7 ms·
What this problem always fails for me is that the show host doesn't pick randomly. What if there was option of opening the car? Also, does the goat come butche
by Ekaros 3y ago
What this problem always fails for me is that the show host doesn't pick randomly. What if there was option of opening the car?
Also, does the goat come butchered or do you need to do it on stage?
- DoctorOetker 3y agoWhere I live most cars have 4 doors, but since we are expected to pretend this is a well-posed problem we must assume there are literally 3 doors at the game host location. Evidently the participant entered through one of them and already knows whats behind one door. If he saw the car during entry, the correct choice would be the door of entry. The host can open (and close, and open, ...) doors with goats all day long, the participant would know the car is where he just saw it. If the participant did not see the car during entry it must be behind one of the remaining doors: either behind the back door, or behind the emergency exit door. Clearly it would be highly illegal to obstruct the emergency exit door with a car, so under Standard Assumptions (see assumption 42, the last one in the code) we can assume the host did not park the car behind this emergency exit door. Especially since emergency exit doors open outwards. Hence the car was parked behind the remaining backdoor, and since this follows from the Standard Assumptions we can conclude the participant made the same (by definition valid assumption) as described here, since its a Standard Assumption, and assumption 1 of the Standard Assumptions is that in the absence of necessary knowledge, everyone makes the Standard Assumptions. Given that the participant (using the standard assumptions) knew immediately which door hides the car and given that this door was his initial "guess", the correct solution (under Standard Assumptions) is to stay with the initial choice.
- drexlspivey 3y agoIf the host picked randomly then there would be a 1/6 chance that the show would end rather anticlimactically and you would be indifferent in switching. Now this 1/6 becomes your edge turning your 1/3 to 1/2 after the goat is revealed. EDIT: 1/3 not 1/6
- IanCal 3y ago1/3 not 1/6. There are six outcomes of you picking a door and the host opening one of the remaining doors. In two of them you pick a goat the first time and then the host reveals the car.
- IanCal 3y agoIf they pick randomly, there's no benefit to switching. No harm either. If it's random, 1/3 of the time you're right on your first guess and switching doesn't help. 2/3rds of the time you're wrong - if the host knows and deliberately doesn't open the door showing the car switching means you win. If however he opens randomly, half of those cases show the car and you can't win - so the breakdown is 1/3 switching wins, 1/3 switching fails and 1/3 the car is shown and you lose regardless.
- cman1444 3y agoThis is an extremely important part of the problem that is always glossed over in explanations of the Monty hall problem, and it really bothers me that it's ignored because it is crucial to determine what is the "correct" decision. If the game show host is opening a door at random (i.e. it's possible that he opens the door with the car behind it OR the door you already picked) then the outcome is 50/50 whether you switch or not. But if the host knows what's behind the doors, and purposefully opens one of the remaining two with the goat, then you should switch doors to increase your odds to 66 percent. On the above article this is only briefly addressed and not explained. In many tellings it is not addressed at all.
- dylan604 3y agoNot "rigging" the decision, would be pointless in the game. Yes, it is failed to be mentioned, but if the host revealed the car, then what's the point?
- tromp 3y agoIn this article it's addresses with this sentence > The show's host then reveals the contents of one of the two remaining boxes, but, importantly, always a "goat box." but it could be made slightly more explicit as: The show's host, who knows the location of the car, is then compelled to always reveal one of the two unselected boxes as containing a goat.
- andy800 3y agoAs far as solving the problem in an academic sense, your explanation is clearer. However, one of the things that makes the whole thing fascinating is that the actual players are not told this specific information, that the host knows. If you watch the show religiously it might dawn on you, hey, he must not be picking the preview door randomly because he has never accidentally revealed the car -- but that's beyond most people's observation. In practice, the revelation of one door is likely to make the player even more committed to the original choice -- the odds (seemingly, not actually) just went from 33% to 50%, momentum is good, I'm feeling lucky, no way am I going to switch now!