7 ms·
Tumblr’s core product strategy
- rpgbr 3y agoI hope they improve the platform. Tumblr is such a nice place with a cool atmosphere, but I hardly can justify using it (working in a tech news outlet) when there are so many rival platforms with way more people to talk to.
- ravedave5 3y agoSeems like they have the right idea. I signed up after the first twitter meltdown and I had a hard time using it. I couldn't find good communities and when I did I didn't know how to engage.
- robotnikman 3y agoWasn't there a great exodus when Tumblr was bought out and they banned anything with a hint of NSFW? I doubt they will be winning back those users again...
- zztop44 3y agoDifferent owners. As I understand it, the current owners (Automattic) have allowed some, but not all, nsfw content back on the platform
- biccboii 3y agoThis is the exact verbiage from the community guidelines: Sexually Explicit Material. Visual depictions of sexually explicit acts (or content with an overt focus on genitalia) are not allowed on Tumblr. That includes pictures, videos, GIFs, drawings, CGI, or anything similar. Historically significant art that you may find in a mainstream museum and which depicts sex acts—such as from India’s Śuṅga Empire—are now allowed on Tumblr with proper labeling. Nudity and other kinds of adult material are generally welcome. We’re not here to judge your art, we just ask that you add a Community Label to your mature content so that people can choose to filter it out of their Dashboard if they prefer. You have the option to add a community label when making a new post, reblogging a post, or editing an existing post. Depending on your content, you can label it as generally mature or choose a specific category such as “Sexual Themes” if your post contains sexually suggestive subject matter. Blogs which have a focus on mature content may not be eligible for certain Tumblr features, including monetization options. We need to consider the policies of our partners in the payments space, so the rules there are a bit different. For more information about this guideline, and how to appeal decisions about sexually explicit material, check out our Help Center article. https://www.tumblr.com/policy/en/community https://www.tumblr.com/policy/en/community
- mathewsanders 3y agoPolicy is what is said, and that’s often a huge gap between what actually happens. Tumblr had a huge content moderation issue where (based on my personal experience) I’m guessing there are incentives in place around flagging explicit content. I’ve never posted or reblogged anything that would break this policy, but every single post I make on my main blog is automatically flagged as explicit/adult content (eg a photo of my cat) and going though a content appeal I’d say 50% the human-reviewed content appeal fails and my post gets hidden. I ended up creating a separate blog that I now post content to, and then reblog to my main account. It’s impossible to get a hold of any support to try and resolve. Despite non-existent support and increasingly buggy apps, it’s still the best online community I’ve found and I love it :)
- photomatt 3y agoWe'll try to get better about support, bugginess, and account switching should be a lot nicer so you can actually use Tumblr as different personas when you want to.
- scrozier 3y agoI'm afraid this sounds really generic and a bit desperate. I don't see any of the guiding principles really looking at Tumblr's strengths.
- chambers 3y agoYeah, the diagnosis is really weak. Superbly weak actually. "<X> is not easy to use" has zero insight and takes no stand. It's a flimsy, worn-out string to connect the dots; the upside is that any stakeholder can grasp it and no one can strangle you with it. Also, the pattern of "diagnosis, guiding policy, coherent action" is copy-pasted from the book "Good Strategy, Bad Strategy"[1]. I've seen this internally at companies and even though the article is a great read, the application leaves much to be desired. [1] https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/the-perils-of-bad-strategy https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/strategy-and-corporate...
- photomatt 3y agoI actually agree, "easy to use" is not the right framing. The core stuff needs to work really well, be friction-free. New features don't matter if the app crashes, or if you get spam. It's hard to run a social network, and do it in a public and open source way, but we're trying both.
