6 ms·
Elephant in corner of room: The City which he is so contemptuous of is the one industry in the UK that pays technical people fair wages. I studied Mech Eng at
by gaius 15y ago
Elephant in corner of room: The City which he is so contemptuous of is the one industry in the UK that pays technical people fair wages.
I studied Mech Eng at college; no-one does that who doesn't want to be an engineer. When I graduated in the mid-90s there were no jobs, so I went into high-tech. But my CV is still floating around, and I occasionally get called by recruiters in engineering. Now I am no rock star, I am paid well (market rate) but not extravagantly so. But these engineering jobs pay a fraction of what I earn, for the equivalent years of experience. And they wonder why no-one wants to do it?
This comes back to the old class system which is still strong in the UK. No matter how educated, an engineer is not "one of us" to the management class, and will never be paid fairly in the old industries, never more than a paper-pushing middle management bureaucrat who went to the "right" school. Only high-tech (enlightened) and The City (where managers are so well paid that they don't feel threatened) pay technical people fairly.
Anyone smart enough to be an engineer - and there are plenty who want to be - is smart enough to not be exploited in that way. And that is why manufacturing died in the UK.
- dasil003 15y agoI'd be curious about City vs Wall Street salaries for engineers. Even in the US they are paid more than the vast majority of other programmers. I wouldn't be so proud of the financial sector paying engineers fair wages, because the bottom line is it's crumbs to them. They are skimming more cream off the economy without producing anything tangible than anyone else, so they can afford to pay above market to the privileged few. It's not a scalable model for increasing average salaries though. The UK (and Europe) really needs to figure that out. I was able to move to London because I was moving from SV and I got a cost of living increase on top of my US market salary. If I was born here and forced to accept London market salaries I would be looking for my ticket out of here ASAP. As technology and mobility increases it's going to be increasingly important to economies to retain talent, something which I believe is obscured for the super rich who make money by arbitrage highly abstracted from the value in the base economy.
- gaius 15y agoIt's not "above market"; that's the point. Why shouldn't engineers be paid as well as doctors, lawyers, accountants, etc? What The City pays is what all should pay. Engineering died in the UK because the management class can't tell the difference between a professional mechanical engineer and a car mechanic (not that the latter isn't a skilled worker). In the rest of the world "Engineer" is a meaningful, exclusive title.
- rmc 15y agoYep, reminds me of a great quote: "If you're having trouble hiring, you are by definition offering below market rates".
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWhich is true in a perfectly efficient market, with perfect information, interchangeable commodities, low search costs. Many people complaining about hiring trouble are complaining about high search cost.
- rmc 15y agoMost software companies that hire now could solve their problem by offering more money. More people will hear about your job the more above average your pay is. The higher your pay above average is, the easier it is to entice people to move (i.e. you widen your pool of potential people to include people who already have a job). If you pay more, you can make up for any disadvantages in your workplace, from boring dull work, to "you're not a sexy workplace like Google". The lesson is that companies are strugglying because they aren't offering enough money. Ergo, if you offer more money, you struggle less.
- dasil003 15y agoMarket rates are not what people "should" be paid. It's what they are paid.
- ig1 15y ago
- blasterford 15y agoManufacturing actually died in the UK because of the unions. Workers became greedy, and unproductive. They were unable to compete with other countries, and instead staged big endless strikes demanding ever rising salaries, better working conditions etc - which made them even more uncompetitive with emerging countries. You can either have great working conditions and pay, or a good manufacturing industry. Can't have both. Some other poorer country will just treat their workers worse, and so be more productive. (I'm reading "Thatcher - the downing street years" at the moment - a great read).
- gaius 15y agoYes it was a combination of factors, but most of them were class-based.
- mattmanser 15y agoI hope you realise that regurgitating from what's obviously going to be a right-wing book is only half the story. For example there was a discussion that I half caught on Radio 4 this very morning that claimed the death of manufacturing in the UK is mainly due to the government totally failing to invest in R&D for the last 15 years or so. I think the truth is probably somewhat more complex and a combination of a lot of factors. Also find people who were around in the Thatcher days, you'll find a lot of people who either despise her or love her, the book will be biased.
- Isofarro 15y ago"the death of manufacturing in the UK is mainly due to the government totally failing to invest in R&D for the last 15 years or so." Interesting. Why is it the government's obligation to invest in R&D (of manufacturing?), surely that's the responsibility of the manufacturers themselves?
- blasterford 15y agoTo a socialist it's the governments obligation to do everything.
- arethuza 15y agoIt's only very recently that I learned how odd the legal status of the City of London is - it's effectively a private corporation that has assumed the functions of a local authority. It is also the only place in the UK where businesses get to vote - businesses have 24,000 votes and actual residents only have 8,000 votes. The actual amount of money controlled by the City of London Corporation isn't public either - e.g. there is the "City Cash" fund. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London_Corporation My favourite bit of City trivia is that they have an official representative at Parliament, who gets to sit opposite the speaker - the wonderfully named Remembrancer. [Edit: For some highly entertaining, if slightly paranoid, ranting about the City and the evils of offshore finance I can recommend "Treasure Islands" by Nicholas Shaxson - http://treasureislands.org/ http://treasureislands.org/]
- rmc 15y agoThe UK is weird when you start looking at "constitutional issues" (since it doesn't really have one). There are lots of "technicalities" which aren't true in practice. Like technically it has a state religion (Church of England), however it's quite secular as a country compared to many others. Technically the Queen has to approve and sign any law, but it's a rubber stamp, she can't refuse to sign an act. Technically Parliament can pass just about any law "that's not naturally impossible" (checks and balances? what's that?), but there are laws and other treaties, and the judges have some power etc.
