5 ms·
> Shopify laid off 20% of its global workforce today — its second sizeable employee culling after a reduction of 10% announced last July. -- https://techcrunch.
by neilv 3y ago
> Shopify laid off 20% of its global workforce today — its second sizeable employee culling after a reduction of 10% announced last July. -- https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/04/how-shopify-bungled-its-latest-layoffs-and-made-employees-feel-like-npcs/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/04/how-shopify-bungled-its-la...
I'd like to make an HN grassroots proposal... that people impose a moratorium period on indulging a company's PR attempts to sell their enlightened management culture, right after something like that.
Layoffs looks like either a huge fudge-up that screws employees, or screwing employees as a greedy or dumb business move.
In neither scenario is it in the interests of the hiring pool to pretend it didn't happen.
- hackernewds 3y agoNot to mention, companies announcing major acquisitions (Uber acquiring Postmates), or share buybacks (Apple) right afterwards. If a company really did mismanage their workforce the CEO would be fired for it, not rewarded.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoLayoffs are not seen as mismanaging your workforce by investors. They're generally seen as a gamble that didn't pay off. Especially with tech companies, taking gambles is a good thing, investors want to see that management is taking risks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sam0x17 3y agoThough sometimes the gamble _is_ the layoff (see Twitter atm)
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoTwitter's layoffs are because Elon Musk has no idea how to manage a company, not because of actual business or market pressures
- sam0x17 3y agoRight. He's gambling
- passing_by_and 3y agoIn what reality do you live in? He is the most successful and transformative figure of his generation.
- coffeefirst 3y agoYes, but I am not obliged to entertain this fantasy.
- twelve40 3y agoholding up people's wages to get the company through a bump or two would be another bold gamble and a savvy business move until it was made illegal (luckily for all of us non-sociopaths)
- np- 3y agoA gamble? But who’s paying off the “gambling loss” during a layoff? Because it’s certainly not the person making the bet.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWhen did Apple do layoffs?
- ares1 3y agoIn ‘97 they layed off 4100 people - close to A third of their workforce at the time https://money.cnn.com/1997/03/14/technology/apple/ https://money.cnn.com/1997/03/14/technology/apple/
- paulryanrogers 3y agoApple's return to office in 2022 may have been partially meant to serve as a stealth layoff.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoNah ceos get fired for mismanaging profit margins, not people.
- no_wizard 3y agoNot that I'm quibbling, however I don't think Apple had any meaningful sized layoffs? I know there was some shake up in the retail division, but its unclear from the outside what the motivation was. I've heard through 2nd hand sources that there's been alot of churn and issues in the retail division really spanning back to Ron Johnson's retirement Only mentioning this as I'm not sure it categorizes the same as these huge 10%+ layoffs the rest of tech have participated in, sometimes multiple times by the same company.
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoThey may have meant meta? Meta announced a 40B stock buyback the day after it announced it was laying off 10,000 people. 4,000,000 per employee fired
- wepple 3y agoWhy are share buybacks seen so negatively? Isn't it somewhat to offset the fact that a lot of shares are issued as comp, so dilute the pool?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agobecause it uses free cash to increase share price in order to increase executive compensation based on said share price, instead of using said free cash flow to compensate actual workers/employees
- jetpackjoe 3y agoor for R&D, improving operations, or anything else that benefits the company.
- ryandrake 3y agoExactly. When your company buys shares back (or issue a dividend) you're basically telling shareholders "We have all this cash but we have no idea what to do with it that will provide a return greater than our Hurdle Rate, so we're just going to give it back to you." It doesn't exactly inspire confidence to me as an investor that the company is creative and forward-looking, but apparently most investors love this signal.
- Eisenstein 3y agoIsn't a company supposed to make a profit though? At some point aren't a lot of companies pretty much at their functional maximum? Investing in 'growth' isn't always practical. Example: All-Clad makes great cookware, but they last a long time and the number of people who need new pans are finite -- why should they invest more money into the company when they are operating optimallly?