- LordDragonfang 3y ago>Tumblr’s competitive advantage lies in its unique content and vibrant communities. Cool, I wonder if whoever is writing this understands the reason those communities are like that? >The lack of feedback stems from the outdated decision to only show content from followed blogs on the main dashboard feed (“Following”) ...And there it is. The thing that makes Tumblr unique among social media is the fact that it has a non-algorithmic feed, and is centered on people you like sharing posts they enjoy. By default, you never see a post unless someone you follow either authors it or vouches for it. If they try and change that, and shove an FYP-style page in front of the user by default, they're going to lose that distinguishing feature. I personally support adding some algorithmic feed in (tumblr's discoverability does kind of suck), but a vast majority of the active users are very opposed to even the features they've added so far (like "best stuff first"). They need to be very careful about how they proceed here. Also: >Creators are essential to the Tumblr community. However, we haven’t always had a consistent and coordinated effort around retaining, nurturing, and growing our creator base. Yeah, it's almost like you drove half the creators off of your site with one fell swoop. >Additionally, we need to ensure that when people search for content related to their interests, it is easily accessible without any confusing limitations or unexpected roadblocks in their journey. Coming from a website that is known for having the second-worst search function in social media (after reddit, which at least is easily parsed by google), this is almost laughable.
- permo-w 3y agohave you tried searching on Threads?
- jchw 3y ago> Principle 2: Provide high-quality content with every app launch. This one is a tricky one. I understand the intent, but I think platforms need to shy away from trying to optimize this in particular. One reason is you can't define "high-quality content". Thinking in terms of Tumblr's userbase, there are users who have very specific things they want to see, and if you try to focus on some measure of "quality" (how? engagement? bad idea!) you may just frustrate and alienate them by making it hard to do this curation. That means it's important to make sure you DON'T force an algorithmic feed, even if you're not doing the Threads thing and making it basically a giant sponsored post section in the timeline. Another reason is that's not what people actually like about the internet. The internet is fun because it's a mixed bag: you get a lot of everything. Seeing only the best things every day is neat, but after a while you just get numb to it. What you want is something enticing and interesting. A good example here is YouTube in say, 2008 or so. That was crazy. There was not much of an "algorithm" to speak of: your homepage was just surfacing your followers and their interactions with others. This made a natural social graph of content for you to explore, and you could find stuff that people you like thought was interesting. The experience of crawling through this web of content is enticing in a difficult to explain way, but it would certainly be made worse if you just select stuff that an ML algorithm thinks I would like. Case-in-point, YouTube's recommendations for me are horrible, because it more often than not finds superficially relevant content that doesn't actually scratch the same itch as the stuff I do like. Worse, I think over time having systems like this cause lots of feedback loops. People discover ways to game the algorithm and suddenly everybody is playing the game. Content that is de-prioritized by the algorithm becomes less visible, and makes discoverability of things that people would like to see much harder. I suspect most people who sign up for Tumblr have a specific entrypoint: another person or account that they came there for. The focus on discoverability should, in my opinion, focus on moving outward from there rather than trying to push a bunch of viral content on the user in hopes that it will appeal to them. Same goes for a lot of other social networks that do literally the same thing. It will help your metrics in the short term, but you may very well bleed even more dedicated users. Metrics can obscure a lot of important things...
- karpour 3y agoRegarding YouTube, I'm very split. I wish the platform would give control to the users. There is a lot of stuff I want to see, like.. I subscribe to people because I want to see their things, show their videos on my front page. On the other hand, the algorithm, for all its flaws, has introduced my to a whole world of music I would have never found otherwise. Though then I watch one video about the Ukraine conflict and YouTube suddenly thinks that's all I ever want to watch. Luckily a friend told me about the incognito switch, so now whenever I watch a video I don't want to influence the algorithm, I use that. Not ideal, but better than nothing. On a social media site, on the other hand, I don't want an algorithm deciding what I see. I follow my friends, I don't follow celebrities. Just show me what I want.
- tiffanyh 3y agoTumblr 2.0 Now, more than ever (Twitter/Reddit), is the perfect time to re-launch Tumblr.
- permo-w 3y agoperhaps we are at an inflection point reddit is at war with its users, twitter is being scuttled in live view, Threads is a newborn baby. chaos?
- photomatt 3y agoI'm not sure what version we're on, this would probably be 4.0.
- neowo 3y agonot entirely related, but has anything happened WRT tumblr and activitypub? or is that no longer being considered?
