10 ms·
VanMoof encryption key exporter
- gregdoesit 3y agoNote that a competitor to VanMoof, Cowboy Bikes, have also created an iOS app - with a beta on the App Store - that supposedly does the same (saving the encryption keys locally). I say supposedly because the source is not available to inspect. However, the linked FAQ states that no data is stored outside the app. Here it is: https://bikey-app.cowboy.bike/ https://bikey-app.cowboy.bike/ (Note this is not en endorsement for Cowboy - whom I know nothing about - just pointing to the currently only iOS app I know of to save these same encryption keys for VanMoof owners).
- yabatopia 3y agoGoing from Vanmoof to Cowboy Bikes is like switching from the plague to cholera. Same modus operandi: excessively VC funded, lots of hype, proprietary parts, mounting losses, loosing money with every sale, ... and it's getting worse every year. Cowboy Bikes is just another bankruptcy waiting to happen.
- wraptile 3y agoHow on earth are they losing money selling a 3000-5000$ _bicycles_ lol. I'm flabbergasted.
- arp242 3y agoThey spent a lot of money on expansion, opening stores in places like NYC and Tokyo. I'm also betting that since all the parts in their bikes are custom-produced for them, the production cost of their bikes is quite high as well (that is, they're not making that much money per bike).
- Gasp0de 3y agoThen why do they do it? What is the supposed gain from producing your own parts, when mass produced parts like Shimano are available all over the world? Is it to increase sales of their repair services after the warranty ends?
- arp242 3y agoThey want to "re-invent the bike". They do (or did) produce some pretty new/innovative designs; I haven't really followed them since they went electric because I'm not that keen on electric bikes, but the original (non-electric) had the lock roll up inside the frame for example, which is pretty nifty. Lots of people also like the design from an aesthetic point of view. "Use standard stuff" has a lot of value, obviously, but it also limits you. This is true for everything: from bike parts to the POSIX API or POSIX shell.
- jbverschoor 3y agoThey said because of repairs
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoIt's not about how expensive it is, it's about how much you sell.
- fleischhauf 3y agohow can you lose money with every sale then tho
- madeofpalk 3y agoMaybe they have other expenses?
- tnolet 3y agoYou make up for that in volume!
- patd 3y agoThe team behind Cowboy also has a history of going bankrupt and not doing the right thing. Their previous venture was a Uber Eats competitor and they took the end user’s money until the end but never paid the restaurants nor the deliverers. That’s the main reason why I can’t get myself to buy one their bike. But it seems Van Moof wasn’t any better.
- jtwaleson 3y agoI'm riding a Cowboy right now, and I chose it because they didn't have the service and quality issues that Vanmoof had. I've been very happy with it and hope they will not go under. I was annoyed with the app but I created a bluetooth key fob so I don't have to use the app to unlock it. Now I'm even happier with my daily rides. That being said: if I were in the market today I think I'd go for the Veloretti Ace. Less proprietary parts, great design and owned by a stable company.
- mimischi 3y agoCare to share more details on that bluetooth fob? Thanks!
- jtwaleson 3y agoSure: https://blog.waleson.com/2022/03/the-worlds-first-cowboy-key-fob.html https://blog.waleson.com/2022/03/the-worlds-first-cowboy-key...
- madeofpalk 3y agoI have a Vanmoof in for repair which I may or may not get back, and I'm foolishly tempted by Cowboy. I would like to get the Veloretti Ace, but they only sell it in three countries :/
- vayan 3y agoYeah I would go the Ampler Bikes way if I were in Europe. More grounded company.
- wjnc 3y agoDon’t buy products made by VC funded firms! Especially not if it’s a real product and you value repairability and service. VanMoof made losses the size of their revenue. They made bikes… where’s the natural monopoly to be chased there?