- ryandrake 3y agoAbsolutely. If you're the water utility or an energy company or some other company not positioned as a "growth" company, sure, hand back your extra cash to investors. But if you're a tech company, a stock buyback just says "we're out of ideas but still want the stock price to go up".
- beachy 3y agoI used to think like this but external factors such as interest rates are real and most companies need to react to them. Take two hypothetical companies. One is conservatively run, never takes on anyone that they might need to let go. The other hires aggressively when times are good, and fires when they get bad. The second company will (if well run otherwise) likely be more successful over time and create more wealth than the first.
- spandrew 3y agoI agree that interest rates have essentially driven most of the layoffs recently. Debt that used to cost 10c on the dollar to service has started to cost 2 dollars. If your expenses don't give, then your profits will. And potentially your liquidity. But it's kool-aid drinking to assume a company that is over aggressive at hiring in a bull market and fires in a bear market will create more wealth. Wealth for whom is the better question to ask — certainly not the thousands of laid off employees.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- indecisive_user 3y ago>Wealth for whom is the better question to ask — certainly not the thousands of laid off employees I think that depends on the pay structure. If a large part of your compensation is in stock then you'll still benefit from the additional wealth creation. Assuming a decent severance package it's certainly possible you come out ahead compared to the more conservative company, even being laid off.
- inetknght 3y ago> If a large part of your compensation is in stock then you'll still benefit from the additional wealth creation. Oh yes, the beautiful golden handcuffs will give those laid off workers wealth. Except... the handcuffs come off and are kept by the employer. Otherwise they wouldn't have been handcuffs
- 3y ago
- seabass-labrax 3y agoIf the economy and an industry is generally doing well, frequent lay-offs can be a good thing. It would be better financially for the employees, as they will be able to find a different employer quickly and/or will receive severance payments. It is better for employers (those who know what they're doing, at least) as they can reduce their costs quickly if they need to. Those who are unhappy with a job can find a new one more easily with an elevated level of staff turnover in their industry. The psychological effects for employees can be greatly harmful, though. Additionally, there is a cost to society when projects are cancelled that would be beneficial to the world, even if not profitable, and such flitty business practice could become exaggerated if lay-offs did not carry such stigma.
- JohnFen 3y ago> It would be better financially for the employees, as they will be able to find a different employer quickly and/or will receive severance payments. This is making a lot of assumptions that I think make the hypothesis very shaky. The only people who can decide if they'll be better off when this happens are the individuals being laid off, because they're the only ones who have enough information to know.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoMy reasoning is that, from a purely financial perspective, individuals would probably prefer to be made redundant in a good economic situation than a poor one. However, many companies continue projects that are unprofitable while the economy and their business is doing well, only to make massive lay-offs when times are more difficult or even collapse entirely, flooding the job market. Thus, my intuition is that smaller but more frequent lay-offs would smooth-out the troughs and peaks of an industry's job market to make it more closely resemble the value of that industry as a whole. I would be very curious to know what I'm missing in this picture; would you have the time to elaborate?
- JohnFen 3y ago> from a purely financial perspective, individuals would probably prefer to be made redundant in a good economic situation than a poor one. Oh, OK. I agree with that. I thought that you were saying that being laid off is a good thing when economic times are good. I think that it's never a good thing. However, if it has to happen, it's certainly better when times are good than when they aren't. > Thus, my intuition is that smaller but more frequent lay-offs would smooth-out the troughs and peaks I suppose, but I would not want to work for a company that engages in regular layoffs, even small ones. It means that you can never really settle in to the job. I've turned down several job offers from companies solely because they engage in regularly-scheduled layoffs.
- pesfandiar 3y agoAlong the same cynical lines of thinking, I bet this is part of the whole belt-tightening move. If employee retention is not a priority, managers can reduce or neglect related tasks (think 1:1s, career development, ...) and manager-to-IC ratio can be reduced.
- icedchai 3y agoIn 20 years, I can count the times I had a useful 1:1 on one hand. Early in my career, it seemed like a monthly thing. Only in the past decade or so did it become a weekly "requirement."