3 ms·
> CS is really a mathematics major Not really, and it's not really an engineering major either unless your CS is also part of the engineering school like MIT's
by satvikpendem 3y ago
> CS is really a mathematics major
Not really, and it's not really an engineering major either unless your CS is also part of the engineering school like MIT's is. Compared to mathematics curricula, you are doing a lot less complex stuff, there are few proofs and the classes are much easier than math ones.
- fortran77 3y agoAs a Math major (who now writes computer software for a living), I agree.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah, it varies by school. At MIT it's EECS. Sure there's a lot of math but it's hardly a math major. But I was early on in computers. I took a FORTRAN course for another engineering major and otherwise never used computers undergrad.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoMy school was a top engineering school world wide and the CS Eng program was insanely difficult compared to math. When people failed out they switched to math typically. We were heavily theory and proof based, with a strong emphasis on numerical methods, but also with deep systems and architecture components. It depends on the school. Although my datapoint is 15 years old now. I’ve heard they’ve dumbed down CS at the behest of tech companies looking for base level talent factories.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoUW had (still has?) CSE in the college of arts and sciences and Computer Engineering in the college of engineering. CSE and CE shared many classes, CE got to take some EE classes as well as the general engineering pre-reqs. CSE had more flexibility (e.g. take more math classes, but nowhere near what a math major would take!), and no given access to engineering courses. CE was harder to get into than CSE, but CSE was still hard to get into (and probably still is!)...most of the CE graduates back then went straight to the Portland Oregon area to work for Intel (pretty sure that is no longer true!).
- satvikpendem 3y agoIndeed, some universities put CS as a Bachelor of Arts while most put it as a Bachelor of Science, while even other have them both, with the students' option of either.
- fuzztester 3y agoAnd I've read that Harvard or MIT uses A. B. instead of B. A. for a Bachelor of Arts.
- buildbot 3y agoYep! And now the EE department is ECE for electrical and computer engineering, which is a different program/degree than the Computer science and engineering (CSE) programs CE degree. Wild! They also share a building sorta, with ECE having the older portion connected to the newer CSE building via weird mid-floor staircases. CSE at UW was unique too in being the only program that had a degree in both the college of engineering and the college of arts and sciences, which meant they literally had different deans and budgets, but the same program advisors and such. Unless something has changed, I believe the original idea was to merge the computer engineering degrees from both departments, not sure how that panned out. I left before it was even ECE!
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoHuh, ECE is way after my time (I graduated before the new CS building was even completed, Sieg hall for me) but it makes sense. But with most people going into pure software after graduating (hardware jobs don’t pay as well), it doesn’t seem to be the right direction.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoAll of the material is math. Easy math is still math, and people who hate math, or can't do it at all, will have the same problems studying CS that they do studying other types of math.
- srcreigh 3y agoName your school when you make comments like this. At UWaterloo half my classes were proofs. The other half were projects/coding assignments. If you can’t prove things and don’t cheat, you can’t get a UWaterloo CS degree. Can’t get past first year.
- satvikpendem 3y agoUniversity of Maryland. We didn't do proofs for year 1, we mainly did them for our discrete math and algorithms classes. Our curriculum was very focused on learning theory and coding that up (ie, a regex engine or an interpreter and compiler), not really any proving.
- srcreigh 3y agoAt UWaterloo 2 required first year courses are heavily proof based. One is basically intro to proofs. And second year there’s required graph theory/combinatorics course which are also proofs. 2nd year formal logic. 3rd year algorithms courses are highly proof based as well. This isn’t a flex tho, cuz there’s so much optional advanced math that isn’t required. Everything in the combinatorics and optimization department at UWaterloo basically. Most of us UW CS grads are normies who didn’t do any of the hardest stuff including me :-)
- CydeWeys 3y agoI graduated UMD in 2007, and I remember some of the upper level theory courses (which I tended to concentrate on) being quite proof-heavy.
- olvy0 3y agoNot going to name my school, but had a similar experience.
- xupybd 3y agoAt Massey University in New Zealand. The CS papers had almost no math.
- asimpletune 3y ago
- throwaway675309 3y agoBack when I majored in computer science, 20 years ago, mine was an equal combination of computer architecture, theory of information, mathematics, and some electrical engineering.
- Claude_Shannon 3y agoMy uni in Poland - CS and software engineering were basically the same things when it comes to Math classes, the difference was mostly in programming classes (we at software engineering had more project based classes and they had a lot of smaller ones)
- btgeekboy 3y agoIt's not the full mathematics major, but double majoring in both CS and Math at my university was common. And a CS major who wanted a Math minor needed no additional coursework.
- bakuninsbart 3y agoSince CS as a discipline came up after the rise of modern universities, the question was where to setup the departments. Most universities went with either mathematics or electrical engineering, and I think you can still see the effect of that in their curriculi today. A few also were spun out of business schools or built up from the ground.
- reuben364 3y agoMy CS degree (University of Cape Town) was basically a software engineering degree with a light sprinkling of theory. Basically our only proof that I remember was the the halting problem, and it was really only the basic idea with not much rigor. We covered data structures & algorithms, concurrency, schedulers and virtual memory but it wasn't very math heavy. We have one full semester on software dev cycle and one for UI and mobile app development. Our final project was a group project to assess applying software dev cycle in a team. As far as I'm aware the CS department has a sizable HCI group. I remember in first year with Python they taught the students to parse integers with `eval`.
- zer8k 3y agoI'd agree it's not really an engineering major. I have an ABET accredited CS degree and the majority of my BSc in CS was done on paper. It was a majority of proofs and mathematics (though, focusing on the discrete side). The amount of programming I did outside of a few select classes was reasonably minimal. Software engineering was an elective. Analysis of algorithms, though, for example was ALL math.