- dtech 3y agoBlitzcaling to achieve monopoly is not the only reason for funding. A manufacturing company like this has high up-front costs for R&D and manufacturing, orders of magnitude more than a typical software companies. You also don't need to chase a monopoly to make expanding to new market with investor money a sound decision. Obviously VanMoof didn't make it work here and had horrible OPEX due to expanding to markets without getting the sales to support it.
- Arnt 3y agoWhat did Van Moof make, exactly? Do you think they were normal bikes? They made expensive e-bikes with theft recovery features. They have features that make it possible to trace and locate them, and Van Moof would actually do this. For people who spend €3-4k on an easily stolen object that the police won't care about, that's a unique selling point.
- wiseowise 3y agoWaiting 6 weeks for any kind of repair was also their unique selling point?
- Arnt 3y agoHardly unique, I've heard that from Tesla owners too. From a VC's point of view that doesn't per se speak against the prospect of a successful venture.
- greenpresident 3y agoThat’s a common waiting time at my local bike shops to be honest. The difference is that you can do most stuff on a normal bike yourself with off the shelf parts (supply chain woes permitting).
- fermentation 3y agoI'm just now hearing about VanMoof failing. This is surprising, considering these bikes seem to have pretty meh build quality and are being priced much higher than one would expect.
- ashald 3y agoI've got an X3 that is rock solid even after me and the bike flying apart in an attempt to avoid collision with a truck. And its design is the primary reason why I decided to start biking again to begin with - I just find it so pleasantly satisfying I just want to ride it. So IDK, but I haven't seen a viable alternative yet.
- nicbou 3y agoWhat about it makes it so satisfying? If you're not into bikes, try a few of them. I find any properly tuned bike to be an absolute joy to use, although I never tried a Van Moof.
- dirtyid 3y agoFor me, it's just nice/satisfying using a aesthetically designed piece of kit, even if not top of the line performance. Which is issue for bikes, since a well tuned bike makes a huge difference. I don't like looking at all the bits of gear drive system, I like aesthetics of single speed, but riding one PIA. Ended up with a slick belt drive + internal hub setup. Van Moof (which I was considering buying) was basically the only ebike vendor that had similar aesthetics, and cover for chain/belt drive option. Checked my aesthetic boxes enough that I was fine if performance was average because it's ebike and I won't be physically struggling if something goes out of tune anyway. Support killed it for me though, and it seems like killed the company as well.
- sorenjan 3y agoHave you looked at bikes with the Pinion gear box? They recently launched an e-bike version too. https://pinion.eu/bike-selection/ https://pinion.eu/bike-selection/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chizhik-pyzhik 3y agoA cursory look at the code and this seems legit, nothing that would steal my login credentials. It's a small codebase. I'm curious how long the hardcoded api key here will work, though: https://github.com/grossartig/vanmoof-encryption-key-exporter/blob/main/pages/api/config.ts https://github.com/grossartig/vanmoof-encryption-key-exporte... used in https://github.com/grossartig/vanmoof-encryption-key-exporter/blob/main/pages/api/getBikes.ts https://github.com/grossartig/vanmoof-encryption-key-exporte...
- alias_neo 3y agoI don't know anything about these bikes; but what is one supposed to do once they retrieve their keys? Does the app/bike provide an alternative method of presenting the key? Are keys rotated, so they need to be downloaded more than once (I assume that's that's the case since this code is intended to be run as a service, in a Docker container)? If so, what happens when their servers do shut down and there is no API? Are people like the creator of this tool hoping for a future option to make use of the keys, and they're just being backed up for a rainy day at this point?
- rjacksonm1 3y agoThe keys in this case are used for bluetooth comms locally between somebody's device and their bike. These are ordinarily used by the VanMoof app to unlock the bike and control the bike's settings. There are already some third-party apps (Moofer, Mooovy) to allow alternate access to those settings – including some hidden ones. With a few tweaks those third-party apps should be able to support direct key upload, rather than having to log in and proxy authentication through to VanMoof's API.