- evanelias 3y agoTumblr 3.0 launched way back in Nov 2007, when David shut down his software services consultancy to focus entirely on Tumblr: https://davidville.wordpress.com/2007/11/01/tumblr-3/ https://davidville.wordpress.com/2007/11/01/tumblr-3/ Internally, the mysql database schema was called "tumblr3" as an artifact from that. Or at least that's the explanation I heard when joining the company in 2010. I don't think anything was ever versioned after v3. So that means if you're saying this is now 4.0, I guess we should expect the biggest change in 16 years :)
- weare138 3y agoThe default position should always be that the user does not know how to navigate the application. I really wish tech companies would stop designing apps for this mythical moron user who's apparently seeing a software application for the first time ever. Everyone knows how to use these apps. Think about it, kids can figure it out. Modern UIs have become so oversimplified that they're counter-intuitive to average users and useless to power users. When you try too hard to make an app for everyone you just end up with an app the doesn't work for anyone.
- szundi 3y agoThis
- maxbond 3y agoI call this "usability nihilism," as an allusion to therapeutic nihilism - the idea, not that the user shouldn't be made to think unnecessarily, but that in fact they are not capable of it. That the user cannot be empowered or trusted to learn by experiment. In short, that usability is impossible.
- DylanDmitri 3y ago1) Add "calls to account creation" to un-logged in view. Annoying but fine. 2) Use an algorithmic feed and not a chronological one. Bad. 3) Clear up internal replies structure. Good. 4) Show you content from people you aren't following. Bad. 5) Rework push notifications. Depends on execution. 6) Reduce crashes. Good. I'm on tumblr mostly to keep in touch with a circle of friends from 10 years ago. I don't want to "grow my blog" and I don't want content from people I don't follow.
- darkerside 3y agoUnfortunately, they probably don't want you either. They want the person who is looking to grow their blog and expand their followers. Not surprising that their product principles would reflect that.
- grishka 3y agoThat's the problem. Every single large enough commercial social media service devolves into this kind of thing. So where are people who don't want to grow their following or see content from people they don't know supposed to go? The fediverse would be my answer but I'm curious what others think.
- mawise 3y agoGo private with something like Haven[1], or stay public but on a platform that explicitly avoids "viral loops" like Micro.blog[2] [1]: https://havenweb.org https://havenweb.org [2]: https://micro.blog https://micro.blog
- darkerside 3y agoOutside? Sorry, couldn't resist!
- grishka 3y ago$ sudo touch grass
- mathewsanders 3y agoTumblr is the only platform that I’m still active on- I’ve had an account since 2009-ish. It’s a really fun community to be active with and the only one that hasn’t attracted a majority of insufferable people. It’s great to see the Richard Rumelt format of strategy with diagnosis/guiding principles, I’m a fan of this format but it also feels a bit like strategy-by-committee and just a laundry list of things. Reading though this I get the sense that no one at tumblr has great insights around the pain points of their own product. I think they need to take a step deeper in their diagnosis and ask “how did we end up with a platform that’s so hard to use?” Otherwise they won’t make progress on the actual underlying issues.
- 50 3y agotumblr was really something in the first several years - all due in part to the great early (design) hires. i was in my teens then but i rememeber my time on the platform pretty fondly
- macintosh-hd 3y agoAs an ex-user who has yet to return, the worst part about using it in 2018 was no post body searching and how bad the home page was. You could be reading a post, it randomly refreshes, and you will never find that post again due to the search being unusable. Considering how much I hear about users searching for old classic posts on the platform, I am doubtful they fixed the search.
- stemlord 3y ago>You could be reading a post, it randomly refreshes, and you will never find that post again due to the search being unusable. I experience this with every platform that utilizes infinite scroll. Infinite scroll seems deliberately unsearchable in favor of slot machine style "who knows what's next" scrolling. Pretty degenerate.
- macintosh-hd 3y agoI almost never have this problem with Twitter. But for the most part, yeah.
- niam 3y agoOn the one hand, they're right that the new user experience needs some attention. On the other hand: they seem woefully tone deaf on how to do that attending without royally botching the things that appeal to Tumblr users. Good luck to them, but I'd suggest they scrap this whole plan and go with something drafted by a team who hasn't drank the engagement kool-aid.