- arethuza 15y ago"Church of England" - there is a hint in the name there, it is most certainly not a UK-wide state church.
- rmc 15y agoWell it gets tricky here. The Queen is Supreme Governor of the Church of England, and the head of state of the UK (the Queen/King) has to take an oath to defend & uphold it (i.e. no catholics allowed to be monarch), though they are changing that. There is also a Church of Ireland (which was disestablished as the offical religion of Ireland (which was in the UK) in 1870ish), and Church in Wales. Scotland has sorta it's own church (think it's a slight different variant) which it has a right to exist due to the Act of Union of 170x. So it's all a bit complicated and depending on how you define "UK" and "UKwide"
- husky 15y agoI just love the fact that the Raspberry Pi isn't about money at this stage - it's a philanthropic initiative designed to help the world progress. Ultimately it gives computer access to far more people who will benefit economically in the long run
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoWe can't all be rich, there aren't enough resources. We can all be moderately well off IMO (but we have to address population with vigour) and the rich dont want to stop being privileged.
- jsvaughan 15y agoHave you read "The myth of Britain's manufacturing decline"? http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/02/22/manufacturing_figures/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/02/22/manufacturing_figure...
- gaius 15y agoInteresting that there is a dip in the graph around the time I graduated! But, are these engineers being paid proportionally to the value they create? That is the acid test. The class system works both ways; people being held down are ingrained to believe that that is their station in life.
- sbmassey 15y agoPay is determined by supply and demand, not by a cabal of fat cat plutocrats agreeing how much to dole out to different positions. The idea that people be paid "proportionally to the value they create" is an obsolete Marxist idea. Check out the "Marginal Revolution".
- yeureka 15y agoI agree. When I left my job as a games developer for a gig in the City my salary doubled. I had zero experience in financial software and about 5 years as a professional game developer. In that year I was the third developer leaving that studio for the City. The work was less interesting, but I went from living like a student to having enough income to live independently in London while saving enough to start my own business. The only software jobs in the UK that approach the US in salary terms are in the City.
- peteretep 15y ago> The only software jobs in the UK that approach the US in salary terms are in the City. You can find considerably more interesting contract work outside the City that pays the same as a salaried role in the City - worth considering if you don't mind a little uncertainty, don't want to work overtime, and want to be able to switch around whenever things get dull...
- rickmb 15y agoI doubt this has anything to do with the "old class system", because you can see this pattern anywhere in Western culture.
- itmag 15y agoWhich means that either 1) The free market is not efficient 2) There is some hidden benefit to overpaying clueless PHBs I'm genuinely curious about this, actually...
- arethuza 15y agoHave you seen this? It actually identifies the role of the "clueless" in organisations quite well: http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-o...
- rmc 15y agoOr that there is nor a free market in operation in these places/industries. And hence assuming that a free market is more efficient, that you can make more money by trying to make the market more free-er (i.e. hire based on merit, not class, etc.).
- danssig 15y agoOf course the free market isn't efficient in hiring. Companies do everything they can to hide salaries and, for whatever reason, the culture is such that people generally won't discuss it either. Imagine if everything you ever bought worked this way. You want some eggs? You'll need to go in the store managers office, he'll make an offer and you can accept it or negotiate. You might not even get the eggs. Once you do, you're afraid to tell anyone else how much they cost. How efficient would that market be?
- itmag 15y agoThat's because salaries are not just about economics. They are also a proxy for "what is my status in society?" They are not just another type of eggs, so to speak. There is a similar thing going on with sex. The difference between a back rub and rub&tug isn't just the target location, it's also the associated taboos and stigmas. (Circuit IV, for those of you who've read Prometheus Rising...)
- __alexs 15y agoSource? Do you have any actual evidence that say the ratio of profit per employee to average salaries is lower at banks than at engineering firms? Simply paying more isn't the same as not being exploitative, even if it does make you feel better about yourself. I suppose it might make sense to consider the wider picture too, like how much of that increased income is produced by more fully exploiting other laborers.
- omonra 15y agoCan you please define what exploitative means? Is there a split of profit between labor and capital that is universally accepted as such?
- __alexs 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploitation#Theories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploitation#Theories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surplus_labour#Surplus_labour_and_exploitation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surplus_labour#Surplus_labour_a... "Exploitation occurs when those appropriating surplus labour — whether in the form of surplus-value, surplus product or direct surplus labour — are different than those performing surplus labour..." There is no universal definition exactly but they share certain elements. In particular exploitation is the result of a power inequality between the laborer and the exploiter. The question is not simply about the split of profits between capital investors and laborers. (Since capital is the accumulation of surplus labor, it's already exploitative.) The original act of exploitation it's self occurs much earlier. When you do not receive renumeration equal in value to that of your surplus labor. Putting real numbers to those values is hard and I don't really have a satisfying answer to give you. You might find Elinior Ostroms work interesting though. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elinor_Ostrom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elinor_Ostrom
- omonra 15y agoUmm..ok. So this is just plain Marxism. So - if entrepreneurs give away all surplus value to their employees, what motivation do they have to start businesses?
- rmc 15y agoThe City (where managers are so well paid that they don't feel threatened) pay technical people fairly Another reason why The City might pay higher: Since there is so much money at stake/to be made, and since it's so compeditive, and rewards can be gotten so quickly (you could make millions in one year, no need to wait for things to pay off) that it would be foolish for a upper class toff to sit on their hands and not hire the bright young commoner. It could be that the traditionalist companies probably missed out on a lot of good techies, and hence weren't able to compete and were marginalised by companies who did hire based on merit, not class. Capitalism at work for our labour.