12 ms·
Red flags in the Threads privacy policy
- lostintheether 3y ago[flagged]
- jakear 3y agoMan I hate these alarmist hit pieces. - "You cant delete Threads without deleting Instagram altogether": but you can deactivate it. What's the difference, and why do I care? Without including that info, you're useless. - "Threads collects sensitive personal information about you": How? Inferred from the things I post? Well I'll just not post those things. - "Threads collects data about your employment": Same. - "Threads collects data about your body": Same. Alternatively, this could come from the Health API, which I have to provide explicit permission for. Such permission was not even asked for. - "Threads collects data about your web activity": How? It reads referrer headers. So an issue with my User Agent, if it were configured to do that. Which it isn't. - "Threads collects data about your location". It may reverse-geocode my IP. Okay. And? Literally any analytics service with a map does the same.
- epistasis 3y agoInteresting to see the media side of the battle of the billionaires. Honestly, I find it far more interesting than the physical fight that Musk and Zuckerberg were talking about.
- loteck 3y agoThis reply is a good example of someone whose perspective is utterly locked in to their own perceived personal threat model (which may or may not accurately understand their own actual threats). This technology, they think, is perfectly acceptable according to their own sense of threats, so why isn't it good enough for literally everyone? Other people's threat models are so unimaginable, so inconceivable that the commenter "hates" the "hit pieces" that attempt to inform people of risks, people who may face different threats than the hater. I hope most folks can step out of their own context occasionally and view our current zietgeist from the perspective of a sex worker, or a journalist, or basically anybody who may have perfectly good reasons for electing to maintain their privacy. I don't think that's too much to ask.
- jakear 3y agoWhat makes you think these rhetorical sex workers have learned anything at all from this piece? A belief you know more than them about what's best for them?
- tedunangst 3y agoIs it too much to ask how, exactly, other apps safeguard this info? Allegedly, according to the App Store privacy declaration, mastodon collects no user content. Now how does that work? How does one post on a network that doesn't collect user content?
- tsuujin 3y agoMastodon doesn’t actively poll the operating system for data about you. You can input data (via posts) and that may be scanned by some system but you actively control all data that you choose to or not to share. Threads polls just about every bit of data the operating system stores. E.g., on iOS threads reports that they collect data from the health app (“health and fitness”). If you are using the health app to store information about your health and body, Threads wants to get it straight from that app. It’s not that it’s collecting data, it’s that it is asking for permission to passively collect data from other apps in the background (without you explicitly allowing it each time).
- dash2 3y agoThere's a thread above stating that this is not correct. I'm not saying they are right, wish someone would chime in with the authoritative details.
- tsuujin 3y agoFor iOS the authoritative source is apple itself; you can read their post on this topic here: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211970 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211970 The actual list of privacy descriptors and what they actually mean can be found here: https://apps.apple.com/story/id1539235847 https://apps.apple.com/story/id1539235847 For example, the description of “Health and fitness” is: > Health and fitness > Health > Health and medical data, including but not limited to information from the Clinical Health Records API, HealthKit API, and Movement Disorder API, or from health-related human subject research or any other health or medical data that you provide. > Fitness > Fitness and exercise data. Which indicates that the app can use HealthKit etc to gather information about your health and medical data and exercise data.
- rcme 3y ago> "Threads collects data about your body" This could come from any number of sources. Running AI to determine race, height, weight, and age from a profile picture for example. > "Threads collects data about your web activity": How? It reads referrer headers. Or it fingerprints you and your local network so it can associate browsing outside the app with your threads’ profile to better target ads? Honestly you seem 20 years behind the times with how invasive tracking and analysis can be.
- ClassyJacket 3y ago" but you can deactivate it" You actually can't deactivate your Instagram account. The deactivation feature doesn't do anything; they automatically reactivate your account immediately when you try to use it. It's fake. This has been the case for several years and I can confirm this was still the case as of last week: https://www.reddit.com/r/Instagram/comments/k0vxzk/my_instagram_account_was_reactivated_by_itself/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Instagram/comments/k0vxzk/my_instag...
- smohare 3y ago[dead]
- MrVandemar 3y ago> - "Threads collects data about your employment": Same. There are passive ways of doing this. If you take your phone someplace monday-friday, from 8:30 to 5pm, and you have geo-location turned on, it's a pretty good guess they know where you work, and your working hours, minnimum.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoI think you are underestimating Meta's modeling capabilities, and their reach outside the app. You do not need to explicitly talk about employment info, personal information, or permit health api access on Threads for Meta to infer these things "well enough" for advertising.
