3 ms·
This is a silly argument. "Owning" something doesn't mean you have unlimited rights to do what you want with it. Do you not "own" physical books because you can
by IshKebab 3y ago
This is a silly argument. "Owning" something doesn't mean you have unlimited rights to do what you want with it. Do you not "own" physical books because you can't (legally) photocopy them? Do you not own a gun because you can't (legally, at least where I live) lend it to a friend?
I'm not saying the way e-books work is good - it clearly isn't - but not because there's a fundamental law that owning an e-book should be identical to owning a physical book.
- derstander 3y ago> "Owning" something doesn't mean you have unlimited rights to do what you want with it. Do you not "own" physical books because you can't (legally) photocopy them? Do you not own a gun because you can't (legally, at least where I live) lend it to a friend? In your examples, you own the book and the gun because the publisher of the book and the manufacturer of the gun (or anyone else, excepting the state, I suppose) can’t unilaterally take them back from you or modify them without some sort of penalty. This can — and has [0] — happened with eBooks. The “unlimited rights to do what you want with [them]” are not guaranteed by ownership in my opinion. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18amazon.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18am...
- Lio 3y agoWhen the copyright expires on the books you own you will be able to legally photocopy them. Not so for a DRM’d ebook.
- IshKebab 3y agoAgain, "owning" does not mean that something cannot be unilaterally taken from you. Eminent domain is a very obvious example of that. Ownership does not have a single neat list of requirements, which is why it makes no sense to say "this is bad because we don't own it".
- derstander 3y ago> Again, "owning" does not mean that something cannot be unilaterally taken from you. Eminent domain is a very obvious example of that. Eminent domain is the state taking from you. I already mentioned this in my comment. In fact, the state pays a penalty for doing so in the US as enshrined in the 5th amendment: “… nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.“ > Ownership does not have a single neat list of requirements No, it does not have a comprehensive list for all use cases, but I would say that the one I mentioned in my first comment is a necessary one: fundamentally that it cannot be taken from you without penalty.
- _v7gu 3y ago(Taking continental law as basis because lol common "law") Ownership means you have these three rights towards the object: usus, fructus and abusus. usus (use, i.e reading) and abusus (abuse, i.e deleting the file) are fine under DRM, but DRM introduces non-legally-required limitations for enjoying the fruits of the ebook you own (renting it, lending it, selling it). Any "ownership" with DRM is not ownership in the legal sense. Copying falls under the ownership of the text within the book. It is something completely separate.