5 ms·
The one solution that will work (and is vehemently resisted) is to pay teachers a base salary plus a bonus for each student that meets grade level expectations
by WalterBright 3y ago
The one solution that will work (and is vehemently resisted) is to pay teachers a base salary plus a bonus for each student that meets grade level expectations at the end of the year.
- ordersofmag 3y agoCan you offer any evidence or reasoning as to why I should believe this? It would seem to assert that somehow student success/failure currently sits entirely in the hands of teachers: they know what is needed and could do it if only they were marginally more motivated. I'm not a teacher myself but have been involved in the system my entire life and this doesn't ring true at all. Even if it were possible it would almost certainly result in teachers focusing all of their efforts on the best students and none of it on those who are struggling. Which seems to run counter to the goals of public education.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt works everywhere in the private sector. Having a base salary plus incentive pay for meeting objective goals is commonplace. Companies wouldn't do that if it didn't work. In my own company, Zortech, the staff was paid a base rate plus a cut of the gross sales for the month. > it would almost certainly result in teachers focusing all of their efforts on the best students and none of it on those who are struggling Actually the reverse would happen. The best students would automatically attain grade level performance, and likely exceed it. They'll already get the bonus for those students without any effort. The gold is in getting the underachievers to achieve.
- donw 3y agoIt... really doesn't. Sales is a great example. In companies where bonuses are based on, say, revenue booked per quarter, salesmen play all kinds of games to jack that number up as far as it can go, regardless of the collateral damage. Piss off the engineers by promising the impossible? Who cares, I closed that McScully deal. Sold a customer a product that won't actually solve their problem? Cha-ching, bonus time! Now, when you figure out how to tie sales bonuses to positive outcomes... that's a different story. Then the incentives match the actual goals. But that's really hard to do. Outcomes can take years to measure, if they are measurable at all. Hence why you end up with all kinds of really screwed-up corporate behavior. It's not because people or corporations are evil -- they just take the shortest path to the win, even if that's not really the road you wanted them on.
- WalterBright 3y agoCompanies fix it or they go out of business. I've seen them tweaking it.
- donw 3y agoThat only applies to small companies. Schools are equivalent to large companies, and large companies can screw the proverbial six ways from Sunday for years before it hurts their bottom line, for any number of reasons. Many Americans seem to have this mental disease whereby they think every problem can be solved with more money. This problem can't be.
- WalterBright 3y agoLarge companies still have plenty of incentive pay. Currently, teachers have zero incentive to get results. I bet you'll see results that follow incentives. Of course it won't be perfect - but I bet it'll be much better than the current disaster. People like money. Especially the people who say they aren't motivated by money :-)
- saagarjha 3y agoI work for a large company notorious for shooting itself in the foot because someone’s personal incentives to ship a shiny new thing and get promoted causes long-term repetitional harm as older things get abandoned. We pay for performance too, and quite well at that :)
- wcarey 3y agoHave you thought out the perverse incentives your pay scheme would create?
- viraptor 3y agoLike teachers giving answers to students because higher grades / more passing means more money...
- hakfoo 3y agoI suspect the problem is how you can reasonably write a general spec for that which doesn't systematically doom some teachers, especially during the bootstrap phase (arguably quite a few years). In an ideal world, our perfectly spherical students would enter the classroom "at grade level" and ready to proceed to the next level. But what happens if you inherit a class of students that's barely above "remedial"-- starting one or two grades back on day 1-- what's the right metric for success? Getting all the way up to "at grade level" is probably unrealistic, but should we expect them to make up 1.25 grades per year, or 1.75? Or are we in a "we started back, and are going to beat them by going slower" mentality, and even getting 0.75 grade per year would be a win? Conversely, if you're at a magnet school, you may be taking in students already a few grades above the norm on day one of class. There are kids who can absolute bury the needle on a standardized test-- "12th grade equivalent" at 5th or 6th grade. You could simply babysit them all year and still clear the bar. I also expect there's a huge amount of dealing with Karen parents too-- I suspect an firm hand in holding back underachieving students could result in parental backlash. Too many parents would rather see the kid tossed out the moment he turns 18, even if they haven't gotten them career or independent-life ready.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> But what happens if you inherit a class of students that's barely above "remedial"-- starting one or two grades back on day 1-- what's the right metric for success? Getting all the way up to "at grade level" is probably unrealistic, but should we expect them to make up 1.25 grades per year, or 1.75? Well, obviously, they've been making less than 1.0 grades per year so far; you'd expect them to keep going at that rate, not to suddenly double their rate.
