4 ms·
Was Richard III a Bad King?
- rstuart4133 3y agoIn case there is any doubt on what the article says the answer is, this is the 2nd paragraph: > Surely Richard was the least successful of English kings. His reign was brief (1483-85) and he left no legitimate issue and no political heirs. He destroyed his immediate Yorkist family and indeed the whole Plantagenet dynasty. He plunged England back into civil war. He re-started the Wars of the Roses that had ended with Yorkist victory in 1471; the conflict raged on for another 20 years. Richard’s principal achievement, albeit inadvertent, was to make feasible the vestigial claim of the obscure Henry Tudor and to create the Tudor monarchy. His regime was catastrophic.
- hardlianotion 3y agoCertainly a bonafide loser on Crusader Kings.
- VintageCool 3y agoThe article really really wants to put a positive spin on Richard III, but in Dictator's Handbook terms he clearly failed at building an effective coalition to rule England. The people whose opinions counted in 1485 mostly did not want Richard III to be king. > That many allies of his brother, Edward IV, supported Henry Tudor speaks to Richard’s inability to command widespread loyalty. Richard’s rule failed because too few people supported him The established figures who had supported his brother rebelled against Richard. > Richard’s subjects and foreign observers were stunned by his brazen betrayal, his swift execution of Lord Hastings, and the disappearance of his young nephews, all of which undermined efforts to stabilise the kingdom in the two years that followed. Further resentment and anxiety festered when Richard misjudged regional politics and redistributed southern property among his northern affinity. Richard was redistributing southern property to northerners because he couldn't find southerners that would support him. On the plus side, Richard III ended the War of the Roses by convincing all the Yorkist supporters (who had supported his brother) that they had to cast their lot with the last Lancastrian candidate (Henry Tudor) in order to get rid of Richard.
- yesbut 3y ago[flagged]
- pharmakom 3y agothanks for saying this. with popular media I think people can get nostalgic for a time that they never experienced and almost certainly would not enjoy.
- nindalf 3y agoNo one is comparing Richard III to Barack Obama. They’re questioning whether Richard III was better or worse than his peers. Table stakes for a king through most of history is providing stability and peace within the realm. This guy failed to do that. This Sith like attitude of “there are only bad kings” is indicative of a mind lacking in nuance or critical thinking.
- pharmakom 3y agoParent was simply pointing out that kings are not good in a moral sense, even if they might be considered good in an effectiveness sense.
- roenxi 3y agoThey aren't good in an effectiveness sense. They only manage to be good relative to other ineffective forms of governance. Statistically some kings might manage to be outliers, but even then to be genuinely effective one suspects they'd be best known for dismantling the monarchy and bringing in either a democracy or republic. Even an oligarchy probably has better odds than a monarchy.
- yesbut 3y agoHis peers were bad too.
- defrost 3y agoThe subjects of King Charles the IIIrd would like to hear more of your thoughts on what they are not experiencing.
- petesergeant 3y ago> Richard was forced to deny to his council that he had poisoned [his ex-wife in order to] marry his niece, Elizabeth Quite the start to a character reference
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoThe successful CV should focus on positive achievements, and avoid negative language. Successfully developed new and innovative union methods, replacing old legacy systems.
- vintermann 3y agoReading history I'm surprised at how many kings were bad kings even on monarchists terms of what's a good king. You'd think they would at least be somewhat good at "reducing conflict related to succession", but then they go and do things like murder their heir in a fit of rage or abolish hereditary monarchy in favour of appointing their own successor, then dying before bothering to do it.
- ycombinete 3y agoThere's a very good book called The Dictator's Handbook. It covers why these conflicts are inevitable. IIRC it boils down to zero-sum power distribution in such systems.
- jacquesm 3y agoMurdering your heir is probably a case of 'who moves first'. Kings dying because someone was tired of waiting is a recurring theme in history. Other candidates are leaders of the military and extended family. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regicides https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regicides
- arethuza 3y agoThe real life Macbeth appears to fall into the "military leader" category: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macbeth,_King_of_Scotland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macbeth,_King_of_Scotland
- vintermann 3y agoI was thinking of Ivan the terrible. I don't think he was terribly rational about it. If he was, it didn't work, since it led to a period of civil war and the eventual end of his dynasty.
- jacquesm 3y agoFor the longest time there was the theory that he died of syphilis, but that appears not to be the case, however, he did have an excess of mercury in his body and that was used back then to treat syphilis. So he may well have suffered from the disease and that in turn plus the mercury itself could well have resulted in him being less than rational.
- guender 3y ago[dead]
- sherr 3y agoI've recently read Josephine Tey's novel "The Daughter of Time" and enjoyed it immensely. It has a fictional detective, laid up in hospital, investigating how true the terrible tales and crimes of Richard III were and comes to the conclusion that it was almost certainly a stitch-up. Great book.
- serallak 3y agoI have loved that book, but I seem to remember that it was based of historical research that has since been revised. Another good book that takes the side of Richard III is the historical novel "The Sunne in Splendour" by Sharon Kay Penman (1982).
- wly_cdgr 3y agoHe was a king, so yes
- throwaway8351r 3y agoThis classic comedy song about Richard III summarizes most of the misconceptions https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XL2se6BzIHk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XL2se6BzIHk I highly recommend this video and TV series for those who are interested in history and comedy