6 ms·
See also LOVEINT. Every once in a while, some NSA spy gets caught spying on their loved ones. Not even incompetence, just plain malice and abuse. Looks like the
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
See also LOVEINT. Every once in a while, some NSA spy gets caught spying on their loved ones. Not even incompetence, just plain malice and abuse. Looks like they don't even face any criminal charges either.
Governments are essentially adversaries, enemies we have to defend against. It must be mathematically impossible for them to abuse their power. Anything short of that is not enough.
- wpietri 3y ago> Anything short of that is not enough. I like that in spirit, but not as a practical standard. A major function of government is to prevent abuses of power. So I'm more inclined to shoot for overall minimization of abuse.
- zozbot234 3y agoWell, in this case a random law enforcement deputy could get sensitive location information about random people with no meaningful cross-check of any sort - and this has only come to light after the fact, as part of a criminal investigation. So there's reason to be highly skeptical that the status quo is the best we can do when it comes to preventing abuse across the board.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> A major function of government is to prevent abuses of power. But they can still do this. If you want to know where someone is, instead of compelling devices or carriers to spy on everyone at all times, you attach a tracker to the suspect's vehicle, or assign an agent to follow them. That's more expensive -- which is the deterrent to abuse. A bad cop doesn't have time to follow around their ex all day. They do have time to follow around the subject of an official investigation, because that's their job. Tracking devices cost money, so it limits the number of people who can be tracked at once and prevents mass surveillance. The argument for compulsory backdoors is purely an efficiency case, but efficiency is less important than preventing abuse.
- zozbot234 3y agoThe carrier is not spying on you here. A cell phone network has to know your phone's location in order to function at all, and this info has only gotten more and more fine-grained with newer network standards. There's nothing wrong with granting access to such data with proper authorization. The "expense" involved in getting warrants approved is a better check on abuse, since it's very easy to do this as part of official law enforcement duties, and quite hard otherwise - the corrupt cop will need to come up with some reasonable justification, and not have it fall apart under deeper scrutiny. Of course if your local judge will rubber-stamp blank_document.docx as a proper "warrant" you have a problem again. But that can be addressed in turn.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt would be simple to design a cellular data network that didn't tie account holders to devices. Issue access tokens good for e.g. 10 GB of data to the mobile device. Don't store the token in connection with the account. Anyone could buy a prepaid card with tokens for cash at any convenience store. The network identifies the device via the token, which is temporary and anonymous. Telephone routing is done via VoIP which anyone has the option of routing through a VPN. It's designed the way it is now on purpose, to spy on everyone. > The "expense" involved in getting warrants approved is a better check on abuse Except that they don't actually get warrants when they're doing abuse, they just lie about it because the phone company has minimal incentive to check and the victim who does typically isn't notified. > Of course if your local judge will rubber-stamp blank_document.docx as a proper "warrant" you have a problem again. But that can be addressed in turn. "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes" is in latin because it was published circa 100 AD. No effective solution to this problem has yet been uncovered.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nurple 3y agoThere was a phone called the AN0M that came on the market a couple years ago that purportedly had similar features, turns out it was an FBI honeypot op to sell it to people that were seeking "privacy" with the hope that criminals would purchase it. https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7b4gg/anom-phone-arcaneos-fbi-backdoor https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7b4gg/anom-phone-arcaneos-f...
- theossuary 3y agoThat's just impossible. Even if everyone had perfect e2e encryption, the government could just ban it and throw people who use it in jail. You can't solve social problems with technology. What is necessary is a governmental system which tends away from the abuse of power. This requires better voting, more transparency, and the literacy and engagement of its citizens. The problem is, just like in Conway's game of life, the current system's state informs what states it'll progress to. If a system tends toward corruption or abuse and isn't actively changed, well eventually it no longer will be possible to change. https://xkcd.com/538 https://xkcd.com/538
- neodymiumphish 3y agoThat's why you use a constitution strong enough to prevent the government from having authority to ban a tool like that. The solution's been known and described for 250+ years now.
- mschuster91 3y agoThe problem is, if you rely on tools - and a constitution is nothing else than a tool - you will end up developing a reliance on that tool. And all of a sudden, that tool breaks, and you're fucked. Democracy must be fought for every single day, and for that matter so does all progress. Democracy isn't something a society automatically converges to and which everyone loves, it must actively be maintained or someone will come, sow mistrust and preach "easy" solutions - and then you wake up and your country isn't a democracy any more.
- vacuity 3y agoThe US Constitution certainly isn't modern or flexible enough to definitively protect (users of) E2EE. There are arguments for their protection, but none is ironclad (like "this is speech that is protected" ironclad). I'm not saying the Bill of Rights was wrong in its time period, but it would be more appropriate to lay out fundamental principles that must be upheld, and protection for E2EE (users) could then be derived. There's some of that already, but not in a clear and comprehensive manner.
- vacuity 3y agoWant mathematical assurance that your government won't abuse power against you? Either you have to be the government or you don't live in a society with a government. Abuse isn't so easily constrained. Try proactive regulations, vigilance, and strict punishments (not comprehensive). Best effort, but what else can you do?
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago"Government can never abuse power or government can systemically abuse power" is a false dichotomy. You can make it cost more so it happens less. Encryption is the common example. As far as anybody knows the government can't break e.g. AES. But they can still find out what's on your device because with a warrant they can install surveillance devices in your house to capture it when you enter your passphrase, then seize your device. Which makes it possible but not easy, which limits the scope for abuse.
- vacuity 3y ago> "Government can never abuse power or government can systemically abuse power" is a false dichotomy. I didn't make it a dichotomy. I was just commenting that "mathematically impossible" is too strong to the point of absurdity. Not fun at parties, but I would hope it's fine on Hacker News. I then provided a rough overview of a system to mitigate abuse. We're not even disagreeing about trying to minimize government abuse. To discuss your example of encryption, the abuse is the government installing and using the surveillance devices (let's assume the suspicion isn't beyond reasonable doubt or whatever and the warrant is invalid). The question is whether that abuse is prevented or routed and justice is enacted.
- I_am_uncreative 3y agoThe standard for a warrant is probable cause, a far lower bar than beyond reasonable doubt.
- vacuity 3y ago
- rnk 3y agoWith us all carrying cell phones and most all EVs having a net connection, anonymity is hopeless. For phones I could get a burner and then when I login in, no privacy. So then a burner w net connection that somehow isn't on at my house, and I ssh to my home computer to read my email. For my EV w a net connection, I could pull the fuse for the lte modem. But I like the map w routing and plug and charge at a supercharger. I only have one idea, I use my friends phone and my friends car. We need a big swap meet every morning.
- redeux 3y ago> ssh to my home Dead giveaway
- rnk 3y agoOkay, but what about trusting everyone in the world and doing a random car and phone swap every morning, isn't that a great idea?
- BHSPitMonkey 3y ago> and most all EVs having a net connection This is a drivetrain-agnostic feature; ICE vehicles have OnStar and all that jazz too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]