- bandrami 3y agoIt doesn't really work in the private sector though; it leads to destructive and short-sighted juking of the relevant metrics.
- WalterBright 3y agoCompanies wouldn't use it pervasively if it didn't work.
- jcranmer 3y agoPervasiveness seems to be more a function of whatever the latest workplace fad is rather than based on underlying assessments of how well it works. I've heard upper management outright say things like they're mandating return-to-office simply because everybody else is doing it.
- WalterBright 3y agoWFH is the fad. Work In Office and pay for performance has been around since the Dawn of Man.
- defrost 3y agoIt's only recently that more than 50% of humans even live in an urban area (the home base of offices). Most of human history has seen the bulk of humans living in rural areas within all manner of labor exchange schemes. "Modern Capitalism" was founded with "work from home" as a significant factor. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piece_work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piece_work Since the phrase 'piece work' first appears in writing around the year 1549, it is likely that at about this time, the master craftsmen of the guild system began to assign their apprentices work on pieces which could be performed at home, rather than within the master's workshop. Did you not have any history classes in your early schooling?
- WalterBright 3y ago
- astrange 3y agoPerformance reviews aren't always based on "objective goals" and it'd be bad if they were, because almost anyone outside of sales could game them. Typically it's a kind of stack ranking based on how you performed relative to peers, where relative means in the vague opinion of your management tree.
- WalterBright 3y agoPublic teacher unions are adamantly against subjective reviews, which is why I suggested an objective mechanism. > in the vague opinion of your management tree I know it's popular to believe that management has no idea who the real performers are. But every office I've worked in, everyone knew who the good performers were and who the deadwood was. Including the managers. It's also true that every person I've talked to who had been laid off was sure he was unfairly targeted. Even the ones who'd come to work strung out on coke.
- bandrami 3y agoLet's apply this to bankers, too. They must give a checking account to anybody who shows up, and their pay can be based on how much money is in those checking accounts at the end of the fiscal year.
- leetcrew 3y agoa teacher's job is to teach their students. a "banker" (at the sort of bank where you might open a checking account) isn't expected to grow your checking account for you. you're supposed to do that, and the bank is supposed to hold it safely. I don't understand the comparison you are trying to make.
- bandrami 3y agoEven sales manipulates them -- giving away way too much to lock in a longer deal this quarter because it makes this quarter's numbers look better had been a problem at places I've worked.
- denton-scratch 3y ago
- csydas 3y agobut it doesn’t really work in the private sector. MBOs are common for US companies and to this day i’ve got teams across other departments that haven’t met MBO at 100% for years but the higher management seems it okay. the minimum work is still done but the full goals are never realized and these departments are just stuck in a rut. but, who cares? the minimum work is done, the progress numbers still go up, just we don’t have the ideal end result, just an acceptable one. teachers already run the line of barely enough compensation to make it worthwhile except for those who are inclined towards teaching. teachers are expected to do too much and there are too many goals imo for the position. whether we want it to be the case or not there is a huge social and mental health aspect to their jobs, and the standards look to be wildly inconsistent even within the same city as to what a successful education means. like would you want to put a ton of effort in on a project knowing that the very next quarter you’re going to have to basically change the entire stack you’re working with and have a completely different set of regulations and project goals? and on top of it all, you need to get your team to even take the project seriously? and to make it even more fun a bunch of your teams’ families and friends are telling the world that the language you picked is awful and evil and are trying to regulate it out of use? how much would you want for conditions like that every single project?
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Having a base salary plus incentive pay for meeting objective goals is commonplace. Companies wouldn't do that if it didn't work. Management methods are full of cargo cult "science".
- baanlox 3y ago[dead]
- donw 3y agoI don't think that would make a difference. Incentives are whack across the board in education. At every level, hiring and purchasing are done on the basis of political loyalty, rather than competence or fitness-for-purpose. An entire cathedral has been built upon patronage, and that cathedral will fight quite literally to the death rather than reform itself. We're just now approaching the end-stage of what that looks like in-practice.
- WalterBright 3y agoHence the vehement opposition to the idea, sadly.
- donw 3y agoCash incentives aren't going to make a difference. The only thing that works is school choice. If parents can choose the schools, the schools have to deliver results.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Cash incentives aren't going to make a difference. If they don't make a difference, then there won't be any payouts to make. It's a can't-lose proposal.
