3 ms·
The initial question was polite and reasonable, as was @mhils's response. What wasn't at all reasonable was the follow-up email from IBM (same person?) accusing
by lolinder 3y ago
The initial question was polite and reasonable, as was @mhils's response. What wasn't at all reasonable was the follow-up email from IBM (same person?) accusing him of a "thinly veiled extortion attempt". Maximilian is not obliged to provide a release schedule to someone who isn't paying him, and it wasn't at all unreasonable to suggest that if IBM really needs a timetable they could pay for it.
Heck, IBM could probably put together their own internal release of mitmproxy today if they cared that much.
- arp242 3y ago> Heck, IBM could probably put together their own internal release of mitmproxy today if they cared that much. They could, and so could I, and most people here if they wanted to. That doesn't mean it's an unreasonable question to ask. If anything it's exactly the sort of question you would ask if you planned to make your own release, so you know if it's going to be worth the effort.
- lolinder 3y agoAgreed. See my first sentence: > The initial question was polite and reasonable, as was @mhils's response.
- arp242 3y ago[flagged]
- gameman144 3y agoI don't find it unreasonable at all, the author is under no obligation to communicate in any particular way. If a stranger drives through my neighborhood and asks "when are you going to plant begonias? I drive through here all the time but I want to see begonias", a fine response is "if you want to pay for some begonias, I'll plant them!"
- arp242 3y agoYou don't have a "begonias, open for everyone to view" sign though. The comparison makes no sense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gameman144 3y agoFair enough, a better comparison might be that my "begonias for everyone to view" yard has a stranger say "when are you going to get bigger begonias?" The response is then the same.
- Shaanie 3y agoYou have "begonias for everyone to view" and purchased a bigger begonia (visible to everyone but not yet planted), and a stranger asks "when are you going to plant the big begonia?". Doesn't sound strange or entitled to me.
- gameman144 3y agoTotally, it's not strange or entitled to ask. But it's also not strange or entitled to reply with "when I get around to it, unless you want to come help!"
- account42 3y agoRight, instead mitmproxy comes with this sign: THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. So not only is there not "begonias, open for everyone to view" sign in this case but there is a big sign saying "NO BEGONIAS GUARANTEED. IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE PLANTS WE CURRENTLY HAVE, THAT'S NOT OUR PROBLEM."
- lolinder 3y agoThe maintainer could theoretically have responded a bit more gently, but if I got that response to a query on a GitHub PR, I would have thought "oops, touched a nerve" and apologized for coming off as pushy. Maintainers are humans, and they're humans who deal with an insane amount of entitlement from unreasonable people. Their "I'm being exploited" nerves are a little oversensitive from repeated exposure, and that's understandable and forgivable. Besides, the fact that the IBM employee followed up the way they did shows that Maximilian's "I'm being exploited" reaction was dead on—the person he was dealing with was not being reasonable. They responded to a very slight escalation in tone by throwing around dangerous words like "extortion". Would you have done that?
- arp242 3y agoObviously "apologized for coming off as pushy" would have been better, yes, but it's not just the maintainers who are human: turns out IBM engineers are also human. It's a simple question that can have a simple answer; there's no reason to not give it, really.
- vsl 3y agoYou don’t give planned release dates to customers as a rule of thumb for the simple reason that somebody will take it as a promise and complain when you miss the date for some reason. It’s a lesson you learn quickly. This goes double for Open Source projects. And the person asking is a leecher like here, I definitely wouldn’t commit to date either.
- hitekker 3y agoI think you’re right; the conversation was civil until the requestor started accusing the maintainer of extortion. Some people in this thread didn’t read that far, and now seem to be to twisting reality to defend their judgement.
- ncr100 3y agoThere was a follow-up? Not being a logged in Twitter user, the remainder of the thread is hidden to me.
- lolinder 3y agoThird picture in the same tweet: > I'm assuming your response to my request for the next mitmproxy target date was a joke rather than an official project response or, worse, a thinly veiled extortion attempt. In reviewing the project's official documentation...
- ncr100 3y agoThank you @lolinder!
- account42 3y agoI don't think the initial response was really reasonable. Expecting an open source project that your company is leeching off of to care about your customer's problems is pretty tone deaf. Asking about a release schedule: fine. Trying to pressure the project into releasing sooner by talking about regulations: dick move.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoIBM is a cash poor company that just doesn't have the resources to pay for the software it sells.</snark> Seriously though, I am kind of curious why IBM can't cough up cash. I'm guessing it takes a while to set up a vendor in their system. So they probably //could// pay for a support contract, but by the time they set it up they'll have blown through some internal deadline. Or maybe this request is being made from a lower level person and someone in their reporting chain has blocked the idea of setting up a support contract. My memory of IBM is they're pretty insular, the particular person involved could just not understand what open source is. For instance, I was hired into a team in Boca Raton in the late 80s because my resume said I had experience with multiple Virtual Machines (VMs). I actually had experience with VMS, which was an operating system from Digital Equipment Corporation. When I asked my boss about that, her response was "What's VMS? What's Digital Equipment Corporation?" Which was a very strange thing to say as they had (more than) decimated IBM's S/36 and S/38 sales. Later on when I worked for the AIX division, I found many people who were clueful. I think what I'm saying is: 1. IBM is a big company. It's probably not accurate to judge the whole organization from one person's interaction. 2. You can survive at IBM without understanding the outside world. (though I'm just extrapolating that assertion from what I saw in the 80s,90s and late 2000s.)
- datavirtue 3y agoThis is what it's like at GE. Stocked with people who have been there their while life. They extrapolate what they know (GE) to the outside world and hence fail to understand almost everything impacting them. The people who come there mid-career are a distinct, and marginalized, class who don't really fit in (mostly because they aren't dillusional).