5 ms·
> If you can't find it, the AC may have to be grounded and thoroughly searched/panels removed etc. _Why_ is this? Weight reduction or something? On the face of
by rsynnott 3y ago
> If you can't find it, the AC may have to be grounded and thoroughly searched/panels removed etc.
_Why_ is this? Weight reduction or something? On the face of it it sounds like a design flaw.
- PuffinBlue 3y agoI think the article and this mishap is an example of the reason why - if you can't find a dropped and loose object in the cockpit then you can't fly the aircraft because it may move in flight to somewhere where it can interfere with the controls. In writing this answer it struck me you might be reading AC as Air Conditioning, instead of AirCraft, which I suppose could have lead to your question asking about weight reduction.
- lukeschlather 3y agoOut of context I read AC as "alternating current" with "grounded" taking on a totally different meaning.
- dylan604 3y agoHopefully, we never need an aircraft to be fully grounded with a tethered cable. That'd be ridiculous. As a kid, I had a plane that was tethered and would only fly in circles. Oh, where the mind wanders on a Friday
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WastingMyTime89 3y ago> Hopefully, we never need an aircraft to be fully grounded with a tethered cable. That’s one way of landing an helicopter on a boat in a rough sea. It works surprisingly well.
- dylan604 3y agoSpeaking of grounding a helicopter, it reminded me of the Hunt For Red October scene of trying to get a person from a helicopter to a submarine. It always seemed like such a complicated something as opposed to just putting someone in the water to let a diver collect them, which is precisely what wound up happening anyways
- chipsa 3y agoWhen planes are on the ground, they usually are fully grounded with a tethered cable for ESD reasons.
- Arrath 3y agoIts standard to ground out a helicopter carrying a sling load before the load is touched/handled (it may even have a longer grounding cable that drags across the ground as it descends) because it can gather some pretty dangerous levels of charge.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 3y agoOh, sure, I get that if something gets lost you need to find it. My impression from the comment was that military cockpits were designed such that it was easier for stuff to get lost than it might be, tho, which is what I was curious about.
- TylerE 3y agoMilitary cockpits are a moving target in more ways than one. The cockpit of an aircraft like the B-52 is unrecognizable from when it was built.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWhy would one waste money (and weight) building a cockpit that was more than just utilitarian? It is a war machine which may get lost in war (or war practice).
- dTal 3y agoAvoiding the need to ground and strip the aircraft every time someone drops a pen seems pretty utilitarian.
- rsynnott 3y agoOne way to get lost, in war or otherwise, feels like someone dropping an iPad where no iPad should be. And these things aren't _generally_ exactly built on the cheap.
- sitkack 3y agoSounds like a design flaw if there is so much open machinery that a dislodged part can jam everything up. Stuff comes apart. A general engineering design principle is that things degrade smoothly so that there aren't abrupt changes in performance. The aircraft controls should be protected such that foreign objects should have a low likelihood of jamming them. That there aren't things preventing someone from clearing any blockages and there aren't places where they could lever themselves in. My car has a design flaw with respect to the floor mats and the accelerator pedal (its not a Toyota). Between how the lever arm and the pedal surface itself are design and the aftermarket floor mat, if the mat slides forward it can jam the accelerator down. These are the deep groove mats for catching mud and water. The designers didn't think of this, if the pivot point for the pedal was further up the firewall. The pedal also has a hard square edge. Both of those things are in general a design flaw for pedals. The NHTSA (National Highway Transportation Safety Administration) should and maybe they have (my car is old) the design of the pedal linkage and the shape of the pedal to reduce this kind of risk. The hooks for securing floor mats should also be standardized to help keep them in place. The hard mount points for child seats are a great positive example of this.
- awhow 3y agoYou don't want a screwdriver, or anything else, pressed up against a control rod or a rotating component.
- 83 3y agoBecause while the FOD might not be an immediate problem, it could bounce around and get caught in a mechanical linkage causing a fatal crash, could be rubbing against wires causing a fatal crash, could start on fire (if it has lithium battery) causing a fatal crash, could cause a huge delay when maintenance finds a random part bouncing around later on and they don't know what it's from... you get the idea.
- ta123456789 3y agoI thought the question is not why this is a problem, but rather why is it possible at all for a loose object to end up in the depths of the AC to cause problems. Is there some reason we cannot avoid this? From a laymans perspective I think of a car, where dropping something small while driving is unlikely to cause problems in the machinery.
- r3trohack3r 3y agoDepending on your definition of “small” this is not true. I used to slide my flip flops off while driving until one got wedged under the break pedal and prevented me from breaking.
- qotgalaxy 3y ago[dead]
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoWell, for starters, cars are designed to only travel in two dimensions, so that limits the problem quite a bit.
- bitwalker 3y agoCars have a lot of trim/seals/insulation/carpeting to reduce road noise and be aesthetically pleasing, and military aircraft cockpits don't care about either of those things, and are largely just a metal tube with racks on which all of the avionics and other cockpit equipment are mounted, with holes in a handful of places where wiring harnesses enter/exit the cockpit. All of that equipment is regularly worked on, removed/replaced, and so it is necessary that it be (relatively) easy to access and remove. The equivalent would be like if you had to pull all of the instruments, electronics, and seats out of your car every 1000 miles, clean them up, replace faulty bits, and then put it all back again. All of the fancy trim, carpeting, etc., just makes that job harder, so you would probably want a car that doesn't have any of that, and is designed to make doing that kind of work easier, better still if you can avoid having to remove everything, and only have to remove the bits individually that need to be maintained. The down side of course, is that without all of the fancy trim and stuff, there would be gaps where things could fall and be hard to reach, and holes where wiring travels to the engine compartment/trunk/etc. Of course, FOD presents way less of a danger in a car than it does an aircraft, so you might not care if you drop something there, but aside from that, I think the analogy holds up.
- maushu 3y agoBecause the missing device might cause something similar to this crash but instead with a internal mechanism. You really don't want loose stuff around moving mechanisms.