- sokoloff 3y agoI’m generally supportive of finding ways to better use the talent of teachers and if paying incentives is part of that, great. But this claim is pretty absurd. Imagine that payoffs (in a poorly designed system) are based on a random number generator. That won’t have any lasting, society-wide effect (I suspect you agree), but would result in some payouts. Incentive design is the difficult nut here, but if cracked, there’s a lot of value to the next generations.
- lacrimacida 3y agoDesigned incentives can look good on paper but in reality they get gamed a lot until they are insignificant or detrimental to the final outcome.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI think that could work but you would need to give teachers more control over the discipline and syllabus in their classrooms. If you can't maintain order and can't adapt your teaching to meet the needs of your students, there's limits to what can be achieved.
- WalterBright 3y agoOf course there are limits on what can be achieved. But we won't know until we try. It's hard to be worse than the current system of no incentive whatsoever.
- tremon 3y agoIt's hard to be worse than the current system This is hardly ever true, for any kind of system.
- bandrami 3y agoWhere did you get the idea that US public schools are in some kind of crisis? They're doing pretty well, like they always have, but people are remarkably willing to simply accept claims (often by parties with financial interests in making them) that they aren't.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Where did you get the idea that US public schools are in some kind of crisis? Declining achievement levels, the perfectly horrible results in inner city schools, and the disparities between different racial groups.
- bandrami 3y ago> Declining achievement levels Nope. Do the homework here. > the perfectly horrible results in inner city schools Another claim remarkably free of any data > the disparities between different racial groups. African American kids today score better than white kids 30 years ago did.
- waterhouse 3y agoOne way to achieve that, for a teacher, would be to get all the good students into your class, and avoid having any bad students, or find reasons to kick them out. Do you have countermeasures for that?
- WalterBright 3y agoSure. Assign the students at random. Some years the teacher will get a better batch than other years, but it would all even out.
- davidgay 3y agoDon't forget to bus the kids randomly across town (county? state?), or else your suggestion is ineffective. That has always been a very popular and well received idea (or maybe your should think a bit before blaming teachers).
- WalterBright 3y agoWhy would it be ineffective? Suppose you're a teacher at a school where the kids are all below grade level. Sounds like a much larger opportunity to get those bonuses than a school where all kids are above average. > or maybe your should think a bit before blaming teachers Teachers are only human, and humans respond to positive incentives. The current system has no incentives.
- davidgay 3y agoYou claimed that the fix to getting lucky with a batch of good students (or unlucky with bad) is random assignment. Now it seems that you're claiming that getting a bad batch is a good deal as it will be easier to get them to improve...
- WalterBright 3y agoBoth can be simultaneously true.
- wrp 3y agoWhile I'm not completely against performance-based pay, there are some issues that would make this particular approach unworkable. One is that in dealing with children, personal compatibility matters a great deal more. Some teacher-student relationships will "just click" and others fail. Another is the dependence of the students' performance on their home environment. So, even an excellent teacher will get poor results when working in a disadvantaged district. These things would have to be taken into account when designing a reward system for teachers.
- WalterBright 3y agoA proper proposal would be a lot more words than my little posting! It doesn't have to be perfect. It just has to be significantly better than the existing system, which has zero incentive for the teachers to get results.
- reverius42 3y ago> zero incentive for the teachers to get results Except, of course, wanting to educate -- which is ostensibly the reason they got into the profession in the first place. It probably wasn't for the pay.
- WalterBright 3y agoEvery job has its drudgery, no matter how much someone wants to have that job. I would also expect teachers who love to teach also want to teach those eager to learn. This is about teaching those who are not so interested in learning. Also, you can't say teachers are poorly paid by neglecting they only work 8 months of the year, have a gold plated medical plan, and can retire with a lifetime very generous pension.
- bandrami 3y agoI find it weird the intensity with which people believe that teachers rather than students are the bottleneck here. If you want to add an incentive it makes much more sense to incent the students to do well.
- WalterBright 3y agoAn incentive for the teachers is better than no incentive. I recall a case at a company I worked for. They snagged a major contract with IBM, but it had a tight deadline. They hired a team of 6 or 7 greybeards to do the work. The fun thing was they each got a $10,000 bonus if delivered on time. They delivered it on time, got the $10 grand each (a lot of money in those days), IBM was happy, all good. So I asked them, did the $10 grand bonus motivate them to get it done on time? They were offended, saying they were professionals and would have worked just as hard without it. I laughed, and didn't buy it. Do you? Here's another case. There was an earthquake in LA, and one of the cloverleaf freeway interchanges fell down. They contracted out the job with a tight deadline, and a bonus of ONE MILLION BUCKS per day it was finished ahead of schedule. It was finished several weeks ahead. Ka-ching! Money talks, BS walks.