- lbhdc 3y ago> I'd suggest they scrap this whole plan and go with something drafted by a team who hasn't drank the engagement kool-aid What teams come to mind for you?
- abeppu 3y ago> without royally botching the things that appeal to Tumblr users I feel like some form of active involvement from users and creators as stakeholders would be nice to see, shouldn't be that hard, and for some reason seems forever off the table. The idea that a bunch of people created all the content on your social network, and their continued (often free) labor is part of the reason new people would become engaged and so keeping them happy is important seems foreign to insiders, and I don't understand why. Not as "user group research" but as collaborators who you are already in a de facto partnership with, because they create all the stuff people look at.
- Kye 3y agoI had to move my blog off Tumblr shortly after moving on when I realized I couldn't access the archive when logged out. There's no way to turn this off. And as far as I can tell, there's no way to convince it you're logged in when viewing under a domain. I was logged in, but it still showed a logged out view. Something to do with cookies, I'm sure, but this was with default security settings. I'm sure I could fix it for me, but I can't expect everyone who visits to do that.
- photomatt 3y agoThat sounds like a bug I'd like to fix, happy to communicate directly on it.
- Kye 3y agoI moved (or will be) it to wordpress.com, so it's not like I don't trust you to host my blog. It's mainly about the change itself. The locking down of archives was an announced change on the Tumblr blog, so not a bug, and that would have been a deal breaker even if it worked for me.
- mmanfrin 3y agoHonestly, as much as this argument has been beaten to death, they just need to allow explicit NSFW content. This is Twitter's edge right now, and Reddit maybe. Let people post freely, and they'll return.
- paulcole 3y agoWhere does the money come from? I’m assuming it’s more difficult to find ads to run on NSFW content and/or there’s some other reason why monetizing NSFW content is challenging for businesses like Reddit, Tumblr, etc.
- rincebrain 3y agoI believe the specific problem they've claimed before is they'll be banned from the Apple App Store if they do that.
- mmanfrin 3y agoTwitter and Reddit both still exist on the app store.
- philipkglass 3y agoHaving seen this from the inside, well known platforms get more forgiving treatment from app reviewers even if policies are nominally the same for all apps. If Tumblr launches a new or heavily redesigned app and they have adult content, the review process may block it even if Reddit's app has similarly graphic content.
- rincebrain 3y agoOh, I know. But they are correct that the policies state that this is the case, even though Tumblr does still have quite a bit of porn, both compliant and not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoThey made a big mistake by removing porn.
- chrisallick 3y agoI call bs on this strategy being consumer centric. They couldn't monetize "enough." They're saying they had a product problem, but not for their users. Tumblr was lovely, just didn't have the gross design patterns that drive the level/type of usage that advertisers want. Reddit has the same issue and you see them prying the product out of the hands of their users. Lol, also yes to that comment, let the NSFW fly free.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoIs this the joke social network that lost 99.7% of its value? It’s literally a case study of how to drive a social network into the ground. It was sold for 1 billion in 2013 and for 3 million in 2019 They banned most of their artists and content creators when the new owners started their neo-puritan war on porn. Thousands of artists used it to get commissions of fan-art. They suddenly found their income disappear and didnt know why - they were getting shadow banned, often in error. In this announcement I see no indication that they’ve learned anything Once the creators leave, they are not coming back. Quality content is gone. The social network only lives so long as they can re-market someone else’s work. It’s a predatory business.
- dotBen 3y agoI see no indication that they’ve learned anything To be fair, it was Yahoo that banned NSFW but Automattic are the current owners of the property.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI somehow can't see the Wordpress people wanting to become porn moguls. Though on the other hand, they're also the WooCommerce people - with such a name, who knows...
- felipellrocha 3y agoSure, but "Tumblr is not easy to use" doesn't really instill confidence. Tumblr used to be very easy to user. Perhaps one of the easiest websites out there in terms of usage. The underlying problem is actually two fold: 1. They didn't understand their own customers need (which was, to be frank, share porn) 2. That they quite simply lost momentum The first one is addressable. Just say you're going to allow porn again. The second one... Well, that's harder to address.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoI don't think I understand who Tumblr is for anymore, or, maybe I just don't know who it was ever for. I'm not sure any of this is actually coherent or makes sense. They're all points that could be applied to any social network. Maybe Tumblr itself no longer knows who it's serving.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bentt 3y agoI had to double check that the date on the post wasn't 10 years ago.
