6 ms·
I'm kind of amazed at how saturated the news is with stories about Threads. And not just tech news, but also every mainstream news site has at least one or more
by ryandrake 3y ago
I'm kind of amazed at how saturated the news is with stories about Threads. And not just tech news, but also every mainstream news site has at least one or more "submarine" marketing articles promoting Threads. Meta Marketing Team: You're not fooling anyone into thinking these are grassroots and viral, but honestly, well done with the media saturation. Meta's clearly got all the right channels on full-blast. It's really impressive.
- conception 3y agoI don’t know with Twitter going through various meltdowns having met a step up and say hey, you can come here instead I feel like it’s pretty big news. This product also wasn’t at least on my radar at all and so I think it was sort of a big surprise for everybody. The eighth largest website on the planet size to go toe to toe with Twitter… Seems like big news?
- yeeetz 3y agoHonestly I don't fuck with social media that much besides my private Instagram, but there's more to it than just viral marketing. It's a pretty smooth app that appeals to people like my 18-25-ish age that feels like Twitter has gotten super weird and toxic. The honeymoon effect won't last forever, but it has something that a lot of social media users are looking for.
- jxramos 3y agolol, makes me think of serial monogamy applied to social media
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe real market is for brands, they can't stand the insanity on Twitter. I think of Musk's idea of turning Twitter into a super app. Well, if I go into a business and somebody asks me to pay with Twitter that business is going to be associated with Musk, Twitter, and all that. If the business is selling anti-woke razor blades it might be a good fit, but an ordinary business just doesn't want to be associated with that. Contrast that to Visa, Mastercard, or American Express, all of which have worked hard to be associated with a positive image.
- wlesieutre 3y agoI can just imagine it, “spend $500/month with Twitter Pay and you get a green checkmark, promoting your tweets even above the already promoted blue checkmark tweeters”
- granzymes 3y agoMeta isn’t that stupid. Messing with the verification system is one of the blunders that put Twitter in the position where Threads could eat its lunch.
- sugarpile 3y agoInstagram offered the same system (pay for blue check) shortly after twitter. But yes, they didn't revoke anyone's existing tick or make it a prerequisite for future "notable" people.
- wodenokoto 3y agoThe problem with blue checkmark wasn’t that it was paid for verification. The problem was that there was no verification. You paid to be verified as anybody you’d like. I’m no twitter owner, but to me the reasonable thing would be to put the name on the credit card on the account along with the checkmark. That would scale for personal accounts, but not businesses. They could be charged extra and manually verified against national business registries.
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe comparables on my mind are the EV (Extended Validation) SSL certificates and the Legal Entity Identifier, both of which involve a lookup against business records for a corporation/LLC and have a sustainable cost of around $100 year. EV failed in the marketplace. “No LEI, No Trade” made a lot of companies get an LEI but last time I looked it was widespread for companies to keep using their LEI without renewing it.
- hyperhopper 3y agoBut why didn't those users just go to mastodon?
- 0xFF0123 3y agoBecause there is significantly less friction to the onboarding of Threads, and the significant network effect that Meta is capitalising on
- itsmartapuntocm 3y agoThe narrative had already been seeded that mastodon is too fractured/difficult. And Threads has the momentum of Facebook/Instagram pushing it forward.
- nvr219 3y agoThe narrative is right though. Here is a common thing that happens to me: - someone sends me a funny post - I want to "like" it or save it or whatever On Twitter and other centralized social media this is very easy to do. On Mastodon, it is not. I have to copy the URL, paste it into a text field on my instance, and then like it.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoThreads is polished in a way that Mastodon isn't. I'm part of a few Japanese subcultures and most of them couldn't make heads or tails of the Fediverse despite the existence of Misskey. Threads though? They signed up through Instagram and were posting in minutes. I really want Meta to commit to federation, even if existing Mastodon communities defederate so that techie weirdos like us can live their dreams of running custom clients and interfacing with regular folks (like XMPP federation with GChat back in the day.)
- yeeetz 3y agoYeah, Twitter is super big in Japan for mainstream teen and young adult users in the 18-25 city student/young professional demographic. Same with Instagram. Mastodon adjacent stuff like Misskey, Pawoo, and Mstdn got the reputation for being for hosting weird, niche, or pretty much illegal content, and nobody really understands the point of Fediverse.