- nmltpaxc 3y agoIf this is all true, then how does Facebook make so much money? The first stock market bubble in 2000 partly burst because investors realized that large user numbers by themselves were worthless. Then other monetization schemes were discovered ...
- bool3max 3y agoThere are so many more sophisticated, more accurate, and scarier ways to collect data about web activity, location and your body that you don't seem to be aware of.
- Levitz 3y agoI'm sorry to be callous but you just don't understand how any of this works. You can't just "not post those things". If we are on good terms I can literally just post "Saw you working the bakery this morning, did you skip your morning jog?" and the system already knows where you work and that you are physically active, no input from you required at all. Facebook already did this with shadow profiles. Facebook has information about me and I have never posted there, I don't even have an account there.
- e63f67dd-065b 3y agoIn my opinion, all the people complaining about privacy policies are barking up the wrong tree. As the saying goes in business, if you have to read the contract, you're already screwed. The reality is that the privacy policy will almost never be a determining factor in whether somebody will use a service. The Facebook haters on HN were never gonna use a Facebook product anyways, regardless of what the policy said, and the same goes for the people that are happily using threads now. Does the privacy absolutist who refuses to do anything outside of a VM behind Tor exist? Of course, but not in any meaningful amount for it to matter. The people closely reading terms of services and opting out of arbitration provisions or whatever are wasting their times with busywork. It's doing work that feels meaningful and feels like giving it to the man without actually accomplishing much of anything.
- timmytokyo 3y agoWhy should a social media app have access to the health data stored inside your phone? Why should we not be demanding laws to make this illegal?
- g5revo 3y agoI wish iOS would give us the capability to selectively toggle these app privacy permissions on an individual/granular level. If I want to disable all the toggles and have a non-functioning app, I’d be ok with that. At least I could selectively enable the bare minimum and then have a more deliberate decision regarding how much of my privacy I want to give away, rather than what an app developer might be hungry for (and not actually need).
- epistasis 3y agoWhich social media app has access to your phone's storage of health data? Certainly not the one that's the subject of this post. Strava, a social media app for exercise, has selective access to "health" data about exercise stored on the phone, but that's the closest I can think of.
- brxck 3y ago
- twobitshifter 3y agoIf your problem is with the ownership of Twitter, I don’t understand why you would run from the arms of one wannabe cage-fighter into another’s. If your problem is with ethics, FB isn’t a beacon of good behavior. If your problem is getting rate-limited or losing your blue checkmark, I guess go wild, but you probably already loved Twitter too much to leave.
- tqi 3y agoI think we spend too much time and mental energy questioning other people's reasons for how they spend their free time.
- scythe 3y agoYou do realize the irony in that statement, correct?
- burnished 3y agoThis isn't ironic, they aren't questioning or otherwise probing motives
- jaynetics 3y agoWell, they are questioning the motivation to question the motivation of others. Assuming that this invalidates their point would, however, be a logical fallacy. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
- burnished 3y agoExcept that they are not questioning that motivation at all - blanket assertion that the activity is done too much but nothing supposed about anyone's reasons or whyfores. I think that statement is being incorrectly reduced/interpreted to 'mind your own business' which would be ironic.
- 3y ago
- l0b0 3y agoIsn't the biggest red flag of any privacy policy the ubiquitous "We can change this any way and any time we like, and you have no useful recourse."?
- bigmattystyles 3y agoAlways makes me think of this scene https://tenor.com/view/darth-vader-alter-the-deal-empire-strikes-back-star-wars-gif-15971205 https://tenor.com/view/darth-vader-alter-the-deal-empire-str...
- threeseed 3y agoOf course you have a recourse. You can choose not to use the service. Unfortunately most people aren't willing to pay for websites and so the only successful model ends up being advertising driven.
- dylan604 3y agoyou're skipping over the fact that any data that you shared under the previous agreement are now subject to the new agreement whether you agree to them or not. if they provided a way to nuke everything you've ever posted because you no longer agree to the new terms, that might be something to discuss.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- proxiful-wash 3y agoSo basically tame compared to ShitTok?
