7 ms·
Workers are competing for their own jobs
- ryandrake 3y agoI wonder if, at any of these companies, management (including senior, C-level management) also needs to re-apply to justify their own jobs and pay and beat out the other managers, or if this Hunger Games process is only for the worker bees.
- version_five 3y agoTo be fair, at a very senior level you are always fending off criticism and attempts at your job. Not saying they have it worse overall, just that such high level jobs are way more at risk in general.
- epicureanideal 3y agoThat isn't what I've observed. I wonder if there's any data on this?
- easterncalculus 3y agoI can believe the CEO, CTO, CFO, etc would be subject to more scrutiny, but for a lot of the new VPs parachuting in and running the show on this kind of thing I'm sure they're comfortable.
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoProbably depends on the business; I'm sure there are slow moving companies where upper level managers can rest and vest. In big tech, though, the competition to climb the ladder can be pretty fierce and a manager is only worth as much as as the value their team has delivered recently. It wouldn't really be wrong to say they have to justify their own jobs more or less every quarter.
- anotherhue 3y agoLife is too short to spend time playing some wanna-be-dictator's game. Move on and find a job that doesn't extract such a needless emotional toll.
- Traubenfuchs 3y agoSorry, but what you wrote is a feel good message that can only be spoken from a place of incredible privilege. Many people are in positions where they would struggle to find another job that doesn‘t pay less, if they can find one at all.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prewett 3y ago> incredible privilege Bah. It's spoken from a place of valuing yourself. We can choose to be a victims of "the system" or we can choose to be powerful people and place boundaries on how we want to be treated. It might take some time to locate a job that treats us well, but contrary to the Marxist view of business, not all businesses are exploitative. > Many people are in positions where they would struggle to find another job that doesn‘t pay less, if they can find one at all. That's convenient rhetoric, but who exactly are these people? It sounds like these are just abstract "people" based on an assumption that almost all businesses are exploitative, and that the few unexploitative ones actually pay less (my observation is that the exploitative ones pay less and the unexploitative ones both have a better work environment and pay more). Depending on the industry, it might take some hunting to find good management, but there's no reason you have to quit your current job while you're looking. And you might need to gain some skills if you are working in a low skill industry, but even there, you could apply to Trader Joe's instead of Walmart, for instance.
- coldtea 3y ago>Bah. It's spoken from a place of valuing yourself. You can value yourself all you want, if the market doesn't value your skills, your domain within your job sector, or your job sector in general, it's meaningless.
- drewcoo 3y agoShould be a reality TV show.
- Barrin92 3y ago>At the request of new bosses who’d come in, she says her colleagues had to join a large group call, then prove why they deserved a role over the others. This is just dehumanizing and humiliating. At that point you might as well strike and throw the managers into the Battle Royale pit. Also a good reminder why unionization makes sense even in well paying white collar professions, employers will pit people against one another regardless.
- MilStdJunkie 3y ago"I'm a good fit for this role because of my insatiable appetite for the mutilated, braised flesh of Yalie techbros."
- Kamq 3y agoThis seems like a real weird strategy. Most often, a company's competent people are (at the very least) slightly underpaid and going along out of a sense of inertia. The day to day routine is comforting and interviewing is a real pain, and while I'd take a good pay bump, it's definitely not worth going through the entire process for a couple thousand dollars a year. I've had teams just shattered when the first person left because it reminds everyone else that leaving is an option. Forcing your most competent people, the ones that preform the day to day work, to get their resumes updated and practice interviewing seems like it's going to make jumping ship a realistic option for all the people you're relying on. Now, maybe half the staff or something is dead weight, and you can afford to offer the competent ones a ~20% pay bump to the new market rate (as opposed to the market rate when you first hired them) while cutting 50% of payroll, but that doesn't seem like what these companies are going to do. It seems like they're going to make everyone interview for the same salary they currently have, and I'd be rather shocked if that was the best deal most people with skills could get. This seems like it's going to backfire hard.
- praptak 3y agoYeah the classic management by spreadsheet. Intentional "X percent voluntary attrition" might look good in a spreadsheet ("Y million saved in severance!"). Somehow it never takes into account that it's the best people who leave and those who stay won't have a very strong morale.
- flashgordon 3y agoDefinitely a sad state of affairs. I've learnt to look at management and more importantly corporate leadership from the lens of macleod's theory of org hierarchy - ie org being a pyramid of sociopaths, clueless and losers (in the financial sense). This attrition biz makes a lot of sense as our entire economy is geared towards showing short term improvements by sociopaths who will jump ship before any of the long term impact comes into play or can be attributed to them. Why else would wall st be rewarding these crazy layoff numbers? Take meta. They reduced costs by Culling about 25% of the workforce. While a great short term financial gain, how has that changed the long term outlook re productivity to merit a stock doubling in a good few months (or was it a tripping?). Is anyone seriously beleiving this culling, stack ranking and doubling of workload and stress and infighting is actually going to attract missionaries? Or is it that just warm bodies would do?
- praptak 3y agoIf coworkers are competition then it doesn't make sense to help them too much. And if you have to do anything with hiring it makes sense to steer the process towards hiring people less capable than you.
- swader999 3y agoCollaboration in programming always gets things done faster with better design and quality. It's why pair programming, code review, mentoring, design sessions, bouncing ideas, team building, and even offices are a thing. As soon as you measure and evaluate at an individual level you destroy all this. I only track and mention velocity at the team level and the team spans requirements, dev and QA.