- 0xDEF 3y ago>Twitter has gotten super weird and toxic This is correct but it's helpful to specify how much more toxic twitter has become than other platforms. For example anti-LGBT sentiments are common on other platforms just like they are common in society. But on twitter people like Jake Shields literally call for the murder of therapists, doctors, and teachers who are supportive of LGBT teens. How did twitter respond? First they let the tweets get thousands of engagements. Then they removed the tweets without banning Shields. Finally they removed other people's tweets, archive links, and screenshots documenting Shields' hate speech. Jake Shields is still on twitter pushing toxic lies and disinfo. TL;DR: Elon Musk's twitter protects people who want to murder doctors and teachers.
- yeeetz 3y agoYeah, IMO Musk seriously overestimated the average person's tolerance for toxic and hateful political content.
- sangnoir 3y agoI think it was a very deliberate ploy by Musk to shift the political Overton window to way to the right. Unfortunately for him & his backers, the political shenanigans and general incompetence left Twitter vulnerable, with users seemingly choosing to trust Meta over it, of all fucking companies. This will be case study in business school for years.
- rebuilder 3y agoThe problem is, it’s made by Meta. I remember when Facebook was a place you went to get in touch with friends. That was a long time ago now - at some point they stopped showing the feed in chronological order and I thought it was the worst change. They just kept making it worse. Now, if I go look, most of my feed is just random “viral” content and ads. Meta takes a thing you find useful and gradually tweaks it until it no longer does what you originally wanted it for. I don’t trust them to run a service .
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoHN is downright quiet on the topic, with only 21 posts over 20 comments since the launch (2023-07-05), 4 posts per day. Compare that to the Reddit blackout posts which seem to be closer to 8 posts per day. Only 8 posts with over 100 comments, whereas it's hard to find even a single Reddit blackout post at less than 100 comments. My friends in every other community are buzzing about Threads, but here on HN someone comes into every thread to remind me that Mastodon doesn't need growth to be a success, whether the thread was about Mastodon or not. Just gives me more of that feeling that the community here is becoming more detached. Maybe it's just me, but I'm watching The Great Fragmentation with open eyes to see what comes next.
- nicpottier 3y agoIt is a bit weird. I've been toying with all the various Twitter alternatives as they have had their 5 minutes of fame and Threads definitely feels different and like it might stick. That feels like very big news but not to HN I guess?
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoI think over time HN has become more like a lot of other tech communities; a bit ideological, zealous, and detached. Most of these groups have ingroups (the virtuous hackers) and outgroups (CIA, NSA, RIAA, MPAA, Microsoft, Big Tech, Social Media, techbros, billionaires, <zeitgeist enemy>.) This is the kind of community you'll find in a lot of FSF mailing lists, Libera (formerly Freenode) channels, and Linux subreddits. Threads, being a Meta project, is an outgroup project, so not worth talking about no matter how many use it. The other Twitter alternatives align more with the ingroup so worth boosting beyond their actual usage. It depends on what you want out of a community, some people want a space that is a bit relaxed and others want something a bit more cliquish. The FSF orbit communities have always been on the cliquish side. For me if I wanted something more zealous I'd spend more time on Libera channels or FSF MLs. The few I do spend time in satisfy my fill of that culture.
- TheHappyOddish 3y ago
- themitigating 3y agoDid you slow clap at your last statement because you figured it all out? Because of Elon Musk Twitter has been in the news for months. That includes his impulsive decision to buy it, firing massive amounts of people, and to keep everyone focused on him a barrage of right wing themed tweets about hot button political topics. Of course the news media is reporting on this. Then a massive US tech company, whose founder has a hollywood blockbuster biopic, releases a clone of Twitter. That's also news. THEN Elon Musk sues them right after the launch publically claiming former Twitter employees stole code. You know, Elon Musk, the person I mentioned who did all those things he what did. Then you make this "oh typical US media, the Zucks has them under his liberal soft thumb" comment because no way the news would normally report on all these major public and outrageous figures along their big business infighting
- Gh0stRAT 3y agoYou forgot the literal billionaire cage match that Musk tried to initiate but then backed out of when it seemed like Zuck wasn't afraid to fight him. Seemed like everyone was talking about it for a couple of days…
- runlaszlorun 3y agoDamn it… how did I possibly miss that story. Not exactly weighty news. But oh so entertaining. <runs off to google it>
- dghughes 3y agoElon didn't back out of the fight his Mom told him to cut it out. Really. I'm no Elon fan but it's pretty funny and good that his Mom has some common-sense. In a way they are in a cage match only it's Threads vs Twitter.