- DonHopkins 3y agoWhen is Threads dropping in the UK? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHoMSRZOS4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHoMSRZOS4
- nologic01 3y agoThe adtech business model is predicated on the maximum invasion of privacy that is permitted by law (and the law has been quite accomodating of "innovation" in this space). It is a necessary but thankless job to document how they get away with it. My pessimistic take is its not going to move the needle. There is a huge captive audience (the most likely users of threads are existing users of facebook and instagram) that has been socially engineered not to worry about privacy. Internal cannibalism between surveillance capitalists aside, the true change will only come when authoritative bodies (public sector and other institutions) walk the talk, vocally refuse to use these platforms and throw their weight behind the fediverse.
- mellosouls 3y agoTbh if you are concerned about the privacy and ethics concerns here the biggest red flag is in the subtitle: Meta's Twitter rival launched in over 100 countries today—but not in the EU Anything more is simply detail - if a major launch of this sort of service omits the EU we immediately know exactly why.
- TylerE 3y agoNot sure I buy this. Some of the EU stuff is good, I think a lot of it goes to far and it's a terrible nightmare to navigate now, never mind in a decade when we're all using software that doesn't exist yet.
- hnhg 3y agoCan you say specifically what goes too far? I don't find it onerous or unreasonable at all, but my business model doesn't improve by violating it either.
- TylerE 3y agoRight to be forgotten has some really nasty edge csaes.
- yoaviram 3y agoSuch as?
- jay_kyburz 3y agosuch as the ability easily support redaction of personal data? Errg: sorry folks. I miss read the thread and thought the "such as" was responding to the comment next to it about the design flaw of not being able to delete personal data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- llacb47 3y agoTerrible article. They linked to another product named Threads’ privacy policy.
- wahahah 3y agoWhat were they reading off of? In the App Store they set the privacy policy to Instagram's; https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id6446901002 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id644... https://privacycenter.instagram.com/policy https://privacycenter.instagram.com/policy
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoI must be missing something obvious here. Allegedly Threads has launched to the public by now, which is how all these revelations are being uncovered. But threads.net still points to a generic landing page with a QR code, no obvious way to create an account, sign in, etc. How am I even supposed to access this?
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agoIt's app-only for now, no web version
- thinkingemote 3y agoThe web version works as read only e.g. https://www.threads.net/@crumbler https://www.threads.net/@crumbler
- cygx 3y agoWorks in Chrome, but in Firefox, I just gets a bunch of CORS errors...
- Daz1 3y agoI have never met a single normal person in my life who uses twitter
- _aaed 3y agoMaybe you should meet more people then
- nmltpaxc 3y agoYou have a point in that it is somewhat tech-specific. If, e.g., you are in an open source project with 100 people and 20 are on Twitter, 18 of the 20 are raging, manipulative, self-promoting politicians, all with the correct "Twitter Bio" and the correct set of flags. They use Twitter to intimidate others and promote their clique. I find that the only people worth reading are the independently minded ones who don't care what others think. In the current climate, they are either journalists or independently wealthy.
- dgb23 3y agoIronically this reads like a tweet.
- imdsm 3y agoThreads collects sensitive personal information about you The data collected by the Threads app could include your sexual orientation, race and ethnicity, biometric data, trade union membership, pregnancy status, politics, and religious beliefs. This data may potentially be sent to “service providers” and “analytics partners,” which is often code for third-party advertising and marketing firms. Threads collects data about your employment Information about your company, your role on your team, your job history, and your performance evaluations may be collected and sent to third parties. Threads collects data about your body Details about your health, fitness, and exercise may be hoovered up to be sent to third parties. Threads collects data about your web activity Threads may scour your browsing history, web page interactions (including with ads), and the referring web page or source through which you accessed Threads links. This information may be sent to third parties as well. Threads collects data about your location Photos, videos, or other recordings of a user’s environment, as well as “IP-address-based location information,” may be collected and sent to third parties. ---- 1. How does it access biometric data? 2. How does it access your performance evaluations? 3. How does it access your browsing history? 4. How does it access "photos, videos, or other recordings of a user’s environment"? If the answer to this is that it extracts information from the things you post, mining the data of your threads over years and extracting a profile, then that isn't that big of a privacy invasion -- especially if you post publicly. If the answer is that they activate the camera without you knowing, that they bypass security features to access browser history and biometric data, and that they... I don't even know how they'd access performance evaluations, then that's a different question and less of a privacy issue and more of a computer misuse issue. Does anyone know the answer to this? Perhaps it's time for phone cameras & microphones to have hardware lights next to them like Macs do.