- pylon 3y ago2010-2012 Tumblr was truly a magical experience. It wasn't a social media for your real life friends or news, it was just a place for fandoms to share tons of gifs. And there was a lot of creativity once people started sharing their own art as well. It's such a shame that we probably won't have another website like this again. I guess some of that stuff has moved to Discord now or sub-communities within Twitter, Reddit, etc but it's just not the same.
- sen_armstrong 3y agoIt's surreal to see posts[1] now eulogizing the 2010s in the same way as the 2000s so often was. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36661497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36661497
- ryukoposting 3y agoOkay, so they're reducing the role of blogs, moving further away from chronological feeds, and replacing isolated replies from people you follow with... something else. I remember when Tumblr was the place to find individuals posting passionately about all kinds of super-niche topics. It had more personality than any of the other mainstream social media services. What the hell happened?
- xlance 3y agoHope they didnt pay too much for this "strategy", because these are plans - not choices.
- MollyRealized 3y agoRecently indicated fixing their broken RSS was "not really aligned with [their] current priorities." [1] [1] https://wip.tumblr.com/post/721930712517853184/rss-feeds-need-love-theyre-an-excellent-way-of https://wip.tumblr.com/post/721930712517853184/rss-feeds-nee...
- hoofhearted 3y agoSo is there room for a new “Tumblr” in 2023? It feels like the community wants it, but Tumblr themselves don’t understand what people actually want. I’ve been working on a side project in my off time, and my wife tells me that what I’ve built is like a “Tumblr” lol. What do you think? Is this something worth pursuing? https://github.com/elegantframework/elegant-cli https://github.com/elegantframework/elegant-cli
- oddevan 3y agoLooks cool! I really like your focus on not needing a database and just using a free Vercel account to run your website. I love seeing stuff like this communicated well; gives me hope one day that I can tell some of my less-technical friends they can do that. :) (I'm working on a project that started as a Tumblr replacement... it's kinda gotten out of control and I'm rapidly trying to get it shippable... ^_^;; https://github.com/smolblog/ https://github.com/smolblog/)
- hoofhearted 3y agoHey thank you! Very encouraging words :)
- appleflaxen 3y ago> As the forerunner of internet culture, Tumblr encompasses ... The forerunner? Woah. That's some serious smug
- pram 3y agoTumblr was extremely comfy. It had a different feel from any other social site, everyone was a lot nicer and friendly and supportive. In a very genuine way. Twitter on the other hand feels like endless sociopaths trying to sell you something. It’s gone though. I know it isn’t Automattics fault, but the high-water mark was almost a decade ago now. Then it was taken behind the shed and put down by Verizon lol
- ben0x539 3y agoEverybody website is trying to pivot to doing what tiktok is good at, instead of what they were good at. Most websites are probably not going to eat tiktok's userbase. I guess we can't have nice things because what those websites are traditionally good at isn't profitable. I can't really be surprised that monetizing tumblr proves challenging, when it seems to consist of like half starving artists, half anti-capitalist shitposters, and half young adults talking about fanfic. I remember monetizing blogging being a running joke on the site over a decade ago, and I can't imagine it's gotten easier with, you know, the economic situation impacting those demographics.
- solarkraft 3y ago> Tumblr is not easy to use The UX is all weird and always has been. Maybe the hardcore users like it, but I personally hate having to "quote tweet" every response. Replies are there now, great, but they are a completely different post type and are unthreaded. You can't have multiple videos in a post. You can't use videos in a reblog. There are so many "what the hell why would it be like this" moments. But the user base is pretty cool. Besides: What happened to the ActivityPub plans? I think it's great that y'all are thinking about this. If you succeed (hopefully without angering the current user base too much), Tumblr could house a lot of Twitter/Reddit refugees.
- BasedAnon 3y agoI still like Tumblr because they let me have HTML, the new restrictions on iframes are annoying tho