4 ms·
> And while at $0.078 a kilowatt, Phoenix's power isn't as cheap as Washington State, which is closer to $0.04 a kilowatt, but it's still competitive, Howard sa
by mschuster91 3y ago
> And while at $0.078 a kilowatt, Phoenix's power isn't as cheap as Washington State, which is closer to $0.04 a kilowatt, but it's still competitive, Howard said.
JFC. Meanwhile, Hetzner charges 26 ct/kWh in Finland and 53 ct/kWh in Germany [1]. At these prices (and yes, I'm aware these also include the cooling costs) it's completely inexplicable to me how Germany can ever get actually competitive with US services.
[1] https://www.hetzner.com/de/colocation/ https://www.hetzner.com/de/colocation/
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> it's completely inexplicable to me how Germany can ever get actually competitive with US services. Speed of light and data governance laws.
- marcosdumay 3y agoHetzner competes mainly on price. And completely clears the market on that metric. My guess is it's because the US competitors are run by incompetent people that see no need to improve anything because they have non-competitive lock-in.
- mardifoufs 3y agoOr because major American competitors do not compete on price, but rather on providing different features? Competing for low cost is not always a good idea, especially if you want to provide more services than bare bone hosting. The proof is on the scale, American corporation dominate market share internationally, and dwarf the likes of Hetzner. (not a dig against hetzner, I for sure would use them more than I'd use AWS if I was looking at building a budget conscious infra) If anything, European operators have been utterly incompetent in that regard. And not for lack of trying. The only European players left are scaleway and ovh. On the other hand, you can find tons of cheap operators in the US, they just don't get a similar rep to hetzner here on HN. Hetzner also found a very good niche with their second hand server that you can bid on, for sure. And to be clear, it provides a great service for the price.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI thought my 0.10¢ /kWh was a bit pricey. Whew. What was more shocking to me in that article was that google used 25% of Dallas's water supply. Between power use and water use, while I appreciate teaching people to be mindful and responsible, I feel like caring slightly less about where I set my thermometer or if I have a long shower when our country's resources are being depleted by big tech and alfalfa shipments to China and almond harvests in California.
- Cipater 3y agoAnother commenter has pointed out that the claim about Dallas' water supply is untrue. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36737353 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36737353
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- martinpw 3y ago> What was more shocking to me in that article was that google used 25% of Dallas's water supply. As someone else pointed out, it is not Dallas, it is The Dalles. Totally different and vastly smaller town.
- cloudwalking 3y agoIt’s not actually Dallas Texas, it’s The Dalles Oregon. Much smaller town. Bad journalism.
- rvnx 3y agoand somewhat a bit condescending / insulting with a joke as well: "With more than a hundred 100F (37.7C in non-Freedom units)" non-Freedom units...
- lacksconfidence 3y agoPerhaps you haven't lived the same life they have, where receiving condescension for using your normal weights and measures is par for the course. Not saying it's justified, but when it's something you expect to receive it's not unheard of to head it off ahead of time with the same tone that you tend to receive.
- hguant 3y agoIncreased regulatory burden for US companies, increased labour enforcement targeting foreign companies in general, and preferential treatment for DE/EU companies codified in law.
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago>increased labour enforcement targeting foreign companies in general How? And can you provide any examples?
- VWWHFSfQ 3y ago> Increased regulatory burden for US companies EU is actually doing the opposite because they don't want to be cut off from the US internet companies. For instance, now allowing EU citizens data to be transferred to and stored in the US.
- sclarisse 3y agoEasy. Nuclear. Oh, wait … you’re telling me they just phased that out? :( But yeah, as it turns out energy prices matter; it’s not just corporate overlords of the fuel companies spreading astroturf when people point out the still-high costs of using renewables. It matters to homes and cars and industry too, and when energy costs more, the nation will have less.
- mx20 3y agoThey now buy from the Nuclear Power plants a few km nearby the German Borders. The Prices are that high because of Taxes. They also probably get cheaper Industry Prices for electricity, but aren't allowed to resell that cheap energy to their customers.
- Timon3 3y agoAnd they sell to the country with the nuclear power when it gets too hot in the summer and the country with the nuclear power can't safely run it without killing their wildlife.
- mqus 3y agoThe myth that nuclear is cheap needs to die[1]. Nuclear is only "cheap" because of government subsidies that mandated its low price per kWh. The actual cost is far above most other options. So if we subsidize anyways, why not subsidize cheaper energy production methods? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source (but also take a look at https://www.oecd-nea.org/upload/docs/application/pdf/2020-12/egc-2020_2020-12-09_18-26-46_781.pdf https://www.oecd-nea.org/upload/docs/application/pdf/2020-12... from the IEA/NEA)
- H8crilA 3y agoSee that would be reasonable, but Germany decided to go one step further, to throw away even all the CAPEX they had already spent in the past. Also, all of this due to pressure from the Greens party, which must be respected for the ruling coalition to operate. I will never understand why Greens think that nuclear reactor problems are just as bad as global warming. Tried talking to some voters, got nothing back except "humans are bad". I guess we're far, far away from a solution if the political parties built around global warming do not understand the problem.
- yuliyp 3y agoYou're comparing apples and oranges. The cost you're paying Hetzner is not just for the power they are buying from the electric company, but the cooling of that same number of watts as well as other building maintenance, networking, etc.
- nik736 3y agoAlso note that this is Hetzner, a cheap provider. I am paying 65ct in one of the big data centers in Frankfurt.
- wkat4242 3y agoDon't forget we have a huge energy crisis right now due to the cutting of Russian gas. It's not directly affecting electricity production but overall energy pricing is severely affected due to people switching away from gas.
- davidzweig 3y agoI was planning on renting a 1/3 rack at Hetzner Finland, but power is cheaper in Bulgaria now (I'm in Bulgaria). Currently 19c/kwh for businesses and looking like it's coming down still (used to be closer to 10c I believe). It's also 80% nuclear/renewables, better than Finland, seems. I have three Asus ESC8000 G3 with 8*3080 GPUs each. I have been hosting in the basement but looking at colocation or renting a space. Colocation pricing doesn't seem to favor power-hungry GPU servers though. I have a source for cheap Asus ESC8000 G3 and cheap 3080 turbo cards, in case anyone needs to set up machines for ML inference, mail me.
- genewitch 3y agoIn all the datacenters i've used in the US they don't charge per kwh, they charge per max amperage, so you can get dual 15A 240VAC or dual 45A or whatever you need, and that's baked into the cost. Each rack has a power budget due to cooling concerns, etc. On the one hand, the bill is always the same amount, regardless of power consumption. On the other hand, you gotta make sure you use your power budget or you're wasting money.
- miguelazo 3y agoWhy do you think Germany was so keen on getting more cheap Russian gas, and why the US was willing to do anything to stop it?