- jstarfish 3y agoThat's one way to look at it. You see competition. I see leverage. I always encourage my teammates to seize something critical and gatekeep the shit out of it. Do the worst possible job automating or cross-training anybody else when asked. Insist on handling everything yourself at every opportunity and quietly revoke the trainee's permissions, then deny doing so in spite of any evidence presented. You want to fire Alice? There goes your only Exchange admin. You want to fire Bob? Nobody else knows IAM. Good luck onboarding his replacement. Firing Charlie? He was the PCI compliance guy. Me? There goes security. I don't owe my colleagues job security, but I do like and respect them. And there is strength in numbers. For every team member I lose, some aspect of the business will be disrupted.
- praptak 3y agoFrom the company point of view this too means reduced cooperation, just maybe a different flavor.
- easterncalculus 3y agoLooking forward to seeing where all that 'intellectual property' these companies are simultaneously worried about ends up after putting the people that actually handle it through this.
- swader999 3y agoYup, have no problem knocking on competitors doors, bringing my best colleagues along with me in the months following an exit from hostile management.
- knallfrosch 3y agoIf half the company gets fired, I'm bolting out the door anyway, no matter the process that decides who gets to survive the first round.
- RadixDLT 3y agoAs job security slips away, the cruel dance of competition begins within the walls where friendships once blossomed. The heartache of watching colleagues forced to vie for their own livelihoods is a cruel reality.
- captainbland 3y agoThose employers should be careful. It would be a shame if they bit off more than they could chew and nobody reapplied until certain demands were met.
- renewiltord 3y agoBritish HR management is bottom tier. HR management in general is a bottom 30 percentile job, but British HR management is really bad. They comprehend nothing about running a company's workforce. I don't mean this out of a "they're exploiting the workers" angle. I mean that they literally damage the company's success. This new technique is particularly egregious since if you're interviewing you might as well interview elsewhere as well. It's going to take as much effort. And the reality is that there is a cone of outcomes that is wider at a new place and narrower at the existing place so the new place is attractive if the cone shifts downwards here. There's no surprise that most British companies cater to the local market and that few software successes have arisen from this economy that is as large as California. The cost is felt by the UK alone which generally just has poorer products than elsewhere. If I knew leadership of some company learned primarily in the UK, I would probably just look elsewhere. They can't even fix it because employees there expect management to transform into this at any time, and so don't feel ownership of what they're doing. Essentially, everyone in the UK has been "quiet quitting" for 40 years.
- canthemall1111 3y ago[flagged]
- tsuujin 3y agoBad managers do exist, but painting every manager as useless is a bit short sighted. A good manager is your shit shield. They’re doing their job well when you have no idea how much work they’re putting in to minimize the amount of bullshit you have to deal with day to day.
- soverynottrue 3y agoSo very not true. I would say 80% of managers in tech. Don't do anything essential. If the acquisition of the twitie bird didn't prove that to you. I don't know what will. Granted there was also a lot of developer role fluff there as well.
- tsuujin 3y agoDo you know 80% of managers in all of tech? Seems like a grandiose claim to make without any solid backing. Twitter is not all of tech.
- domoarigato33 3y agoI don't need to. Domo Arigato Mr Pareto. Pareto already figured it out for all of us.
- tsuujin 3y agoWell, good for you having detailed context into absolutely everything all at once, I guess.
- heresanidea 3y agoI have always thought that managers should be technical managers. That way they can actually pitch in. Instead of trying to justify meetings for everyone all the time. The only reason Product Managers exist is because the next level up wants to trade stocks all day. There is a point where Taylorism does break down. I believe we are there in tech. As far as management is concerned.
- cheese_van 3y agoIf my own worth to my employer is sufficiently opaque to require me to defend my position, this suggests they have insufficient data to evaluate me - and if my worth is not obvious to them, then I guess it's time to go. What else does this company not have a good handle on? It's a red flag they'll be poor performers in whatever market they've staked out.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThat and if your employer starts calling you a "worker" then you better open your eyes and pay attention. That's a term from communism and dictatorial regimes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dehugger 3y agoI'd rather be a worker than a "resource" any day of the week.
- dec0dedab0de 3y agoI swear executives think that employees are robots. It matters how much workers of all skill levels care about the company and what they're doing. Any developer who has worked with temporary contractors can see this. When people stop caring it all falls apart, and no one is going to care about what you want them to if you threaten them and fire their friends.
- zerodensity 3y agoWow just wow
- bentt 3y agoThis is simply the cowardice of leadership to make the calls. If they force everyone to "convince me" then it becomes somehow the employee's fault when they can't. It's bullshit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hgsgm 3y agoImagine working somewhere for years and management saying thry have no idea if what you do is useful, and their solution is to ask you to explain it to them. Why isn't management interviewing and proving their worth?
- crnkofe 3y agoThis sounds like one of those wonderfully insane ideas. Either the company has a need for a role or it doesn't. It's up to the leadership to figure it out. Pitting the workforce against themselves is avoiding the responsibility of making hard decisions while making a reality show out of the situation. It reminds me of this weird management nugget, I personally heard once, where the idea was to have multiple devs within the team solve the same problem and pick the best solution. It's as-if turning the office into a moshpit would suddenly optimally solve real world problems.