- bandrami 3y agoRight but you give the incentive to the construction company, not to the food truck that feeds the workers. The teachers aren't the problem (to the extent there even is a problem, which is an embarrassingly unexamined question), the students are. So give them an incentive to stop being a problem.
- WalterBright 3y agoGiving the teachers an incentive to find a way to incentivize the students is a perfectly reasonable approach.
- peterfirefly 3y agoHow do you incentivize IQ?
- fn-mote 3y agoThese suggestions of "pay for results" have a complicated history. I suggest anyone interested actually search the literature on it. Ever since I saw the critique of the 2012 NYC value added measure results, which shows VAM scores uncorrelated between different classrooms of the same teacher [4], I have been very skeptical that any kind of incentive pay will work. (Also, this NYT article is pretty damning considering the source. [3]) The question is not whether VAM can work, it is a question of does a particular implementation work. The paper [1] is a classic (search for it). In this particular case: the exact method is not clear but it sounds like there is no adjustment for prior achievement, so all teachers of advanced classes will automatically get the bonus? What if instead what is being measured is the change from year to year? Same result: in this case history is an excellent predictor of the future. [1]: Rothstein, Jesse. “Teacher Quality in Educational Production: Tracking, Decay, and Student Achievement.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 125, no. 1, February 2010, pp. 175–214. [2]: Methodological issues in value-added modeling. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11092-019-09303-w https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11092-019-09303-w [3]: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/25/education/teacher-quality-widely-diffused-nyc-ratings-indicate.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/25/education/teacher-quality... (paywall) [4]: https://garyrubinstein.wordpress.com/2012/02/26/analyzing-released-nyc-value-added-data-part-1/ https://garyrubinstein.wordpress.com/2012/02/26/analyzing-re... (Found it!!)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- light_hue_1 3y ago> The one solution that will work (and is vehemently resisted) is to pay teachers a base salary plus a bonus for each student that meets grade level expectations at the end of the year. You're talking as if this isn't how the system works today. Your proposal is literally how US education has worked since the 80s. The disaster you see in the public education system in the US is in part caused by merit-based systems including merit-based pay for teachers. The key problem is that we cannot measure how educated someone is. We can only measure their results on a test. Garbage in, garbage out. This means that everyone teaches to a test. That's a horrible experience for teachers and students. And it literally leads to the solution the article warns us about: water down all the tests and eliminate as much knowledge from the curriculum as you can so that everyone excels and everyone gets their merit-based pay. We also know that merit-based pay has a tiny impact on student scores in the short term at the scale that one teacher can control over a student-year, under 0.1 standard deviations. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0002831220905580 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/000283122090558... So not only does merit-based pay for teachers not work, not only does it not raise scores in any meaningful way, not only does it erode the curriculum, it's literally a big part of the current problem in the US. Oh, and let's not forget kids with any kind of disability. Under this system they become a massive liability. Instead of teachers trying to help such students, they're quickly routed to the closest holding area so that they don't affect scores. This has been going on for almost 20 years now because of No Child Left Behind. This is why teachers are opposed to the idea of doubling down on merit-based pay. It's not because the best teachers don't want to make more money. It's because it only rewards the teachers of kids that are already performing well, while punishing teachers in schools that aren't performing well, without any means for the teachers to meaningfully intervene.
- throw9away6 3y agoWhy does teaching to a test not work? If the curriculum was standard and the test was well made it should work fine. All my college grades were 50-100% test based and it seemed to work fine. Maybe you break down the content into testable units or something instead of one big test but still what’s wrong with tests?
- 3y ago
- slowmovintarget 3y agoWe have already seen that such incentives produce the wrong effect. At the whole-school level, what we see from incentives like this is that the system gets gamed such that the standard is lowered so that pay milestones are achieved, as opposed to the actual results of educating the children. Tests get dumbed down. Teaching to tests instead of to understanding occurs. Pay teachers more, but put them in a system where the students matter, not the money.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoThat seems like more of an incentive to get a job at an already high-performing school than it is to do a better job of teaching.