- themitigating 3y agoBecause he's Elon Musk I can't tell if his mom actually stopped the fight or you were making a pun about immaturity by implying his mother still controls his life like a kid. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law
- tw04 3y agoI can't necessarily disagree, but even if Meta wasn't marketing, Twitter suing less than 24 hours after launch meant it was going to be front page news for at least a couple days.
- crossroadsguy 3y agoI am just wondering what this app is (do not have an Instagram account so can’t try it; I had deleted mine, so not creating one). How the fuck everyone is talking about an app on HN that’s is Facebook one of the richest tech companies with one of the biggest tech pool out there which is just essentially a copy of Twitter. It’s like kids got a new toy. Any toy. So they gotta play with it.
- granzymes 3y agoIt’s been downloaded close to 100 million times at this point and has blown past every growth record to date. I think it’s completely logical for every mainstream news site to mention it. I honestly can’t imagine a source like the New York Times not having an article. Twitter’s threatened lawsuit alone merited coverage.
- ScoobleDoodle 3y agoUntil your comment I didn’t think about that Streisand Effect Elon Musk brought on by filing that lawsuit over Threads. And his tweeting about it.
- kahnclusions 3y agoIt’s not surprising because they are promoting it with, for example, pop ups in Instagram about claiming your username. They already have a wide reach to promote the product.
- dboreham 3y agoI had the same thought when I saw our local tv weather people praising the threads app this morning. Some powerful PR bazooka must have gone off.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoThis comment is the HN bubble talking. Threads has accumulated a huge number of users in a very short amount of time, and it's related to the instability, near-implosion we've seen at Twitter from Musk's leadership. Of course that's big news. It's just not really big news here, because people here REALLY hate Meta (and probably dislike the Twitter-style model of social media anyway).
- gumballindie 3y agoBrings unfond memories of when openai spammed everything under the sun to promote their little chatbot.
- bawolff 3y agoI don't know, i think this could be authentic. People have been mad at elon for a while now and there is a blood in the water - i think mainstream is interested in this drama and the new contender. I think tech news is relatively quiet on this front because quite frankly, twitter is not that interesting as a product technically speaking. This is a political story not a technical one, and it ties into so many beats that are popular with the masses (e.g. the ultra rich being stupid and getting their comeuppance, increased influence of the far right with twitter being seen as a breeding ground, musk specifically being hated by a large segment of the population, etc).
- flagrant_taco 3y agoAre people outside of the tech industry and Politics really concerned at all with Elon or Twitter? My anecdotal experience is that the only people I interact with where this comes up are either people who seen to be parroting a story from 24 hour news or a techy that abandoned Twitter shortly after the purchase (many of have since whom quietly returned).
- hhh 3y agoMy entire friend circle is outside of tech and hate politics, and are tired of Twitter imploding. They all want something new, or at least Twitter before Elon. Most recently, we were trying to find news about the Paris riots, and there’s nothing but misinformation (videos from other riots) spammed consistently, that have no community notes, and have nothing but racist twitter blue users pushed to the top of the replies. It’s creating a huge fog of war when just trying to figure out what’s going on. It’s like all the moderation systems have just gone offline.
- vladvasiliu 3y agoHonest question, as someone who doesn't use Twitter: why don't you just read the papers? For the specific case of the Paris riots, you could check on Le Figaro (right-leaning) and Le Monde (left-leaning) – yest, both of them. I find that following two newspapers allows me to get a balanced-enough take on current events. No need to try to decipher some ultra-short quip from random people and infer the 90% of missing context on my own.
- didntknowya 3y agoyea it was pretty obvious they were spamming on the day, when you could see numerous reddit posts announcing that "threads is launching" with pretty much the exact same title in multiple subreddit, all from different accounts.
- oarabbus_ 3y agoCan you point out some examples of astroturfed articles? I cannot say I find your statement convincing based on a google search of news about threads.