12 ms·
Is that really a problem if asymptomatic cases are less infectious and do not cause much issues to the carrier? (This is a question, not a statement)
by amelius 3y ago
Is that really a problem if asymptomatic cases are less infectious and do not cause much issues to the carrier?
(This is a question, not a statement)
- taeric 3y agoI think the big problem is that a large number of "asymptomatic" cases can also be seen as "presymptomatic?" And it is not fully clear on when you would flip to being a carrier/spreader.
- dmbche 3y agoThe point of the test is to tell the carrier if they should isolate to slow the spread - if you're asymptomatic today, take the test, get a negative, go to work for the week, it's as if you didn't do the test. It's not to begin treatment. So it is a pretty big problem!
- pc86 3y agoThis doesn't answer the question. Why, if asymptomatic cases are unlikely to infect others, is a false negative for asymptomatic cases a problem? Doesn't this all boil down to "if you feel sick, stay home, if you don't, don't worry about it?"
- blagie 3y agounlikely ≠ won't Defense-in-depth gives a broad range of tactics, and the goal is to combine enough of them to limit risks.
- pc86 3y ago"won't" isn't a reasonable standard. People get sick. You get other people sick. Other people will get you sick. It happens, and completely eliminating every occurrence is not a valid or reasonable goal.
- blagie 3y agoGoing from 50% to 75% to 88% to 94% to 97% to 99% to 99.5% reduction in risk carries an exponential increase in cost. Bringing risk to zero isn't a reasonable -- or possible -- goal, but how much this should decrease depends on individual and cultural profiles. If you think one risk profile is reasonable, and you're interacting with someone who has a much more conservative profile and putting them at risks they consider unreasonable, you're probably being a dick (and vice-versa). That's not just diseases -- it's everything from gun safety to outdoors safety to sparring. If you've been exposed to covid, and are asymptomatic, you should take reasonable precautions. For introverts, that might be staying at home. For others, it might be testing. For others, it might be using a high-filtration mask. It sort of depends on your preferences. Asymptomatic spread is pretty common, and it's not unreasonable to try to prevent it. If you've been exposed to covid and are symptomatic, you should take stronger precautions.
- dmbche 3y agoIf someone is testing themselves to make sure they will not spread it, they expect a level of certainity higher than the subjective "feel sick" - say you're visiting grandma who has asthma, and you take the bus everyday. I'd want to be as sure as I can be that I can't share it. This isn't saying everyone needs to be testing at all times and tests should be 100% effective - some situation require testing, and it'd be nice if it caught asymptomatic covid as well.
- worldsavior 3y ago> (This is a question, not a statement) It's just funny that you have to mention this is a question even if a question mark exists. It shows how much toxic people got instead of understanding others.
- blagie 3y agoI actually think it's the opposite. There is a hyper-polite culture in the west where people tone down statements: - It's [X] - Have you considered it might be [X]? - Is it possible it might be [X]? - ... The goal is to not appear overly assertive / confident / arrogant. Once that happens, people start to read subtexts into questions, and all of a sudden, you need disclaimers. I like direct communications, so I find this obnoxious, but I don't think it's ill-willed or toxic.
- worldsavior 3y agoWhat you're mentioning is good and reasonable criticism. This is not what I'm talking about. You don't have to mention anything and be afraid of what people might say because you don't want toxic behavior towards you. People need to stop. Read, understand, conclude and write. This is basic communication.
- blagie 3y agoThis is basic communication within a traditional setting. There are at least two issues: 1) In a multicultural setting, words written and words read may carry different meaning. Words carry subtly different meanings, and tones and subtexts need to be translated. 2) Unless one takes 2 hours to draft each email, people will misspeak. Miscommunications are part of life. Any process needs to account for that.
- bamfly 3y ago> It's just funny that you have to mention this is a question even if a question mark exists. It shows how much toxic people got instead of understanding others. Excessively-defensive Internet writing style. You have to make everything clear in three different ways and over-explain everything so that careless, poor, or hostile readers won't/can't flame you or derail the conversation over something that isn't even actually true about your post. See also: disclaiming "in my opinion", sometimes more than once, for things that are obviously opinions, just to keep idiots from going "LOL that's just your opinion but you're stating it as fact" in all your responses. Once you notice this style, it's a can't-unsee kind of thing. Makes reading Web forums frustrating. This kind of distracting, mealy-mouthed crap is absent from any decent, say, traditional-publishing book or article, but is standard online. It's worse on HN (which, you'd think the whole "read generously" guidance would counter it pretty well—but no) than most places, but it's common all over. It's a bad way to write, generally, but there's a reason people do it in these kinds of contexts—one reliably draws lots more stupid or angry-for-dumb-reasons responses, when one does not so-write.
- blagie 3y ago.... maybe .... It depends on the purpose of the test. For example, a trillion dollar question is still long covid. Very significant numbers of people are on disability right now. About 10% of Americans have some form of long covid, and >1% are unable to work due to long covid (or >2% of the workforce). Long covid comes up even with mild and asymptomatic cases, and seems to have a strong autoimmune component. If you're trying to understand where those sorts of symptoms came from, it's good to know whether or not you had covid before they started. Given that we don't understand what's going on here medically at all, it's not immediately useful, but it may be useful to know as treatments come up. A big part of the reason why I test is simply to know. There are many other potential purposes one might have for testing too. For example, studies might want to track prevalence of covid in populations. It's good to know, methodologically, what they're tracking.
- euix 3y agoCan long covid be considered post-viral fatigue? I remember being knocked out with Mononucleosis years ago and being tired out for over a month afterwards. Or is long Covid something entirely different?
- jnovek 3y agoA cursory google suggests that post-viral fatigue from COVID is expected to last a few weeks. Long COVID can last months; I know at least one person who still has long COVID symptoms from an infection that occurred in April 2020.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoHave they tried paxlovid?
- blagie 3y agoI'd be very surprised if it helped. There's pretty good evidence that long covid isn't caused by persistent virus. My own speculation is that it's autoimmune, simple due to having it seen resolved when people were vaccinated. However, "anecdote" is not the plural of "data," and it just as well be unrelated. There are wonky changes to organs during covid, which many doctors speculate are the root cause. In either case, I'm unaware of any mainstream theories where paxlovid would be likely to help.