4 ms·
The actual ruling [0] is very approachable and far more interesting than the article above. The farmer was in the habit of accepting contracts from this particu
by lolinder 3y ago
The actual ruling [0] is very approachable and far more interesting than the article above. The farmer was in the habit of accepting contracts from this particular company by saying "yup" or "looks good" or similar short responses. SWT quite reasonably took this usage of the thumbs up emoji as just another one of the farmer's casual signatures.
If Chris sincerely did not intend to sign the contract, he really should not have been in the habit of accepting contracts with a casual single-word reply in the first place. Had he insisted on a more formal process in prior negotiations with SWT, I doubt the judge would have granted summary judgement in this case (and SWT probably wouldn't have assumed the thumbs up was a signature).
[0] https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2023skkb116-480130.pdf https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2023skkb116-480130.pdf
- roenxi 3y agoThis behaviour must be the result of some sort of internal policy; but it really highlights just how low the quality of corporate[0] journalism is. They're doing not much useful except polluting a search for the case details with links to their poorly articulated take. It'd be so easy to include the link or a copy of the PDF in the article. But they just aren't in a headspace where people might want facts, context or otherwise have an interest in the details of the story. The professionalism of these services is poor. We don't even have the name of the person stirring up clickbait. [0] The ABC is government funded, but still follows the same basic model as all the rest and it looks like they lifted this off Reuters.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> They're doing not much useful except polluting a search for the case details with links to their poorly articulated take. Polluting a search indeed. On youtube, it feel like every search result, even if not news related, is filled with links to news. I just don't get it. > it looks like they lifted this off Reuters. The source of most news is the AP or Reuters. If the company wants to add their spin on a topic, they'll have their journalists add to the ap or reuters articles.
- tourmalinetaco 3y ago> On youtube, it feel like every search result, even if not news related, is filled with links to news. I just don't get it. Or product reviews. I looked up “science of active noise cancelling headphones” to explain the science more easily to a friend, and 2/10 were actually what I wanted. The rest were “BEST HEADPHONES EVER?! What YOU need to know!”-type garbage.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoAlso worth highlighting that the contact price was $669 per tonne, but the spot price at time of delivery was $1614 per tonne for 87 tonnes ($58k contract vs $140k spot) I am not sure how much the future deliveries and spot prices diverge (I would expect savings on pre-purchasing), but there was potentially significant profit motivation for the seller to find any reason to back out of the deal.
- glimshe 3y agoInteresting. I think that the assumption that a thumbs up is the same of a full contractual acceptance (vs "ok, I received it" or "contract looks good, let me now think about it") should only be made under a very specific and narrow context, that is, the party has a history of accepting contracts with brief sentences.
- lolinder 3y agoYes, the judge explicitly calls out in his decision that it counted as a signature because it was consistent with their prior negotiations (emphasis added): > In my opinion the signature requirement was met by the {{THUMBS UP}} emoji originating from Chris and his unique cell phone ... which was used to receive the flax contract sent by Kent. There is no issue with the authenticity of the text message which is the underlying purpose of the written and signed requirement of s. 6 of the SGA. Again, based on the facts in this case – the texting of a contract and then the seeking and receipt of approval was consistent with the previous process between SWT and Achter to enter into grain contracts. > This court readily acknowledges that a {{THUMBS UP}} emoji is a non-traditional means to “sign” a document but nevertheless under these circumstances this was a valid way to convey the two purposes of a “signature” – to identify the signator (Chris using his unique cell phone number) and as I have found above – to convey Achter’s acceptance of the flax contract.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoWhat a reasonable opinion
- s1artibartfast 3y agoKnowing and having worked with several farmers I have a little bit more mixed opinion on the ruling. Many of them prefer to operate without contract, eg, I'll deliver the goods but I won't sign your docs. This case seems to turn on weather any of these past contracts were actually binding, and maybe they were if there was a clear enough response. However,if both parties have crappy business processes that run without signatures, I would think that disputed signatures would default to non binding. >Had he insisted on a more formal process in prior negotiations with SWT, I doubt the judge would have granted summary judgement in this case (and SWT probably wouldn't have assumed the thumbs up was a signature). Similarly, if SWT had insisted on signed contracts, there wouldn't be any question of if these terms were accepted. It seems like there is at least some contribution here.