- pilif 3y agoI assume that's the key used by the app. So if they kill that key, they also kill all existing applications. That's the thing with this kind of "protection". If your proprietary app needs to access the server, anybody who can either extract the key from the app with reverse engineering or who can listen in on the communication between app and server will be able to use that API. It's the same issue as with DVD encryption: If you need to show the movie to people, people need to be able to decrypt it. If this needs to happen offline, then the material needed for decryption must be static and either be on the disk on in the player - where it can be extracted and used by third parties.
- fsckboy 3y agoif you're going to make a tool that does what this does, you gotta call it Vanmoof Diver
- ano-ther 3y agoHonest question: what’s the appeal of a bike that needs an internet connection & app to unlock?
- gnopgnip 3y agoIf it’s stolen they will either recover it or replace it. And everyone knows this, so no one will buy a stolen one and they are less likely to be stolen.
- fh973 3y agoIf they're still in business.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> And everyone knows this You mean they know the vendor is an infinite supplier of free bikes to steal, deSaaSify, and sell to a different market? Either way, the message doesn't spread itself; I wouldn't overestimate how much small-scale semi-pro thiefs know or care about bullshit tech startups.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoVanmoof's whole thing is recovering the bikes
- hef19898 3y agoWas, didn't work out as planned, did it?
- Bootvis 3y agoYes, but not because of the anti theft features. The anti theft feature seems to have been a good idea.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIn a fight between a bullshit tech startup whose entire business model shows they're actively hostile to both customers and society at large, and minimally sophisticated thieves with access to a dedicated defeat toolkit that is surely already available to buy somewhere[0], I expect the startup to surrender first. EDIT: the only real advantage VanMoof could have here is if they're selling shitty bikes and overpricing customers for the brand name. That would indeed deter most thieves successfully - by making stealing those bikes not worth the effort. Well, until the metal prices spike or something, and it's profitable to steal them and sell as raw material... -- [0] - See e.g. cheaply available conversion kits for Bird scooters; IIRC they were being sold for something like $30. Though those had a plausibly legal use case: converting decommissioned or seized scooters. There were plenty of the latter, as following the example set by Uber, Bird also pretended law and society don't exist.
- demanxe 3y agoLooks like you put some nice work into the project, congrats!
- xyst 3y agoWow - I was really looking forward to the VanMoof V. Shame to see them struggling financially. It was supposed to be delivered in December 2022. But it was eventually pushed back to end of this year (2023). Contemplating canceling my pre-order ($20-30?) now.
- jbverschoor 3y agoThey’re almost bankrupt.. they filed for “uitstel van betaling” yesterday or Wednesday
- jbverschoor 3y agoWhich means they legally don’t have to pay anyone right now. At least that’s what I always understood about it. Not sure if that’s “chapter 11” or somethings else
- sjaak 3y agoIf you want one there are MANY second hand (cheap!) ones for sale on marktplaats.nl as we speak -- for reasons that don't need explaining :)
- NoLinkToMe 3y agoHe's talking about the V, which is not out yet. Not the S5 or A5, which indeed your post applies to.
- jonasdegendt 3y agoThis reminds me of Boosted Boards, which was also VC funded and got killed when Trumps China tariffs killed any profits they had on the hardware. When Boosted went under years ago some people tracked down the manufacturers of the individual components and to this day you can buy brand new replacement motors. It'll be interesting to see if a market pops up for VanMoof replacement parts as well. I sure hope so, I'm sitting on an S3 with a broken e-shifter. Support told me they didn't have any in stock and they'd let me know when they did. With hindsight I know now they probably hadn't been paying suppliers for a while now, and weren't getting any parts in because of that.
- syndacks 3y agoYou don’t need your phone (or internet) to unlock or use the bikes. All these posts bury that part. But fuck Moof, saw this coming a while ago.
- IliVivas 3y ago[flagged]