids this problem by combining the results of many trials together. For example, this analysis: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23440782/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23440782/ finds that whilst the general population probably finds no benefit to Vit C, people who were "exposed to brief periods of severe physical exercise" did. Note that this meta analysis contains 11,000 participants, far more than the 400 in the original article.
- joshspankit 3y agoPersonally I’m more wary of meta-analysis than I am of individual trials. As a reader of a meta paper it’s almost impossible to separate out bad data and it means to be “good science” the analysis compilers must have even more integrity and scrutiny than the original authors (which feels like it’s hard to come by in the current scientific landscape).
- jc_811 3y agoMy totally anecdotal (and probably largely placebo-based) move is to eat a clove of raw garlic anytime I feel a sickness coming on. For whatever reason it seems to work :)
- Animatronio 3y agoSame here, although I eat an onion before bed. I highly suspect it has to do with these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytoncide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytoncide
- distortionfield 3y agoNow I want to see an N=400 study on garlic and onions as cold remedies
- hombre_fatal 3y agoProbably works by keeping the infected person at bay, esp out of kissing / intimate convo distance, so you have time to fight the start of the virus while it’s small.
- trillic 3y agoKeeps the vampires away too. Always a nice bonus for us garlic-lovers.
- aantix 3y agoWasn’t there some contention that Pauling was actually taking the Vitamin C intravenously?
- thenerdhead 3y agoHe did both orally and intravenously later on to get higher doses.
- aantix 3y agoIt’d be interesting to see if intravenous administration changes the results.
- thenerdhead 3y agoIt bypasses the digestive system and goes directly to the bloodstream. Could be interesting to see natural foods vs. supplements as well given the body is more efficient with the former.
- therealdrag0 3y agoSurely there’s more important things to study than age old folk remedies.
- thenerdhead 3y agoIf you are calling Vitamin C an age old folk remedy, consider that only 50 years ago a public controversy had millions of people taking it. And recently, many studies have shown significant benefits to general health. All in the name of finding the right molecules in the right amounts. > Virtually all studies show improved quality of life for cancer patients by minimizing pain and protecting normal tissues from toxicity caused by chemotherapy. Additionally, vitamin C showed synergistic effects when combined with radiation and standard chemotherapies. > Now a growing number of preclinical studies are showing how high-dose vitamin C might benefit cancer patients. Importantly, these preclinical studies provide a clear rationale and potential biomarkers that may help personalize the therapeutic approach and identify patient populations that are likely to respond to high-dose vitamin C therapy https://www.cancer.gov/research/key-initiatives/ras/ras-central/blog/2020/yun-cantley-vitamin-c https://www.cancer.gov/research/key-initiatives/ras/ras-cent...
- 1letterunixname 3y agoMDVC: In an effort to combat the deleterious effects of kidneys with insufficient calcium oxalate kidney stones. ;) Snake oil, grinding up endangered species as "traditional remedies", garlic, and vit C: the cargo cult of pseudoscience marches on. In the case of the Vitamin C fad, it's a classic case of an overconfident public figure operating outside of their wheelhouse where they have no expertise combined with a naive "more=better" assumption.