- lolinder 3y agoThe judge addresses this question and found that neither party disputed that the past contracts were in fact contracts: > So in short, what we have is an uncontested pattern of entering into what both parties knew and accepted to be valid and binding deferred delivery purchase contracts on a number of occasions. It is important to note that each time Kent added to the offered contract “Please confirm terms of durum contract” and Chris did so by succinctly texting “looks good”, “ok” or “yup”. The parties clearly understood these curt words were meant to be confirmation of the contract and not a mere acknowledgement of the receipt of the contract by Chris. There can be no other logical or creditable explanation because the proof is in the pudding. Chris delivered the grain as contracted and got paid. There was no evidence he was merely confirming the receipt of a contract and was left just wondering about a contract.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSo I agree with part of that and disagree with part of that. The part I agree with is that giving a thumbs up too the specific request to “Please confirm terms of durum contract” is acceptance. The part that doesn't sit well with me is the argument that past performance of delivery alone validates a contract. I think I agree with the decision, but it is because the farmer affirmed agreement to the terms each time, not because making a delivery implies that existence of a contract.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI have a client like this. Any 3-sentence email is too long for him to write or read. People ask him "Option A or Option B?" questions and he replies "yes", resulting in 3 more back-and-forth emails to clear up confusion. It's always the other party's fault for being confusing. I can totally see him approving an $80k deal with a thumb's up then turning into a lawyer when held to it.
- kevinventullo 3y agoI’m on my HOA board and this describes every single vendor we work with. Absolutely infuriating, and I don’t understand how they graduated high school.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI don't understand how they graduated high school and they don't understand how I don't own a business that makes 7 figures, since it's so easy for them to do. Life is confusing to me, pretty much every day.
- DANmode 3y agoIt IS pretty easy, if you: pay no deep attention to anything, and delegate all tasks, even if to hacks or fucking idiots.
- DropInIn 3y agoHeres the trick they use: Dont pay anything until the very last minute and spend like there's no tomorrow, then when the credit eventually runs out and the tax man is knocking, declare bankruptcy and feign ignorance claiming for the rest of your life that the system was out to get you and youre just a victim of corruption.
- tennisflyi 3y agoI emailed a YouTuber about a product and their answer was so terse/unprofessional. The bar is low for be successful businesses . Lots of makeup on a pig. Ultimately, just do it.
- Svip 3y agoSince it's a Canadian story, perhaps link to a Canadian news source? https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/thumbs-up-emoji-costs-sask-farmer-82-thousand-1.6898686 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/thumbs-up-emoji-...
- nneonneo 3y ago> Q. Yeah. What kind of phone do you have? > A. An iPhone. > Q. Good. Good. That’s the best kind of phone. So when you’re on your - - I have an iPhone as well. What a funny exchange of pleasantries in cross examination…
- arp242 3y agoHad something very similar happen about 20 years ago. I was a scout leader at the time, and one of the other leaders phoned another scout group to rent their building for our summer camp. They mentioned a price, he said "okay", intending to be "okay, I understood that's the price, let's discus" whereas they took it as "okay, I agree to this price, and we'll rent it". Long story short, turns out verbal contracts like this very much are enforcible, and they were pretty adamant about enforcing it. Who knows if it would have held up in court, but just paying the "cancellation fee" was cheaper than lawyers, Absolutely outrageous a volunteer non-profit organisation would squeeze another volunteer non-profit like this by the way; this was well before the planned date and the confusion came to light within days of the "okay", so they suffered basically zero damages. Bunch of twats.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoThat was a confusingly terse response to give verbally. If someone only said, “Ok”, I suspect I would have assumed the same as the rentee (although, I hope I would have been astute enough to confirm the confirmation). Regardless, for what was likely never much of a money making operation, definitely poor taste to stick to their guns and enforce the deal.
- arp242 3y agoIt's not that uncommon to say "okay" as merely a verbal acknowledgement; I do it all the time! In this context it's indeed ambiguous I guess, but I don't think it can reasonably be assumed to mean "we accept the terms" since where I'm from these type of "verbal contracts" are extremely uncommon – I'm highly skeptical it would have stood up in court (it came as a surprise to everyone that this was enforceable) but we weren't really eager to test that.
- DropInIn 3y agoIf I say to you "pay me $50 to cut your lawn" and you respond with "okay" and Nothing else, there's only one reasonable interpretation. It frankly seems like you're being willfully obtuse...