- Zealotux 3y agoI'm wondering something here, and I humbly ask for feedback: to anyone hyped about Threads, why? Has Meta ever displayed any particular quality regarding content moderation, freedom of speech, privacy, information control, transparency, or mental health? Not implying Twitter is any better, Musk Tweeted, "It is infinitely preferable to be attacked by strangers on Twitter, than to indulge in the false happiness of hide-the-pain Instagram" What a sad state of affairs when a form of abuse somehow becomes "infinitely preferable" to another; maybe I'm being overly sensitive, or has the social media bubble fallen into pure insanity?
- stOneskull 3y agoit's pretty crap. it's just new for people.
- jerezzprime 3y agoThere is a third option: Don't participate. Your quality of life will be better without any of it. Humans were not meant to communicate at that scale.
- Keirmot 3y agoIm someone who doesn’t have a Facebook account for years, and because I still have the same phone number I had back when I deleted my account I can’t even create a new one. But I still want to check it out when it comes out in the EU. Just to see what it is like. I will probably not use it, because the lack of proper chronological feed irks me, but as an iOS developer I want to check out new apps all the time to see if they do anything different.
- superq 3y agoAs soon as you do, you will accept (and can not change your mind later) the new terms of service (and privacy policy, that is: what this post is about) which also are designed to prohibit you from developing an alternative app. Just look at screenshots or videos of how it works to satisfy your curiosity.
- 3y ago
- KaiserPro 3y agoThis level of scrutiny is really excellent. Now we need to apply it to other companies working in the same space. There is a serious lesson for startups though, if you actively start collecting data, you will, if you survive long enough, begin to have to declare what data you have when you "grow up". For example, if you do anything with photos, you will have to ask for permissions to process location data. even if you throw it away, it still counts as processing. Taken in the wrong light, or explained badly, this will tarnish your brand. Rant time Twitter can infer (if they hadn't have sacked all their data scientist people) your sexual preferences, location, and employer. Google already knows your employer, especially if your work uses any google service. they also know everything you look at, type and interact with on the web. If you have an android phone, then your every move is logged, not only that but shared with your phone manufacturer as well. Apple hoovers everything you do. I know they say its all for a "magical" experience. But they will and do monetise it. Anyone who says differently is in denial. let us not talk to deeply about tiktok. Is threads actually setting out to hoover that data? I doubt it. Have some people filled in their facebook profile with gender, preference, employer, house location and significant spouse(s)? you betcha.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y ago> Is threads actually setting out to hoover that data? I doubt it Check out the App Privacy section yourself: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id6446901002 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id644...
- KaiserPro 3y agosee my sister comment: > Sure, facebook the app is all up in your junk. But the apple label about "it stealing your health data" is nonsense[1]. Why isn't there a permissions dialogue asking me to share my health data, like fitness apps? Does apple specifically allow Facebook apps to get at my health data unannounced? what about apple pay, is that leaking to facebook as well? [1] https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id6446901002 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/threads-an-instagram-app/id644... As I said earlier, Tech companies are not reliable narrators. But, to underscore the point, if apple really are letting facebook harvest this data, surely this undermines their "privacy is our magic sauce" shtick? why are they letting them harvest that data? why, as a platform, are they letting them get away with it? Ideally the US would adopt GDPR like laws at a federal level, however thats not going to happen because there are too many tech billionaires.
- hxii 3y agoMeta released a new product that harvests user data without your permission and/or full understanding. Shocker.
- logicprog 3y agoThreads will also automatically, silently, and without your consent doxx and/or deadname you[1] by digging up your legal name from its massive social network and access to personal information and changing your display name to your legal name. This is horrible for everyone, but it also makes it incredibly dangerous for marginalized people who are often targeted for harassment, doxxing, as well as IRL harassment and stalking by people like GaysAgainstGroomers and LibsOfTikTok, which are, incidentally, being allowed free reign on the platform. [1]: https://xantronix.social/@megaspel/110666980545804656 https://xantronix.social/@megaspel/110666980545804656
- privacyphd 3y agoThe rapid growth of Threads app while avoiding compliance conflict in the EU is a pivotal moment in data privacy. This blog post describes key lessons on why and how Meta balanced innovation with compliance. https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7085094247120453632 https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7085094...