2 ms·
>I'm in the camp of "3d spatial is mostly a scam, just use stereo" That's orthogonal to what the parent claims. Their take was that spatial audio is just "ste
by coldtea 3y ago
>I'm in the camp of "3d spatial is mostly a scam, just use stereo"
That's orthogonal to what the parent claims.
Their take was that spatial audio is just "stereo" rebranded, as Dolby Atmos doesn't do anything, just because it's encoded into a stereo signal to play over headphones in the end. Which is obviously wrong.
Your take is more like that spatial audio isn't usually a fitting experience, from an artistic perspective (not that it doesn't do anything more that what plain stereo does or that it doesn't take extra processing logic to mix into it, and extra effort to mix songs into spatial format).
- harry8 3y ago>Their take was that spatial audio is just "stereo" rebranded No it was not, please try to read what is actually written because what you have reported is obviously and clearly wrong. You, me, Brian Eno _can_, regardless of my "take", record 3D audio onto 2 tracks and play it back and hear it with headphones. This has been possible for decades. I've learned today, in this very thread that what I did in the 1980s is called "binaural" You can also record and mix stereo without caring about this possibility and most do. Your choice, and especially Brian Eno's choice to make a 3D audio album or not is entirely and wholly orthogonal to the existence of "Atmos." In so far as Atmos describes speaker related tech, 3D using speakers will be inferior to using headphones, other things equal.
- squeaky-clean 3y agoCorrect, I was disagreeing with the other poster but also making it clear at the beginning that I'm not a fan of Atmos, even though I was defending the technology. The rest of my comment was about how Atmos is not the same as plain stereo. But it's still a scam.