3 ms·
>He's aware of the existence of stereo headphones and that they are not new tech He is. But apparently there are people who are not aware of the difference bet
by coldtea 3y ago
>He's aware of the existence of stereo headphones and that they are not new tech
He is. But apparently there are people who are not aware of the difference between stereo and spatial audio formats.
Not to mention he explicitly says so in TFA: "What’s interesting about 3D music is the possibility of making an immersive space which is capable of sustaining much more detail than a 2 dimensional space (such as that presented by stereo listening)."
- harry8 3y ago> "What’s interesting about 3D music is the possibility of making an immersive space which is capable of sustaining much more detail than a 2 dimensional space (such as that presented by stereo listening)." Yeah this is what pissed me right off and made me think dark thoughts about Eno, who I usually like quite a lot for his normal habit of talking reasonably good sense. So let's just be crude engineers here. Every listener has 2 ears. Using headphones and 2 tracks (stereo) you can control precisely what sound is heard by each ear. You can replicate anything a human can hear, which includes direction in all 3 dimensions of space. This is very similar to 3D using glasses to make separate images each viewed only by one of your eyes. You could even go further with VR head tracking to alter the channels based on your head movement to turn your head to look at the sound source and have it move to be in front of you - maybe some VR people are doing that too but I doubt that is what is being branded "Atmos." Is it? You can achieve this 3D audio using a technique I played with as a child using a stereo cassette tape recorder. I have described how and posted a youtube link of a guy doing it (and been soundly chastised for not just saying "binaural" which is a word I learned today. Shame on me ;) Using headphones will have a higher quality ceiling for /hearing/ audio in 3 dimensional space than is possible with speakers for obvious reasons. You will not get any sound intended for the left ear only heard by the right and vice-versa. So there it is, you can do 3D "spatial" audio and do it better and do it since a very long time and "[sustain] much more detail than a 2 dimensional space" If that is your artistic goal. Stereo is good enough to do "spatial" using headphones and, in fact, will sound better and more accurate than anything, including new branded product, that uses speakers. But yeah take it with some salt because while I like music, I'm no audiophile and am consistently delighted with audio quality I can get from really quite cheap equipment. That probably makes me a bit odd in this space.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoI'm also cheap when it comes to audio gear, and can't imagine buying anything this fancy. What's interesting here is that Eno has done museum installation pieces - music designed for a specific space. The point to him is not that some sound is intended to be in your left ear, but that it's on the left side of the room, and all the sounds are positioned relative to each other, while you're free to move as you please. I could imagine Music for Airports played across an entire airport - that would be something.
- harry8 3y agoYeah totally. I've had ideas like that. Installations where the lighting, imagery and sound all respond to your position in the space for example. The moment you get close to $thing a new riff is dropped in on the next beat, something else when you're no longer close. So many ways to go if you have the budget & space (and audience - I'm vain for that amount of work) to control it all. ...and now we're talking about something much more differenter than an album recorded & mixed to be heard in 3D with some brand name equipment.
- colanderman 3y ago> VR head tracking to alter the channels based on your head movement to turn your head I forget where I read recently, I think this is the intention though.
- harry8 3y agoSomething else news to me today. I always thought "stereo" meant something like "two working in unison". Apparently it is from the greek meaning "solid." Hence sterophonic literally means solid (or spatial or 3d) sound (or speech). Crazy, that's obviously not how we understand it anymore. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/stereophonic https://www.dictionary.com/browse/stereophonic Sterophonic adjective pertaining to a system of sound recording or reproduction using two or more separate channels to produce a more realistic effect by capturing the spatial dimensions of a performance (the location of performers as well as their acoustic surroundings), used especially with high-fidelity recordings and reproduction systems
- 3y ago